Challenge from a Skeptic re: Miracles

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh and also - God is more about the soul. Not that He doesn’t answer prayers concerning our physical bodies and other physical needs, but I can attest that God has never left a prayer for spiritual help unanswered for me.
 
It is the loss of those who do not believe. It affects me not at all, except in my prayers for them.
Thats fine, but it does make you look like a hypocrite on a public forum.
[Evolution
And in what way does evolution discredit science as being something people want to see? Arguements from ignorance will not be accepted fyi.
[My computer is not faith powered. How does that fit into the argument you present?
I guess the irony that you are using a product developed by scientific principles to complain that scientists are deluded escapes you.😉
[Have you checked every single scientific journal since 1960 published everywhere in the world? Would medical journals do?
Nope as there are a few that arnt in english. I do have access to 20 different databases and no evidence comes up.
[And explain to me why they would publish something on a valid miracle. It is not scientific…it is miraculous and spiritual. They talk about science in those journals…not things that cannot be proven with science. Just like they don’t teach miracles in medical school. They spend time teaching about medicine in medical school.
There are several new ideas that recommend further study. Whats required first is for SOME objective evidence to be presented.
[Have their been as many tests done on those fountains as there have been on the stigmata of Padre Pio? Oh, wait. You haven’t done the research on Padre Pio to possibly have the knowledge to answer that?
Thats because no research exists.:rolleyes:
[Why? What you quoted was grammatically correct.
Thats not the kind of period I was referring to.😃
[Never heard of him. I know that any power that does not come from God is evil.
What a lovely cop-out lol.
I looked on the website you provided. That gave neither dates, nor interviews with the afflicted in a way that was explained at all. It was a jumble of words, and not making much sense. I couldn’t tell who the person was talking about, when it happened, or where the person was. A general location of Europe would not be sufficient, but that is what they might as well have said. They gave no evidence at all.
[/quote]

[/quote]

[/quote]

[/quote]

[/quote]

[/quote]

Lying again are we? Tsk tsk. It cited where the information came from clearly.
[And if that kind of evidence is all you need, simply because it may have been found in one of your journals, then you should have no problem believing about the miracles of Padre Pio. The Church did a very medical and scientific profile of all that was involved with Padre Pio. You just have to do the research
Back up your arguements with evidence. This is getting tiresome. Put up or shut up, to put it bluntly.
You made an arguement that you are unwilling to defend. There is no reason to take you seriously.

Jesus N Cherie;4047238 said:
*

Yes you are. You are also being intellectually dishonest.

Jesus N Cherie;4047238 said:
[It would help you to understand exactly where the evidence came from, and how it was proven correct if you do the research. We have already told you where to go in order to find the evidence YOU seek.
You have yet to cite a single academic source.

PS. If you are going to continue to be intellectually and dishonest, then don’t bother responding as Im getting tired of it.
Either you can defend your claim that there exists academic evidence or miraclaes, or you can’t. Simple as that.
[/quote]

[/quote]

[/quote]
 
Sideline:

I just wanted to let you know I don’t believe that you are actually an individual that is posting on the forum. I think it’s a hoax. In fact I think everyone beside me on this forum topic is the same person posting to themselves on different accounts to generate a discussion. Can you prove me wrong?
Burden of proof would be on you to demonstrate that everyone posting is really one person.
I want undeniable proof and I have to see it with my own eyes, I don’t care if 10’s, 100’s, or 1000’s of people claim they have seen you write you and only your posts. Once again, I must see it for myself, with my own eyes.
Just ask a mod for IP addresses.
 
PS. If you are going to continue to be intellectually and dishonest, then don’t bother responding as Im getting tired of it.
Either you can defend your claim that there exists academic evidence or miraclaes, or you can’t. Simple as that.
C’mon, can’t we be respectful of each other at all? Disagree with believers - fine, debate it - fine, but go so low as to name-call… You don’t have to be Christian to have values. Let’s keep this polite and respectful please.
 
C’mon, can’t we be respectful of each other at all? Disagree with believers - fine, debate it - fine, but go so low as to name-call… You don’t have to be Christian to have values. Let’s keep this polite and respectful please.
In what way have I name called? S/he has been misrepresenting my posts, and continously keeps trying to shift the burden of proof.
 
Burden of proof would be on you to demonstrate that everyone posting is really one person.
You can’t definitively prove the miracles didn’t happen, yet you argue against them for your lack of seeing evidence yourself. So how come I must prove my opinion, while instead of prove your all you point out is that they can’t be proved.
Just ask a mod for IP addresses.
That would entail me trusting a mod, putting faith in him. Sorry but that breaks the rules, otherwise you guys couldn’t bash us placing our trust in the witness of these various miracles.

It seems to me you only want to put your ‘scientific’ standards on arguments that go against you and not for you.
 
You can’t definitively prove the miracles didn’t happen,
Something noone argued.
yet you argue against them for your lack of seeing evidence yourself. So how come I must prove my opinion,
Burden of proof lies with the person making the positive claim
while instead of prove your all you point out is that they can’t be proved.
Actually, the arguement is that there is no objective proof.
That would entail me trusting a mod, putting faith in him.
Mods run the forum, logically it would be the place to start.
Sorry but that breaks the rules, otherwise you guys couldn’t bash us placing our trust in the witness of these various miracles.
Ah shifting the goal post fallacy, we meet again.

Here what you originally said “I want undeniable proof and I have to see it with my own eyes, I don’t care if 10’s, 100’s, or 1000’s of people claim they have seen you write you and only your posts. Once again, I must see it for myself, with my own eyes.”

This can be accomplished by checking IP addresses and the boards records of said addresses activities.
It seems to me you only want to put your ‘scientific’ standards on arguments that go against you and not for you.
I have no idea what this means.
 
Something noone argued.
Nor did I claim it, I said it in preparation for the next statement. You can’t pull bits of pieces to make it sound like I was saying something I wasn’t.
Burden of proof lies with the person making the positive claim…Actually, the arguement is that there is no objective proof.
My argument is the same as yours but differently applied. My argument, also, is that there is no objective proof. Therefore I don’t see how I made a positive claim. Sure I stated where I stand, but so did you guys.
Mods run the forum, logically it would be the place to start.
Likewise wouldn’t the witnesses be the first place to start? Or perhaps the Moderator, namely, God. Though then we’re led into a whole new range of different hypothetical which its best we not enter.
This can be accomplished by checking IP addresses and the boards records of said addresses activities.
Sure, but the problem is that I myself haven’t been moderating the IP address records nor do I have access to them. Therefore I have to place my trust in both the person telling me the results (if I’m being told) or if I see it first-hand I have to trust no one has tampered with those records. I know it sounds ridiculous, but you guys are applying the same standards on our belief in the miracles. Whereas we believe, for example, in Padre Pio’s case that the various secular doctors and religious witnesses were not lying about what they saw, you guys would make claim to the invalidity of these people. And in the tests scientists performed you discard the results. Therefore in the same way I dismiss the equivalent of the scientists and witness, the moderators, and I also dismiss the validity of the equivalent to the test results, the IP records.
 
My argument is the same as yours but differently applied.
Not really as you tried to shift the burden of proof.
My argument, also, is that there is no objective proof. Therefore I don’t see how I made a positive claim. Sure I stated where I stand, but so did you guys.
There doesn’t have to be as you position lies on shifting the burden of proof which is a fallacy. I just as easily say “prove unicorns never existed”.
Likewise wouldn’t the witnesses be the first place to start?
No, as the situation you presented has the witnesses suspect to begin with.
Or perhaps the Moderator, namely, God. Though then we’re led into a whole new range of different hypothetical which its best we not enter.
Not comparable as the mod can be defined. God can’t without delving into incoherence.
Sure, but the problem is that I myself haven’t been moderating the IP address records nor do I have access to them.
Print screen and send.
Therefore I have to place my trust in both the person telling me the results (if I’m being told) or if I see it first-hand I have to trust no one has tampered with those records.
Print screen and send. Just get a friend to request the same thing and if the time on the photos doesn;t match the time lapsed, then you know its been tampered.
I know it sounds ridiculous, but you guys are applying the same standards on our belief in the miracles.
No we arn’t. It was argued that objective scientific evidence existed in regards to Padre Pio. Nothing has been presented except fallacies and misrepresentation.
Whereas we believe, for example, in Padre Pio’s case that the various secular doctors and religious witnesses were not lying about what they saw, you guys would make claim to the invalidity of these people. And in the tests scientists performed you discard the results.
It would seem none of experts felt confident enough to publish their findings in any academic journals. The person credibility and motivations then becomes irrelevant as irregardless of what might’ve happened, no objective evidence exists.
Therefore in the same way I dismiss the equivalent of the scientists and witness, the moderators, and I also dismiss the validity of the equivalent to the test results, the IP records.
As I mentioned, your example is not only flawed, but a non-sequiter as well.
 
We don’t pray for God to give us a diagnosis? We pray for His healing. And remember, your on a Catholic forum, not some crazy evangelist one. We believe in going to doctors and all and that we, as children of God, have the utmost responsibility to preserve and protect out bodies (gifts of God) as we mortally can.
So… evangelicals that trust in God to heal them are crazy? You really don’t have that much faith after all in God’s healing powers then, do you?
Also remember that in being Catholics we believe, unlike most Protestant sects, in faith AND reason. The laws of science and of God must not conflict each other - this we know (for obvious, logical reasons). Therefore we must, in our faith, take into account everything which science has proved or theorized to a likely extent. This is most evidently seen in the Catholic Church’s acceptance of the possibility of evolution and clarifying that it wouldn’t contradict anything about our faith.
Do you think that you are building rapport with me by slamming protestants? You aren’t.
The scientific method has its uses, but they’re limited. It provides no answers to those bigger questions in life.
Yes it does. Just not the big, imaginary questions.
 
Ok I apologize on my behalf. I’m not a lawyer and it appears I’ve left some legal loopholes in my original argument, which you have so nicely pointed out. However you divulging too much into the argument I tried to make a connection with (that I just came up with on the spot, better examples can be made of course) instead of the point of what I was trying to say which was this: When someone refutes something, whether generally accepted or not (for example my argument was against what was generally accepted), its very hard to prove anything if looked at in a purely scientific way without common sense.

And the round-up point I was trying to make was that if you can’t prove hardly anything with a purely scientific method, how can you guys point out that because you can’t find that proof in these various that they can’t be true (since you can’t derive proof from many arguments)?

Anyway honestly this isn’t a very interesting topic. We’re not debating theology nor are we giving things to prove or disprove the various miracles (which by the way are up to the individual Catholic to decide if they want to believe them). Also we’re not making progress and this thread is much too overgrown. So I bid you farewell. I think we both understand where each other stand and come from and so in this case I don’t think we can make much more progress than that.

Anyway so nice chatting with you guys, peace be with you always.
 
Anyway honestly this isn’t a very interesting topic…

Also we’re not making progress and this thread is much too overgrown…

So I bid you farewell. I think we both understand where each other stand and come from and so in this case I don’t think we can make much more progress than that…
If it’s any consolation, I agree with all these points! 🙂

We probably would all feel better if we stopped beating our heads against the wall on this topic. :banghead:

Cheers.
 
So… evangelicals that trust in God to heal them are crazy? You really don’t have that much faith after all in God’s healing powers then, do you?
No, however what I am saying is that it is sacrilegious to presume God’s healing and not strive to fix things yourself through a doctor. God has a plan of which I do not know, and everything fits in and it is because of this that some prayers are answered and some not. So being that not all prayers are answered, it is my duty as someone sane and respectful of God’s gift of body to us that I see a doctor (if I can afford it of course). It’s been said God helps those who help themselves. You aren’t suppose to be a bum and do nothing presuming God will answer the prayer that He provide you with everything.
Do you think that you are building rapport with me by slamming protestants? You aren’t.
That’s not what I’m trying to do, so I apologize if I came across that way. I just realize lots of atheists find Christians ‘crazy’ because of some of the beliefs within Protestant sects that are not the beliefs of Catholics. Therefore I make sure we are on the same page.
Yes it does. Just not the big, imaginary questions.
Only can it apply to the physical things of this world. It has no being in anything supernatural - whether to prove or disprove, it’s just not its place. Just as rats aren’t meant to live in ant farms (and I have no clue why I just chose that as an example).

As I alerted Isambad, I think this topic has become overgrown and since I believe we understand each others positions, we have made all progress as can be made here. Therefor this will be the last post on this thread. Peace be with you always.
 
When someone refutes something, whether generally accepted or not (for example my argument was against what was generally accepted), its very hard to prove anything if looked at in a purely scientific way without common sense.
Not if properly evidenced and documented. It is tedious certainly, but not necessarily hard. Just look at some of theories that are out there already.
And the round-up point I was trying to make was that if you can’t prove hardly anything with a purely scientific method, how can you guys point out that because you can’t find that proof in these various that they can’t be true (since you can’t derive proof from many arguments)?
The arguement from the last 10pgs has simply been that these miracals are in academic journals, not that they exist/don’t exist. The former is easily demonstrable. Nothing comes up when typed into a academic database, then it doesn’t exist.😃
Anyway honestly this isn’t a very interesting topic. We’re not debating theology nor are we giving things to prove or disprove the various miracles (which by the way are up to the individual Catholic to decide if they want to believe them). Also we’re not making progress and this thread is much too overgrown. So I bid you farewell. I think we both understand where each other stand and come from and so in this case I don’t think we can make much more progress than that.

Anyway so nice chatting with you guys, peace be with you always.
Agreed. The last 10 or so pgs has basically just been one poster dancing around a yes/no question. Anyways, have a good night.👍
 
What is this thread talking about now? I left it the other day and now it is about who is lying and who is shifting the burden of proof.

It appears to me that some of the Catholics that are defending the faith on this thread don’t know too much about the miracles they are discussing. They may know about them, like I do, but don’t know the specifics (aka don’t have research from a secular authority). This in turn is what the skeptics are using as ammunition to prove the sketchy-ness of the christian faith.

In my opinion (I am entitled to one right?), I think the skeptics on this thread are being very rational, and have not been mean or rude or insulting, etc. They just represent the opposite side of the miracles arguement (the “They didn’t happen” side). We (Catholics) should not be so quick to get angry because they don’t believe the same things we do. There are always a minimum of two sides to every arguement, so basically they are the “other side”.

So this may or may not be helpful, but if you don’t have a link to research done on a “miracle”, it probably won’t help the arguement to briefly bring it up. The skeptics will continue to ask for proof or a source and will just aggrivate you until you go crazy. If anyone has a legit miracle with actual data and research, it would be useful in this discussion. I hope that both sides can remain open-minded to all data presented, if it is suitable for discussion in the first place. If we want to go based on opinions, then you have no room for arguement because it is just that, an opinion.

Sorry for the long post, I just hope to see actual data of miracles to talk about and I am tired of reading posts about “well you said this” or “you lied about this”, etc.
 
We don’t pray for God to give us a diagnosis? We pray for His healing. And remember, your on a Catholic forum, not some crazy evangelist one. We believe in going to doctors and all and that we, as children of God, have the utmost responsibility to preserve and protect out bodies (gifts of God) as we mortally can.

Also remember that in being Catholics we believe, unlike most Protestant sects, in faith AND reason. The laws of science and of God must not conflict each other - this we know (for obvious, logical reasons). Therefore we must, in our faith, take into account everything which science has proved or theorized to a likely extent. This is most evidently seen in the Catholic Church’s acceptance of the possibility of evolution and clarifying that it wouldn’t contradict anything about our faith.

The scientific method has its uses, but they’re limited. It provides no answers to those bigger questions in life.
Well actually it would contradict in a few areas. Eve coming from Adam, preternatural gifts, and bodily immortality.
 
Thats fine, but it does make you look like a hypocrite on a public forum.

How do you come by that?

And in what way does evolution discredit science as being something people want to see? Arguements from ignorance will not be accepted fyi.

Which is exactly why your arguments are not accepted.

I guess the irony that you are using a product developed by scientific principles to complain that scientists are deluded escapes you.😉

Science proves itself wrong many times. God never changes.

Nope as there are a few that arnt in english. I do have access to 20 different databases and no evidence comes up.

My argument still stands. Why would something that isn’t about science be put into a scientific journal? Miracles aren’t scientific…and science cannot explain them. So why would they be in a scientific journal?

There are several new ideas that recommend further study. Whats required first is for SOME objective evidence to be presented.

The objective evidence was already tested and proven to be miraculous, as science could not explain it. You have to do your research to find out what was done and how it was proven. I shall not do the leg work for you.

Thats because no research exists.:rolleyes:

Yes, it does. You denying that it exists is as worthless as anyone’s claim that Jesus didn’t rise from the dead. Just because you haven’t seen it…especially when you haven’t tried to find it in the place it does exist…doesn’t mean that it doesn’t. Even though you cannot see me from where you sit, doesn’t mean I don’t exist. You just have to look for it in the place it is…which you have already been led to.

Thats not the kind of period I was referring to.😃

Huh?

What a lovely cop-out lol.

There has been no cop out. You simply don’t understand and unfortuntatly you seem to deny anything you cannot understand.

Lying again are we? Tsk tsk. It cited where the information came from clearly.

there were nothing clear in what you gave on that website in so far as evidence of the type you are asking for us to provide for yourself.

Back up your arguements with evidence. This is getting tiresome. Put up or shut up, to put it bluntly.

Yes, your arguments against miracles are indeed getting tiresome. Do the research before you say it isn’t scientific or that it is untrue.

You made an arguement that you are unwilling to defend. There is no reason to take you seriously.

You mean that you don’t understand or will not accept…irregardless of the common sense truth of it. There is no reason to take what you say as serious as long as you haven’t done the research. You are arguing against something you know nothing about.

Yes you are. You are also being intellectually dishonest.

***I am being totally honest. I don’t need a high IQ score in order to understand common sense. That is the problem with many who have high IQ scores. They look for high levels of intellectualism in everything. If it is simple yet true, they give it no credit because it does nothing to give them a sense of superiority. It is a form of pride on their part. ***

You have yet to cite a single academic source.
I am not a walking library. I know that evidence exists for what has been our claim about Padre Pio. You are the one who has a problem believing it. Why should I do your leg work for you. Contact the Vatican, and they will lead you in the right direction for finding the evidence you apparently need to see before you agree that it exists. Why should I go through the trouble, especially when you…because of your skepticism…will just deny its authenticity?

PS. If you are going to continue to be intellectually and dishonest, then don’t bother responding as Im getting tired of it.
Either you can defend your claim that there exists academic evidence or miraclaes, or you can’t. Simple as that.
See ya on your next post.
 
Another post providing no evidence. I think I can safely say you have nothing to back your claims. Thanks for wasted 10pgs+ avoiding a question, at least you are consistant. I think Im done with you as Im tired of your intellectual dishonesty.

Cheers.
 
Another post providing no evidence. I think I can safely say you have nothing to back your claims. Thanks for wasted 10pgs+ avoiding a question, at least you are consistant. I think Im done with you as Im tired of your intellectual dishonesty.

Cheers.
Skeptics can’t win against the Truth. You haven’t done the research…which would have been the scientific thing to do. How could you think to prove a point by just accusing? I sincerely hope that the Faith of Christ Jesus will be planted in your heart and that you will soon be counted among those who follow His Way, Truth and Life.
In the following words, I am being totally sincere. I was not trying to attack or insult your person. I merely defended the Truth of which I pray you will come to. I will be praying for you and the health of your soul.
 
Another post providing no evidence. I think I can safely say you have nothing to back your claims. Thanks for wasted 10pgs+ avoiding a question, at least you are consistant. I think Im done with you as Im tired of your intellectual dishonesty.

Cheers.
Ahhh - the old intellectual dishonesty ploy. What are the underlying assumptions of intellectual honesty?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top