Commandments

  • Thread starter Thread starter BTTG
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You are absolutely correct. I should not have stated that the Catholics changed Exo. 20 vs 3 and 4 into 1 commandment. This was wrong of me. I have asked God for forgiveness.
It is my thinking that vs 3 is one commandment and vs 4 another commandment.

craig
Hi BTTG,
It may further the discussion to remember that the bible, when originally written, was not divided into chapters and verses. The chapter and verse divisions that we know today were not done until 1555 AD.

Catholic bishop Steven Langton was the first to divide the bible into chapters in 1227 AD. A Jewish rabbi named Nathan divided the OT into verses in 1448 AD, Robert Estienne divided the NT into verses in 1555 AD, and used Nathan’s OT verse numbering. His numbering system has been used in nearly all bibles since that time.

God bless you,
Paul
 
Hi Craig.
This is the way Lutherans number the commandments also. Lutherans also, generally, accept the early ecumenical councils. one of which rejects iconoclasm. Would you then say, knowing this, that Lutherans have also “submerged” the graven image thing?

Hi Jon, you are pleasant to talk to.

I do not no much about Lutherans to be honest. However, if that is the case, I would say that they also are submerging the command of graven images.

Verse 17 also say, “you shall not” twice. Apparently the need was there to separate “wife” from other property. And it seems to me that is the reason.

I believe it was you I was speaking with about how many commandments are there. At first I said there could be 9, 10 12, etc., because they are not numbered. However, the bible does read that there are 10 commandments…(Deu 4:13) And he declared unto you his covenant, which he commanded you to perform, even ten commandments; and he wrote them upon two tables of stone.

Well, you can’t blame Catholics alone for this, as virtually the entire Christian Church, east and west recognizes the Lord’s day.

How many Jews, believed that Jesus was the Messiah? How many people believed Noah after more then 120 years he informed the people of what was going to happen. It is not to say that because the mass observes one day that it is the correct day.

Again, it is the practice of virtually all Christianity to celebrate the resurrection on Sundays.

We ought to obey God rather then men.

Thanks Jon

craig
 
Hi Craig.
This is the way Lutherans number the commandments also. Lutherans also, generally, accept the early ecumenical councils. one of which rejects iconoclasm. Would you then say, knowing this, that Lutherans have also “submerged” the graven image thing?

Verse 17 also say, “you shall not” twice. Apparently the need was there to separate “wife” from other property. And it seems to me that is the reason.

Well, you can’t blame Catholics alone for this, as virtually the entire Christian Church, east and west recognizes the Lord’s day.

Again, it is the practice of virtually all Christianity to celebrate the resurrection on Sundays.

You are welcome,
Jon
Hi BTTG,
It may further the discussion to remember that the bible, when originally written, was not divided into chapters and verses. The chapter and verse divisions that we know today were not done until 1555 AD.

Catholic bishop Steven Langton was the first to divide the bible into chapters in 1227 AD. A Jewish rabbi named Nathan divided the OT into verses in 1448 AD, Robert Estienne divided the NT into verses in 1555 AD, and used Nathan’s OT verse numbering. His numbering system has been used in nearly all bibles since that time.

God bless you,
Paul
Thank you Paul for that information. I never knew that. See we all can learn, praise God!!

I just posted that the bible does state, Deut. 4:13, that there are 10 commandments that were written on two tablets of stone.

craig
 
Thank you Paul for that information. I never knew that. See we all can learn, praise God!!

I just posted that the bible does state, Deut. 4:13, that there are 10 commandments that were written on two tablets of stone.

craig
hi bttg, are you SDA? thx
 
In utmost respect Jon, God provided one commandment for; you shall have no other gods before me and another commandment for " graven images". God established 2 separate commandments. God is perfect, He knows the past present and future. If God wanted the
two commandments to be joined as one He would have done so we he gave them to Moses. It was the Catholics who changed the 2 commandments into one.

craig
Craig, Just curious:D If you are correct and we put 2 commandments together would there not be 11 commandments instead of 10 ten?
 
Following 10 commandments is hard enough. Adding an eleventh…🙂
 
Craig, Just curious:D If you are correct and we put 2 commandments together would there not be 11 commandments instead of 10 ten?
Hi Rinie ( sorry if I got the spelling wrong)

My thinking is that the catechism separates Exo. 17 , into 2 commandments, where it should be one commandment as it is written in the KJV.

(KJV) (Exo 20:17) Thou shalt not covet thy neighbour’s house, thou shalt not covet thy neighbour’s wife, nor his manservant, nor his maidservant, nor his ox, nor his ***, nor any thing that is thy neighbour’s.

The “shall not covet” encompasses everything under the “house”.

craig
 
Following 10 commandments is hard enough. Adding an eleventh…🙂
In the flesh, our carnal minds, it is difficult and impossible to keep the 10 commandments. With the grace of God, through the Holy Spirit and by faith the 10 commandments are not burdensome.🙂

craig
 
Thank you Paul for that information. I never knew that. See we all can learn, praise God!!

I just posted that the bible does state, Deut. 4:13, that there are 10 commandments that were written on two tablets of stone.

craig
Had to look that up. You’re correct, it does say 10 commandments. Doesn’t show what the break-out is though. That gets left for someone else to define. I’ll trust the Magisterium for that.
 
SDA2RC;6992313:
I agree that our rest in Jesus is to be 7 days a week, without a doubt. Jesus told us to search the scriptures daily.

(Exo 31:13) Speak thou also unto the children of Israel,
saying, Verily my sabbaths ye shall keep: for** it is a sign between me and you** throughout your generations; that ye may know that I am the LORD that doth sanctify you.

(Exo 31:16)** Wherefore the children of Israel shall keep the sabbath,** to observe the sabbath throughout their generations, for a perpetual covenant.

(Exo 31:17) ** It is a sign between me and the children of Israel for ever**: for in six days the LORD made heaven and earth, and on the seventh day he rested, and was refreshed…

Please notice the parts that I have bolded above… God specifically said that it was a sign between He and the Children of Israel. You cannot simply insert yourself into this covenant because you want to follow the Sabbath. If you understand scripture than you know that the New Testament clarifies the Old. We find in the New Testament a very different Idea than what you had. Even the Jews of the Old Testament had a very different idea than what you have.

BTW… the verses you quoted also state that anyone who works on the Sabbath shall be put to death! When was the last time you put someone to death for working on the Sabbath? Why dont you do this? If you believe that this passage is binding on you and me… why have you not killed anyone working on the Sabbath like this passage says? It seem to me that you are picking and choosing what you want to be applicable to you! This is the problem with your position!

**Please answer, why do you not kill people who work on Saturday like God commands in this passage? **

Please note that your position is also different than that of the Jews, as noted in the Midrash:“The Sabbath-keepers who are not circumcised are intruders, and deserve punishment,” (; Deut. R. i. and Ma’ase Torah, ed. Schönblum; see also Hippolytus," Refutatio, Omnium Hæresium," ix. 21).

Read more: http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=514&letter=C&search=circumcision#ixzz0xdtGJz2D"The Jews believed that for one to keep the Sabbath they must be circumcised… Since Paul taught there was no need for circumcision it effectively answered the Sabbath question. Jews were actually offended if Non-circumcised people tried to keep the Sabbath and wanted them punished.
The seventh day is Holy and Blessed. Did God now change his mind after the resurrection of Jesus and change the day to Sunday as the Holy and Blessed day. i don’t read this in scripture .
Then you need to keep reading Scripture and begin to understand the doctrine of the Church and the Covenants. Your premise is that because God said that his Sabbath was a perpetual sign with Israel and throughout their generations that it must still be in effect because he wouldnt change His mind?

Lets examine that a little, please answer the following questions:


  1. *]If the Sabbath will endure forever because it is called “eternal” then won’t all the Jewish feasts and circumcision also endure because it is also called eternal in Gen 17:10-14 (same Hebrew word used)
    *]If the Sabbath will endure forever because it is called “holy” then won’t all the Jewish feasts also endure forever because they are also called holy?
    *]If the Sabbath will endure forever because God hallowed it, then won’t Solomon’s temple Ps 65:4; 1 Ki 9:3 and the vessels in the tabernacle Ex 40:9; Num 31:6; 1 Ki 8:4 also endure forever because God hallowed them too?
    *]If the Sabbath will endure forever because it was an eternal sign between God and his people, then shouldn’t we also still practice circumcision Gen 17:11 and Passover Ex 12:13 because it too is called an eternal sign between God and his people?

    Please answer these questions… and explain why you selectively apply traits to the Sabbath.
    The above verse was written at least 40 years after the crucifixion. The key words here are “according to the commandment”. It doesn’t read" according to the commandment that was
    ". Therefore, the Sabbath day of rest and worship during the time of Luke were being obeyed.

    No one is arguing against the idea that the Jews Kept the Sabbath at least until the day of Pentecost and many possibly afterwards… But we are not Jews and we are Christians. What I said was that No Christians are commanded to recorded as observing the Sabbath. As far as Paul preaching on the Sabbath… um… yea he did! But preaching on the Sabbath is not what is commanded in the 4th Commandment, scripture never records Paul or any other Christians as observing the Sabbath as day of Rest.

    Many sabbatarian preachers will preach or teach on Sunday - Friday… that doesnt mean they are keeping those days as a Sabbath. Thats just silly.
    As a side note the Sabbath will be observed in the new heavens and the new earth…(Isa 66:22-23) And it shall come to pass, that from one new moon to another, and from one sabbath to another, shall all flesh come to worship before me, saith the LORD.
    Craig, Craig… you need to read the entire passage and study it more… LOL

    Don’t be too hasty to apply Isaiah’s vision to Heaven, LOL, it is about the Maccabeus time 200-164 BC the rebirth of Jewish independence in their land and the rebuilding of the temple after the exile.;

    Is 66:20… They will bring …horses and Chariots, in litters, on mules, on camels to my Holy Mountain Jerusalem.

    Is 66:21… I will choose priests and LEVITES.

    Do you really believe that we are going to bring Horses, chariots, on mules and camels to heaven and Levites in Heaven? Really?

    Please note.
    Levites ended with John Lk 16:16
 
The “shall not covet” encompasses everything under the “house”.

craig
And thou shall have no other Gods before me, covers everything on heaven and earth… including graven images… 😉

What I am saying Craig is that your rendering of how they should be divided is no better than ours… our is no better than yours… its just different.

you have been asked at least twice that I have seen, what denomination you are, what religion you identify yourself with… can you tell us please?
 
My thinking is that the catechism separates Exo. 17 , into 2 commandments, where it should be one commandment as it is written in the KJV.

(KJV) (Exo 20:17) Thou shalt not covet thy neighbour’s house, thou shalt not covet thy neighbour’s wife, nor his manservant, nor his maidservant, nor his ox, nor his ***, nor any thing that is thy neighbour’s.

The “shall not covet” encompasses everything under the “house”.

craig
Craig, we follow the division that was used by St. Augustine, which he got from the Jews at that time… The way we divide them was how the synagogue scribes divided them at that time. The jews begain dividing them the way protestants do now, much later… the plain fact is that there were no verses or punctuation in the original text, therefore MAN had to decide how to punctuate and notate the verses…

It was done this way for years… then protestants wanted to change them… thats ok… but dont tell us we changed them! LOL How could we change an ordering to the commandments that wasn’t established yet… LOL

A mans wife is not his property therefore is not lumped in with his house and goods, that is why the last commandment is split. You may see that differently, i.e. a woman is the mans property so it is all the same… but we dont see it that way. Plain and simple.
 
Following 10 commandments is hard enough. Adding an eleventh…🙂
Isn’t that the truth:D I have this older lady she always said there are ten commandments but her Mother always said there should be one more. Mind your own business:rotfl:
 
And thou shall have no other Gods before me, covers everything on heaven and earth… including graven images… 😉

What I am saying Craig is that your rendering of how they should be divided is no better than ours… our is no better than yours… its just different.

you have been asked at least twice that I have seen, what denomination you are, what religion you identify yourself with… can you tell us please?
Exactly!! Also there is no scripture that forbids the use of images in worship. God forbade the WORSHIP of statues. He did not fobid the religious use of statues. He actually commanded their use in the bible. Ex. 25:18-20 1 Chr. 28:18-19 Ezekiel 41:17-18.

Also I would like to know if at Christmas his Church sets up a manger. Is so then looks like the protestatants are going down with us 😃

God only forbids the worship of graven images as gods, but he does not ban the making of images. If so there would be no religious movies, photos, paintings, it would all be banned. Even in the case of the bronze serpent shows God does not even forbid the ritual use of religious images. It is when people begin to adore and worship the serpent as a god that makes it a sin.

Now why would God make a command that would make us sin? He wouldn’t!!😃
 
Exactly!! Also there is no scripture that forbids the use of images in worship. God forbade the WORSHIP of statues. He did not fobid the religious use of statues. He actually commanded their use in the bible. Ex. 25:18-20 1 Chr. 28:18-19 Ezekiel 41:17-18.

Also I would like to know if at Christmas his Church sets up a manger. Is so then looks like the protestatants are going down with us 😃

God only forbids the worship of graven images as gods, but he does not ban the making of images. If so there would be no religious movies, photos, paintings, it would all be banned. Even in the case of the bronze serpent shows God does not even forbid the ritual use of religious images. It is when people begin to adore and worship the serpent as a god that makes it a sin.

Now why would God make a command that would make us sin? He wouldn’t!!😃
Hey Rinnie,

You’ve got a point there about mangers. You could add to that golden altar crosses, ( or communion table crosses), framed “portraits” of Jesus, and the Christmas tree, not to mention all the items that could be in the parish/fellowhsip hall, but not in the sanctuary.
 
Hey Rinnie,

You’ve got a point there about mangers. You could add to that golden altar crosses, ( or communion table crosses), framed “portraits” of Jesus, and the Christmas tree, not to mention all the items that could be in the parish/fellowhsip hall, but not in the sanctuary.
Also,
Pictures of family, pictures in books, pictures on church tracts, church leaders/etc. TV…
 
Craig, we follow the division that was used by St. Augustine, which he got from the Jews at that time… The way we divide them was how the synagogue scribes divided them at that time. The jews begain dividing them the way protestants do now, much later… the plain fact is that there were no verses or punctuation in the original text, therefore MAN had to decide how to punctuate and notate the verses…

It was done this way for years… then protestants wanted to change them… thats ok… but dont tell us we changed them! LOL How could we change an ordering to the commandments that wasn’t established yet… LOL

A mans wife is not his property therefore is not lumped in with his house and goods, that is why the last commandment is split. You may see that differently, i.e. a woman is the mans property so it is all the same… but we dont see it that way. Plain and simple.
Ok, we agree to disagree.🙂

craig
 
=BTTG;6993739]
Hi Jon, you are pleasant to talk to.
hi Craig,
Thank you kindly.
I do not no much about Lutherans to be honest. However, if that is the case, I would say that they also are submerging the command of graven images
Even if it is clear that “you shall have no other gods before me” logically includes 'no graven images", as those images would then be placed as gods before Him?
I believe it was you I was speaking with about how many commandments are there. At first I said there could be 9, 10 12, etc., because they are not numbered. However, the bible does read that there are 10 commandments…(Deu 4:13) And he declared unto you his covenant, which he commanded you to perform, even ten commandments; and he wrote them upon two tables of stone.
Yes. Is scripture clear as to whether or not the stone tablets were numbered 1 - 10, and which commands were placed behind each number?
How many Jews, believed that Jesus was the Messiah? How many people believed Noah after more then 120 years he informed the people of what was going to happen. It is not to say that because the mass observes one day that it is the correct day.
We ought to obey God rather then men.
Well, I won’t concede to you in your argument that all of Christendom is violating God’s law in this matter.
But on the point of obeying God rather than man; does your faith communion follow all of the Levitical laws? Also, do you accept that in the Lord’s Supper, His body and blood are truly and substantially present, as His words (God’s words) are clear: “This is my body…”?

Jon
 
Thank you Paul for that information. I never knew that. See we all can learn, praise God!!

I just posted that the bible does state, Deut. 4:13, that there are 10 commandments that were written on two tablets of stone.

craig
Yes, we all know that, which is why no matter how a church divides up the commandments they always end up with ten.
 
Yes, we all know that, which is why no matter how a church divides up the commandments they always end up with ten.
👍 And they always and entirely reflect the law that was handed down to Moses. No one is trying to submerge parts of it.

Jon
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top