Catholics assist in genocide!!

  • Thread starter Thread starter R_McGeddon
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We can focus on Serbs, since both Stepinac in general and the Church as a whole did do plenty to protect Jews. So much so that the Chief Rabbi of Rome, who had been sheltered in the Vatican itself during the war, converted to Catholicism afterwards. He wouldn’t have done that if Catholic clerics in Croatia had methodically and on a large scale been massacring his Jewish brothers and sisters.
You’re talking to the granddaughter of German Jews but I’m not going to get into an argument about Pius or the ‘Chief Rabbi of Rome’ (didn’t influence anybody else though, I wonder why? But that’s another story) because the whole business is not going to be resolved on a message board and because it’s something of a diversion.
The horrors of that war were enough to drive even clerics, of different nationalities and stripes, to take up arms, and, yes, some of them committed acts of atrocity in so doing. I don’t want to downplay or negate this fact, just to state emphatically that neither side has clean hands in this regard.
This wasn’t all just ‘magicked-up’ when the Germans arrived, it’s a story that is part of the weft and weave of European History between the wars (and indeed before the First World War) and it’s not a history that the Church spends its time bragging about. I’d suggest that, if you wanted to find the most significant reason for the decline of the Church’s influence in Europe after the Second World War - that’s the place to look.
 
I have lost count of the number of people, on this forum, saying how Hitler’s “atheist regime” was responsible for some of the greatest crimes against humanity, then I happen across this website

libcom.org

and find that the Catholic church assisted Hitler in an attempt to exterminate the Orthodox from parts of the Balkans. I’ve read the contents of that link and it doesn’t make pleasant reading. I’m not trying to condone what Hitler did but certain members of this forum have, in the past, taken great delight in tarring atheists with the same brush as Hitler, when it turns out that the Catholic church, led by Pius XII, has taken part in crimes against humanity.

I find this level of hypocrisy staggering and indefensible.
Allow me, perhaps? I posted the following as “Conscience and Choice” in Apologetics, I thought. Instead it appeared in Back Fence (whatever that it).

"There has been so much back-and-forth regarding conscience on this site lately that I’ve decided to use an example of a Catholic who chose to allow his conscience to follow the teachings of the Church during WW II and he died for that choice. The man’s name was Franz Jagerstatter and you’ll find many spellings of that name - check on Vatican sites for the most approved spelling. (I think I’ve used it here.)

The beatification of Franz, who died at age 37 yrs, beheaded for refusal to bear arms for the Nazis brings him to the public forum. When executed, he left behind a wife and three young daughters. Before he was killed, he was approached by many neighbors including priests and even chaplains during his time in prison; all begged him to relent, stressing the very real needs of his wife and daughters. Franz’s consistent response was that God had allowed him to see clearly in this matter of conscience and he remained faithful to the teachings of Pope Pius XI who had callled the Nazi model an evil work from start to finish. (The relevant encyclical, “MIT BRENNENDER SORGE - ON THE CHURCH AND THE GERMAN REICH” was never rescinded and Franz chose to remain loyal to its teachings.)

He never criticized other Austrians, priest or clergy, who managed to regard things otherwise but he KNEW, by the grace of God that his own conscience must follow the true teachings of the Church and he said so. These days, Franz has been covered within all manners of media, from The NCR to the The Wanderer. Many have attempted to make him a hero of this or that; e.g., a model for conscientious objectors and such. Yet, in truth, Franz followed Christ and saw the Nazi party as the Pope described it: as EVIL. So he refused to bear arms for the Nazi Army.

I’ve been sort of half in love with Franz, the man, since I first heard of him in the 1980s. I used his life as the subject of a thesis for a master’s course in Psychology of Mental Health, following Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs as the professor required - and adding a companion comparison of Franz attaining heroic Christian virtue according to the conditions in place for Sainthood. My Jewish professor was delighted (for many reasons).

As Franz becomes better known, the most obvious emphasis has to be on his well-formed conscience. While little material was available to me in the late '80s, now there’s much. If you read about him be prepared to look for any hidden agendas of various writers. As a smile from God perhaps, he was martyred on the same day when Sister Edith Stein was martyred in Auschwitz. (Franz was a third-order Franciscan and had little formal education.)"

In other words, some Catholics choose sin. The Vatican did not. It preached AGAINST Hitler and the Nazi Party and that teaching was never rescinded. Hope this helps.
 
To the best of my knowledge, Hitler was a baptized Roman Catholic and that might be one of the reasons that the Vatican spoke so strongly against him and his political machinations (the Nazi Party) in “MIT BRENNENDER SORGE - ON THE CHURCH AND THE GERMAN REICH” leaving no doubt that Hitler’s actions went against all Church teachings.
 
I have lost count of the number of people, on this forum, saying how Hitler’s “atheist regime” was responsible for some of the greatest crimes against humanity, then I happen across this website

libcom.org

and find that the Catholic church assisted Hitler in an attempt to exterminate the Orthodox from parts of the Balkans. I’ve read the contents of that link and it doesn’t make pleasant reading. I’m not trying to condone what Hitler did but certain members of this forum have, in the past, taken great delight in tarring atheists with the same brush as Hitler, when it turns out that the Catholic church, led by Pius XII, has taken part in crimes against humanity.

I find this level of hypocrisy staggering and indefensible.

What Catholics did in Fascist Croatia from 1941 to 1945 was unspeakable & indefensible, & is one of the great crimes of the century. Catholicism was complicit in Rwanda in 1994, when 800,000 were slaughtered - so even if the lower figure of 700,000 is adopted for the number of those slaughtered in Croatia during WW2, the assertions of a Croatian genocide sound all too plausible. Any attempt to whitewash the Catholics involved is beneath contempt. To attempt to do so, implies that being caught out in evil-doing is more shameful for the CC than admitting wrong-doing. And if that is so, it implies a completely amoral outlook on the part of the CC 😦​

It seems to be beyond doubt that the Vatican - even if the Pope was not involved - helped Pavelic to escape arrest: that’s surely a crime in itself. Would Hitler have been helped, had he survived ? I wouldn’t bet against it. I hope that is thrashed out properly before the Pope’s cause for canonisation is much older, as an abetter of murderers & criminals is no saint. The issue needs to be very thoroughly dealt with, if only for the sake of that Pope’s reputation.

If the CC is not to blame for the activities of Catholics - even when they acted on behalf of the CC in an official capacity - it makes no sense to blame atheists for what a few of them have done. If indeed Hitler or Stalin were atheists: Hitler was not; Stalin’s Communism was in effect a religion. They both followed a sort of millenarianism-without-Christ, in slightly different forms. How is that a reproach to atheists ? What about the innumerable crimes of Christians :mad: ? By any normal standard, it has to be compared with Nazism & Stalinism. Why not ? As an ideology it has (like them) been very bloody; so the decline of Christian political power can only be welcomed. It is much less dangerous when it has no power to harm.

To turn the question around: can it be altogether coincidental that Franco, Salazar, Mussolini, Hitler, Mgr. Tiso, Pavelic, were all RCs ? Stalin was Georgian Orthodox, & Rumanian Fascists were Orthodox too. Hitler & Pavelic & Stalin would have been long-forgotten nobodies, if their fellow-countrymen had not been complicit in their actions. What does that say for the religion of those countries ? 😦

Fascism seems to have an attraction for people who are not Anglo-Saxons - the USA, the UK, are both traditionally Protestant & Anglo-Saxon. Hispanics & Slavs both seem to have problems with setting up government which will be stable yet representative & not genocidal or otherwise tyrannical. 😦
 
The guilt of individuals is the guilt of individuals.

The Church has not been teaching genocide to anyone.
 

What Catholics did in Fascist Croatia from 1941 to 1945 was unspeakable & indefensible, & is one of the great crimes of the century. Catholicism was complicit in Rwanda in 1994, when 800,000 were slaughtered - so even if the lower figure of 700,000 is adopted for the number of those slaughtered in Croatia during WW2, the assertions of a Croatian genocide sound all too plausible. Any attempt to whitewash the Catholics involved is beneath contempt. To attempt to do so, implies that being caught out in evil-doing is more shameful for the CC than admitting wrong-doing. And if that is so, it implies a completely amoral outlook on the part of the CC 😦​

It seems to be beyond doubt that the Vatican - even if the Pope was not involved - helped Pavelic to escape arrest: that’s surely a crime in itself. Would Hitler have been helped, had he survived ? I wouldn’t bet against it. I hope that is thrashed out properly before the Pope’s cause for canonisation is much older, as an abetter of murderers & criminals is no saint. The issue needs to be very thoroughly dealt with, if only for the sake of that Pope’s reputation.

If the CC is not to blame for the activities of Catholics - even when they acted on behalf of the CC in an official capacity - it makes no sense to blame atheists for what a few of them have done. If indeed Hitler or Stalin were atheists: Hitler was not; Stalin’s Communism was in effect a religion. They both followed a sort of millenarianism-without-Christ, in slightly different forms. How is that a reproach to atheists ? What about the innumerable crimes of Christians :mad: ? By any normal standard, it has to be compared with Nazism & Stalinism. Why not ? As an ideology it has (like them) been very bloody; so the decline of Christian political power can only be welcomed. It is much less dangerous when it has no power to harm.

To turn the question around: can it be altogether coincidental that Franco, Salazar, Mussolini, Hitler, Mgr. Tiso, Pavelic, were all RCs ? Stalin was Georgian Orthodox, & Rumanian Fascists were Orthodox too. Hitler & Pavelic & Stalin would have been long-forgotten nobodies, if their fellow-countrymen had not been complicit in their actions. What does that say for the religion of those countries ? 😦

Fascism seems to have an attraction for people who are not Anglo-Saxons - the USA, the UK, are both traditionally Protestant & Anglo-Saxon. Hispanics & Slavs both seem to have problems with setting up government which will be stable yet representative & not genocidal or otherwise tyrannical. 😦
Hispanics and Slavs? As someone of Slavic descent I can’t let pass the generalisation 🙂 Africans, Asians, Middle-Easterners have all been pretty equal-opportunity tyrants as well - need I name Pol Pot, Ho Chi Min, Mao, Idi Amin, Robert Mugabe, Saddam Hussein, Ayatollah Khomeini?

And what about Nazi Germany, which had at least a substantial proportion of Protestants and Saxons (if not Angles) Or South Africa under apartheid, which was covertly if not overtly tyrannical, the tyranny being perpetuated by your Protestant Boers?
 
He’s some kind of Catholic expert on Lenin or something?
Fr Groeschel is not an expert on Lenin as far as I know. He’s probably more of an expert on St Francis of Assisi considering that he’s a Franciscan priest and one of the founders of his religious order–Franciscan Friars of the Renewal:
franciscanfriars.com/

Fr Groeschel is a psychologist, author, and television host on EWTN. Probably most people on this forum are familiar with him, but for those who aren’t, here are some of his books:

amazon.com/s/ref=sr_pg_1?ie=UTF8&rs=&keywords=fr%20benedict%20groeschel&rh=i%3Aaps%2Ck%3Afr%20benedict%20groeschel&page=1
Are they separate quotes or self-referential?
It’s a quote that is attributed to Lenin, though I haven’t found the original source. Of the 3 references I found on the internet, one said he said it on his deathbed; one said he wrote it in his book on modern atheism; and one wasn’t specific (end of Lenin’s life). I don’t have Lenin’s book and I wasn’t present at his deathbed, so I can’t say for sure. If Lenin didn’t say it, he should have. For those of us who have studied St Francis, the quote makes a lot of sense. One person’s life can have a profound influence on the world. St Francis’ life did and still does today. If we had 9 more people like him, no doubt the world would be a much better place.
I’m sorry but I’d say it’s pure fantasy, supposedly sacramental or not.
Maybe it is. I haven’t found the original source, but like I said before, the quote makes so much sense to me that I am inclined to believe it is true.
 
Maybe it is. I haven’t found the original source, but like I said before, the quote makes so much sense to me that I am inclined to believe it is true.
It makes so little sense to me and, while I know virtually nothing about St Francis I do know quite a bit about Lenin, I’m more than inclined to believe that it’s complete nonsense.
 
Originally Posted by Deconi
PiusXII and the Catholic Church saved more Jews than The Red Cross and from memory, any other individual nation.
This may or may not be true but it does not justify their actions in the Balkans.
“May or may not be true” signifies a departure from common sense. If it is true that The Pope and Catholics saved Jews, who are our “worst” detractors (on a logical level) why rally against the Orthodox, who are our brethen?

You’re suggesting that The Pope would move to save the Jews (because His Master taught that ALL MEN are the children of God) but alienate and eradicate others??!..knowing that he will answer for the same, to The Master he obeys by the saving act?

Please, connect the dots, properly. Please! If you’re going to “colour” it, please also stay within the lines!

** Understand also that I do not look to make any excuses for vermin just because they’re Catholics! We do not believe in PREdestination so we understand that vermin can be amongst the fold, until The Master returns to separate the wheat from the chaff, and the sheep from the goats. **

:cool:
 
“May or may not be true” signifies a departure from common sense. If it is true that The Pope and Catholics saved Jews, who are our “worst” detractors (on a logical level) why rally against the Orthodox, who are our brethen?

You’re suggesting that The Pope would move to save the Jews (because His Master taught that ALL MEN are the children of God) but alienate and eradicate others??!..knowing that he will answer for the same, to The Master he obeys by the saving act?

Please, connect the dots, properly. Please! If you’re going to “colour” it, please also stay within the lines!
I don’t want to get diverted into the quagmire of the Pius XII question but there’s not a little disingenuousness here.

Yes, some Catholics were saving Jews - but who the hell do you presume were killing Jews? Are you suggesting that the Germans, Lithuanians, Latvians, Croats etc who were killing Jews were just the Protestant Germans, Protestant Lithuanians, Protestant Latvians and Protestant Croats etc? That somehow Antisemitism was something that came to Luther in a blinding flash while the Catholic Church carried on some glorious tradition of inculcating tolerance?

The defeat of the Reich was not a great uprising of Catholics against some kind of insane Protestant/Atheist/Pagan tyranny over them. There were Catholics at every level of the Reich, in every aspect of the forces of the Reich, in every aspect of its killing machine - and then they went to Church on Sunday.
 
I don’t want to get diverted into the quagmire of the Pius XII question but there’s not a little disingenuousness here.

Yes, some Catholics were saving Jews - but who the hell do you presume were killing Jews? Are you suggesting that the Germans, Lithuanians, Latvians, Croats etc who were killing Jews were just the Protestant Germans, Protestant Lithuanians, Protestant Latvians and Protestant Croats etc? That somehow Antisemitism was something that came to Luther in a blinding flash while the Catholic Church carried on some glorious tradition of inculcating tolerance?

The defeat of the Reich was not a great uprising of Catholics against some kind of insane Protestant/Atheist/Pagan tyranny over them. There were Catholics at every level of the Reich, in every aspect of the forces of the Reich, in every aspect of its killing machine - and then they went to Church on Sunday.
In the same way I’m sure there are Jews who, for example, have cheerfully bombed unarmed and innocent Palestinian or Lebanese civilians to smithereens or gruesomely tortured political prisoners in Israel, and then equally cheerfully went to synagogue on the Sabbath. It’s an undeniable fact that there’s a percentage of people in any faith who are total bald-faced hypocrites as well as xenophobic monsters of brutality.

Read ‘Mit Brennender Sorge’ - those Catholics who were killing Jews were doing so IN SPITE OF and DIRECTLY CONTRARY TO the teachings of Pius and the Church. In spite of and directly contrary to their professed Catholicism, not because of it or as part of it.

Doesn’t matter how many times they went to Mass, it doesn’t make them faithful Catholics if they ignored Church teaching - and they did. Any more than a Jew who wilfully breaks the commandment against murder is truly practicing Judaism merely because they attend synagogue. 🤷
 
I’ve heard this rubbish before, and here’s my response. Someone Has Lied to You About Our Pope Pius XII

GoG, I’m kinda surprised that you would allege complicity of the church in the cases that you mention. I’m sure the Pope got on the phone and told the Rwandans to carry that out.:rolleyes:

Before anyone goes nailing the church for stuff like this, why don’t we put the blame where it really belongs. On the self appointed world cops of the “super powers” who will start a war over non-existent WMDs but won’t effect their “regime change” in an African nation where hundreds of thousands are killed in genocidal civil insanity.

Rwanda doesn’t have oil does it?

The fact is that the West did the same thing in WWII with the Jews, and the governments KNEW what was going on in those camps… they just didn’t care.

The church isn’t always perfect, but the kind of complicity you people are trying to hang on it is not even close to right or fair.
 
And there have never been Jews who, for example, cheerfully bombed unarmed and innocent Palestinian or Lebanese civilians to smithereens or gruesomely tortured political prisoners in Israel, and then equally cheerfully went to synagogue on the Sabbath? It’s an undeniable fact that there’s a percentage of people in any faith who are total bald-faced hypocrites.
Nevermind the fact that this is, actually, a logical fallacy (known as ‘Tu quoque’), it’s also beside the point and another trip to the equivalent of the ‘Pius XII’ quagmire.
Read ‘Mit Brennender Sorge’ - those Catholics who were killing Jews were doing so IN SPITE OF and DIRECTLY CONTRARY TO the teachings of Pius and the Church. In spite of and directly contrary to their professed Catholicism, not because of it or as part of it.
Actually, I’ve read the Encyclical and it’s not actually quite what it’s made out to be - just where is the protest at the actions of the Reich Government against the Jews of Germany? It isn’t some magical protection against the fact that the Catholic Church, as much as the Protestant Churches, was creative of an attitude to Jews that fed traditional anti-Jewish prejudices and provided the soil for ‘modern’ Antisemitism.
Doesn’t matter how many times they went to Mass, it doesn’t make them faithful Catholics if they ignored Church teaching - and they did. Any more than a Jew who wilfully breaks the commandment against murder is truly practicing Judaism merely because they attend synagogue. 🤷
Back to the ‘no true Catholic has ever done anything wrong ever’ defense. I expect it was us naughty, naughty Jews who were responsible for the whole thing as usual.
 
Actually, I’ve read the Encyclical and it’s not actually quite what it’s made out to be - just where is
the protest at the actions of the Reich Government against the Jews of Germany? It isn’t some magical protection against the fact that the Catholic Church, as much as the Protestant Churches, was creative of an attitude to Jews that fed traditional anti-Jewish prejudices and provided the soil for ‘modern’ Antisemitism.I don’t think so.

An encyclical teaches. What did it teach? Does it say anywhere that it is good to do evil to the Jews? No it does not. Does it tell the Germans that it’s okay to follow the Nazis into any evil or excess? No, it does not.

I suppose the thousands of Jews that Pius XII hid out in Castel Gandolfo are indicative of his “creative attitude towards the Jews”, and if so then all I can saw is BRAVO Pius XII. Blame it on the Nazis where it belongs.
Back to the ‘no true Catholic has ever done anything wrong ever’ defense. I expect it was us naughty, naughty Jews who were responsible for the whole thing as usual.
Thanks for a rational response… NOT!

There have been Jews who have done stuff. Gee…look at Herod Antipas… real charmer that one. You can go all back into the the OT and dig out Jews who were less than exemplary of their faith, but I never bother with them because I am too impressed with the guys who did their best and are an inspiration to me. And I sure as vitam aeternam don’t blame all Jews for the few that were bad dudes and I was taught to be that way by… you guessed it…my Catholic upbringing. (Even in the middle of the deep South) 🤷
 
I don’t think so.

An encyclical teaches. What did it teach? Does it say anywhere that it is good to do evil to the Jews? No it does not. Does it tell the Germans that it’s okay to follow the Nazis into any evil or excess? No, it does not.

I suppose the thousands of Jews that Pius XII hid out in Castel Gandolfo are indicative of his “creative attitude towards the Jews”, and if so then all I can saw is BRAVO Pius XII. Blame it on the Nazis where it belongs.Thanks for a rational response… NOT!

There have been Jews who have done stuff. Gee…look at Herod Antipas… real charmer that one. You can go all back into the the OT and dig out Jews who were less than exemplary of their faith, but I never bother with them because I am too impressed with the guys who did their best and are an inspiration to me. And I sure as vitam aeternam don’t blame all Jews for the few that were bad dudes and I was taught to be that way by… you guessed it…my Catholic upbringing. (Even in the middle of the deep South) 🤷
Do you find the large font size helps?
 
Back to the ‘no true Catholic has ever done anything wrong ever’ defense. I expect it was us naughty, naughty Jews who were responsible for the whole thing as usual.
Silly me, and here I thought it was the responsibility of the individuals who actually did the shooting, bombing and gassing and signed the orders for the killings etc etc - and who called themselves all sorts of things, including “Catholic”, “Protestant” and “atheist” 🤷

Have you learned nothing from the Nuremberg Trials? Didn’t they state in so many words that the responsibility for these atrocities lies squarely on the shoulders of those who commit them? And that the individual cannot shift blame - not even onto military superiors who give the actual orders let alone religious superiors???
 
Do you find the large font size helps?
Yeah… I do. It’s clean and legible and that’s all there is to it.

Did you have a real response in mind? Something relevant to the topic perhaps, since my font size is not?:ehh:
 
Silly me, and here I thought it was the responsibility of the individuals who actually did the shooting, bombing and gassing and signed the orders for the killings etc etc - and who called themselves all sorts of things, including “Catholic”, “Protestant” and “atheist” 🤷

Have you learned nothing from the Nuremberg Trials? Didn’t they state in so many words that the responsibility for these atrocities lies squarely on the shoulders of those who commit them? And that the individual cannot shift blame - not even onto military superiors who give the actual orders let alone religious superiors???
I’m sorry for being so annoying as to suggest that the Catholic Church should accept some responsibility for the past - John Paul II was obviously wrong.
 
Yeah… I do. It’s clean and legible and that’s all there is to it.

Did you have a real response in mind? Something relevant to the topic perhaps, since my font size is not?:ehh:
I don’t like being shouted at - even by moderators.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top