Charlie Hebdo rejects Catholic support

  • Thread starter Thread starter _Abyssinia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
**
Muslim protests of Charlie Hebdo turn violent; 4 killed in West African country of Niger**
Sad anyone would die in protests.

The last time we saw something like this happen was with that Pastor who threatened to burn the Koran. What is his name? Terry Jones, I think. I saw he was “blacklisted” too in some list of people which had Salmon Rushdie on it as well.

Again, I would not care to do something “inflammatory” such as what Jones was saying he would do. That case probably makes a good analogy to this one.

Just like the Feinstein report, I would never incite the enemy.
 
I wonder how many are now reconsidering their ‘solidarity’ with this publication once they get a second look.
 
The opening of that movie is very poignant.

Cyprus, Paris, Cairo, Amsterdam, Lillehammer, Tel Aviv, New York.

Munich

That’s how many 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 5th looks I need.

 
They did, I’ve had the misfortune of accidentally seeing it. They depicted the Blessed Virgin on one of their covers giving birth to Our Lord in a lewd and degrading manner. I was naturally scandalized, revolted and deeply offended. However this did not make me want to use the law as a repressive instrument against them or barge into their offices and butcher them all to death. Rather it made me wish to debate them in a spirit of dialogue and show them the error of their ways through leadership by example.
I have seen that cartoon as well.
I had the same response as you
I also did not decide to rush off and shoot them.
As to debating them it is hard to think what you could say to them as it is clear they do not wish to debate they wish to insult. I am not defending or promoting Islamic fundamentalism but I am querying the right of a group of self appointed left wing agitators to insult artichokes of faith with impunity. There should be some attempt by the state to limit this. This is bot a moral issue and a pragmatic one. The French embassies throughout the world are now experiencing rioting and agitation as to the world it appears that the French government is now insulting their religious beliefs
In short I have very little sympathy for Charlie or for the secular French government.
 
Ed West, Catholic Herald 1/8/15 (already posted this - this shortened second version is for those too lazy to read the link :))
Deliberately stirring up hatred is not from God but from the evil one.
What Charlie did is stir up anger and hatred.
Reminds me of that old Ogden Nash ditty about the person who lies here died defending his right of way.
Charlie set out to inflame and stir up hatred.
It achieved that end and now tires to cloak itself in the flag of freedom of expression.
 
Any Catholic who is “Charlie” is plain dumb.

As HRH put it:

“I refuse to take part in a “republican sacred covenant” to defend Charlie” - STATEMENT BY HRH PRINCE CHARLES PHILIPPE OF ORLEANS:

"I will go against the tide of emotional propriety by separating me from the movement “I’m Charlie.” No, I’m not Charlie because I never liked that Manichean newspaper.

Charlie Hebdo is a vulgar paper, despising all opinions except its own, which, under the guise of freedom of expression, will allow provocative behavior to all. Charlie Hebdo is an aggressive newspaper that produces hatred of religions through its, supposedly, humor. Charlie Hebdo is the very image of the European atheist society which creates enmity and distress instead of respect and brotherhood among peoples and men, regardless of their differences, race, color, religion.

So I refuse to take part in a “republican sacred covenant” to defend Charlie because, simply, I do not understand what I have to defend.

I am neither disrespectful nor indecent and do not want to offend the memory of the killed cartoonists. Words fail to tell the horror of the attack that hit the newspaper. I condemn this barbaric act and present to families and relatives of the deceased my deepest condolences.

I denounce justly this sterile attempt to bring about national unity and I denounce the hypocrisy of the citizens who have never read this humor publication and who have always criticized the weekly.

To honor the victims, yes.
Honour Charlie Hebdo, no."
👍
 
Deliberately stirring up hatred is not from God but from the evil one.
What Charlie did is stir up anger and hatred.
Reminds me of that old Ogden Nash ditty about the person who lies here died defending his right of way.
Charlie set out to inflame and stir up hatred.
It achieved that end and now tires to cloak itself in the flag of freedom of expression.
Will you say the same thing of the KKK?
 
Will you say the same thing of the KKK?
Well the KKK stir up hatred so I would say they are not from God but from some where else.
I also think there should be restrictions on how they operate.
Turns out now in France people making pro-Jihadist statements are going to jail.
So it seems as if freedom of speech only applies to a select few
 
Well the KKK stir up hatred so I would say they are not from God but from some where else
Should the KKK have the right to assemble and the right to free speech, to make their viewpoints (no matter how distasteful or evil by Christian standards) publicly available? Or should that be illegal because of the potential to incite violence?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top