Comic Book & Graphic Novel talk

  • Thread starter Thread starter MarcoPolo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
(name removed by moderator), thanks for the update. What are some of Miller’s and Ditko’s recent works you are referring to that have really gone astray?
 
I must be the only one on the thread who thinks that manga is HIGHLY overrated. All style no substance.
 
I must be the only one on the thread who thinks that manga is HIGHLY overrated. All style no substance.
Really? Have you read One Piece? The character design isn’t exactly my type of eye-candy but it certainly makes up for in terms of story and cosmology. 😛
 
I must be the only one on the thread who thinks that manga is HIGHLY overrated. All style no substance.
You just haven’t read the right manga. Some of it rivals the best of any type of lit for depth.
 
You just haven’t read the right manga. Some of it rivals the best of any type of lit for depth.
I heartily disagree! Maus, Marvels, Kingdom Come, Earth X, Killing Joke, Preludes and Noctournes—all amazing works. What does manga give us? Tenchi Muyo, Dragonball, Sailor Moon, and Initial D—all mind numbing.
 
I heartily disagree! Maus, Marvels, Kingdom Come, Earth X, Killing Joke, Preludes and Noctournes—all amazing works. What does manga give us? Tenchi Muyo, Dragonball, Sailor Moon, and Initial D—all mind numbing.
Actually… the titles you just gave sorta proved Sailor Kenshin’s point. Sailor Moon and DBZ are classics but they’re already considered retro by a majority.^^; As with Initial D, I don’t like it either. Non-moe styles have never sat well with me. :rolleyes:
 
I heartily disagree! Maus, Marvels, Kingdom Come, Earth X, Killing Joke, Preludes and Noctournes—all amazing works. What does manga give us? Tenchi Muyo, Dragonball, Sailor Moon, and Initial D—all mind numbing.
Not quite.

Face it—you don’t like manga. Fine. But you mentioned a couple of excellent and very successful stories.

I don’t like your ‘stuff.’ Maus, eck. The rest, eck.

Big deal. If you want to fight, meet me on the corner and bring reinforcements. 😛
 
So sue me. I was just hoping that i would be able to find discussion from peeps who hadn’t jumped on the manga bandwagon. I can just bide my time. Like disco, this too, will pass. :cool:
 
So sue me. I was just hoping that i would be able to find discussion from peeps who hadn’t jumped on the manga bandwagon. I can just bide my time. Like disco, this too, will pass. :cool:
Um, it’s been going on since Astro Boy (which was started during the time of Disco :rolleyes: ). Manga/Anime isn’t just a fad. It’s an art form, a work of literature, and a culture all on its own. Face it, we otaku have reached the same level of archetype as Trekkies, Star Wars fans, comic book geeks, and Tolkien junkies and we’ll forever continue to be so. :cool:
 
Um, it’s been going on since Astro Boy (which was started during the time of Disco :rolleyes: ). Manga/Anime isn’t just a fad. It’s an art form, a work of literature, and a culture all on its own. Face it, we otaku have reached the same level of archetype as Trekkies, Star Wars fans, comic book geeks, and Tolkien junkies and we’ll forever continue to be so. :cool:
Not sure the last time I saw “literature” with the same degree of proliferation of porn
 
Um, it’s been going on since Astro Boy (which was started during the time of Disco :rolleyes: ). Manga/Anime isn’t just a fad. It’s an art form, a work of literature, and a culture all on its own. Face it, we otaku have reached the same level of archetype as Trekkies, Star Wars fans, comic book geeks, and Tolkien junkies and we’ll forever continue to be so. :cool:
Actually manga has existed since long before Astro boy, and includes subject matter like historical events, Japanese literary classics, legal cases (think courtroom drama), sports, and every other kind of subject matter.

That other guy might just as well have said, “I don’t like books,” just because there are one or two books he isn’t sophisticated enough to appreciate. 😉
 
Actually manga has existed since long before Astro boy, and includes subject matter like historical events, Japanese literary classics, legal cases (think courtroom drama), sports, and every other kind of subject matter.

That other guy might just as well have said, “I don’t like books,” just because there are one or two books he isn’t sophisticated enough to appreciate. 😉
Perhaps but Osamu Tezuka was the guy who sparked the flames of the anime revolution! XD
Not sure the last time I saw “literature” with the same degree of proliferation of porn
Excuse me but if you’re going judge anime and manga for the amount of ecchi series and doujin it has, you’re being quite shallow. There are a ton of popular series like Death Note and Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles and they don’t resort to fan service. :rolleyes:
 
My point is this: this board has turned into a discussion about manga which is a tiny slice of comics/graphic novels. And to refer to any kind of comic/graphic novel as serious art or literature is a stretch at best.Only once in a great while does something like maus come along that defies description. NO manga can come close to Maus, Watchmen, Marvels, or Sandman. Anime/Manga is populated almost exclusively by archetypes–not real characters. Tell me, when was the last time a manga title tackled something like the Holocaust? Or the child sex industry? Until manga can producee something other than fluff, i won’t be impressed.
 
My point is this: this board has turned into a discussion about manga which is a tiny slice of comics/graphic novels. And to refer to any kind of comic/graphic novel as serious art or literature is a stretch at best.Only once in a great while does something like maus come along that defies description. NO manga can come close to Maus, Watchmen, Marvels, or Sandman. Anime/Manga is populated almost exclusively by archetypes–not real characters. Tell me, when was the last time a manga title tackled something like the Holocaust? Or the child sex industry? Until manga can producee something other than fluff, i won’t be impressed.
Well then give these a chew cuz you’re seriously asking for it. :rolleyes:

Death Note - Interesting manga regarding the use of death in punishing criminals.

Akumetsu - You might wanna get books on Japanese history, politics, and economics for this one (oh and a barf bag while you’re at it)

P.S.

Why do I get the feeling that all you’ve been watching are the harem style anime? Cuz out of all genres that happens to contain the most archetypes. 😛
 
ack exactly my point!!! some random teenager finds a mystical or high tech thingamabob and carnage ensues. But no mature, intellectual presentation of the subject matter. Take a look at Daredevil: The Man Without Fear TPB (Miller/Romita, Jr./Jansen) and you will see what I mean. and just so it doesn’t throw you…this one reads left to right 😛
 
ack exactly my point!!! some random teenager finds a mystical or high tech thingamabob and carnage ensues. But no mature, intellectual presentation of the subject matter. Take a look at Daredevil: The Man Without Fear TPB (Miller/Romita, Jr./Jansen) and you will see what I mean. and just so it doesn’t throw you…this one reads left to right 😛
CWBetts, I think you should not concern yourself by putting down manga to the others. They are my friends and I enjoy hearing what they read about. Whatever one person or another likes is subjective.

I’d like to hear what you are reading now and what you recommend. Do you have high hopes for the Watchmen movie? What did you think about what I said about Moore in post 14 above?
 
ack exactly my point!!! some random teenager finds a mystical or high tech thingamabob and carnage ensues. But no mature, intellectual presentation of the subject matter. Take a look at Daredevil: The Man Without Fear TPB (Miller/Romita, Jr./Jansen) and you will see what I mean. and just so it doesn’t throw you…this one reads left to right 😛
I thought you said you wanted a manga that tackled issues like crime, the sex industry, etc? And how much of Death Note have you read? Certainly you did not just stop at the pilot chapter… did you? :confused:
 
And to refer to any kind of comic/graphic novel as serious art or literature is a stretch at best.Only once in a great while does something like maus come along that defies description… Until manga can producee something other than fluff, i won’t be impressed.
Definitely.
Just a note: my son writes/draws graphic novels, which are pretty popular. Escalator, or King City by Brandon Graham.amazon.com/King-City-1/dp/1598169823/ref=pd_sim_b_1 He was raised Christian but doesn’t live it (prayers appreciated) but occasionally you can see the influence. I really like his art, and his sense of humor is awesome.

He tries to avoid the superhero plots, but it’s an uphill fight. His comics are about everyday people trying to live normal lives, often under bizarre circumstances. His hero is an anti-hero who keeps trying to avoid spectacular deeds, but of course the publishers keep pushing him to write more action. (Not for children)
 
My point is this: this board has turned into a discussion about manga which is a tiny slice of comics/graphic novels. And to refer to any kind of comic/graphic novel as serious art or literature is a stretch at best.Only once in a great while does something like maus come along that defies description. NO manga can come close to Maus, Watchmen, Marvels, or Sandman. Anime/Manga is populated almost exclusively by archetypes–not real characters. Tell me, when was the last time a manga title tackled something like the Holocaust? Or the child sex industry? Until manga can producee something other than fluff, i won’t be impressed.
Manga tackles every subject. Please stop revealing your ignorance and go back to reading Maus.

Don’t make me get up off this couch!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top