Children, Religion, & Atheism

  • Thread starter Thread starter restenergy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I understand that, but when they get to be older & they realize that their parent doesn’t believe in the church (if I still don’t at that time), how good of an example will I be? I feel like I’m being judged for considering having a family based on one faith (because my fiance wants us to start going to mass & “getting involved” & also for possibly raising our children this way) when I don’t personally believe it. Maybe I am being overly sensitive, but I’ve had a few family members (all of who are not Catholic) look down on me for “letting my fiance get what he wants where religion is concerned”.
Well, you won’t be allowed to marry him in the Church, if you don’t. And he won’t be allowed to marry you outside of the Church - so, if you want to marry him, he is going to “get his way” with regard to religion.
Of course, I’m speaking to mostly Catholics right now, but I am guessing that part of my concern with raising my children Catholic is that it isn’t what I personally believe and people will view my family’s religious values as invalid. I don’t know if that makes any sense!
Perhaps you should re-evaluate whether you want to marry outside of your own belief system. Perhaps a husband who shares the same beliefs as you would be easier to explain to your family, easier to raise children with, and easier to get along with, in the long term. Just a thought … 🙂
 
I would never dream of making my child choose their faith at a young age; I think the only way to ever understand what you believe is by looking at all of the options available although being in one might help someone make a better decision. My fiancé really wants our children sent to Catholic school, and I did get a lot out of it. But that is also one of the places that made me see the bad in the church, which I’m not blaming the entire church for. My biggest problem is that I have trouble not arguing my point on what I believe, and I don’t understand how I will be able to pretend to be something that I’m not. I’m a confirmed Catholic, but I went through the process without truly wanting it. I only did it so my mom wouldn’t take away my car! I feel almost guilty going into a church when I have the thoughts that I do against the religion. Perhaps it is a selfish reason to not want to raise my children Catholic but I don’t want to be a hypocrite either.
I hear your concern, you don’t want to choose a faith that you don’t believe. Have you tried to re-engage with your faith? There is only goodness and beauty in the core teachings of Christ. When was the last time you prayed?

Have you watched EWTN? In particular, I would suggest Sunday Night Live with Fr. Groeschel - he has many good and short clips on youTube. Here is one I picked for you

At some point, you have to forgive these people that pulled you away from your faith. Forgiveness is one of the most powerful messages of Christianity
 
If your husband to be wanted to teach your children Piano, even though you don’t know how to play or enjoy listening to the piano, would you object? In this example, you don’t know anything about other musical instruments either (musical atheist, lol?) Of course not. You would see the benefits of your child learning a musical instrument and permit it (if not encourage it!). And maybe, just maybe, you would fall in love with the piano along with your children!!

You don’t believe in God but you have already acknowledged that you think the teachings had benefits for you as a child. I would suggest you allow your husband to raise your children Catholic and even participate as much as you can!

Of course, as a Catholic, I am biased but you did come here for advice on this subject which to me suggested you wanted to be told to raise your future kids Catholic. God may be speaking to you…Pray and listen.
 
I hear your concern, you don’t want to choose a faith that you don’t believe. Have you tried to re-engage with your faith? There is only goodness and beauty in the core teachings of Christ. When was the last time you prayed?

Have you watched EWTN? In particular, I would suggest Sunday Night Live with Fr. Groeschel - he has many good and short clips on youTube. Here is one I picked for you

At some point, you have to forgive these people that pulled you away from your faith. Forgiveness is one of the most powerful messages of Christianity
I am confirmed in the catholic church, and I have been considered going back to the church, mostly because I do catch myself praying more often than I feel comfortable with & I always get that guilty feeling when I talk about why I believe God doesn’t exist. But, going back to religion isn’t something I feel comfortable with because as much evidence provides that he does exist, I notice more that makes it almost impossible for there to be a God. I see too many reasons why religion is convenient and not truth. Which I guess would make me more or less undecided at times rather than fully atheist.
 
I think you might be more of an agnostic than atheist, since you believe there might be something. I am agnostic and like you I was raised Catholic. My wife is Catholic and wanted to raise our children in the Catholic church. Since that’s what my wife wanted, I agreed and that’s what we did. Our children were raised in the church, and received all of their sacraments. My wife taught CCD and our children attended those classes as well. I never discussed what I thought with them. Since I am agnostic by nature and not because of any conviction wither way, I didn’t feel compelled to present any atheist ideas to them. If they had such inclinations I figured they would find them on their own. They both grew up fine. So, if you don’t have strong convictions about why someone shouldn’t believe in God, and it’s just because you have doubts either way, why not go with it and see what happens? If, however, you are strong in the conviction that there is no God, that’s another story. I get the sense that’s not the case with you though. I think you believe there might be a God of some sort.

Respectfully and good luck,
Sufjon
 
I feel comfortable with because as much evidence provides that he does exist, I notice more that makes it almost impossible for there to be a God.
What evidence has convinced you that it is ‘almost’ impossible for there to be a God? Is it that you can’t understand how a loving God would allow so much evil and suffering in the world?
 
What evidence has convinced you that it is ‘almost’ impossible for there to be a God? Is it that you can’t understand how a loving God would allow so much evil and suffering in the world?
No, that part actually makes sense. I just don’t think it’s possible for there to be a God or any higher power out there. I think that, to a certain extent, humans are just animals. I also think that society created religion to keep people in line, to comfort people in times of distress, and make us seem less like animals. Religion is just way too convenient for society, and I think people gravitate towards religious activity because it’s more comforting to believe that this life isn’t all there is, that we will see those we love again someday, and that there is justice for all the bad things that happen. Those in power of religious orders (even priests) use religion as a tool for control over people and power. Science and history also make religion a little less believable. People created religion to explain things they couldn’t understand, then science came along & much of it basically disproves a lot of religion. Even in the Bible, the entire concept of religion is based around how people of the time think people should live. The church edits its ideas on things whenever they are challenged, but in the end, whether the Bible was inspired by God or not, it was still written by humans and for society.

Another subject I studied is death, and I’ve heard the stories about people seeing those they love & talking to God shortly before they leave this Earth, and although there are stories of people seeing God, there is the explanation that dying people go into a subconcious state & the mind “dreams” to allow the person a mentally easier exit from earth. Those are just some of the many things that I’ve seen to disprove religion. I can verbally argue this for hours, but unfortunately, when it comes to actually writing my thoughts down I can’t write them down the way I want.

I really don’t believe that if there is a God he would send his children to hell for being who they are (homosexual) or for having premarital sex, reading Harry Potter or watching the DaVinci code, and not going to mass. I just have trouble believing in something that contradicts itself in so many ways.

Of course, I don’t think there’s actually any hard proof evidence that there is no God, just as there’s no evidence that there is. I guess that’s why its such a mysterious subject.
 
Hello there. First of all, I am an atheist (self-proclaimed although human & therefore occasionally doubtful).

I was born & raised Catholic; my birth parents went specifically out of their way to make certain that I would be adopted & raised Catholic. I was Catholic until I was about 16. I went through a very rough time & I witnessed some very terrible things caused by “devout Catholics” & was completely turned off against the Catholic church, & eventually against the idea of God.

My fiancé & I are getting married in January. He’s a Catholic & although he’s not extremely religious, he believes & was a bit touchy against my beliefs for awhile (I was Catholic & strongly believing when I met him). He wanted to get married in the Catholic church, but due to us moving in together & moving our wedding date up a year, we couldn’t go through with the process in four months.

One of the biggest concerns we have right now is raising children. As children, we both attended mass regularly with our parents, & I have to admit it was comforting to me to have something whole & united like that community growing up, & I really did believe strongly in God & Jesus when I was younger. That belief helped me through my grandparents’, father’s, & best friend’s death, & MANY other hard nights for many years. I remember feeling at peace & very much happy, as opposed to the cynical, “jaded” way I view life today 😉

Well, our concern is how to raise our children. I don’t believe in any of the religious ideas, but my fiancé really does & he’s very adamant about raising our children Catholic. When I argued that our children should be able to decide for themselves from a neutral ground, he argued that they should be raised Catholic & stray from the church if that’s what they choose.

Does anyone have any advice (perhaps from experiences or anything) on what the best option is? Although I still do wonder/sort of believe there might be a god, I don’t believe enough to raise my child that way. What is the best option for our child when my fiancé really does believe?
Expose your children to all aspects, and let them find out for themselves, as they grow up. That’s the much better approach, compared to enslaving their minds to any particular dogma. This type rationale doesn’t apply anywhere else in life. You never hear of a parent referring to their 2-year-old as a fiscal conservative. Their brains have not fully formed yet. They have no reference point or prior knowledge/experience to draw from. I don’t think it’s right that religion gets a free pass.

A child’s mind is extremely susceptible to whatever their parents say is so. With repeated reinforcement, it becomes deeply ingrained in the still forming mind of a child.
 
I think you might be more of an agnostic than atheist, since you believe there might be something. I am agnostic and like you I was raised Catholic. My wife is Catholic and wanted to raise our children in the Catholic church. Since that’s what my wife wanted, I agreed and that’s what we did. Our children were raised in the church, and received all of their sacraments. My wife taught CCD and our children attended those classes as well. I never discussed what I thought with them. Since I am agnostic by nature and not because of any conviction wither way, I didn’t feel compelled to present any atheist ideas to them. If they had such inclinations I figured they would find them on their own. They both grew up fine. So, if you don’t have strong convictions about why someone shouldn’t believe in God, and it’s just because you have doubts either way, why not go with it and see what happens? If, however, you are strong in the conviction that there is no God, that’s another story. I get the sense that’s not the case with you though. I think you believe there might be a God of some sort.

Respectfully and good luck,
Sufjon
Occasionally I think there might be a God, but most of the time I don’t think there’s anything else out there. I just simply don’t (or can’t allow myself to) believe it. I know people on both end extremities - all of their life is devoted to God and those whose lives are lived for the moment. Not only do those who live for the moment have more fun (selfish reason) but they’re more realistic about life & more accepting of others.

I’m glad you & your wife found a way to work the religious differences out!
 
Expose your children to all aspects, and let them find out for themselves, as they grow up. That’s the much better approach, compared to enslaving their minds to any particular dogma. This type rationale doesn’t apply anywhere else in life. You never hear of a parent referring to their 2-year-old as a fiscal conservative. Their brains have not fully formed yet. They have no reference point or prior knowledge/experience to draw from. I don’t think it’s right that religion gets a free pass.

A child’s mind is extremely susceptible to whatever their parents say is so. With repeated reinforcement, it becomes deeply ingrained in the still forming mind of a child.
Why do you fear to teach susceptible minds the Golden Rule, or the Ten Commandments?
Yes, when they become teenagers, they will question the black and white dogma they learned as children, that’s what teenagers DO.

When young, you teach them to never play with fire or with electricity.
When older, they can learn to play safely with both,
However, that early training will seve them well their whole lives, like learning good manners.
 
My answer is not going to be popular. I think you should not marry and not have children until you both agree on a direction. It is rare for this to not become an issue in a marriage but more often then people like to admit the ‘religious’ wars can destroy a marriage.

The spiritual well-being of your children should not be left to chance.
I will definitely agree with you and your answer from experience…my first marriage to a Mormon ended because of religious differences…children complicate this in a tremendous way. It isn’t fair to them or to the parents if there is a huge difference in their religions.

Catholics are obligated to raise their children in the Catholic faith…it’s a given and it will cause problems if you aren’t on the same page.

I would discuss this thoroughly before being married.

stormy
 
Occasionally I think there might be a God, but most of the time I don’t think there’s anything else out there. I just simply don’t (or can’t allow myself to) believe it. I know people on both end extremities - all of their life is devoted to God and those whose lives are lived for the moment. Not only do those who live for the moment have more fun (selfish reason) but they’re more realistic about life & more accepting of others.

I’m glad you & your wife found a way to work the religious differences out!
Hi restenergy: There are religions that stress living in the moment, just not the mainstream religions of the west. They actually require a lot more work than the “go to church” variety. You know, I think just believing in you is a start. You have yourself and your fiance. There are two things to love and believe in right there. Whether your children participate in a religious program or not, the love they have at home is the one that will guide them. You don’t have to believe in anything to love and to be a good person. I though t the church setting was a bit counter to what I wanted for my kids, because of the restrictive nature of the teachings. I did it for my wife. They grew up to be very spiritual people who (funny you should mention it) follow a religious path that focuses on the moment that you’re in.

I struggled with atheism, after having been raised Catholic. I am no longer an atheist, however, I am agnostic when it comes to Christianity. I am trying to figure out how Christianity fits. I know it does, but for me it’s just such a mess to sort through. I’m working on it.

Anyway, I just would avoid an “all or nothing” approach with your fiance. If he wants to do the church thing, I don’t think it’ll hurt anything. If they grow up to be Catholic, well, that’s a fine thing to be I think. If they grow up to be atheists, at least they’ll know what it is they don’t believe in. 🙂

Respectfully,
Sufjon
 
No, that part actually makes sense. I just don’t think it’s possible for there to be a God or any higher power out there. I think that, to a certain extent, humans are just animals. I also think that society created religion to keep people in line, to comfort people in times of distress, and make us seem less like animals. Religion is just way too convenient for society, and I think people gravitate towards religious activity because it’s more comforting to believe that this life isn’t all there is, that we will see those we love again someday, and that there is justice for all the bad things that happen. Those in power of religious orders (even priests) use religion as a tool for control over people and power.
But religion also controls the leadership.

Atheism actually gives more power to leaders over their people (Stalin, Hitler, Pol Pot, etc.) because there isn’t any moral code - if they want to kill a lot of people for whatever reason, there isn’t anything stopping them. So, the idea that religion was created to give leaders power over people falls a little flat - since in order to make the religion seem believable (assuming it’s not true), the leaders have to follow the rules, too. And of course if it is true, then everyone has to follow the rules, anyway, because it is God who makes the rules; not people. 🙂
Science and history also make religion a little less believable. People created religion to explain things they couldn’t understand, then science came along & much of it basically disproves a lot of religion.
Like what, for example? :confused:
Another subject I studied is death, and I’ve heard the stories about people seeing those they love & talking to God shortly before they leave this Earth, and although there are stories of people seeing God, there is the explanation that dying people go into a subconcious state & the mind “dreams” to allow the person a mentally easier exit from earth.
If there is no God, and nothing spiritual out there, then what is it that’s giving people an easier exit from the earth, in death? :confused:

But if there is a God, then wouldn’t He give us rules to follow that make our lives better, and wouldn’t He provide a place for people to go, who don’t want to follow the rules, or to be with Him in eternity? 🙂
 
But religion also controls the leadership.

Atheism actually gives more power to leaders over their people (Stalin, Hitler, Pol Pot, etc.) because there isn’t any moral code - if they want to kill a lot of people for whatever reason, there isn’t anything stopping them. So, the idea that religion was created to give leaders power over people falls a little flat - since in order to make the religion seem believable (assuming it’s not true), the leaders have to follow the rules, too. And of course if it is true, then everyone has to follow the rules, anyway, because it is God who makes the rules; not people. 🙂
I’m not saying that religion is a bad thing as far as control over how people live; I’m just saying it’s really conveinent & a good controlling agent. As in an explanation as to how it came about (instead of people actually speaking with God or something). Because without religion, people would do exactly what you said - anything they want because there is no consequence for their actions.

And in religion, leaders do have more power over people, even if they claim they are doing God’s will. In all of my experiences with the churches, especially the Catholic church, it all revolves around money and power. The leaders never follow the rules, in any situation - religious leaders, political leaders, any. You can do what you want, how you want with very little consequence if you are in any position of power, and I have seen people from all levels of leadership fall to that more often than not. At the end of the day, the church is just another business, and you have to knock someone down to get to the top.
Like what, for example? :confused:
To this, I have no immediate answer because I don’t have any of the sources saved that I need.
If there is no God, and nothing spiritual out there, then what is it that’s giving people an easier exit from the earth, in death? :confused:

But if there is a God, then wouldn’t He give us rules to follow that make our lives better, and wouldn’t He provide a place for people to go, who don’t want to follow the rules, or to be with Him in eternity? 🙂
The human mind is giving people an easier exit from earth. The mind goes into a subconscious state where it comforts itself through hallucinations of people from the far past and the idea of God. The human mind can make itself believe anything. The human mind can prevent someone who’s dying a very traumatic death from realizing that their life is ending. The human mind protects itself from the body shutting down in some cases by bringing back comforting things - like dead family members or God. It’s easier to accept death if you don’t feel alone.

If there is a God, I would think that he would provide better leaders who actually live those rules. I get that it’s ruled by humans and humans are indefinitely sinners, but it is completely ridiculous how these religious leaders we’re supposed to look to are the ones doing the most damage! If you’re going to talk the talk, you can at least attempt to walk the walk.
 
But religion also controls the leadership.

Atheism actually gives more power to leaders over their people (Stalin, Hitler, Pol Pot, etc.)
hitler was not an atheist…he was a rather misbehaved catholic, just ask Pope Pius XII

but either way…its not atheism or Christianity or Islam or religion at all that gives these horrible men power…it is an uneducated and or fearful populace that can be easily manipulated or made to believe things that just aren’t true.

now from an atheist’s perspective I do believe that atheism has a role to play in keeping such men at bay…BUT ONLY AND ONLY because in the western world atheists tend to be hardcore and outspoken skeptics of EVERYTHING…IE we question everything and trust very few.

now there are atheists who are just as bad as the blindly following masses who believe in god because their family believed and their friends believe etc just like there are skeptical and thinking christians muslims etc who have examined the evidence and really feel that the position they hold is the most accurate…

so how about instead of arguing whether hitler was an atheist or a catholic…we spend that time promoting free thought in all areas of life…encouraging people to ask questions to do research and to make up their own minds with out fear…

“No nation is permitted to live in ignorance with impunity.” --Thomas Jefferson
 
I’m not saying that religion is a bad thing as far as control over how people live; I’m just saying it’s really conveinent & a good controlling agent. As in an explanation as to how it came about (instead of people actually speaking with God or something). Because without religion, people would do exactly what you said - anything they want because there is no consequence for their actions.
Interesting observation. Personally, I think humans are pack animals like dogs. They would find a way to police themselves with or without religion. Religion happens to be the way it was done for thousands of years. If there was no religion, humans would have found another way to form societies. These ways would probably have been no more or less brutal. Not to say that religion is not a good working control system. It has been, but there are plenty of other potential options for control models, and humans would naturally have developed them I think, because it is essential to the survival of the species. I think it was the realization of the need for such controls that gave rise to the Old Testament. Most of it’s laws promote behaviors that promote the propagation of the human species (specifically Jewish humans), for instance, good to be heterosexual and make children, bad to be homosexual and not make children. Dietary controls also promoted protection and growth of the species as well, as it was dangerous to eat pork and shellfish and the like. Rules about kosher diets cooked in kosher kitchens, kept Jewish women (who spent most of their days in the kitchen) from meeting and mating with non-Jews, hence promoting the autonomy of the Jewish people. Nowadays I see religion creating divisions among people that offer more danger than security to society. It probably wouldn’t be that way if each of us could see the hopes of others as sacred, whatever those hopes are.

I think the value of religion is outside the realm of control and constraint, and of infinitely more worth. How the Judeo-Christian tradition fits is my only question. I’m certain it does, but that’s my problem of course, not yours.

Respectfully,
Sufjon
 
To this, I have no immediate answer because I don’t have any of the sources saved that I need.
Creation of the Universe(Quantum Physics, Quantum Mechanics, Astronomy)
Simultaneous Creation of all Animals(Geology, Biology, Chemistry, Paleontology)
Special Creation of Man(Biology, Geology, Paleontology)
Age of the Universe(Quantum Physics, Quantum Mechanics, Astronomy)
Age of the Earth(Geology, Chemistry)
Age of Man(Geology, Paleontology)
Flooding of the Entire Planet(Hydro physics, Geology, Engineering, Biology)
Shape of the Earth(Astronomy, Physics)
Men don’t rise from the dead(Biology)
Men don’t fly with out the aid of technology(Physics)
Spit does not cure Blindness(Biology, Medicine)
Jews were not in Egypt(Archeology, Chemistry, Biology)
There was never a crossing of the Red Sea(Archeology, Geology)
Hell is not inside the earth(Geology)
Heaven is not in outer spaceThe sky is not an upside down bowl(Astronomy)
Men can not live to be 900(Biology, Medicine)
It is not possible to be Omnipresent(Quantum Physics, Quantum Mechanics)
It is not possible to be Omnipotent(Quantum Physics, Quantum Mechanics)

This is a small list with the major field of science that has proven such events not in line with the basic functioning of the universe as we know it.

Feel free to inject miracles, but as soon as you demand the requirement for miracles you may as well throw science out the window but then don’t ever use science to support your position either…either you feel the scientific method is useful in determination of the true nature of reality or you don’t.
 
I would strongly suggest that you listen to the wisdom of your future husband about raising your kids Catholic. I was born and raised Catholic but was atheist for several years before returning to faith in our Lord. Atheism is not like faith in something else, it is the lack of faith in anything, it is a large dark hole within the self. Atheism does not and cannot have a morality. All of your morality is based upon your past Christian teaching, not upon your atheism. Do you want your kids to have that dark hole within themselves? But more importantly, what if you’re wrong about your Atheism? Have you asked yourself what if there really is a God? How sad can it be to not only find yourself in Hell but to also find your kids there and know that they are there simply because you raised them as atheists. I would beg you to raise your kids as Catholic and while doing so seek to build your own faith. To not do so is not simply risking their lives, it risking their very souls. Should a mother not be willing to go through hell to save her children lives? Should a mother not be willing to build a real spirital life to save her children souls from Hell? Although much less important than salvation, the social life of your kids is also very important. What would also be sad is if the children that would have been born to you and your fiancé were not born because you didn’t marry because you were not willing to step up into a wonderful, and often very hard, spirital life. We should all pray that God’s grace come to you and fill you with faith, wisdom, and strength. May you, your husband, and your future kids experience a wonderful life and an even more wonderful after-life with our Lord Jesus Christ.

Ranp
 
One of the biggest concerns we have right now is raising children. As children, we both attended mass regularly with our parents, & I have to admit it was comforting to me to have something whole & united like that community growing up, & I really did believe strongly in God & Jesus when I was younger. That belief helped me through my grandparents’, father’s, & best friend’s death, & MANY other hard nights for many years. I remember feeling at peace & very much happy, as opposed to the cynical, “jaded” way I view life today 😉
You have the answer right here. At the very least allow them to have the same chance at comfort.

Take care and good luck. Try to keep your mind open.
 
Atheism does not make people jaded…some jaded people become atheists…I am far happier and have found great comfort and peace in my atheism that i never had in faith.

and also atheism is not lack of faith in ANYTHING its the lack of BELIEF in a god or gods nothing more nothing less
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top