His maxim was that if you have trouble giving it up, you have a problem.
I agree with this, and the counselor that got me to recognize I had a problem wasn’t one that said “can you give it up” it was one who said:
Could you have a case of beer in your fridge, and each and every day you would need to drink 2 beers, no more, not less (you see I could drink zero drinks in a day, but couldn’t stop at 2). He said you would have to drink 2 beers and then just go on with whatever your doing, watching TV, whatever. But you couldn’t have a 3rd beer or more. You would have to have 2. You coudn’t have none.
And that made it sunk in for me I had a problem because I knew once I got the feeling from 2 beers it would be basically impossible for me to not continue to have more, especially if they are right there in the fridge.
I have since been cured of my alcohol problem, it was a long time in the making and I used multiple different resources/strategies. I am in the very, very small minority of people who used to drink like a pig but now drink 3-5x/ year, maybe 1/2 glass of beer/wine to a max of maybe 2 drinks, all on special occasions with family. And now since I have a baby I wouldn’t even drink 1/2 a drink despite being 250 lbs, if I were driving, even if 2 hours went by after having the 1/2 drink. I have alcohol in my house, it dosn’t effect me. I can be around others drinking, mostly I don’t want to, it makes me tired.
But for years I attended AA and practiced the 12 steps. I believe that drinking is a way of coping with mental/emotional/spiritual/psychological/soulful problems… and one must dig into those painful area’s and figure out other ways of dealing with them.
At age 19-21 I drank every other day (was too hung over to drink daily) and would drink like a 12 pack AND a pint of hard liquor. And this pattern came on quick. Prior to this I would gather with the guys and maybe drink 1 beer, pouring out another 1-2-3 ‘pretending’ to drink them to avoid being made fun of and to look like I was fitting in and keeping up to some extent to the others.
Then I went to the hardcore drinking and wound up waking up in towns not knowing how I got there or where I was and other extreme behavior. I have come to see this behavior as a sort of passive suicidality, putting myself in extreme danger while not regognizing it (but think that is what was going on subconsciously).
I did many other things in addtion to AA to get where I am. And I don’t recommend anyone with a problem drinking (regardless of how long ago their last drink was) to attempt to drink socially. I think I am an extreme exception to the rule, with the rule being true that if you can’t control your drinking, if you can’t drink in safety, that you will never be able to do so.
But don’t be jealous, I have more than my share of problems and alchol is basically a non issue for me. I don’t think about it and don’t need it. It’s like artichoke or something to me. I might have some on the rare occasion it’s offered but never crave it and turn it down more often than accept if others are drinking.