Confused about the devil telling the truth

  • Thread starter Thread starter johnnyt3000
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So I have heard that the devil never tells the truth and in the bible says in John 8:44

But at the same time, St. Dominic had an experience when exorcising someone, and the demon(s) said: here is the link to the page: michaeljournal.org/secretrosary.htm How do you comprehend this? I thought demon’s never tell the truth:confused:
The demons are FORCED to speak the truth by God and Mary during exorcisms. The demons say this themselves in the quote you have provided us with. God bless you.
 
I remember reading in an interview with another exorcist priest, reported in a German magazine, that during an exorcism, the demon which is being expelled ridicules and blasphemes everybody in sight - the exorcist, the local bishop, the Pope, even God.

But he said they never blaspheme Mary. His words were “It’s an enigma”.

I tried to find the link to the interview, but I’m afraid I couldn’t find it. I haven’t seen it for a while.
 
Mary, like us, has no inherent strength; our strength comes through our reliance on God.
This is the Catholic position, as well. Mary was quite clear she called God her Savior, and when she stated that the Almighty had done great things for her.

What you’re addressing is ultimately the way that devotional language of past centuries was used, and not the theology which underpins Mariology. Poetic hyperbole should be understood as a characteristic of a certain genre of Catholic writing, and should not be confused with the sort of expression we would find in, say, official documents or something like the new Catechism.

For example, this language about Mary saving folks from falling into hell. Now, you say that only Jesus can save individuals from falling into hell. Ultimately, this is certainly true. But how are people to know about Jesus and the Gospel unless they are told? Such individuals require the help of parents, teachers, preachers, and others in order to come to Jesus in the first place. There is a participation in God’s working His grace in people’s lives which is evident all around us, and which Christ commanded of His disciples in Matthew 28:19.

Now, obviously, this is not by necessity, but by God’s will, and the Catholic Church incorporates this into her theology of salvation. We are saved, not as individuals, but *as a family, *since this is God’s good pleasure.

Mary’s role in all of this is far greater than that of any other mere human creature, since she is the very Mother of God, the very ark which housed the incarnate Word of God. At this point, I would introduce a wonderful little article to you: calvin2catholic.com/?p=227
 
This is the Catholic position, as well. Mary was quite clear she called God her Savior, and when she stated that the Almighty had done great things for her.
I read the article you referenced and he tries to bring together a logical case for Mary’s special role in Catholic theology, but I find it to be quite a stretch to try to justify it scripturally. I think that one would need to first accept the authority of the Catholic church magesterium in order to accept this concept of Mary’s role in our salvation. Does the church consider Mary to be a "co-redemptress.?
 
+JMJ+
I read the article you referenced and he tries to bring together a logical case for Mary’s special role in Catholic theology, but I find it to be quite a stretch to try to justify it scripturally. I think that one would need to first accept the authority of the Catholic church magesterium in order to accept this concept of Mary’s role in our salvation. Does the church consider Mary to be a "co-redemptress.?
The Catholic Church teaches that we are all “co-redemptors” in that we participate in the saving mission of Jesus Christ.

Now I rejoice in my sufferings for your sake, and in my flesh I complete what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions for the sake of his body, that is, the church. Colossians 1:24

Is any among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord; and the prayer of faith will save the sick man, and the Lord will raise him up; and if he has committed sins, he will be forgiven. Therefore confess your sins to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The prayer of a righteous man has great power in its effects. James 5:14-16

Above all, keep loving one another earnestly, since love covers a multitude of sins. 1 Peter 4:8

Note what was said in James 5:16 and 1 Peter 4:8. Does love ever end, even in heaven? Do people in heaven stop praying for us, if praying for each other is part of loving each other (see Matthew 5:44)?
 
Respectfully I say the devil was lying about Mary. The very first sentence was a lie when he said that Mary is all powerful. Only God is all powerful. Then he says that she can save her servants from falling into hell, but only Jesus can save us from falling into hell. It sounds like Satan is trying to convince us that we can be saved through devotion to Mary and pull us away from the truth of the gospel. He says “if only Mary had not pitted “her” strength against ours.” Mary, like us, has no inherent strength; our strength comes through our reliance on God. I really believe that Satan was trying to throw us off track on this one.
Bingo!!! Good eye! I think your insight about the devils intent is correct too. Unfortunately I think there are some naive Catholics who make an idol of our Blessed Mother. Good call 👍
 
+JMJ+

The Catholic Church teaches that we are all “co-redemptors” in that we participate in the saving mission of Jesus Christ.

Now I rejoice in my sufferings for your sake, and in my flesh I complete what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions for the sake of his body, that is, the church. Colossians 1:24

Is any among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord; and the prayer of faith will save the sick man, and the Lord will raise him up; and if he has committed sins, he will be forgiven. Therefore confess your sins to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The prayer of a righteous man has great power in its effects. James 5:14-16

Above all, keep loving one another earnestly, since love covers a multitude of sins. 1 Peter 4:8

Note what was said in James 5:16 and 1 Peter 4:8. Does love ever end, even in heaven? Do people in heaven stop praying for us, if praying for each other is part of loving each other (see Matthew 5:44)?
Actually, I agree with you about the saints in heaven hearing our prayers and praying for us, even though I take a lot of heat from other Protestants for it. I don’t agree that Mary has any more influence than any other person - “for God shows no partiality”. Romans 2:11 (ESV). Even though Paul was talking about the Jewish people vs gentiles, the principle still applies here. He doesn’t love Mary any more than anyone else.
 
Actually, I agree with you about the saints in heaven hearing our prayers and praying for us, even though I take a lot of heat from other Protestants for it. I don’t agree that Mary has any more influence than any other person - “for God shows no partiality”. Romans 2:11 (ESV). Even though Paul was talking about the Jewish people vs gentiles, the principle still applies here. He doesn’t love Mary any more than anyone else.
You seem to be ignoring Romans 2:6–10: [6] [God,]Who will render to every man according to his works. [7] To them indeed, who according to patience in good work, seek glory and honour and incorruption, eternal life: [8] But to them that are contentious, and who obey not the truth, but give credit to iniquity, wrath and indignation. [9] Tribulation and anguish upon every soul of man that worketh evil, of the Jew first, and also of the Greek. [10] But glory, and honour, and peace to every one that worketh good, to the Jew first, and also to the Greek.

Mary was the most perfect of God’s creation, as is fitting for the bearer of Christ, no? Thus, she is the most holy human, and for this reason, she is the highest in Heaven, under God.

All veneration to Mary is directed towards Christ. He is pleased when we follow Him and honor His mother, whom “all generations shall called blessed.”
 
So I have heard that the devil never tells the truth and in the bible says in John 8:44
But at the same time, St. Dominic had an experience when exorcising someone, and the demon(s) said: here is the link to the page: michaeljournal.org/secretrosary.htm How do you comprehend this? I thought demon’s never tell the truth:confused:
At the heart of any believable lie, there must be some truth. A truth which may be distorted or bent, or words which can be parsed in multiple ways. Modifiers which are ignored while the thing the liar wants focused on are noted and overly emphasized.

The catechism teaches that:

2111 Superstition is the deviation of religious feeling and of the practices this feeling imposes. It can even affect the worship we offer the true God, e.g., when one attributes an importance in some way magical to certain practices otherwise lawful or necessary. To attribute the efficacy of prayers or of sacramental signs to their mere external performance, apart from the interior dispositions that they demand, is to fall into superstition.41

It also teaches of prayer that:

2562 Where does prayer come from? Whether prayer is expressed in words or gestures, it is the whole man who prays. But in naming the source of prayer, Scripture speaks sometimes of the soul or the spirit, but most often of the heart (more than a thousand times). According to Scripture, it is the heart that prays. If our heart is far from God, the words of prayer are in vain.

Certainly, the Rosary is beneficial as is any prayer. But to focus simply on the Rosary as if it’s some kind of magical incantation that can compel God to do our desires based on Mary’s intercession is wrong. Note, the demon refers to the Rosary in connection with prayer with perseverance. Something Christ Himself taught in at least two parables- the man who receives visitors late at night who than has to go to his neighbor asking for bread. And the old woman and the unjust judge.

The demon refers to her ‘faithful servants’ and again their perseverance, and Mary wants us to be obedient to her Son. We do not serve Mary, but we are faithful servants when we do as her Son bids us.

ETA: Why do we pray the Rosary? It is not to simply appeal to Mary-- it’s purpose is to raise our hearts and minds to God. Something many find easier to do through the Rosary, to contemplate more fully the human aspect of Jesus via His earthly Mother. She who understood Him best, to help us to be closer to Him.

Certainly, she can intercede even at the point of our death, if we truly repent of evil and turn to her. But didn’t Christ show us that aspect of His divine mercy when He forgave the criminal on the cross next to Him? But to get Mary’s intercession we must ask for it, we must turn to her and trust, not in her, but in her Son’s mercy. Certainly, Mary is a powerful intercessor- Christ performed His first miracle at her behest, specifically saying that it was not yet His time. He chose to emphasize the special relationship that Mary had with Him.

The demon may be telling the truth, but it doesn’t appear he was telling the whole truth. Like any accomplished liar, perhaps he was telling truth in a way that folks would hear and focus on what they wanted to hear.
 
You seem to be ignoring Romans 2:6–10: [6] [God,]Who will render to every man according to his works. [7] To them indeed, who according to patience in good work, seek glory and honour and incorruption, eternal life: [8] But to them that are contentious, and who obey not the truth, but give credit to iniquity, wrath and indignation. [9] Tribulation and anguish upon every soul of man that worketh evil, of the Jew first, and also of the Greek. [10] But glory, and honour, and peace to every one that worketh good, to the Jew first, and also to the Greek.

Mary was the most perfect of God’s creation, as is fitting for the bearer of Christ, no? Thus, she is the most holy human, and for this reason, she is the highest in Heaven, under God.

All veneration to Mary is directed towards Christ. He is pleased when we follow Him and honor His mother, whom “all generations shall called blessed.”
Romans 2:6-10 says that God will render to every man according to his works. This promise is to all who follow him - they will receive eternal life. Those who don’t will not. These verses are not referring to any special status in heaven. We don’t know much about Mary’s works during her lifetime. Of course, we assume that she lived a life in service to God, but did she live a life more exemplary than, say the apostles Paul and Peter? Maybe it’s pointless for us to argue this because you approach the matter from a position of belief in the immaculate conception, whereas I approach it from a purely scriptural basis. I believe that one would have to be first convinced of the authority of the Catholic church to define doctrine in order to accept the doctrines of the Catholic church concerning Mary.
 
Romans 2:6-10 says that God will render to every man according to his works. This promise is to all who follow him - they will receive eternal life. Those who don’t will not. These verses are not referring to any special status in heaven. We don’t know much about Mary’s works during her lifetime. Of course, we assume that she lived a life in service to God, but did she live a life more exemplary than, say the apostles Paul and Peter? Maybe it’s pointless for us to argue this because you approach the matter from a position of belief in the immaculate conception, whereas I approach it from a purely scriptural basis. I believe that one would have to be first convinced of the authority of the Catholic church to define doctrine in order to accept the doctrines of the Catholic church concerning Mary.
I’m always curious about reliance on scripture. You reject the authority of the Church, why do you trust in Her authority on the canon of scripture? Or do you rely on the authority of Martin Luther on the canon of scripture and his amendments/changes to it?

I approach this from a belief in Jesus Christ, and that He established a Church to whom He gave the authority to preach and teach in His name. I rely on that authority in accepting the Bible as scripture.

I would not accept the Bible as scripture if it were not for first accepting the authority of the Church. Hence, I accept all the teachings of the Church, as St. Paul put it-- those handed on by word of mouth and letter. Even the Bible says, not all that occurred is contained within it.
 
I’m always curious about reliance on scripture. You reject the authority of the Church, why do you trust in Her authority on the canon of scripture? Or do you rely on the authority of Martin Luther on the canon of scripture and his amendments/changes to it?

I approach this from a belief in Jesus Christ, and that He established a Church to whom He gave the authority to preach and teach in His name. I rely on that authority in accepting the Bible as scripture.

I would not accept the Bible as scripture if it were not for first accepting the authority of the Church. Hence, I accept all the teachings of the Church, as St. Paul put it-- those handed on by word of mouth and letter. Even the Bible says, not all that occurred is contained within it.
Christ gave his apostles the “keys to the kingdom” and the authority to “bind and loose”. The church recognized the doctrinal teachings of the apostles to be authoritative from the beginning. When the church came together to formalize the canon of the new testament, they were not affirming new doctrines, but rather verifying that the contents of the new testament actually were attributable to the direct teachings of the apostles. They also placed emphasis on whether they had already been in use in the various christian churches throughout the years leading up to that time. Therefore, the Holy Spirit was working through the church to bring about the formation of the new testament. I don’t believe that the “church” that the Spirit works through is just the Catholic church, but rather the universal church that is comprised of all followers of Christ. God has promised to be with and protect that church against the devil until until the final day. There’s always been disagreement and contention within the church, but it still goes on, spreading the gospel message around the world - the Protestant churches as well as the Catholic church. The spread of the gospel and the good works of the church continue to this day and will go until the end of the world.
 
Christ gave his apostles the “keys to the kingdom” and the authority to “bind and loose”. The church recognized the doctrinal teachings of the apostles to be authoritative from the beginning. When the church came together to formalize the canon of the new testament, they were not affirming new doctrines, but rather verifying that the contents of the new testament actually were attributable to the direct teachings of the apostles. They also placed emphasis on whether they had already been in use in the various christian churches throughout the years leading up to that time. Therefore, the Holy Spirit was working through the church to bring about the formation of the new testament. I don’t believe that the “church” that the Spirit works through is just the Catholic church, but rather the universal church that is comprised of all followers of Christ. God has promised to be with and protect that church against the devil until until the final day. There’s always been disagreement and contention within the church, but it still goes on, spreading the gospel message around the world - the Protestant churches as well as the Catholic church. The spread of the gospel and the good works of the church continue to this day and will go until the end of the world.
Lek, thank you for your response. I do agree on emphasizing those things that we have in common. I also came to a crisis of faith where I re-examined why I am Catholic vice some other branch of christianity. It came down to what you refer, to the beliefs and practises of the early christians prior to the declaration of the canon of scripture. That included the Marian doctrines, the Real Presence in the Eucharist, the structure of the liturgy, infant baptism, the Sacrament of Reconciliation etc.

Hence, I can understand the claims about what the demon said about Mary, and correlate it with scripture and the teachings of the Church. The demon doesn’t say ‘Rely on Mary’ or say that anyone who is a ‘servant’ of Mary will be saved. He states, as I pointed out the requirement for perseverance and being faithful. Things Christ Himself emphasized.

May God bless you and yours always.
 
Lek, thank you for your response. I do agree on emphasizing those things that we have in common. I also came to a crisis of faith where I re-examined why I am Catholic vice some other branch of christianity. It came down to what you refer, to the beliefs and practises of the early christians prior to the declaration of the canon of scripture. That included the Marian doctrines, the Real Presence in the Eucharist, the structure of the liturgy, infant baptism, the Sacrament of Reconciliation etc.

Hence, I can understand the claims about what the demon said about Mary, and correlate it with scripture and the teachings of the Church. The demon doesn’t say ‘Rely on Mary’ or say that anyone who is a ‘servant’ of Mary will be saved. He states, as I pointed out the requirement for perseverance and being faithful. Things Christ Himself emphasized.

May God bless you and yours always.
Thanks also for your comments. I’m sure we’ll talk again.
 
I believe that one would have to be first convinced of the authority of the Catholic church to define doctrine in order to accept the doctrines of the Catholic church concerning Mary.
To be sure, Catholic converts have a series of objections that they eventually have answered to their satisfaction, and moreover, there seems to be an order in which these objections are resolved. Mary is always one of the final hurdles, and part of the reason is certainly as much cultural and emotional as it is intellectual. So many folks just feel weird about praying to Mary, even if they’re basically convinced intellectually.

However, in the meantime, I’m not so sure it’s necessary to be convinced that the Catholic Church is right on Mary, so much as it is to understand what she teaches about Mary and why. Approaching it from that perspective can be so refreshing. You may not feel compelled to see things as we do, but at least you’ll understand the reasoning.

I would really recommend the following free audio series: hebrewcatholic.net/07-mary-daughter-of-zion-and-mother-of-god/

Dr. Feingold presents his series on Mary as being “from the perspective of Scripture, Tradition, the Magisterium of the Church, and theological reflection,” and with an emphasis on how Mary ties in with the wider Catholic understanding of both salvation history as well as basic spirituality.

For a seminary-level introduction to Mariology, you really can’t beat this wonderful resource. 👍
 
Bingo!!! Good eye! I think your insight about the devils intent is correct too. Unfortunately I think there are some naive Catholics who make an idol of our Blessed Mother. Good call 👍
I understand that it’s not the official Catholic doctrine that Mary is to be worshiped as someone more than human. I do believe though, that the practice of going to Mary in a “special” sense can lead people to attribute qualities to her that are “super human”. It just seems to me that the demon was trying to keep him away from being fixed on Jesus. Just my own take on it.
 
My opinion on this 😃

I quote the Douay-Rheims:

John 8:44
You are of your father the devil, and the desires of your father you will do. He was a murderer from the beginning, and he stood not in the truth; because truth is not in him. When he speaketh a lie, he speaketh of his own: for he is a liar, and the father thereof.

See the bold part? That means that devil not always speaking lie. 😉

Now take a look at Matthew, if we assume that devil always lying

Matthew 8:29
And behold they cried out, saying: What have we to do with thee, Jesus Son of God? art thou come hither to torment us before the time?

What so Jesus is actually not Son of God? :eek:

So see, devil can speak truth, especially under holy authority. 👍

Ah for those who try to ignore Our Blessed Mother’s roles, I take this from the topic a few days ago.

catholicexchange.com/5-facts-to-ignore-before-accusing-catholics-of-mary-worship
 
I see some of you arguing that the devil is telling the truth, but as a Catholic I agree with Leks statement. Its true that our Blessed Mother can do wondrous things and intervene for us, but she is not all powerful. Only God is. She can help save souls by interceeding for us but the only one who can save is Jesus. So the devil is lying here.
 
+JMJ+
I see some of you arguing that the devil is telling the truth, but as a Catholic I agree with Leks statement. Its true that our Blessed Mother can do wondrous things and intervene for us, but she is not all powerful. Only God is. She can help save souls by interceeding for us but the only one who can save is Jesus. So the devil is lying here.
“Sooner,” says the devout Blosius, “would heaven and earth be destroyed than would Mary fail to assist any one who asks for her help, provided he does so with a good intention and with confidence in her”…

St. Anselm, to increase our confidence, adds, that “when we have recourse to this divine Mother, not only we may be sure of her protection, but that often we shall be heard more quickly, and be thus preserved, if we have recourse to Mary and call on her holy name, than we should be if we called on the name of Jesus our Savior;” and the reason he gives for it is, “that to Jesus, as a judge, it belongs also to punish; but mercy alone belongs to the Blessed Virgin as a patroness”… * Meaning, that we more easily find salvation by having recourse to the Mother than by going to the Son*—not as if Mary was more powerful than her Son to save us, for we know that Jesus Christ is our only Savior, and that he alone by his merits has obtained and obtains salvation for us; but it is for this reason: that when we have recourse to Jesus, we consider him at the same time as our judge, to whom it belongs also to chastise ungrateful souls, and therefore the confidence necessary to be heard may fail us; but when we go to Mary, who has no other office than to compassionate us as Mother of mercy, and to defend us as our advocate, our confidence is more easily established, and is often greater. “We often obtain more promptly what we ask by calling on the name of Mary than by invoking that of Jesus. Her Son is lord and judge of all, and discerns the merits of each one; and therefore if he does not immediately grant the prayers of all, he is just. When, however, the Mother’s name is invoked, though the merits of the suppliant are not such as to deserve that his prayer should be granted, those of the Mother supply that he may receive.”

St. Alphonsus Liguori, Glories of Mary, First Part, “4. TO YOU DO WE CRY, POOR BANISHED CHILDREN OF EVE: Mary is prompt to help those who invoke her”
 
+JMJ+
Romans 2:6-10 says that God will render to every man according to his works. This promise is to all who follow him - they will receive eternal life. Those who don’t will not. These verses are not referring to any special status in heaven. We don’t know much about Mary’s works during her lifetime. Of course, we assume that she lived a life in service to God, but did she live a life more exemplary than, say the apostles Paul and Peter? Maybe it’s pointless for us to argue this because you approach the matter from a position of belief in the immaculate conception, whereas I approach it from a purely scriptural basis. I believe that one would have to be first convinced of the authority of the Catholic church to define doctrine in order to accept the doctrines of the Catholic church concerning Mary.
I think it is strange for you to use this passage to disprove Mary’s special status in heaven, then when somebody points out that it was incomplete, you then say then that the passage has no correlation to any person’s position in heaven whatsoever. I am confused.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top