Confused

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pargo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

Pargo

Guest
Ok, I was born and raised Catholic and attended Catholic school. I was recently invited to attend a Pentecostal church from a friend of mine. Now I feel more allegiance to this church then my own. I was also baptized again, in this church. I really need some answers or help on what to do.

My mother is up-set that I left the Catholic Church. Is there a difference in religion or what is the difference.
 
I don’t want to answer until I understand the question.

are you saying you left the Catholic Church because of what this new church teaches says, or does, and you even accepted baptism in this church, a formal public rejection of your Catholic faith and baptism, yet you cannot even state the differences between teaching of this denomination and the Catholic Church?

what is it about Catholic teaching and practice that you rejected?

what is it about the teaching and practice of the new church that caused you to take such a drastic step?

perhaps if you answer those questions it will help you answer your OP yourself.

Pentecostalism rejects the Holy Trinity, rejects the Catholic doctrine of Jesus Christ as fully human and fully divine, and rejects CAtholic teaching on the nature of God, The Father, Son and HOly Spirit, and is therefore not even Christian.

It might be best if you ask the leaders of your new church to explain their doctrine and practice to your satisfaction, and then you can ask specific questions here about Catholic doctrine and practice, and then you will have the tools to answer your own question.
 
There are two major groups of Pentecostals - Trinitarian Pentecostals and Oneness Pentecostals.

Regardless, what made you reject the Catholic church and its teachings?

Did you decide to join the Pentecostal church because you were there and maybe you were swept up in the moment?

My best friend is Pentecostal. I would visit her church if she asked, but I would not leave the Catholic faith for it.

And, yes, I agree - you should talk to the leaders of the new church you have chosen. And, I would talk with a priest too.

You seem to be questioning what you did.

God bless you on your journey. I will be praying that you get the answers you seek and that you make the right decision as it pertains to you. :highprayer:
 
Thank for all the advice and prayers. I need to continue to find what suite me better.I still consider myself a Catholic.
 
The first time i heard of Pentacostals was on this forum. Sorry but when did it exist?
 
Ok, I was born and raised Catholic and attended Catholic school. I was recently invited to attend a Pentecostal church from a friend of mine. Now I feel more allegiance to this church then my own. I was also baptized again, in this church. I really need some answers or help on what to do.

My mother is up-set that I left the Catholic Church. Is there a difference in religion or what is the difference.
I can see why your mother is upset. She’s payed tuition for you to go to Catholic school and you go once to a pentecostal meeting and you leave the Catholic Church?

I sense lots of pieces are missing in this story :hmmm:
 
Thank for all the advice and prayers. I need to continue to find what suite me better.I still consider myself a Catholic.
Did you look at th equestions posted to you about the differences in belief, faith and practice between the Chruch and Penticostalism?

You said you are looking for what “suits you better” … What about searching for what suits God? In other words, searching for the Truth … Where is the truth … did Jesus die to redeem mankind or not? Is God One, as in Triune - Father, Son and Holy Spirit? Or not? Is Jesus the Son of God and Son of Man, born of a Virgin and the Holy Spirit, fully Divine, fully human?

If you are looking for entertainment and fellowship, go to the movies and join a club … those should be chosen to ‘suit’ your preferences …

Faith challenges, it is not always ‘comfortable’ nor easy … it does not always "suit’ …
 
Ok, I was born and raised Catholic and attended Catholic school. I was recently invited to attend a Pentecostal church from a friend of mine. Now I feel more allegiance to this church then my own. I was also baptized again, in this church. I really need some answers or help on what to do.

My mother is up-set that I left the Catholic Church. Is there a difference in religion or what is the difference.
You might have wandered too far not knowing the dangers outside of the Catholic church. You’re still very young I would guess. Why not learn and nourish yourself first with the teachings of the Catholic church (mostly available online) and become strong in your faith. False teachers will only feed you with false teachings, misleading opinions and lies.

Read the gospel of John chapter 6: only in the Catholic Church whereby you will find Jesus as the truth, the way, and the life… thru the Holy Eucharist!

Are you also going to leave…?😦
 
Well, I just want to say that the more I learn about Catholic the stronger my faith as catholic. I was baptized and raised in Catholic family but now, I know more about catholic church teaching more than my parents. Why?? because I read and learn from internet and books more than my parents do.
God bless
 
Ok, I was born and raised Catholic and attended Catholic school. I was recently invited to attend a Pentecostal church from a friend of mine. Now I feel more allegiance to this church then my own. I was also baptized again, in this church. I really need some answers or help on what to do.

My mother is up-set that I left the Catholic Church. Is there a difference in religion or what is the difference.
Oh Dear, what have you done???

***“I should not believe the Gospel except as moved by the authority of the Catholic Church.”
Saint Augustine (354-430), Against the Letter of Mani, 5,6, 397 A.D… ***
 
Thank for all the advice and prayers. I need to continue to find what suite me better.I still consider myself a Catholic.
In the CC there’s everything that is typical for Pentacostals (gift of tongues, prophesying, healings, etc.) and much more (miracles that don’t happen in protestant denominations like Fatima, Real Presence, Pope - the vicar of Christ, etc.). God wants us to be obedient so first of all we should find what suits God. Good luck!
 
Pargo,
I need help. PLease let me know what you found that you were lacking, what you have learned that you did not know. The short story does not tell us how to help you.
 
Ok, I was born and raised Catholic and attended Catholic school. I was recently invited to attend a Pentecostal church from a friend of mine. Now I feel more allegiance to this church then my own. I was also baptized again, in this church. I really need some answers or help on what to do.

My mother is up-set that I left the Catholic Church. Is there a difference in religion or what is the difference.
We are not allowed to ask for personal information on these forums but it would be helpful if you could tell us your age – within a range of a couple of years, e.g., senior in high school, early twenties. Can you do that?
 
Ok, I was born and raised Catholic and attended Catholic school. I was recently invited to attend a Pentecostal church from a friend of mine. Now I feel more allegiance to this church then my own.
Wow, one visit and you feel “more allegiance” than to the Church you’ve spent your entire life in?

Jesus has a parable where it talks about the seeds planted in rocky soil, sandy soil, good soil, etc. Your faith must be on sandy soil indeed if it is so easily swayed to group that lacks the fullness of Truth and the Sacraments.
I was also baptized again, in this church. I really need some answers or help on what to do.
There is no such thing as a second baptism. Baptism is a one-time event. You need to go to Confession and talk to your priest about this.
My mother is up-set that I left the Catholic Church. Is there a difference in religion or what is the difference.
Really, you’ve left the Catholic Church? Your mind is made up so easily? Your mother is quite right to be upset.

Of course there is a difference. The Pentacostal denomination does not have the fullness of Truth. They do not have the Sacraments. They deny many truths about the Faith. And, some Pentacostals-- called “Oneness” or “Holiness” Pentacostals deny even the Trinity. They do not believe in God the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

Get yourself back to the Catholic Church.
 
You might have wandered too far not knowing the dangers outside of the Catholic church. You’re still very young I would guess. Why not learn and nourish yourself first with the teachings of the Catholic church (mostly available online) and become strong in your faith. False teachers will only feed you with false teachings, misleading opinions and lies.

Read the gospel of John chapter 6: only in the Catholic Church whereby you will find Jesus as the truth, the way, and the life… thru the Holy Eucharist!

Are you also going to leave…?😦
Thanks so much!!!
 
this article on Catholic Exchange this morning by Marcello d’Ambrosio gives a great description of “Catholic Pentecostalism” and what Pentecost and the Gifts of the Holy Spirit mean for Catholics
catholicexchange.com/2008/05/10/112411/
since OP’s mailbox is full I offer it for general reading
 
Pentecostalism rejects the Holy Trinity, rejects the Catholic doctrine of Jesus Christ as fully human and fully divine, and rejects CAtholic teaching on the nature of God, The Father, Son and HOly Spirit, and is therefore not even Christian.

**Oneness Pentecostals, also called Apostolic Faith (though obviously, it treally is not) reject the Trinity. They are really Sabellian Modalists, which is a heresy.

But these are the minority. Most Pentecostals, such as Assemblies of God, are strongly Trinitarian.**
 
belief, practice and teaching in AG varies widely and there is no central theology or governance that mandates what individual preachers and congregations do. One cannot take for granted that any AG minister preaches and understands a Trinitarian theology with the Catholic understanding, or that baptisms are valid.
 
Thank for all the advice and prayers. I need to continue to find what suite me better.
Sorry but that’s the wrong approach. You need to continue to search for where the truth revealed by God lies, and then conform yourself to the truth (suite yourself to the truth, you might say).
 
Thanks so much!!!
You have gotten some good advice here. I would highly recommend studying the doctrine of the Eucharist. You need to learn what is meant by the term “transubstantiation”, and what the Catholic Church means by this and why she teaches it. Although the word is a relatively new word, the teaching itself has been taught since the Apostles themselves. This is in contrast to the Pentecostals and other Protestants, who have only been around since the 16th century and teach things that were not known in the time of the Apostles.

You should also study the fathers of the Church. People like Augustine of Hippo, Thomas Aquinas, Ignatius of Antioch and Irenaeus of Lyons. We have thousands of writings from these people, and the one thing in common with all of them is that they are all Catholic! It would take a lifetime and you would still be scarcely scratching the surface of these guys, but it really doesn’t take all that long to see just how Catholic they are.

Now, I’m going to make a prediction, Pargo. I predict that if you tell the church leaders at this Pentecostal Church that you’re attending that you’re a Catholic, then they are going to tell you all kinds of things that the Catholic Church teaches. And I also predict Pargo, that all of these things they tell you will be false. OK, maybe not all of them, but a fair deal of them. Anyway, I want to point you to a wonderful resource that we Catholics have. It is called the Catechism of the Catholic Church and you can find it at the Vatican website here. Catechism basically means “teaching”. It is what is supposed to happen at Catholic schools, but sadly it often does not. And so Pargo, when these guys at your Pentecostal church tell you that the Catholic Church teaches something or other, I encourage you to go to the Catechism and find out if what they say is true. And then, find out exactly what it is that the Catholic Church does teach.

I suspect these guys already know that you are Catholic, right Pargo? Well let me tell you that what they did to you - in baptising you again - is absolutely terrible. It was not your fault, since you did not know what you were doing. But they really should have known better! Not only Catholics would be scandalised by them doing this, but probably 99% of all Christians in the world today. Maybe you should research baptism so you can find out what I’m talking about.

My last word of advice is to learn about the Sacrament of Confession. If you come to realise that what you did in being baptised again (or anything else) was wrong, then you need to go to the Sacrament and Confess it. Again, you must only do this if you know that it is wrong. If you don’t really mean the Confession, then it doesn’t count. Confession is really a wonderful thing. You might think it is the scariest place on Earth, but once you know what it is, it becomes almost the most wonderful place on Earth.

The other resource I encourage you to use is these forums! You can really learn a lot here. I don’t visit the forums that often these days, but feel free to pm me if you have any specific questions and I’ll try to reply as soon as I can. God bless!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top