Confirmed: Obama, Romney to attend Al Smith dinner [CWN]

  • Thread starter Thread starter CWN_News
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
With all due respect I really, fundamentally disagree with the fact that this can be turned into a good idea, in any way, whatsoever.

God bless.

-Paul
Obama has doubled down on his views on employers paying for drugs they consider objectionable a few weeks ago. He going to be campaigning with Sandra Fluke in Denver. I am convinced, nothing will change Obama’s mind, not even the good attentions of Catholic leaders
I believe God can bring good out of anything. I believe there is always hope for conversion and change. After all, how would any of us be able to achieve salvation otherwise? We are all miserable sinners, and we have all fallen short of the mark-yet, God has brought us to the Church, to the sacraments so that we will have hope of salvation. Who are we to deny that to anyone else, no matter how much we disagree with the place they are in now?
 
Exactly, so there’s still no conservative there. 😛
I do not think Romney is the most conservative ever, but he has conservative views on big issues, like marriage, religious conscience, and most of his economic views are conservative
 
Maybe Rick Santorum has a big role and will get all the diehard Catholics going.
 
Obama has doubled down on his views on employers paying for drugs they consider objectionable a few weeks ago. He going to be campaigning with Sandra Fluke in Denver. I am convinced, nothing will change Obama’s mind, not even the good attentions of Catholic leaders. There’s no incentive for Obama to change. The devout Catholics will not vote for him, and the non practising will vote for him
I think that’s right. The President essentially betrayed the Cardinal over the HHS mandate. Rather than worrying about losing the Catholic vote, he’s appealing to his special interest lobbies, especially Planned Parenthood, NOW, and others.

I think he wants to take on traditional Catholicism on the mandate, because he thinks he can win, and it will make him look like a hero to the anti-Catholic and anti-Christian parts of his base. It will also make it easier to push the mandate further in a second term, and further marginalize Catholics. He knows he won’t get the Catholic Answers vote anyway! He won’t get the vote of most Catholic with orthodox doctrinal views. But he will use such groups as “Catholics United,” to snag the loosely attached Catholics, and make him seem acceptable to Catholics.
 
I think that’s right. The President essentially betrayed the Cardinal over the HHS mandate. Rather than worrying about losing the Catholic vote, he’s appealing to his special interest lobbies, especially Planned Parenthood, NOW, and others.

I think he wants to take on traditional Catholicism on the mandate, because he thinks he can win, and it will make him look like a hero to the anti-Catholic and anti-Christian parts of his base. It will also make it easier to push the mandate further in a second term, and further marginalize Catholics. He knows he won’t get the Catholic Answers vote anyway! He won’t get the vote of most Catholic with orthodox doctrinal views. But he will use such groups as “Catholics United,” to snag the loosely attached Catholics, and make him seem acceptable to Catholics.
Exactly. Very scandalous and dangerous indeed. And Cardinal Dolan is playing right into Mr. Obamas hands.

God bless.

-Paul
 
I agree that this is a gamble by Cardinal Dolan, but although President Obama and Governor Romney are both smart men, Cardinal Dolan is also smart and he has the truth on his side. This is an opportunity for the truth about both candidates to be exposed and sound bites from the dinner will be playing until the election and even afterwards.

The people on this forum are way better informed about Obama’s record and what the Church teaches than the average Catholic. Many of the Catholics in the pew, and especially the lax Catholics still don’t know about Obama’s record on life issues and religious liberty. It is mostly their own fault that they are uninformed, but Church leadership also needs to take responsibility for a generation or two of bad catechesis.
 
The people on this forum are way better informed about Obama’s record and what the Church teaches than the average Catholic. Many of the Catholics in the pew, and especially the lax Catholics still don’t know about Obama’s record on life issues and religious liberty. It is mostly their own fault that they are uninformed, but Church leadership also needs to take responsibility for a generation or two of bad catechesis.
Yes, and that is the danger here, that uninformed Catholics will see the pre-eminent Prelate of the Catholic Church in the United States having a nice dinner filled with jokes and laughter and think that the Church is alright with President Obama’s policies and agenda. It sends a mixed message to the faithful. That’s a huge problem in our Church for the last few decades, the mixed messages and inconsistent teaching, and Cardinal Dolan has an opportunity to send a HUGE message to Catholics that President Obama is not ok, and also to non-Catholics/Catholic politicians, that the Church no longer will allow itself to be used as a political pawn to pick up votes. It is incredibly scandalous of Cardinal Dolan.

God bless.

-Paul
 
The Alfred E. Smith dinner is an annual event. Candidates from both parties have been invited to it since 1960.

I don’t see a huge scandal, provided that both candidates were invited…and they were.

The initial news reports on this indicated that only Obama was invited. That would have been scandalous. I’m glad the reports have been corrected.
 
Yes, and that is the danger here, that uninformed Catholics will see the pre-eminent Prelate of the Catholic Church in the United States having a nice dinner filled with jokes and laughter and think that the Church is alright with President Obama’s policies and agenda.
No, it’s understood that it is just an old-fashioned political dinner where enemies leave their swords and shields by the door to shmooze and enjoy themselves. It is NOT a place where either the President or the Cardinal is going to make a speech that either man or the audience is going to find uncomfortable… It’s tradition! 🙂
 
No, it’s understood that it is just an old-fashioned political dinner where enemies leave their swords and shields by the door to shmooze and enjoy themselves. It is NOT a place where either the President or the Cardinal is going to make a speech that either man or the audience is going to find uncomfortable… It’s tradition! 🙂
Exactly the problem, we shouldn’t shmooze and enjoy ourselves with someone that has disrespected and disregarded our deeply held beliefs, has betrayed and lied to us, and has made no attempt to show his disdain for our Catholic faith, indeed Christianity itself, at every turn. This just adds to the scandalization of the faithful, it doesn’t diminish it at all. It is an opportunity for Obama to pretend that everything is okay.

There is a precedent for not inviting President’s in the past, ‘tradition’, is an inadequate excuse for this horrible decision.

God bless.

-Paul
 
Exactly the problem, we shouldn’t shmooze and enjoy ourselves with someone that has disrespected and disregarded our deeply held beliefs, has betrayed and lied to us, and has made no attempt to show his disdain for our Catholic faith, indeed Christianity itself, at every turn. This just adds to the scandalization of the faithful, it doesn’t diminish it at all. It is an opportunity for Obama to pretend that everything is okay.

There is a precedent for not inviting President’s in the past, ‘tradition’, is an inadequate excuse for this horrible decision.
I, for one, will not call or consider His Eminence a naive fool, and I expect that he knows more about what he is doing than any poster on this Forum does. You can, however, contact the Cardinal at his Chancery Offices at 1011 First Ave, New York, NY 10022 @ 212-371-1000 to complain to him if you like.
 
I, for one, will not call or consider His Eminence a naive fool, and I expect that he knows more about what he is doing than any poster on this Forum does. You can, however, contact the Cardinal at his Chancery Offices at 1011 First Ave, New York, NY 10022 @ 212-371-1000 to complain to him if you like.
I have made my opinion known, already. And I signed the petition to disinvite Obama. I thank you for the information though.

There is nothing wrong with the laity voicing their concerns, in fact we have a duty to do so. If you agree with what is happening, that is fine, but I will continue to encourage others to speak up about this.

We can respectfully agree to disagree on the topic.

God bless.

-Paul
 
We can respectfully agree to disagree on the topic.
Yeah, among ourselves, but it’s chutzpah to presume that you might know better than a Cardinal does about his job and how to do it. I’m sure that he knows what Pres. Obama is all about.
 
Yeah, among ourselves, but it’s chutzpah to presume that you might know better than a Cardinal does about his job and how to do it. I’m sure that he knows what Pres. Obama is all about.
We will respectfully agree to disagree on this topic, I have no interest in debating. I have made my feelings known, and you have yours. We’re not going to convince each other otherwise, so…that’s about it.

God bless.

-Paul
 
I expect after a nice, polite dinner, we’ll see commercial from a Super PAC claiming Romney is reponsible for Al Smith’s passing.
 
I expect after a nice, polite dinner, we’ll see commercial from a Super PAC claiming Romney is reponsible for Al Smith’s passing.
Except that the dinner is going to be, as always, raucous and loud, you may be right. 😃
 
I expect after a nice, polite dinner, we’ll see commercial from a Super PAC claiming Romney is reponsible for Al Smith’s passing.
As well as an Obama commercial in which he’s pictured with Cardinal Dolan – to the confusion of the faithful, which is exactly Obama’s purpose.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top