Challenge from a Skeptic re: Miracles

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Pretty darn close wouldn’t you say?
disrupting christians and messing with the faith of christians are entirely different things.

By disrupting I mean getting people wound up. By messing with the faith of christians I assume one to ridicule one for believing in a God.
 
I think it is rather odd that the purpose of this thread has gone from responding to claims that there are no real miracles, to trying to prove that I am trying to “disrupt Christians” (What does that even mean?)

Why not prove me wrong if it is so easy to do so instead of trying to convince people I am a bad person?
 
It’s amazing how rotten you can make a person sound when you look at only one side of an argument isn’t it?

Although, I have to say you are stretching a little. How is saying someone isn’t delusional a bad thing? Should I have said, “Yes, you are delusional?”

And how is, “That’s good.” Insulting? That’s really a stretch.
Again, these responses were the ones that the skeptics used in response to points posted by non-skeptics. I refer to these as the way you proved the skeptics wrong (aka your arguement does not hold water). If you had substantial evidence to prove God does not exist, you would not say things like “whatever floats your boat”. I did not say these things were used to insult christians. You are continuing to prove my point. 🙂
 
I think it is rather odd that the purpose of this thread has gone from responding to claims that there are no real miracles, to trying to prove that I am trying to “disrupt Christians” (What does that even mean?)

Why not prove me wrong if it is so easy to do so instead of trying to convince people I am a bad person?
I have proved that the skeptic can never be proven correct. I have not said you were a bad person. I said you were on this site trying to disrupt christians (aka get people wound up, get people bickering, etc). I never said you were mean or rude or insulting. I said your points tend to get to a “whatever” line after a while, but other than that, I have no problem with you or other skeptics. I think it is good that there are skeptics because they keep up on the balls of our feet. You being skeptical also shows that you are looking for the truth, and in time, maybe it will lead you to the church.
 
By skeptic, I am assuming you do not believe in a God.The skeptic I am refering to (as most are) is the one that believe science is what explains everything, not religion.
Religious Skepticism says nothing about God. That said, who ever said science explains everything?
With science as the explaining force, there would be no possible room for a God. My explaination listed above is showing that there is indeed room for God within science. There are many spaces that cannot prove God does not exist. Science will never be able to prove God does not exist.
Thats nice, but god concepts being unfaslifiable were never brought up in this thread, so I have no idea who you are addressing.
Therefore, a skeptic can never be proven correct. If you are thinking of some other sort of skeptic, this does not apply to them because it is not the issue at hand.
Of course not, what you argued against was a stawman. The main arguements of the thread were that miracals were supernatural events that had academic backing as evidence. When asked to present this info, those who were vocal about the existence of said evidence, abandoned the thread. Ergo, unless proper objective evidence is presented, the claim is proven void by default.
The responses that I refer to are the ones such as…

“Whatever floats your boat.”
“It isn’t delusional. It’s obviously a fairly common belief.”
"That’s good. "
“I can’t. I can’t prove that the sun isn’t pulled through the heavens by an invisible chariot either. I still think the idea of invisible chariots is rather silly.”

These were responses to points made by “believers”. This is the type of response that does not win arguements and proves nature of your visit.
No it doesn’t, as disinterest in strawman arguements, and reducto ad absurdum are perfectly valid.
 
Catholicism is called a religion. It is also called a FAITH.

That being said, it takes faith to believe in what Catholicism is and believes and teaches. One cannot prove today by science that Christ Jesus rose from the dead and ascended into Heaven. It is something that takes faith.

Just because we, who are Catholic, have heard stories all of our life and read things by Catholic scholars and medical scientists who were there to witness and examine the miracles of God given as a witness to the world through Padre Pio doesn’t mean that we have a memory to the exact books, doctors names and documents to prove it is truth.

Most of us are not walking Catholic library catalogs. We learned these things through time, and we did not have problems believing them, because we know that Jesus is capable. So many of us take a lot of these things on faith. And, as Catholics who talk about our Faith with others of like Faith, we have an opportunity to learn more about what God is doing in the world through others of our Faith. I don’t have to demand scientific evidence proven by the academic scientists of today’s world in order to believe. Faith carries me a long way toward the truth. Unbelief carries those who require such proof…without doing the research themselves…to continue to reject the truth.

Why is it that you expect us to do the research for you? And if we refuse, you may feel justified in your rejection of miracles? We have told you that if you contact the Vatican, they can steer you in the right direction for your research. As a matter of fact, someone on the thread told you what office of the Vatican to contact. You simply do not wish to do so. You want us to do it for you. The problem with this is that we have no need to do so, as we do not require to see and hold such evidence. You, as a skeptic of miracles, are the one who supposedly needs it. And even if you held the evidence in your hands, you would, no doubt, deny it. You have an idea of who has to approve it as a miracle in order for you to believe it. My question to you is, what makes this person or organization more trustworthy or knowledgable about TRUTH than those who did the scientific and medical examinations? And you cannot say it is that those who did the examination were biased. The Church did much better than that. They were aware that no bias could be used in the proving of the miracles of Padre Pio…among many others…in order for it to be believed.

What I suggest you do if you require proof because of your lack of faith is do the research yourself. Coming on to CAF on the Apologetics Forum was for the purpose of stealing the peace from we believers. You could have asked the question on the Encyclopedia Forum, or another one. You came to Apologetics in order to debate…without a desire to be provided with proof. And then you do not accept what is said…and you knew you wouldn’t, no matter what was said or provided. It proves that you were not coming here for any good reason.

I hope though, that seeds of faith have somehow been planted, and that you will come to faith in Jesus Christ, Who created, loved, died and rose again for you, Who wants very much to be acknowledged by you, and Who wants to spend eternity with you. He will never force you…as that is against love. And Jesus is Love. He is using this forum to try to reach you. I hope you let Him in to your heart, that these seeds of Faith in Him will grow.

Peace.
 
Unbelief carries those who require such proof…without doing the research themselves…to continue to reject the truth.
Sorry buddy, my research has shown that there is no credible objective evidence.
Why is it that you expect us to do the research for you? And if we refuse, you may feel justified in your rejection of miracles?
Ever hear of the burden of proof?
We have told you that if you contact the Vatican, they can steer you in the right direction for your research. As a matter of fact, someone on the thread told you what office of the Vatican to contact. You simply do not wish to do so. You want us to do it for you.
The Vatican isn’t an objective academic source.
The problem with this is that we have no need to do so, as we do not require to see and hold such evidence.
You make the claim, you provide the evidence to back up your claim.
You, as a skeptic of miracles, are the one who supposedly needs it. And even if you held the evidence in your hands, you would, no doubt, deny it. You have an idea of who has to approve it as a miracle in order for you to believe it. My question to you is, what makes this person or organization more trustworthy or knowledgable about TRUTH than those who did the scientific and medical examinations?
No scientific evidence has been presented.
And you cannot say it is that those who did the examination were biased. The Church did much better than that. They were aware that no bias could be used in the proving of the miracles of Padre Pio…among many others…in order for it to be believed.
So then why the lack of academic sources?
What I suggest you do if you require proof because of your lack of faith is do the research yourself.
I have.
Coming on to CAF on the Apologetics Forum was for the purpose of stealing the peace from we believers. You could have asked the question on the Encyclopedia Forum, or another one. You came to Apologetics in order to debate…without a desire to be provided with proof.
As I recall, noone forced you into this thread. Noone forced you to make claims you couldn’t back up. Don’t complain when you get called on it.
And then you do not accept what is said…and you knew you wouldn’t, no matter what was said or provided. It proves that you were not coming here for any good reason.
Obviously requesting that claims be backed with objective evidence is a sign of malice on our part:rolleyes:
 
Sorry buddy, my research has shown that there is no credible objective evidence.

Have you contacted the Vatican? If so, what office? Who did you talk to? When, exactly did the conversation occur? Prove to me that you talked to someone, and what exactly was said by each party during the conversation.

Ever hear of the burden of proof?

You have come on to CAF and claimed that there were no miracles. The burden of proof is on you to prove we are wrong for our claim that they are true miracles.

The Vatican isn’t an objective academic source.

The Vatican is the place where the research and evidence you claim to seek is found. That does not make it non objective. It makes it the library.

You make the claim, you provide the evidence to back up your claim.

You made the claim. The name of the thread is Skeptic re: Miracles. You claim that what we believe are miracles are really hallucinations or figments of our irrational minds…or what ever you have claimed. The burden of proof is yours.

No scientific evidence has been presented.

You have done no research, and the Apologetics Forum is not, nor has it ever been the Vatican’s Library.

So then why the lack of academic sources?

There are no lack of sources. Why do you refuse to look where you have been told to look for the academic sources?

I have.

As I recall, noone forced you into this thread. Noone forced you to make claims you couldn’t back up. Don’t complain when you get called on it.

I have only been called on the fact that I am not a human reference section of a library that holds the knowledge you claim to need in order to believe. However, I have enough knowledge to point you in the direction you obviously reject for reasons I have already stated.

Obviously requesting that claims be backed with objective evidence is a sign of malice on our part:rolleyes:
***Where is your scientific proof that no miracles have taken place? Where is your scientific proof that the evidence in the Vatican about Padre Pio is false? Where is your objective evidence?

Trying to steal the peace of the Faithful Catholic Christians on this forum is an act of malice.***
 
Why is it that you expect us to do the research for you? And if we refuse, you may feel justified in your rejection of miracles?
With their scientists, no less. And if “no natural cause” is found, clearly that’s just a law of physics we haven’t discovered yet.
 
With their scientists, no less. And if “no natural cause” is found, clearly that’s just a law of physics we haven’t discovered yet.
You have proved my point about why skeptics are here, what they are trying to do here, and the futility of wasting my time trying to prove to them what it takes faith to believe.

Without faith, no amount of evidence is good enough.
With faith, no amount of evidence is needed
.

Thank you, Lord Jesus, truly present in the Holy Eucharist…which is a miracle in itself, for the precious gift of Faith.

I pray all of you skeptics will come to believe with faith.
 
faith Audio Help /feɪθ/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[feyth] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation
–noun 1. confidence or trust in a person or thing: faith in another’s ability.
2. belief that is not based on proof: He had faith that the hypothesis would be substantiated by fact.
3. belief in God or in the doctrines or teachings of religion: the firm faith of the Pilgrims.
4. belief in anything, as a code of ethics, standards of merit, etc.: to be of the same faith with someone concerning honesty.
**5. a system of religious belief: the Christian faith; the Jewish faith. **
6. the obligation of loyalty or fidelity to a person, promise, engagement, etc.: Failure to appear would be breaking faith.
7. the observance of this obligation; fidelity to one’s promise, oath, allegiance, etc.: He was the only one who proved his faith during our recent troubles.
**8. Christian Theology. the trust in God and in His promises as made through Christ and the Scriptures by which humans are justified or saved. **
—Idiom9. in faith, in truth; indeed: In faith, he is a fine lad.
As a christian with faith, as defined above, I do not need proof to justify my position. If a skeptic wants to argue a person with faith (who needs no proof other than what they have) they would have to be the one to provide it. It is a moot point to ask a person relying on faith to provide proof.
 
Where is your scientific proof that no miracles have taken place?
Nice strawman. The arguement is that there is nor eason to assume miracals as there is no objective evidence. Its a faith based position to assume miracals, not a scientific one.
[Where is your scientific proof that the evidence in the Vatican about Padre Pio is false? Where is your objective evidence?
Strawman number 2. The Vatican has yet to try and publish its findings in any scientific journals. Ergo, no objective evidence exists.
[Trying to steal the peace of the Faithful Catholic Christians on this forum is an act of malice.
I didn’t start the thread, nor did I force you to make claims you couldn’t back up. You claimed you needed time to get the scientific studies, then abandoned the thread when you couldn’t any. Now you are here trying to strawman your critics.

Quick Note

To quote someone’s points, highlight the first bracket ie.
Jesus N Cherie;4045399 :
. Its very tedious for for me to do it for you.
[/quote]

[/quote]
 
As a christian with faith, as defined above, I do not need proof to justify my position. If a skeptic wants to argue a person with faith (who needs no proof other than what they have) they would have to be the one to provide it. It is a moot point to ask a person relying on faith to provide proof.
The arguement J. N. Cherie put forward was that faith wasn’t required as objective scientific evidence exists.
 
The arguement J. N. Cherie put forward was that faith wasn’t required as objective scientific evidence exists.
So are you (or rather JN Cherie) indicating that with adequate proof, one no longer needs faith?
 
Nice strawman. The arguement is that there is nor eason to assume miracals as there is no objective evidence. Its a faith based position to assume miracals, not a scientific one.

***there is no reason for the argument as the Vatican does not need to use what “you” consider objective evidence. Many of today’s “academic evidence scientistis” do not believe in what is right in front of them if it disproves what they want to be the truth. They are not interested in the truth, only interested in appearing correct in order to keep those of you who follow faithfully. ***

Strawman number 2. The Vatican has yet to try and publish its findings in any scientific journals. Ergo, no objective evidence exists.

***This doesn’t mean it is any less true. It is a matter of faith for the faithful. And it is backed up by scientific and medical evidence done by many who were not Catholic. As I said, the Catholic Church is not stupid, and it had to be proven by those who would be very skeptical before being accepted as truth. The fact is, skeptic medical doctors and scientific researchers could not explain it. It is an accepted miracle, as are many others.

Something that bleeds often, without a wound is not medically or scientifically possible. And there are no scars. Just because you have not yet been shown the pictures (as if that would make you accept it) of Padre Pio’s hands when they were not bleeding, does not make it any less true.***

I didn’t start the thread, nor did I force you to make claims you couldn’t back up. You claimed you needed time to get the scientific studies, then abandoned the thread when you couldn’t any. Now you are here trying to strawman your critics.

Although you may not have started the thread, you argued for the OP. And after realizing that it would take time and much research to find the evidence for you, I realized that if you were in need of it, I could point you in the correct direction…and you could do the research yourself. I have better things to do with my time than do the research for you. I have no need of the research myself, since I have no problem believing the truth…which is that miracles are indeed true…example of Padre Pio.
Quick Note

To quote someone’s points, highlight the first bracket ie.
Jesus N Cherie;4045399 :
. Its very tedious for for me to do it for you.
 
The arguement J. N. Cherie put forward was that faith wasn’t required as objective scientific evidence exists.
that was never my point!

My point was that, where faith exists, no “evidence outside of what the Church offers” is required. The Church does present objective scientific evidence. I just do not need to see it, or take it ouside of what the Church has already provided for proof in order to believe it.
 
So are you (or rather JN Cherie) indicating that with adequate proof, one no longer needs faith?
Do not lump me into that statement, as I vehemently deny that statement!!!

Faith is TOTALLY important!!!

I would be nowhere in my walk with Jesus, or able to believe in Jesus without FAITH!!!
 
Do not lump me into that statement, as I vehemently deny that statement!!!

Faith is TOTALLY important!!!

I would be nowhere in my walk with Jesus, or able to believe in Jesus without FAITH!!!
Im sorry JN Cherie, I didn’t realize that was you, and I believe you, faith is absolutly necessary. But is the skeptic saying that it is no longer necessary once proof is provided?
 
that was never my point! .
My apologese. I got confused as you keep saying this.
My point was that, where faith exists, no “evidence outside of what the Church offers” is required. The Church does present objective scientific evidence. I just do not need to see it, or take it ouside of what the Church has already provided for proof in order to believe it.
Objective evidence tends to render faith in something meaningless as it now becomes demonstrable.

For ex. If I told you I could jump 30 feet into the air, but only on certain days and in private. You could only take my word on faith.

If I jumped 30 feet in the air in front of a crowd of people and it was confirmed by scientists that its no trick, then objective evidence exists and no faith is required as I can simply show the person the evidence.
 
Is it just me, or is the text on this thread getting increasingly bigger?

I guess the original poster has got the answer to their question. They should just answer that blind faith should be enough for anyone. That people should have faith not only in miracles, but that the Church will investigate those miracles for them.

Of course, if they want to believe something that hasn’t been tested is also a miracle, why not? No one can prove that any good thing ever has happened without praying for it, so it isn’t a leap to think anything good thing happening is a miracle.

All of this seems a horrid way of living to me, but it is an incredibly popular point of view on this site. Oh well, to each their own. I, for one, won’t bother you anymore.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top