Clapping during Mass

  • Thread starter Thread starter ImKevin
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I

ImKevin

Guest
I get so frustrated when our priest makes the announcements during Mass, it is right after communion and everyone starts clapping, it makes it hard for me to concentrate on our Lord after just receiving Him.😦

Do you have this problem? and if so, how do you cope with it?
 
I get so frustrated when our priest makes the announcements during Mass, it is right after communion and everyone starts clapping, it makes it hard for me to concentrate on our Lord after just receiving Him.😦

Do you have this problem? and if so, how do you cope with it?
It sounds hard, but I would deal with this by switching parishes.
 
I get so frustrated when our priest makes the announcements during Mass, it is right after communion and everyone starts clapping, it makes it hard for me to concentrate on our Lord after just receiving Him.😦

Do you have this problem? and if so, how do you cope with it?
i would just talk to the priest it seems a bit drastic to switch parish over something like this ask him if he can make the announcements before Communion or right before mass starts
 
Announcements are allowed to be made, and following the post Communion prayer is where they belong. I don’t think this is a reason to switch parishes. I am not sure why people are clapping however. Our announcements are about parish blood drive. K of C selling raffle tickets, registration for CCD, Etc.
 
I agree, announcements are made at the end of Mass as they should be, and occasionally we have had clapping, i.e., several weeks ago when the ground breaking date of our new church was announced and also when one of our ā€œretiredā€ priests 50th anniversary in the priesthood was announced. I did not find it inappropriate at all. I would find it hard to concentrate on anything else during the announcements and wouldn’t want to miss something that may be important.šŸ™‚
 
Announcements are allowed to be made, and following the post Communion prayer is where they belong. I don’t think this is a reason to switch parishes. I am not sure why people are clapping however. Our announcements are about parish blood drive. K of C selling raffle tickets, registration for CCD, Etc.
I agree. Most of our announcements are such that applause is not expected or warranted. On occasion, we do receive good news, i.e., when we will have a new deacon at our parish, etc., but even with that type of announcement, clapping in Church is something I do not abide well. I really dislike clapping at the end of Mass and the recessional hymn. To me, it appears that some people feel as though they have just attended a performance or concert of some kind and were entertained. I don’t find that appropriate at all, nor do I appreciate the talking in Church that frequently accompanies the clapping.

With that being said, I do not think it is something to prompt a search for a new parish. I find clapping in Church disrespectful and annoying, but I try to do as my mother always said to do and ā€œoffer it up.ā€
 
Clapping used to be a problem and it was initiated by the celebrant to thank the choir (still happens Christmas and Easter). Several years and different pastors have lead to a change.

You could begin by not clapping but sit/stand with a pleasant expression, i.e not scowling as in disapproval. I try to do this but I can’t help but join in when there is a baptism!:clapping: 😊
 
…You could begin by not clapping but sit/stand with a pleasant expression, i.e not scowling as in disapproval. I try to do this but I can’t help but join in when there is a baptism!:clapping: 😊
I smile when good news is announced. I try to remain expressionless when people clap at the end of Mass.
 
I live in the bible belt, so there is only one Catholic church where I live. I love this parish, just don’t like the clapping.

I like the advise someone gave - guess I will just offer it up. šŸ™‚
 
I used to be annoyed by that practice as well. However at the present, I got to Contemplative religious Houses for Mass, and that is no longer a problem. I am so thankful for them, becuase if they were not there, I sure would have a hard, hard, time in attending Mass. My area does not offer the EF sadly, so I probably would be up that creek wihtout a paddle. Thankfully, things have worked out.

There have been no clapping or any liturgical abuses that I have seen in attending Contemplative religious Masses. I am not saying that it’s not out there, just have not run into any, and I am thankful for it.

God bless.
 
I smile when good news is announced. I try to remain expressionless when people clap at the end of Mass.
I try that too but my face has always been a mirror for my thoughts. I’ve even had a deacon say to me, ā€œHmm, I could tell you weren’t impressed with what Fr. C had to say in the homily this morning.ā€ After that I tried to keep my thoughts locked in my mind instead of broadcast on my face but it’s very difficult to keep a deadpan expression when you’re furious. 😃
 
I try that too but my face has always been a mirror for my thoughts. I’ve even had a deacon say to me, ā€œHmm, I could tell you weren’t impressed with what Fr. C had to say in the homily this morning.ā€ After that I tried to keep my thoughts locked in my mind instead of broadcast on my face but it’s very difficult to keep a deadpan expression when you’re furious. 😃
Well, it helps that my husband knows exactly what I am thinking whenever there is clapping in Church. He sometimes just smiles at me, which makes me smile too. At other times if I am not being very successful at hiding my disapproval and am having trouble offering it up (i.e, if there was excessive clapping, noise, and rowdiness while still in Church) he will take on an exaggerated look of disapproval and shake his finger at me and tsk just to make me smile. :tsktsk:

I generally respond with ā€œI just cannot abide it,ā€ but because of him, I say it with a genuine smile on my face and in my voice and can offer it up successfully.
 
I After that I tried to keep my thoughts locked in my mind instead of broadcast on my face but it’s very difficult to keep a deadpan expression when you’re furious. 😃
LOL if you ever find out how, then please tell me. That could come in quite handy down here.

God bless.
 
The adoration of the music (band) at OLOL has gotten so engrained at my parish, the music director announces at the beginning of the mass to please not leave until AFTER the recessional song. Last month (and for years earlier), the pre-mass instruction was to not leave before being dismissed by the priest.

Half the crowd breaks out in clapping, and I bite my tongue. Walk out without any bad thoughts or grimaces on my face. Still.

I do clap for the wee ones after a baptism. God and that child are the focus of that time of celebration. Maybe I wrong there.

It’s just clapping for a musical performance (so called music ministery) that bothers me.
 
I don’t understand why this is a problem other than the impression that I get on CAF that some people just enjoy complaining. Its one thing if there are legitimate liturgical abuses going on and certainly one should not be clapping for every little thing, but if the priest acknowledges a couple in the parish who is celebrating their 50th wedding anniversary or wishes to thank the social committee for the work they did putting together the reception following the Easter vigil, why not clap for them? They sure as heck deserve it. Its not in the middle of Mass and it is following the post communion prayer so where is the harm? Acknowledging someone who has lived as a witness to the Gospel through the vocation of Christian marriage for 50 years or has dedicated their time and talents on behalf of the body of Christ is a beautiful and joyful thing. Furthermore, if, following the recessional hymn, people wish to clap in appreciation for the choir, is that destroying the Mass? No, the Mass is over at that time. Again, these are people who dedicated their time and talents for the good of the parish.

In our parish my wife and I try to sit up front which means that by the time the rest of the parishioners have received the Eucharist and the priest/deacon have finished their responsibilities following communion, we have had a good 10 - 12 minutes to pray and thank Jesus for his body and blood. Combine that with the post communion prayers (we say the Anima Christi which is then followed up by the prayer led by the priest) and you have at least 10 minutes of private prayer followed by two community prayers.

I get the impression on this forum all too often that people feel as if one should never experience anything but solemnity at Mass. As if joy is not to be felt or expressed. I have heard it stated before that if the Good News does not make you happy, then the news must not be all that good in the first place. Frankly, I could not agree more.
 
Well since you brought it up. It isn’t about a 50th anniversary, it was about someone receiving an A in High School. And, my focus is on God, not some person who did a good job in school, so when they clap, it is extremely hard to concentrate on my prayers. I come to Mass to pray and worship God, not to praise a person for something good they did.

Now I’m not saying that person should not be clapped for, all I am saying, is the timing for the announcement is not good timing and should be done in a parish hall.

Reverence has been lost in the parishes. I thank God and Pope Benedict XVI for the changes coming this year.
 
Reverence has been lost in the parishes. I thank God and Pope Benedict XVI for the changes coming this year.
The timing for parish announcements is not changing in the new missal per my understanding. I would also suggest that even if there is no clapping involved, paying attention during the normal parish announcements following the post communion prayer would be the correct thing to do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top