Challenge from a Skeptic re: Miracles

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That’s fine, but I won’t accept any studies done outside the academic process as objective simply because of the potential for bias. Its the same reason why I largely ignore stuff put out by the Discovery Institute, Harun Yahya, or Classical Marxists writings on modern economics.
I would, assuming that they did their research well, and covered all the bases. And assuming that they were open about their methods, and that their conclusions did not reach outside the scope of the test they constructed.
 
Though, even if were discussing God the father, I still can’t see why he would be inconsistant with miracals. I mean Jesus, the early prophets, the disciples, etc. can be said to do things waaay outside the confines of a natural phenomena (assuming it went down just as stated), so God had no problem awing people before. Why should he be concerned about being ambigious now? Argueably, it would do more good to awe us now, as the pontential for “evil” is greatly enhanced through technology.

I guess my problem in the above is more of a theology question, so I’m not really sure what I answer I would accept shrug.
.
Bear with me while I give my own rough theological type answer… 🙂

Jesus and the prophets were sent specifically to draw people to God. The disciples, too. Without them, God could not have built up a Church without denying at least some people their free will. There is nothing inconsistent about the way God works His Will. Just as He can use nature, He can use humans as His hands and legs and mouthpieces. You see, when prophets, Apostles, and Christ came in the flesh, there was still room for “wiggling,” as God the Father did not show His omnipotence in the vast, infinite, undeniable sense. People could (and did, and do) deny the workings of the Apostles, Prophets, and even Jesus Christ. Make no mistake about it, people did not believe Jesus, even after seeing His miracles. People fell away, and even demanded He be killed. If God the Father, however, unambiguously showed His raw, Divine Might without the use of a “mask,” so to speak, it would be undeniable and people would be robbed of free will due simply to His awesome majesty.

I hope that makes some amount of sense.
 
Bear with me while I give my own rough theological type answer… 🙂

Jesus and the prophets were sent specifically to draw people to God. The disciples, too. Without them, God could not have built up a Church without denying at least some people their free will. There is nothing inconsistent about the way God works His Will. Just as He can use nature, He can use humans as His hands and legs and mouthpieces. You see, when prophets, Apostles, and Christ came in the flesh, there was still room for “wiggling,” as God the Father did not show His omnipotence in the vast, infinite, undeniable sense. People could (and did, and do) deny the workings of the Apostles, Prophets, and even Jesus Christ. Make no mistake about it, people did not believe Jesus, even after seeing His miracles. People fell away, and even demanded He be killed. If God the Father, however, unambiguously showed His raw, Divine Might without the use of a “mask,” so to speak, it would be undeniable and people would be robbed of free will due simply to His awesome majesty.

I hope that makes some amount of sense.
God spoke directly to people in the Bible but they did not lose their free will. God does not need to show might in a great display of lights, but… how about just making sure people understand the facts? You have thousands of religions out there, that will work to sway people to all ends of the spectrum. How are people supposed to know which one religion out of them all is accurate (if any)?

So how about instead of having a hundred people tell me a hundred different things, all with their own “facts” to back it up, how about if God merely made sure that people know what the facts are? Simple clarity is all I’ve ever desired. How else can someone make a proper choice if they don’t know for sure what is real and what is fake? How would having unambiguous correct information take away free will?
 
How would having unambiguous correct information take away free will?
It wouldn’t; that isn’t what I said, and your question doesn’t really deal with the topic of this thread.

I have received unambiguous information, which after careful study of various information from different sources (eastern religions, naturalism, dharma, atheism, etc…), prayer, meditation, and deliberation I have accepted as correct and believe to be True. I am sorry you have not received the same certainty that I and countless others have from the Catholic Church.

May you one day enjoy the same certainty that millions of people already do. May the God and Author of Truth enlighten your mind and dispel your doubt.

Peace be with you.
 
I would, assuming that they did their research well, and covered all the bases. And assuming that they were open about their methods, and that their conclusions did not reach outside the scope of the test they constructed.
Sideline,

How about a non-religious study?

Which side is correct on the Global Warming issue? Both sides have scientific evidence to support their claims, and both claim the other side to be liars. Only one can be correct. What about the JFK assassination? Can you tell me the truth on those stories? Both sides have substancial evidence, yet we don’t know the truth? How does that work in with “science proves everything”?

Thank you for proving the skeptics wrong with your responses. It is evident that your sole purpose is to disrupt the christians on this website.🙂
 
I would, assuming that they did their research well, and covered all the bases. And assuming that they were open about their methods, and that their conclusions did not reach outside the scope of the test they constructed.
Yet none of it is published for scientific peer review. Again, how is it any different from various other groups that don’t feel confident enough for their “research” to through the academic process?
 
Sideline,

How about a non-religious study?

Which side is correct on the Global Warming issue? Both sides have scientific evidence to support their claims, and both claim the other side to be liars. Only one can be correct. What about the JFK assassination? Can you tell me the truth on those stories? Both sides have substancial evidence, yet we don’t know the truth? How does that work in with “science proves everything”?
Science deals with what there is evidence for. Given that with the exception of the Global Warming controversy, what has been mentioned (JKF stuff, and the church’s research), does not stand the test of the academic process, is telling of how seriously one should take them.
Thank you for proving the skeptics wrong with your responses. It is evident that your sole purpose is to disrupt the christians on this website.🙂
Care to demonstrate that?
 
Care to demonstrate that?
I already have. I demonstrated that there are plenty of allowances for God’s intervention, particularly the random movements of particles and atoms. No one has disputed that this is not possible. If you can indeed prove that the random movements and interactions of particles cannot be the act of a spiritual / all-powerful being, then we can continue the conversation.

I cannot prove that it is indeed God working through those random movements, but I cannot prove that it is not Him either. That window is large enough for God to work through. Because there are things in science that can never be explained, you cannot ever prove God to be nonexistant.

The term “safety-net” that I used earlier was not to mean God needs “help”. If God interacted with humans openly we would no longer have free will. Everyone would know of God and accept or reject him and the world would be over. I should have used the term “window” instead.
 
Sideline,

How about a non-religious study?

Which side is correct on the Global Warming issue? Both sides have scientific evidence to support their claims, and both claim the other side to be liars. Only one can be correct. What about the JFK assassination? Can you tell me the truth on those stories?
It is difficult to deduce the truth about climate change (a much more accurate description than global warming). You need to look not only at the claims that are being made, but also at the sciences that they make those claims on. But put in a lot of research and it becomes clear after awhile. You start to realize that one side is established scientific protocols and the other is “amazing new research”.

I can’t help you with the JFK thing. I’ve never seen any evidence that Oswald didn’t do it. I think it’s pretty easy to tell truth from fairy tales on that one.
Both sides have substancial evidence, yet we don’t know the truth? How does that work in with “science proves everything”?
When did I say that science proves everything? There is lots that science doesn’t know. We aren’t certain how life evolved from non-life; what makes up dark matter; what happened before the big bang; what version, if any, of super string theory is true.

I’ve never claimed that science proves everything. What I claim is much more modest. If you test for something badly, you haven’t proved anything.
Thank you for proving the skeptics wrong with your responses. It is evident that your sole purpose is to disrupt the christians on this website.🙂
And how have I proved the sceptics wrong? Because we haven’t resorted to personal attacks?

Newsflash for all those Catholics that need to study up on their faith:*** It’s not based on unconfirmed miracles or Padre Pio!***

I know this sounds crazy, but Catholicism ticked along for 2,000 years before Padre Pio decided to start duping it into thinking he was a holy man.

If you don’t like my posts, stop responding. If you think I am breaking the rules, report the post. Otherwise, stop telling me what I’m doing on this website, because there is no possible way you could know.
 
Newsflash for all those Catholics that need to study up on their faith:*** It’s not based on unconfirmed miracles or Padre Pio!***

I know this sounds crazy, but Catholicism ticked along for 2,000 years before Padre Pio decided to start duping it into thinking he was a holy man.
I don’t think there’s any call to be cruel. A rise in temper never solves anything, and snide remarks just add to the temper of others.

If you don’t care to believe, then simply don’t. But please don’t say anyone was a fake, a phony, or a dupe. That is undermining a lot of people’s beliefs–beliefs held by highly educated, scholarly people just as much uneducated “blind” followers of doctrine. Insulting the intelligence of Catholics isn’t going to do any good. I respect you for your beliefs, and I hope that you can return the same respect. I was under the impression that we were having a civil conversation about belief in miracles, not insulting the intelligence of an extremely and academically developed religion. I guess I was wrong. Forgive me.

Blessings.
 
I don’t think there’s any call to be cruel. A rise in temper never solves anything, and snide remarks just add to the temper of others.

If you don’t care to believe, then simply don’t. But please don’t say anyone was a fake, a phony, or a dupe. That is undermining a lot of people’s beliefs–beliefs held by highly educated, scholarly people just as much uneducated “blind” followers of doctrine. Insulting the intelligence of Catholics isn’t going to do any good. I respect you for your beliefs, and I hope that you can return the same respect. I was under the impression that we were having a civil conversation about belief in miracles, not insulting the intelligence of an extremely and academically developed religion. I guess I was wrong. Forgive me.

Blessings.
You guys really need to brush up on the difference between Catholicism and revering Padre Pio. They aren’t the same thing.
 
Sideline,

Is your entire argument that people are fickle with their “prayers”. That they claim prayers helped their friend be healed from cancer or whatever, and when it doesn’t happen they claim “it was God’s will”? Thats a valid argument. And I feel the same way, especially with some christians I know. They are non-denom and every conversion or coming back into the church has some major prayer act involved, but they never include the people they pray for that don’t come back. It’s kind of like when you go to Vegas, and you win big. You never talk about the many many many times you lose, just the time you won.

I do think that prayer does help, however. Not necessarily in the nature of direct intervention, but it does help the pray-er, unless they are insincere. I haven’t looked into any studies, but it would seem that a person that prays would get over a tragic event allot easier than someone who doesnt, most of the time. The ones who are not devote but rely on prayer for all their answers, and get dissappointed are the ones that tend to leave the church, and become skeptics. That is understandable, its like never having Santa visit you when you are a child, you grow cold because all the other kids are happy and “receiving blessings”.
 
You guys really need to brush up on the difference between Catholicism and revering Padre Pio. They aren’t the same thing.
I wasn’t saying they were the same thing. There are miracles I don’t have faith in, and am still extremely Catholic. Don’t tell me what I believe.

What I’m saying is that some people do believe in miracles, so stop insulting our intelligence. Period.
 
Let me put on my prophecy hat for a minute. Sometime over the next few centuries (hopefully much sooner) medical science will be able to regenerate most lost limbs. Once the technology is available then we will see a marked increase in the number of limbs being miraculously restored. The Lourdes gift shop will not only have a good supply of used crutches but an excellent supply of prosthetic limbs as well.

I sure wish that little girl who recently lost her arm in a lawnmower accident could have her limb restored. Even if it did put my free will at risk.
 
Sideline,

Is your entire argument that people are fickle with their “prayers”. That they claim prayers helped their friend be healed from cancer or whatever, and when it doesn’t happen they claim “it was God’s will”? Thats a valid argument. And I feel the same way, especially with some christians I know. They are non-denom and every conversion or coming back into the church has some major prayer act involved, but they never include the people they pray for that don’t come back. It’s kind of like when you go to Vegas, and you win big. You never talk about the many many many times you lose, just the time you won.
Why is it that when I say that, I am “messing with the faith of Christians”, but you aren’t? Kind of hypocritical isn’t it?
I do think that prayer does help, however. Not necessarily in the nature of direct intervention, but it does help the pray-er, unless they are insincere.
I never said it didn’t.
I haven’t looked into any studies, but it would seem that a person that prays would get over a tragic event allot easier than someone who doesnt, most of the time.
Could be. I don’t have a problem with people praying. That’s not what this thread was about. It wasn’t, “Is there any justification for praying.” I never said people shouldn’t pray.
The ones who are not devote but rely on prayer for all their answers, and get dissappointed are the ones that tend to leave the church, and become skeptics. That is understandable, its like never having Santa visit you when you are a child, you grow cold because all the other kids are happy and “receiving blessings”.
Sorry, couldn’t follow what you are trying to say.
 
I already have. I demonstrated that there are plenty of allowances for God’s intervention, particularly the random movements of particles and atoms. No one has disputed that this is not possible. If you can indeed prove that the random movements and interactions of particles cannot be the act of a spiritual / all-powerful being, then we can continue the conversation.

I cannot prove that it is indeed God working through those random movements, but I cannot prove that it is not Him either. That window is large enough for God to work through. Because there are things in science that can never be explained, you cannot ever prove God to be nonexistant.

The term “safety-net” that I used earlier was not to mean God needs “help”. If God interacted with humans openly we would no longer have free will. Everyone would know of God and accept or reject him and the world would be over. I should have used the term “window” instead.
Thats nice, care to demonstate what that has to do with what you said?
Thank you for proving the skeptics wrong with your responses. It is evident that your sole purpose is to disrupt the christians on this website.
 
Why is it that when I say that, I am “messing with the faith of Christians”, but you aren’t? Kind of hypocritical isn’t it?
Yes it indeed would be hypocritical, if I had ever said that.
 
Thats nice, care to demonstate what that has to do with what you said?
By skeptic, I am assuming you do not believe in a God. The skeptic I am refering to (as most are) is the one that believe science is what explains everything, not religion. With science as the explaining force, there would be no possible room for a God. My explaination listed above is showing that there is indeed room for God within science. There are many spaces that cannot prove God does not exist. Science will never be able to prove God does not exist. Therefore, a skeptic can never be proven correct. If you are thinking of some other sort of skeptic, this does not apply to them because it is not the issue at hand.

The responses that I refer to are the ones such as…

“Whatever floats your boat.”
“It isn’t delusional. It’s obviously a fairly common belief.”
"That’s good. "
“I can’t. I can’t prove that the sun isn’t pulled through the heavens by an invisible chariot either. I still think the idea of invisible chariots is rather silly.”

These were responses to points made by “believers”. This is the type of response that does not win arguements and proves nature of your visit.
 
The responses that I refer to are the ones such as…

“Whatever floats your boat.”
“It isn’t delusional. It’s obviously a fairly common belief.”
"That’s good. "
“I can’t. I can’t prove that the sun isn’t pulled through the heavens by an invisible chariot either. I still think the idea of invisible chariots is rather silly.”

These were responses to points made by “believers”. This is the type of response that does not win arguements and proves nature of your visit.
It’s amazing how rotten you can make a person sound when you look at only one side of an argument isn’t it?

Although, I have to say you are stretching a little. How is saying someone isn’t delusional a bad thing? Should I have said, “Yes, you are delusional?”

And how is, “That’s good.” Insulting? That’s really a stretch.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top