"Catholics are not Christians"

  • Thread starter Thread starter drpmjhess
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is my first time posting. Our Pastor when dealing with marriage prep that has one non-Catholic wanting to marry a Catholic will use the term “Christian” generously. He told me that he will say “our Christian” or “we Christians” etc. One time a non-Catholic looked up at him and asked sincerely, “When did you (Catholics) become Christian?” When our pastor told me this I couldn’t help but smile. We should reach out with our Christian hearts with Christian generosity to our non-Catholic Christian friends and show them our Christian faith. Did I say Christian enough for you?
 
I live in an area heavily populated (probably 50%+ of the population) by Baptists, Pentacostals, other Evanglicals and non-denominational “Bible-believing” Christians. My Catholic family has been told numerous times that we are not Christian.

There is occasional reference to the RCC as the Beast and the Whore of Babylon, and accusations of Mary-worship, crucifix and statue-worship, etc. But by far the most common reason offered by these local folks is this:

The only things required to be a Christian are (1) to be baptized as an adult. Christianity requires an adult confession of faith. (2) One must claim Jesus as one’s personal Lord and Savior, and in those precise words.

Alas, one argues without success against these non-biblical charges.

“Baptism is only for believers. Not for infants.”

Baptism makes one a part of the Church, the People of God. It makes one a child of God. Of course it makes no sense to baptize a person who doesn’t know Christ, but there is no unbelief in an infant.

Luke 18:15–16 tells us that “they were bringing even infants” to Jesus; and he himself related this to the kingdom of God: “Let the children come to me and do not hinder them, for to such belongs the kingdom of God.”

Peter declared, “Repent, and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins; and you shall receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. For the promise is to you and to your children” (Acts 2:38–39).

When Paul and Silas were released from prison, the Jailer was converted: "And he took them that very hour of the night and washed their wounds, and immediately he was baptized, he and all his household. And he brought them into his house and set food before them, and rejoiced greatly, having believed in God with his whole household. (Acts 16: 33-34) (See also 1 Cor 1:16)

No exclusion of children there.

“You must confess Jesus as your personal Lord and Savior in those precise words, or you are not a Christian.”

If anyone reading believes this, I have an invitation for you. No 95 theses debate, or anything so complicated. I simply ask you to show me where in the Bible the precise words “personal Lord and Savior” appear, with the indication that the recitation of these words is required to be a true Christian.
 
Those that call Catholics “non-Christian” might want to read the Apostle’s Creed and make a determination whether they BELIEVE it is non-Christian.

That begs the question: Do THEY have a common profession of faith?
 
Those that call Catholics “non-Christian” might want to read the Apostle’s Creed and make a determination whether they BELIEVE it is non-Christian.

That begs the question: Do THEY have a common profession of faith?
Those who call catholics non-christian don’t typically rely on things written by men except in the case of the divine revelation of Holy Scripture.
 
The only things required to be a Christian are (1) to be baptized as an adult. Christianity requires an adult confession of faith. (2) One must claim Jesus as one’s personal Lord and Savior, and in those precise words.
I’d be surprised if anyone with any scriptural knowledge would ever say such a thing… Faith and repentance maybe, but what you stated seems suspect, were you listening closely?
 
I live in a conservative mostly catholic country and while people would not juimp of joy while meeting homosexuals, they do not bash them either. And I think that gay civil unions but not gay marriage with equal right to heteros can be real in the future.
That would probably solve a lot of problems. The secular state cannot sanctify anything anyway; it can only protect basic civil rights, particularly of children. Civil unions should be recognized by the state, leaving it up to churches, mosques, synagogues, and temples, to solemnize those marriages they will, and to refuse to solemnize those they won’t.

Petrus
 
Originally Posted by kam1953f
The only things required to be a Christian are (1) to be baptized as an adult. Christianity requires an adult confession of faith. (2) One must claim Jesus as one’s personal Lord and Savior, and in those precise words.


myfavoritmartin says: I’d be surprised if anyone with any scriptural knowledge would ever say such a thing… Faith and repentance maybe, but what you stated seems suspect, were you listening closely?

Oh, indeed I was listening very closely. Had I not been, I have had hundreds of occasions to revisit these ideas.

“Anyone with any scriptural knowledge” should certainly never say such a thing. This makes me suspicious of how well bible-read these bible-believers really are. I suspect they do less reading and more listening to charismatic preachers who do drama better than they do catechizing.

And, to demonstrate the laziness of many of these locals, the Jack Chick comic books are ubiquitous in our school buses, doctor waiting rooms, park picnic tables and cafeteria chairs. Mr. Chick, a fallen Catholic full of vitriol, seems to be a primary influence among the kids and among many of the parents who raised them.
 
I’d be surprised if anyone with any scriptural knowledge would ever say such a thing… Faith and repentance maybe, but what you stated seems suspect, were you listening closely?
Members of the Christian Churches and Churches of Christ do consider baptism essential to being a Christian–and since they generally describe themselves as “non-denominational,” it would be hard for a Catholic to distinguish them from other free-church Protestants.

You may be right that the poster is mistakenly interpreting what he is hearing–it’s easy for a Catholic to hear “you must profess faith in Jesus Christ to be a Christian, and then you should be baptized” and think it means “you must profess faith in Jesus Christ and then be baptized to be a Christian,” which is what the CC/CC folks say but is denied by other evangelicals.

You will not be surprised to hear that I think that the importance of baptism is something the CC/CC gets basically right, although they define baptism too narrowly (and the more conservative ones don’t make the necessary qualifications).

Edwin
 
With the glaring exception of gay, lesbian, and transgendered people.
No, most are even more tolerant of them also. Some so-called Catholics are TOO tolerant, in the sense that they have the attitude that whatever they want to do is fine w/ them as long as they don’t (fill in the blank)…

Well, it is never OK to be tolerant of sin - only sinners.

God is not tolerant of sin. He destroyed two cities over that one…

So why are humans so “tolerant” when God is not??
 
God is not tolerant of sin. He destroyed two cities over that one.So why are humans so “tolerant” when God is not??
God didn’t destroy cities over homosexuality – that was only in the overactive imaginations of Hebrew authors. (Edited)
 
Then you obviously don’t believe the Bible (Genesis)?
Also, i have this to say:
You can tell a person is against Jesus when he accuses the religious right of hating people …
(1) What do you mean by my not believing the Bible?

(2) The Religious Right do hate people – just look at Jerry Falwell blaming the World Trade Center attacks on gay and lesbian people.
 
I think we’re getting off topic. The discussion on marriage, etc. probably belongs under “morality.”
 
Thread pruned and posts edited of off topic posts and comments.
MF
 
They were evangelical fundamentalist by every means of the title.
:rotfl: Yeah, right. In your dreams maybe.

Let’s check that out very briefly though.
  1. The Eucharistic Real Presence plainly taught by St. Paul in 1st Corinthians 11:23-30. The Eucharist IS Scriptural
  2. Infant baptism. as shown by “whole households” being baptized. Acts 16:15, & 1st Corinthians 1:16. Not to mention the clear early church testimony of Polycarp when on trial for his faith. Martyrdom of Polycarp
So if what you say is true then they were certainly not " evangelical fundamentalist by every means of the title.", they were definitely Catholic.
 
Those who call catholics non-christian don’t typically rely on things written by men except in the case of the divine revelation of Holy Scripture.
Who was of course written by men too. 🤷
 
Those who say Catholics are not Christians are defining “Christian” narrowly so that only those of their own denomination have much of a chance of salvation. I wonder what they think Catholics have been for the last 2000 years? Remember, until Martin Luther there was only one Church in Western Europe and the Americas, and it was not Protestant.
 
Next month I will be giving a lecture on Catholic theology in light of the modern scientific worldview – particularly that of evolutionary biology – to a general audience that will include Catholics, Protestants, seculars and Young Earth Creationists. I wonder if anyone can tell me (with greater or less precision) when Protestant Fundamentalists first began to co-opt the term “Christian” so that it excluded Roman Catholics? I can’t count the number of times I’ve been told, “You’re not a Christian – you’re a Catholic!”
Thanks in advance,
Peter
I have even heart Catholics say that! Shameful. I am not sure when this happened, not before 150 years ago. The Reformers called Catholics “Papists” or “Romans”. However, there were no protestants around when Catholics were first called Christians:

Acts 11:26
and in Antioch the disciples were for the first time called Christians.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top