Columnist doesn't like death penalty

  • Thread starter Thread starter otrrl
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Popularity does not dictate morality. But it is generally a good barometer of morality. That is, things that most people say are good, especially in the area of human interactions, are in fact the moral things. That is because God has planted His law in every human heart. We are, by God’s own design, generally aware of what is right and what is wrong. Some people chose to ignore that God-given love of what is good. But most do not. So if most of humanity finds the death penalty abhorrent, it is very likely to be just that.
 
I think that turning herself into a god, making decisions about life and death, here - yes, there - no, is the essence of making an idol of oneself. As a columnist, she is saying, do what I say, worship me.
 
Seems to me the OP wanted to discuss the contradiction, given his comments on the article.

Since we rarely see news articles discussing both abortion and capital punishment, it’s difficult to bring up via news article.
 
The method, by injection, is not unusual, it is the standard method.

It’s also not intentionally cruel, options are limited to carry out the sentence.
 
Actually, it is quite a good judge of morality - in most cases. You need to make a special argument why something that most of the world finds abhorrent is actually a good thing.
Because the church has found the validity of its use is supported by Scripture. That would seem sufficient.

But as to the article, what the author didn’t mention were these points:
  • The relevant district court rejected his challenge
  • The Eighth Circuit court rejected his challenge
Here is part of the decision:

But because of his unusual medical condition, he contends the protocol is unconstitutional as applied to him. Mr. Bucklew raised this claim for the first time less than two weeks before his scheduled execution. He received a stay of execution and five years to pursue the argument, but in the end neither the district court nor the Eighth Circuit found it supported by the law or evidence. Now, Mr. Bucklew asks us to overturn those judgments. We can discern no lawful basis for doing so.
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
Actually, it is quite a good judge of morality - in most cases. You need to make a special argument why something that most of the world finds abhorrent is actually a good thing.
Because the church has found the validity of its use is supported by Scripture. That would seem sufficient.
The Church allows it, but still finds it abhorrent.
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
The Church allows it, but still finds it abhorrent.
The Church had allowed it, but finds that is use nowadays is unjustified.
The fact is unchanged: its use is supported by Scripture, but the article is nothing more than a bad piece of anti-death penalty propaganda. Looking at the history of this individual, which one can find in the decision, it shows the extent to which death row inmates can game the system. The crime occurred in 1996, Bucklew had appeals settled in 1998, 2001, 2006, 2009, 2010, 2012. Then, twelve days before his scheduled execution date in 2014 he filed the current appeal.

The Eighth Circuit “stressed that, on remand before the district court, Mr. Bucklew had to identify “at the earliest possible time” a feasible, readily implemented alternative procedure that would address those risks.”

The SC decision continues: “Despite the Eighth Circuit’s express instructions, when Mr. Bucklew returned to the district court in 2015 he still refused to identify an alternative procedure that would significantly reduce his alleged risk of pain.”

The appeal before the circuit court continued for two more years "By this point in the proceedings, Mr. Bucklew’s contentions about the pain he might suffer had evolved considerably. He no longer complained about circulation of the drug, the use of dye, or adverse drug interactions. Instead, his main claim now was that he would experience pain during the period after the pentobarbital started to take effect but before it rendered him fully unconscious."

Bucklew failed to make his case but he wasn’t done appealing. “On the same day Mr. Bucklew was scheduled to be executed, this Court granted him a second stay of execution… We then agreed to hear his case to clarify the legal standards that govern an as-applied Eighth Amendment challenge to a State’s method of carrying out a death sentence.” This was in 2018.

On that point: “Mr. Bucklew simply repeats the same argument the principal dissent offered and the Court expressly and thoughtfully rejected in Glossip… Mr. Bucklew’s submission, thus, amounts to no more than a headlong attack on precedent.”

But this was not the only weakness: “Mr. Bucklew’s argument fails for another independent reason: It is inconsistent with the original and historical understanding of the Eighth Amendment on which Baze and Glossip rest.”

By commenting on this case, and treating the criminal’s argument as to the pain he would suffer as fact rather than desperate speculation, the author gives a totally skewed perception of this case. As I said, this whole thing isn’t really about Bucklew anyway: it is about opposing the death penalty with whatever means are useful.
 
Still, one good thing may come out of this case: perhaps cases like it will occur less often now.

Courts should police carefully against attempts to use such challenges as tools to interpose unjustified delay.Last-minute stays should be the extreme exception, not the norm, and “the last-minute nature of an application” that “could have been brought” earlier, or “an applicant’s attempt at manipulation,” “may be grounds for denial of a stay.”… So, for example, we have vacated a stay entered by a lower court as an abuse of discretion where the in-mate waited to bring an available claim until just 10 days before his scheduled execution for a murder he had committed 24 years earlier… If litigation is allowed to proceed, federal courts“can and should” protect settled state judgments from“undue interference” by invoking their “equitable powers”to dismiss or curtail suits that are pursued in a “dilatory fashion or based on “speculative” theories. ”
 
Last edited:
In saecula saeculorum?
Yep, pretty much.

And as the things which the Holy Synod of Trent decreed for the good of souls concerning the interpretation of Divine Scripture, in order to curb rebellious spirits, have been wrongly explained by some, We, renewing the said decree, declare this to be their sense, that, in matters of faith and morals, appertaining to the building up of Christian doctrine, that is to be held as the true sense of Holy Scripture which our Holy Mother Church has held and holds, to whom it belongs to judge the true sense and interpretation of the Holy Scripture; and therefore that it is permitted to no one to interpret the Sacred Scripture contrary to this sense, nor, likewise, contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers. (Vatican I)
 
Last edited:
Yep, pretty much.
Not on point.
Tell me which of the fathers indicated their conviction that the death penalty would be justified in 2019? And was this position unanimous among the fathers?
 
Last edited:
Tell me which of the fathers indicated their conviction that the death penalty would be justified in 2019?
I really don’t want to turn this thread into another discussion of capital punishment rather than the topic the OP started, but the morality of capital punishment, and especially the interpretation of Scripture on which it is based, cannot change. What can surely change are local conditions that make its application inadvisable according to the prudential judgments of the time, but that has nothing whatever to do with whether the punishment is per se immoral.
And was this position unanimous among the fathers?
Turning to Christian tradition, we may note that the Fathers and Doctors of the Church are virtually unanimous in their support for capital punishment. (Cardinal Dulles)
 
…but the article is nothing more than a bad piece of anti-death penalty propaganda.
I thought it was quite a good piece. The label of “propaganda” is often applied to any point of view that one does not like. It has no objective meaning that has been demonstrated here. I find it ironic that the term “anti-death” is meant as a pejorative here, but in other contexts, the term “pro-life” (which is semantically the same thing) is seen as a good thing.
Looking at the history of this individual, which one can find in the decision, it shows the extent to which death row inmates can game the system.
“Game the system” is another loaded term that implies what cannot be established objectively - namely that the mechanisms being employed to avoid being put to death are unfairly being utilized.
By commenting on this case, and treating the criminal’s argument as to the pain he would suffer as fact rather than desperate speculation…
Perhaps you did not see the qualifier in what you call a statement of fact - namely, “according to his lawyers.” You have to read every word.
 
I thought it was quite a good piece.
What specific part?
I find it ironic that the term “anti-death” is meant as a pejorative here, but in other contexts, the term “pro-life” (which is semantically the same thing) is seen as a good thing.
I find it disappointing that you would find it appropriate to distort my argument. What I actually wrote was not “anti-death” but “anti-death penalty”, which was merely a descriptor and conveys no value judgment at all.

“Game the system” is another loaded term that implies what cannot be established objectively - namely that the mechanisms being employed to avoid being put to death are unfairly being utilized.
If by “objectively” you mean to your satisfaction, I might agree. If, however, this is not an example of such a situation it is hard to imagine what would be.

The crime occurred in 1996, Bucklew had appeals settled in 1998, 2001, 2006, 2009, 2010, 2012. Then, twelve days before his scheduled execution date in 2014 he filed the current appeal.

The court surely seemed to think it fit the description:

Courts should police carefully against attempts to use such challenges as tools to interpose unjustified delay. Last-minute stays should be the extreme exception, not the norm, and “the last-minute nature of an application” that “could have been brought” earlier, or “an applicant’s attempt at manipulation…
Perhaps you did not see the qualifier in what you call a statement of fact - namely, “according to his lawyers.” You have to read every word.
Perhaps you should have paid more attention to the lede which set the tone for the story: “This Supreme Court ruling is exceptionally cruel”.
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
I thought it was quite a good piece.
What specific part?
The parts that cited the court precedents, and the parts that cited how the US compares with other countries in our application of the death penalty.
I find it ironic that the term “anti-death” is meant as a pejorative here, but in other contexts, the term “pro-life” (which is semantically the same thing) is seen as a good thing.
I find it disappointing that you would find it appropriate to distort my argument. What I actually wrote was not “anti-death” but “anti-death penalty”.
My mistake. I did miss that. I apologize.
Perhaps you did not see the qualifier in what you call a statement of fact - namely, “according to his lawyers.” You have to read every word.
Perhaps you should have paid more attention to the lede which set the tone for the story: “This Supreme Court ruling is exceptionally cruel”.
The entire piece was under “Opinion / Political Op-Eds / Social Commentary”. So it is not unexpected to find an opinion expressed by the author, even in the lede.
 
Last edited:
What can surely change are local conditions that make its application inadvisable according to the prudential judgments of the time, but that has nothing whatever to do with whether the punishment is per se immoral.
I agree that we cannot say that it is “per se immoral”, but that does not mean that does not mean that its application is per se moral: it can, under local conditions be immoral, and that is what Pope Francis has brought to our attention.
virtually unanimous
I guess that means not unanimous.
 
The parts that cited the court precedents…
She appears to have misstated what those precedents are. This was the Court’s finding:

Mr. Bucklew’s submission, thus, amounts to no more than a headlong attack on precedent.
…and the parts that cited how the US compares with other countries in our application of the death penalty.
What other countries do in death penalty cases is irrelevant. Our laws are either just or unjust, and that is not determined by the laws of other nations.
My mistake. I did miss that. I apologize.
Thank you; I appreciate that.
The entire piece was under “Opinion / Political Op-Eds / Social Commentary”. So it is not unexpected to find an opinion expressed by the author, even in the lede.
I have no problem with people expressing contrary opinions. What I object to are comments that blur the difference between opinion and fact. Writing “according to his lawyers” doesn’t justify the presentation of their speculation as if it was accurate. This is the first paragraph:

Russell Bucklew is on death row in Missouri, and the United States Supreme Court just gave that state the go-ahead to kill him in one of the most torturous and cruel ways possible. Bucklew, who has a rare condition that leaves his body riddled with bleeding-prone tumors, will convulse, choke, and eventually suffocate on his own blood if he is executed by lethal injection, [according to his lawyers]. If this is true, his death will be slow. It will be brutal. It will be excruciatingly cruel.

Do you think adding [according to his lawyers] at the end of a list of flat assertions about how horrible his death will (not might) be really makes a difference? I am curious: roughly how long would you assume a “slow death” might be?
 
I agree that we cannot say that it is “per se immoral”, but that does not mean that does not mean that its application is per se moral…
There is no such thing as an act that is per se moral. That has never been a consideration, let alone an argument that has been made.
… it can, under local conditions be immoral, and that is what Pope Francis has brought to our attention.
Anything can be immoral if done for the wrong reasons or in the wrong circumstances, but I disagree that making an error in judgment about what should be done “under local conditions” is immoral. It would be a mistake, not a sin.
I guess that means not unanimous.
There were two Fathers who took a completely pacifist position on killing: Tertullian and Lantanctius, with Tertullian being the more outspoken. He was also eventually excommunicated so if you take the position your comment implies (that absolute unanimity is required) we would have to say that everything Tertullian disagreed with - including those things that got him excommunicated - cannot be considered settled doctrine. That seems more than a bit unreasonable.
 
What other countries do in death penalty cases is irrelevant. Our laws are either just or unjust, and that is not determined by the laws of other nations.
I would not call them “irrelevant”. According to paragraphs 1954-1960 of the Catechism, all men are created by God with a sense of right and wrong. When, in the process of striving to attain what they perceive as “good”, a vast majority of nations who we otherwise admire for their conduct deem something to be abhorrent, it very likely is abhorrent to God as well. We would do well to listen to their reasoning before dismissing their ethics as “irrelevant.”
The entire piece was under “Opinion / Political Op-Eds / Social Commentary”. So it is not unexpected to find an opinion expressed by the author, even in the lede.
I have no problem with people expressing contrary opinions. What I object to are comments that blur the difference between opinion and fact. Writing “according to his lawyers” doesn’t justify the presentation of their speculation as if it was accurate. This is the first paragraph:

Russell Bucklew is on death row in Missouri, and the United States Supreme Court just gave that state the go-ahead to kill him in one of the most torturous and cruel ways possible. Bucklew, who has a rare condition that leaves his body riddled with bleeding-prone tumors, will convulse, choke, and eventually suffocate on his own blood if he is executed by lethal injection, [according to his lawyers]. If this is true, his death will be slow. It will be brutal. It will be excruciatingly cruel.
Do you think adding [according to his lawyers] at the end of a list of flat assertions about how horrible his death will (not might) be really makes a difference?
[/quote]
Yes. As I said, you have to read every word when you parse a sentence. And the only reason it looked different in the text is because it was a hyper-link. Not because it was being parenthetical.
I am curious: roughly how long would you assume a “slow death” might be?
My opinion hardly matters, but I would think it depends on the amount of pain that accompanies that period. Under extreme pain, any death over two minutes could be seen as comparatively “slow”.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top