Challenge from a Skeptic re: Miracles

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sorry champ, this thread quickly became about no miracals being recognized in objective academic studies. Either produce one, or you’ve lost.😉
Yes this thread was made as such by you because you want to hide the fact that you have way of actually braking the fact that miracles happen by God by this kind of fallacy…
 
Smashing up evolution is and was easy… it doesn’t take more then just saying there is no proof that one species can ever develop into another on a big scale… This would take a few million years to disprove or test, so evolution is not a real scientific theory, i think as a skeptic which i think you are trying to be you should know that…
LOL. I can see you have no idea what the theory of evolution says. I suggest you read one of the many threads dealing with it and educate yourself.
If Nietzsche was alive i think he might have pointed that one out…
He did, and he got it wrong in Twilight of the Idols, of course, Darwins idea was relatively new then so he can be forgiven for his ignorance. You hold no such excuse.
I kind of gotten the impression that Nietzsche was a nihilist… And i want to know how do you put Derrida and Nietzsche together? Because it sounds cool or because there is something real behind it?
Nietzsche say nihilism as inevitable because of the Enlightenment, and what it meant for the former religious thinking.

And Im curious how you find the two mutually exclusive given how Derrida himself got the idea of deconstructionism from reading Nietzsche.

As per calling myself a deconstructist-Nietzschean, its because its an accurate description of my worldview
By the way you haven’t smashed up any miracle you have just successfully avoided the subject… By claiming there is no academic source… Which is like claiming there is no creationist source for evolution… Come on… you should try a bit harder… To really disprove them…
I never set out to disprove them, just the claim that said miracals were backed by academic sources.
 
No this is not true… we can be bias on against religion and make good computers… don’t try to be less intellectual then you are… I was talking about Bias Against Religion of course and that doesn’t have too much to do with such issues as computers airplanes, medicine… Try a bit better, clear fallacy and you are caught…
Go back and re-read what Cherie actually said. She implied that it was so bias and unfactual.
JNS:My question to you is, what makes this person or organization more trustworthy or knowledgable about TRUTH than those who did the scientific and medical examinations?

You:*

No scientific evidence has been presented.
*
Exactly. Medicine follows the scientific method, so there would be an academic journal or two if any such evidence existed.
This was between you and Jesus n Cherie, I am sorry if i am mistaken but it sounds like you don’t think medicine is scientific…
It is, but not the “medicine” s/hes claiming. No academic evidence means that no scientific evidence (medicine included) exists.
O you never claimed so? I see then please check Vatican sources, investigate and find out the objective truth… It is very good for you to say that you never maid such a claim…
The Vatican is not an academic, nor a objective source. Honestly now, its like treating evidence presented by the Flat Earth Society as objective.
Yes you are right definition of objective is not quite the same as science though… hmmm… makes me wonder why…
Actually, it is.
Is it because something outside science can be objective? Or as your favourite Nietzsche might point out, maybe science is not objective but subjective depending on the subjective view point of the researches… Maybe…
Shame that Nietzsche’s hammer is the scientific method in a nutshell but then you being ignorant of philosophy in conjuntion of language and science isn’t exactly surprising.
Yes, it is the exactly the methods of yours otherwise you would be all over Vatican already… but since you haven’t looked from their for real evidence, it is a shame that ignorance does not give you any base in arguments… especially when you are ignorant on your own choosing…
Once the Vatican publishes its “research”, then Ill look into it. As it stands, its just an untested hypothesis.
 
Yes this thread was made as such by you because you want to hide the fact that you have way of actually braking the fact that miracles happen by God by this kind of fallacy…
Hmm, I got a sneaking suspicion you associate disagreement with fallacy. Care to name the fallacy you believe Im commiting?
 
LOL. I can see you have no idea what the theory of evolution says. I suggest you read one of the many threads dealing with it and educate yourself.
Please show me how it works since nobody so far has not proved it well enough…
He did, and he got it wrong in Twilight of the Idols, of course, Darwins idea was relatively new then so he can be forgiven for his ignorance. You hold no such excuse.
I never set out to disprove them, just the claim that said miracals were backed by academic sources.
Miracles are not backed up by academic sources… that would be impossible… only one miracle has academic sources, that is the on the cross…

But miracles are still a fact as i have shown you, just like evolution is a fact, not too much difference… except what comes to sources… read my post 299 you made a fallacy in your statement, Vatican does a lot of investigations in miracles and rejects most of them, the ones it accepts are reviewed by scientist (mostly medicine related) and are peer-reviewed and backed up with tons of evidence, usually thousands of pages of testimonials, especially such huge ones as Padre Pio… If you ask Vatican you will see a few thousand pages of materials on him… There has been many stigmatas in CC history but only 4 has been approved i wonder why…

BTW now this thread became about Vatican sources… you disprove them…
 
BTW do you have any non-bias sources to back up this, since i thought they peer review their studies quite roughly… they use the devils advocate on their saints who tries to disprove everything in the process of studying miracles and such… Where is this claim founded or is it a naked assertion?
There’s a difference between peer-review in academia, and just getting a guy who shares the exact principles as you to look over your work:rolleyes: .
 
Please show me how it works since nobody so far has not proved it well enough…
The thread is already de-railed enough. If you are serious, then PM and Ill give you links to some introductorary videos.
Miracles are not backed up by academic sources… that would be impossible… only one miracle has academic sources, that is the on the cross…
That too is contested, well, the way the Bible portrays it.
But miracles are still a fact as i have shown you, just like evolution is a fact, not too much difference… except what comes to sources… read my post 299 you made a fallacy in your statement,
No, you’ve shown people not knowing what a fact is claim miracals as facts.
Vatican does a lot of investigations in miracles and rejects most of them, the ones it accepts are reviewed by scientist (mostly medicine related) and are peer-reviewed and backed up with tons of evidence, usually thousands of pages of testimonials, especially such huge ones as Padre Pio… If you ask Vatican you will see a few thousand pages of materials on him… There has been many stigmatas in CC history but only 4 has been approved i wonder why…
Yet nothing appears in academic journals that if presented and agreed upon, would mean that Catholocism would have an objective claim to being a scientifically backed religion, yet it has still to do this…hmmm:rolleyes:
BTW now this thread became about Vatican sources… you disprove them…
Why would I have to? You disprove Islamic sources claiming that evolution is an evil Christian-Western plot to discredit Islam.:rolleyes: Both have significant backing among pseudo-academics.
 
Kinda hard to commit naked assertion when you claimed thats its merely people within the Church playing Devil’s Advocate.

What you are now commiting is now called hypocracy.😉
O i didn’t claim that… that is a strawman… you show me where i claim that. i said there is a devils advocate, i didn’t say who it is, maybe they use Sam Harris for all i know
 
No, you’ve shown people not knowing what a fact is claim miracals as facts.
some definition seem quite subjective here… miracles are facts…
Yet nothing appears in academic journals that if presented and agreed upon, would mean that Catholocism would have an objective claim to being a scientifically backed religion, yet it has still to do this…hmmm:rolleyes:
Yes this is a fallacy of yours… you expect that academic sources are non-bias, THEY ARE NOT, please move on… don’t continue with your straw man or what ever it is for you, academic sources are as non-bias to religion as Hitler was towards Jews… and that is fact
Why would I have to? You disprove Islamic sources claiming that evolution is an evil Christian-Western plot to discredit Islam.:rolleyes: Both have significant backing among pseudo-academics.
this is both a straw man and naked assertion plus the fact that it is not true… i never said anything about islamic sources, can you stay on topic…

here are some rules for investigation:
  1. The Congregation examines cases of alleged miracles in the following way:
  1. The Relator assigned to this task is to prepare a Position on alleged miracles. They are discussed in a meeting of experts (in the case of healings, in a meeting of physicians), whose votes and conclusions are set forth in an accurate report.
  1. Then the miracles are to be discussed in the special meeting of the theologians and, finally, in that of the Cardinals and Bishops.
vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/apost_constitutions/documents/hf_jp-ii_apc_25011983_divinus-perfectionis-magister_en.html
 
some definition seem quite subjective here… miracles are facts…
I take it you dont know what a fact is.

Generally, a fact is defined as something that is true, something that actually exists, or something that can be verified according to an established standard of evaluation.[1][2] There is a range of other uses, depending on the context. For example, fact may be argued under authority of a specific pedagogy, such as scientific facts or historical facts.

And here’s what you are doing

“Rhetorical assertion of fact is often forwarded without an implied or express basis of authority.”
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fact
Yes this is a fallacy of yours… you expect that academic sources are non-bias, THEY ARE NOT, please move on…
Because they demonstrate you wrong, they are bias? Lovely thinking there.:rolleyes:
don’t continue with your straw man or what ever it is for you,
You have no idea what a strawman is do you?
academic sources are as non-bias to religion as Hitler was towards Jews… and that is fact
Ah, Argumentum ad Hilterum. You’ve yet to demonstrate that academic sources are anti-religious, then you follow it up with a non-sequiter referencing Hitler. You are truely the fallacy master.
this is both a straw man and naked assertion plus the fact that it is not true… i never said anything about islamic sources, can you stay on topic…
Its neither a straw man or a naked assertion. Its a Reductio ad absurdum. Dont use words of which you dont know the meaning.
I see a lack of publishication in academic journals,
 
Thank You, Lord Jesus, for having urban-hermit join this thread. And thank you, urban-hermit, for speaking up. I appreciate your (name removed by moderator)ut very much. God bless you and your intentions.
I cannot talk now, but will be back soon.
Hi Cherie and thank you for your warm welcome to this thread. Sorry it took me so long to respond - I am also thankful to you for your contributions to this thread. God bless you and yours!
 
Im saying her believing its a miracal is subjective.
Well, it seems to me that the fact that she is able to walk around right now is an objective fact.

… and the fact that she regained that ability in a matter of moments after being unable to walk for 7 years is an objective fact.

When you put those 2 facts together you satisfy the definition of “miracle”.

You are attempting to say that the “placebo effect” is responsible for this healing. Even if it is, this is still a miracle. Because nobody knows how the placebo effect works. Until they do, and can prove that it is not an act of God, it remains an objectively, scientifically inexplicable phenomenon - a miracle.

So maybe you can just use the term “placebo effect” whenever a “miracle” occurs and we can all just go about our lives.

PS: You might run into trouble when you say the Miracle of the Sun in 1913 was a “placebo effect”. I would urge you to consider that there is a God, and He has made Himself known to us very definitely.
 
… I’m saying her believing its a miracal is subjective.
…
Just curious, Isam, and i hope you don’t mind my asking: What kind of objective evidence would you accept to demonstrate that miracles do happen?

🤷
 
Well, it seems to me that the fact that she is able to walk around right now is an objective fact.

… and the fact that she regained that ability in a matter of moments after being unable to walk for 7 years is an objective fact.

When you put those 2 facts together you satisfy the definition of “miracle”.

You are attempting to say that the “placebo effect” is responsible for this healing. Even if it is, this is still a miracle. Because nobody knows how the placebo effect works. Until they do, and can prove that it is not an act of God, it remains an objectively, scientifically inexplicable phenomenon - a miracle.
It would be a dubious evidence for your God no? I mean everyone experiences the placebo effect to some degree. Some people are even put to death because of it (nocebo/somatization disorders) in certain more backwards countries. Schizophrenics also feel its effects so are we to say their delusions are real?
So maybe you can just use the term “placebo effect” whenever a “miracle” occurs and we can all just go about our lives.
Sure, as long as you accept that people killed in Saudi Arabia for withcraft are truely witches.
PS: You might run into trouble when you say the Miracle of the Sun in 1913 was a “placebo effect”. I would urge you to consider that there is a God, and He has made Himself known to us very definitely.
No idea what that is, mind posting a link?
 
**Originally Posted by urban-hermit **
Well, it seems to me that the fact that she is able to walk around right now is an objective fact.
… and the fact that she regained that ability in a matter of moments after being unable to walk for 7 years is an objective fact.
When you put those 2 facts together you satisfy the definition of “miracle”.
You are attempting to say that the “placebo effect” is responsible for this healing. Even if it is, this is still a miracle. Because nobody knows how the placebo effect works. Until they do, and can prove that it is not an act of God, it remains an objectively, scientifically inexplicable phenomenon - a miracle.
It would be a dubious evidence for your God no? I mean everyone experiences the placebo effect to some degree. Some people are even put to death because of it (nocebo/somatization disorders) in certain more backwards countries. Schizophrenics also feel its effects so are we to say their delusions are real?
This is a very immature way of admitting you were wrong.
 
“What kind of objective evidence would you accept to demonstrate that miracles do happen?”

Hmmm, wanna give my two cents on miracles (and yes I’m a Catholic):
miracles- don’t really believe in them. It’s like ghosts and such- if there really are ghosts why isn’t serious scientific people documenting exactly what ghost haunts where at what time? And if weight-loss pills really work then why aren’t there any governments recommending this-or-that pill for their overweight people? Thus if miracles really exist and cannot be disproved in any way then why are people asking whether miracles exist?
It’s like what the Bible said. You can know the false prophets from the true ones by this: false prophecies do not come true. Therefore those who utter them are false prophets. Similarly miracles which are 100% miracles would be or have been world news immediately after they occur. Think about it- what reporter wouldn’t be 100% interested in a amputated leg becoming a whole leg? Or a people who start levitating?
Now the miracles described in the gospel- those I believe. Why? Bcos the Church which I willing submit myself to says I must believe in them. The same Church however not only says all public revelation from God is over and done with but also says I have no need whatsoever to believe in miracles not stated in the Bible. Since I assume the Church tells me what God wants to tell me, so I infer from this that such miracles are not necessarily real and even if they are I am under no obligation to accept their real-ness.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top