Yes, definitely!! Especially if you look at the OP’s posting history – If you were experiencing an emergency and crisis like this would you go to an anonymous website you never joined before and start posting?
…until she posted this (my bolding - that is just not possible at all):
What posting history? The only other thread the OP has started was one about what to do with old rosaries and such. Unless there are some other threads that have been recently deleted by the moderators.
The lack of postihg history is what I am referring to. Reread what I posted.
No. Such is not possible. The Eucharist in such occasions would be returned to the Church.
lady ,whats your problem Just stop, this is pretty sick. People have given you their time, thoughts and prayers. No one knows who you are, how about an apology for your own sake.
The bottom line is, if the Hosts are still in the dumpster, They need to be found and gotten out. The Eucharist cannot be deconsecrated, so the prayers the priest said did NOT remove the Real Presence. Jesus is still present and therefore He needs to be rescued from the dumpster.
this ,if the your story is true pm the location of the dumpster to one of us .i’ll will contact the knights of columbus in the area and we will have someone dumpster diving by daybreak tomorrow.this is serious.if you do not contact one of us ,i for one will have to assume your making this up.this has to be taken care of if true. i have contacted my pastor , and he affirmed what everyone already knew.one can not unconsercrate .he actually was kinda aggravated that i asked such a stupid question.again contact one of us by pm or email
For all the other Catholics in this thread who read this and decided this whole thing is a hoax, let me clarify something.
Such I would propose would not be the case here.
Still the appearance would still likely continue --even if the box was dumped out. It would take a good deal to reduce the number of hosts to what no longer appeared to be bread.
I agree, this is true, but from what I have heard it appears that a lot of food items are being thrown in and the contents of the dumpster are likely in decay… if the hosts are scattered in the mix they likely aren’t in very good shape.
Aye. Any priest wort his salt will likely come and get them out!
Hi,
I don’t understand your point. Her first post was to ask for advice about what to do with the rosaries and other religious items that she found when going through her grandmother’s things. That doesn’t seem strange to me. Do you find it strange?
Any priest worth his salt would check the dumpster to see whether any of the hosts could be safely retrieved. And above all would not give the OP the false impression that the hosts had somehow been ‘dconsecrated’ by his prayer.Hi,
If you had read later in the thread (no harm in not doing so, 'cept for a lack of context) the OP has called a priest, and the said priest said a prayer over the dumpster, left, and called it a done deal.