Conservatives push to speed up Obamacare repeal

  • Thread starter Thread starter AFerri48
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Pope Francis did not say healthcare is a “constitutional” right. He said it is a right. Pope Francis does not need to consult the U.S. Constitution when teaching on moral issues. He does not need to “do his homework” in this regard.

Too often in this forum the word “Constitutional” is imbued with some moral authority. It is not.
As American liberals have said incessantly, there is separation of Church and state.

Considering that politics are discussed in the News Forums, I would think it would be very appropriate for not only the word but the concept Constitutional to appear.

Also, regarding the comments that this is some kind of Christian moral imperative, that doesn’t mean bigger government is the answer.
 
We should all be reassured because Mr. Trump has promised to replace Obamacare “with something terrific.” He also tweeted today that it’s “time for Republicans & Democrats to get together and come up with a healthcare plan that really works - much less expensive & FAR BETTER!”

I can’t wait for that much less expensive, terrific, FAR BETTER healthcare plan! 😉
Well, the one may want to call Democrat leaders and tell them to stop trying to undermine the President-elect, legitimize fake news in roundabout fashion and using cabinet confirmation hearings as a platform to run for office in 2020 and get busy.

Otherwise, we’ll just have to move on without their (name removed by moderator)ut.
 
As American liberals have said incessantly, there is separation of Church and state.

Considering that politics are discussed in the News Forums, I would think it would be very appropriate for not only the word but the concept Constitutional to appear.
Sure, use the word where appropriate. But in the context in which it was used, it was not appropriate.Let me remind you of that context. You responded to:
Well if you believe Pope Francis healthcare is a right, not a consumer good.
with:
Healthcare is not a Constitutional right.

If the Vatican and other Christian leaders are going to comment on policy, the need to do their homework or they could very well mislead the flock.
It is clear that Pope Francis was talking about a universal human right. Your comment that healthcare is not a right guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution is a non-sequitur. Healthcare is also not a raven or a writing desk. So your suggestion that the Pope needs to do his homework on the U.S. Constitution before making statements about universal human rights is ridiculous, and I might add disrespectful of our Holy Father.
 
Well, the one may want to call Democrat leaders and tell them to stop trying to undermine the President-elect, legitimize fake news in roundabout fashion and using cabinet confirmation hearings as a platform to run for office in 2020 and get busy.

Otherwise, we’ll just have to move on without their (name removed by moderator)ut.
Is it then okay to follow Bernie Sander’s call for Trump to stick to his word and not touch Medicare and Social Security?

Personally I find it hypocritical for anyone voting Republican while collecting Social Security and Medicare. Among other things.
 
But for the government to give itself the power to force people to do what is in their own interest seems to me overreach, and also unwise.
Due to the nature of healthcare (everyone needs it at some time or another), I don’t see any way for the government to avoid doing so, one way or another.

Our government for now has “Obamacare” wherein one is compelled to purchase health insurance from private insurers, or pay through the individual mandate. Other governments “compel” one to pay for healthcare through taxation.

Any insurance system requires lots of people paying into it so that it can help the relatively fewer number of people who need it. Allowing people to opt out of a system that they will sooner or later need to use is counterproductive. it’s not a matter of overbearing government. It’s a matter of keeping the system solvent.

The current problems with “Obamacare” are rooted in its basis as a for-profit system. If private insurers are unable to make a profit, they will stop insuring, thus driving up costs for those who remain insured.

A not-for-profit healthcare system would be preferable. But that won’t happen if the government continues to allow profit-driven enterprises to continue running things.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top