Climategate 2.0: New E-Mails Rock The Global Warming Debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monte_RCMS
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Monte_RCMS

Guest
forbes.com/sites/jamestaylor/2011/11/23/climategate-2-0-new-e-mails-rock-the-global-warming-debate/

Despite being a few days old, no one has posted this important news story.

Only the most techie sites seem to be revealing this important story.

But I did find it on an obscure site that linked to Forbes Magazine.

Excerpt:

11/23/2011

Climategate 2.0: New E-Mails Rock The Global Warming Debate

229 comments,

A new batch of 5,000 emails among scientists central to the assertion that humans are causing a global warming crisis were anonymously released to the public yesterday, igniting a new firestorm of controversy nearly two years to the day after similar emails ignited the Climategate scandal.

Three themes are emerging from the newly released emails: (1) prominent scientists central to the global warming debate are taking measures to conceal rather than disseminate underlying data and discussions; (2) these scientists view global warming as a political “cause” rather than a balanced scientific inquiry and (3) many of these scientists frankly admit to each other that much of the science is weak and dependent on deliberate manipulation of facts and data.

Regarding scientific transparency, a defining characteristic of science is the open sharing of scientific data, theories and procedures so that independent parties, and especially skeptics of a particular theory or hypothesis, can replicate and validate asserted experiments or observations. Emails between Climategate scientists, however, show a concerted effort to hide rather than disseminate underlying evidence and procedures.
 
This is one of those topics I gave up on discussing with my liberal friends years ago. There were a couple papers that had come out, I think in the wake of Al Gore’s movie, that specifically refuted a couple of global warming points based on recently released data from NOAA and NASA. I read the reports, which were very clear and to the point, then looked at the actual data from NOAA & NASA, which was equally accessible and understandable. I then brought them to the attention of a couple friends who were on a big global warming kick. They were irate over the report and told me that neither the reports nor the data could be used in our discussion because they clearly came from dishonest, biased, radical right-wing sources. They added that I couldn’t use the hard data from NOAA & NASA because, regardless of how clear and obvious the results were, I wasn’t a climatologist so I wasn’t qualified to draw conclusions from it (this was specifically amusing because they had also questioned the qualifications of the scientists who’d written the papers–both of whom were climatologists–and refuted the papers using work from scientists who weren’t climatologists). I figure this, like Climategate 1.0, will cause a stir among people with a little sense and be completely discounted by the left.
 
I’m surprised this story hasn’t received more attention. The first I heard about it myself was this morning, when I saw it discussed in a Wall Street Journal opinion piece.

Here’s an opinion piece from Commentary that I found much more interesting than the WSJ’s:

commentarymagazine.com/2011/11/28/leaked-emails-nyt-climategate/

“Leaked Emails Raise Questions About NYT’s ClimateGate Coverage”
 
So, will Obama give up on making our utility bills rocket out of sight and making us drive battery-driven cars that catch fire because the batteries overheat? Of course not.
 
So, will Obama give up on making our utility bills rocket out of sight and making us drive battery-driven cars that catch fire because the batteries overheat? Of course not.
Do you have a link for that [the battery fire “thing”?]
 
This is one of those topics I gave up on discussing with my liberal friends years ago. There were a couple papers that had come out, I think in the wake of Al Gore’s movie, that specifically refuted a couple of global warming points based on recently released data from NOAA and NASA. I read the reports, which were very clear and to the point, then looked at the actual data from NOAA & NASA, which was equally accessible and understandable. I then brought them to the attention of a couple friends who were on a big global warming kick. They were irate over the report and told me that neither the reports nor the data could be used in our discussion because they clearly came from dishonest, biased, radical right-wing sources. They added that I couldn’t use the hard data from NOAA & NASA because, regardless of how clear and obvious the results were, I wasn’t a climatologist so I wasn’t qualified to draw conclusions from it (this was specifically amusing because they had also questioned the qualifications of the scientists who’d written the papers–both of whom were climatologists–and refuted the papers using work from scientists who weren’t climatologists). I figure this, like Climategate 1.0, will cause a stir among people with a little sense and be completely discounted by the left.
Do you have links to those papers or data? The problem of course is that looking at raw data isn’t very useful, and without an understanding of how the modelling works, potentially misleading.

This second round of emails looks exactly the same as the first. A few snippets from these emails that sound damaging, but ultimately innocuous when put in context. There may be an investigation (as there was for the first set of emails) that will vindicate the scientists once again, but it will be a waste of everyone’s time. Climate deniers don’t need or want context or complications, they just want to write off science as a conspiracy theory, this initial reporting is all they need to hear.
 
Do you have a link for that [the battery fire “thing”?]
No. Just heard it on the radio this morning. Apparently some of batteries in the Chevy Volts have overheated and caught fire, and GM is offering loaners to anybody with a Volt so GM can check their car out. I’m not sure what GM will do about it, but at least that was the news I heard. Evidently this is a problem with Lithium batteries. I heard that some laptop computers with similar batteries have at least overheated as well.
 
So, will Obama give up on making our utility bills rocket out of sight and making us drive battery-driven cars that catch fire because the batteries overheat? Of course not.
C’mon Ridge, you know better than to knock government manufactured products. What can you expect? They are only trying to help!!

🙂
 
Do you have links to those papers or data? The problem of course is that looking at raw data isn’t very useful, and without an understanding of how the modelling works, potentially misleading.

This second round of emails looks exactly the same as the first. A few snippets from these emails that sound damaging, but ultimately innocuous when put in context. There may be an investigation (as there was for the first set of emails) that will vindicate the scientists once again, but it will be a waste of everyone’s time. Climate deniers don’t need or want context or complications, they just want to write off science as a conspiracy theory, this initial reporting is all they need to hear.
That was dry humor, right? Cause I found it funny.
 
I downloaded the emails in their entirety and found the ones cited in the article. They are mostly innocuous.

For example, this one
I gave up on [Georgia Institute of Technology climate professor] Judith Curry a while ago. I don’t know what she thinks she’s doing, but its not helping the cause,
Leaves out the last bit “… or her professional credibility.” The email was discussing a whiny post she made on this blog about someone beating her to publication: climateaudit.org/2008/05/29/lost-at-sea-the-search-for-windowed-marine-de-trending/#comments

Also, about the line:
I’ve been told that IPCC is above national FOI [Freedom of Information] Acts. One way to cover yourself and all those working in AR5 would be to delete all emails at the end of the process,
This is preceded by
We agreed that the only way IPCC can work is the collegiate way it did with AR4. These people [who file FOI requests for political reasons] know they are losing (or have lost) on the science. They are now going for the process. All you need to do is to make sure all in AR5 are aware of the process and that they adhere to it. We all did with AR4, but these people read much more into the IPCC procedures.
and followed by
We can cope with op-ed pieces, but these FOI requests take time, as the whole process of how we all work has to be explained to FOI-responsible people at each institution.
So basically they are worried about having to potentially account for every email communication, which is time consuming and unhelpful but they are not worried about the quality of their work. They are simply discussing what the best way to defend their work will be.

One more:
Any work we have done in the past is done on the back of the research grants we get – and has to be well hidden,
This one is obvious, I knew what he was talking about before I even opened the email. The data they are using has monetary value. They can’t just release the raw data to the public because the people who collected it get money for their data set. The raw data has to be “hidden” so that people will still pay for a license to the data.

Here is an example of the sort of terms the scientists are working under:
badc.nerc.ac.uk/data/surface/met-nerc_agreement.html

He goes on to say:
I just want these orchestrated requests to stop. I also don’t want to give away years of hard effort within CRU. Many of the agreements [to get the data] were made in the late 1980s and early 1990s and I don’t have copies to hand… Even if I were to find them all, it is likely that the people we dealt with are no longer in the same positions. These requests over the last 2.5 years have wasted much time for me, others in CRU and for Dave and Michael.
 
No. Just heard it on the radio this morning. Apparently some of batteries in the Chevy Volts have overheated and caught fire, and GM is offering loaners to anybody with a Volt so GM can check their car out. I’m not sure what GM will do about it, but at least that was the news I heard. Evidently this is a problem with Lithium batteries. I heard that some laptop computers with similar batteries have at least overheated as well.
OKay, so 4-5 people get loaner cars while their overpriced batteries are checked out.
 
C’mon Ridge, you know better than to knock government manufactured products. What can you expect? They are only trying to help!!

🙂
One of these days, they’ll put us back in horse-drawn buggies perhaps. On the other hand, horses, um, manufacture potentially offensive organic material. But then on the other hand, (one needs three hands with this government…one to keep on one’s wallet) can horse manure really be worse than what’s in those batteries? One has to doubt it.
 
One of these days, they’ll put us back in horse-drawn buggies perhaps. On the other hand, horses, um, manufacture potentially offensive organic material. But then on the other hand, (one needs three hands with this government…one to keep on one’s wallet) can horse manure really be worse than what’s in those batteries? One has to doubt it.
Yeah, well, the Mennonites can show us how to party like it’s 1899…

:rolleyes:
 
They are mostly innocuous.
Mostly innocuous? So which ones weren’t innocuous in your opinion?

Can you trust any of their self praising emails when so many are about how to manipulate them from the FOI requests? “One way to cover yourself…”
I’ve been told that IPCC is above national FOI [Freedom of Information] Acts. One way to cover yourself and all those working in AR5 would be to delete all emails at the end of the process,
 
Shame this is not getting more attention media-wise.

But of course, come to think of it----the media does NOT want to anger or question All Mighty Al, do they?

Yep------they do not. :rolleyes:👍
 
Do you have links to those papers or data? The problem of course is that looking at raw data isn’t very useful, and without an understanding of how the modelling works, potentially misleading.
I’m sure I don’t anymore. However, the raw data, along with the graphs and trends documented in the original documents (the NOAA & NASA docs, not the subsequent reports), were easy enough to read that most high schoolers wouldn’t have a problem with it. The main points my friends were making was that the sources (NOAA, NASA and the scientists who wrote the reports) were invalid, biased or off limits (the same friends had told me in other arguments that “facts don’t count” when discussing anything political), and that the publications the reports came from (the journal Nature was one of them) were unreliable, right-wing rags. You really can’t argue with logic like that.

It’s been 5 years or so since the argument in question, and I gave up on arguing with environmentalists not long after that when we were at a party at a friend’s house and one of his neighbors, who had driven his whole family in his Hummer from 3 doors down, called me a fascist for not buying into his theories 100%, then questioned my manhood because we were shopping for a Prius. We left when the same guy, who’d been on an anti-war rant an hour earlier, tried to escalate the discussion to a physical altercation. I figure you have a better chance of convincing a door it’s a wall than having a rational discussion with a mentality like that.
 
I’m sure I don’t anymore. However, the raw data, along with the graphs and trends documented in the original documents (the NOAA & NASA docs, not the subsequent reports), were easy enough to read that most high schoolers wouldn’t have a problem with it. The main points my friends were making was that the sources (NOAA, NASA and the scientists who wrote the reports) were invalid, biased or off limits (the same friends had told me in other arguments that “facts don’t count” when discussing anything political), and that the publications the reports came from (the journal Nature was one of them) were unreliable, right-wing rags. You really can’t argue with logic like that.

It’s been 5 years or so since the argument in question, and I gave up on arguing with environmentalists not long after that when we were at a party at a friend’s house and one of his neighbors, who had driven his whole family in his Hummer from 3 doors down, called me a fascist for not buying into his theories 100%, then questioned my manhood because we were shopping for a Prius. We left when the same guy, who’d been on an anti-war rant an hour earlier, tried to escalate the discussion to a physical altercation. I figure you have a better chance of convincing a door it’s a wall than having a rational discussion with a mentality like that.
Sorry you had to go through that, Gordon. 😦

Ironical, though, isn’t it? Liberals are supposed to be the “calm, peaceful, reasonable” ones…:rolleyes:

Holy Mother of God, help us all.
 
Sorry you had to go through that, Gordon. 😦

Ironical, though, isn’t it? Liberals are supposed to be the “calm, peaceful, reasonable” ones…:rolleyes:

Holy Mother of God, help us all.
I used to be quite the hot-head, both online and in real life, when it came to arguing over politics, the environment and other issues. After years of the same tactics (evade, deny, mislead, misrepresent, attack the sources then attack the person making the argument), I figured there was no value in arguing with liberals. The near-violence I mentioned above and the family member who shouted obscenities at me because he thought I was criticizing Obama when I wasn’t even talking about him (or anything political, for that matter) were the last two times I even remotely involved myself in real-life political talks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top