Contemplation. How is it for you?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ajecphotos
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The author of Cloud of Unknowing may use a mantra in prayer, but as far as I understand, the mantra was to help one stay focused on God, and rid off preconceived notions, not to achieve a blank mind.
That’s correct 🙂 The mystical authors do use the term “empty”, however it either refers to God’s action of silencing the faculties of the mind during infused contemplation or to the effort of a person to detach themselves from the chatter of their thoughts so as to be aware of God’s still, silent voice above the senses.

There is no such thing as a “blank mind”. Thought is natural. What one must do is notice a thought but “let it go” by keeping an undivided focus upon God.

It is about not allowing thoughts to distract our attention from God, rather than to stop ourselves from having them, which is impossible and IMHO would be a pointless exercise.
 
There is no such thing as a “blank mind”. Thought is natural. What one must do is notice a thought but “let it go” by keeping an undivided focus upon God.

It is about not allowing thoughts to distract our attention from God, rather than to stop ourselves from having them, which is impossible and IMHO would be a pointless exercise.
:amen:
 
I should add that the biblical verse a lot of the mystical writers were inspired by in this respect, that is of noticing but not being attached to thoughts when they arise, was this one from the prophet Isaiah:
Isaiah 30:15 “In returning and rest shall ye be saved; in quietness and in confidence shall be your strength”
Understood spiritually, it is an excellent description of the reality of acquired contemplation, with human effort impelled by grace. Not being attached to anything except God. Even our own thoughts are not Him and tell us more about ourselves than they do about God.

It is about “noticing” thoughts when they come and gently “returning” to God and resting there in his Presence.

Notice and return. Notice and return. Quietness and confidence in Him. Notice and return.

If one’s uses the technique recommended by the Cloud, then notice and return to your prayer word. Keep an undivided loving attention on our Lord.
 
It is about “noticing” thoughts when they come and gently “returning” to God and resting there in his Presence.

Notice and return. Notice and return. Quietness and confidence in Him. Notice and return.​

What is the difference of the above thoughts and constant recollection thru the day of Christ in us?
 
I should add that the biblical verse a lot of the mystical writers were inspired by in this respect, that is of noticing but not being attached to thoughts when they arise, was this one from the prophet Isaiah:

Understood spiritually, it is an excellent description of the reality of acquired contemplation, with human effort impelled by grace. Not being attached to anything except God. Even our own thoughts are not Him and tell us more about ourselves than they do about God.

It is about “noticing” thoughts when they come and gently “returning” to God and resting there in his Presence.

Notice and return. Notice and return. Quietness and confidence in Him. Notice and return.

If one’s uses the technique recommended by the Cloud, then notice and return to your prayer word. Keep an undivided loving attention on our Lord.
Vouthon-

This pretty much sums up what getting lost in God is like for me. It is like I am there just knowing Him and just letting the thoughts come and go. Not really thinking about anything but just mind of letting my mind wonder around on it’s own but not really paying any attention to it. All the time just sitting there and knowing God. It is like my mind is on idle and my sole focuse is God. It is like I kind of detach from my mind and let it just wonder about while God talks to me and I just try to let what He is saying sink in to the deepest recesses of my being. Does this make sense.
 
What is the difference of the above thoughts and constant recollection thru the day of Christ in us?
Dear Fred,

I suppose it depends what you mean by “recollection”. If you mean by this dwelling on thoughts about Jesus, then it would be different and not the same. In this exercise one does not try to suppress thought, one simply “lets go” of thoughts when they arise and returns to one’s continual focus upon Christ.

“Interior recollection” is a very specific term in mystical theology:
“…It is a certain interior recollection of which the soul is sensible; the soul seems to have other senses within itself, then, which bear some likeness to the exterior senses; and thus the soul, withdrawing into itself, seeks to go away from the tumult of its outward senses; for it closes the eyes on purpose that it may neither see, nor hear, nor understand anything but that whereon the soul is then intent, which is to be able to converse with God alone. In this prayer there is no suspension of the faculties and powers of the soul; it retains the full use of them; but the use of them is retained that they may be occupied with God…”
- Saint Teresa of Avila (second Relation to Fr Rodrigo Alvarez, SJ)
Is this what you mean by “recollection”? 🙂

It is not a case of actively thinking about Jesus. Its a case of being focused upon him with a loving, interior attention that thoughts cannot distract.
 
A little more on this “interior recollection” from Dom Cuthbert Butler’s excellent book, Western Mysticism:
“…The word ‘recollection’ is taken, not in its present, secondary, sense of remembering, but in its primary sense of gathering together and concentrating the mind. It consists first in the effort to banish from the mind all images and thoughts of external things, all sense perceptions and thoughts of creatures; then the reasoning processes of the intellect are silenced, and by this exercise of abstraction a solitude is produced wherein the soul may operate in its most spiritual faculties. This shutting off all external things from the mind, and emptying it of distracting thoughts, which is the object of ‘recollection’ is the prelude to that entering of the mind into itself that is effected by ‘introversion’ which is a concentration of the mind on its own highest, or deepest, part. In the account of the soul’s quest for God through creatures, in Enar. in Psalm, xli. (see above, p. 22), the process of introversion is described as the final step before the soul finds God. Thus: 'the mind abstracts itself from all the bodily senses, as interrupting and confounding it with their din, in order to see itself in itself, and know itself as mirrored in itself (7); and again, it is by ‘abstracting its attention from all noise of flesh and blood’ that it arrives at God…”
- Dom Cuthbert Butler, Western Mysticism (1922)
**Essentially, “recollection” consists of not consciously thinking of anything but instead having an undivided focus or “loving attention” upon God. One would make some moderate effort to detach oneself from thoughts and sense impressions and orient the focus of the mind towards Jesus. All one’s powers of concentration are upon him, yet not discursively as in thinking about one of his attributes or how infinitely kind and merciful He is. It is a non-conceptual concentration of the mind.

When distracting thoughts do arise, one “detaches” oneself from them and returns to focus upon Christ.

The word “empty” is used by the mystics and theologians, however it does not mean a “blank mind”. The mind is greatly concentrated and focused in this activity, yet focused and concentrated upon Christ alone rather than its own wandering thoughts or images.

I should add that Butler’s book has the *nihil obstat *and imprimatur 😉 **

**The fear that Fr. Dubay in his modern book seems to have had in relation to “empty the mind”, which he surely knows was extensively used by the mystical theologians, is the fact that it could be mistaken to signify a “blank” mind that had no concentration, when in fact this activity demands full concentration upon Jesus, yet not with mental images conjured up by ourselves about Him, about what we “think” of him and what he is like, rather than letting Him tell us.

I have the impression, Fred, that by “recollection” you might be thinking of “remembering” rather than the term in its strictly contemplative sense. **
 
Contemplation is not about “emptying ones self”. It is about “filling ones self” with God. In “the attempt” to engage in contemplative prayer, one usually goes about entering into such prayer via vocal pray and discursive meditation. True contemplative prayer is not the purview of the Soul attempting to engage in the act. True contemplative prayer is a lifting up of the Soul to God by God. If one seeks to obtain this level of prayer they can never do it on their own. Begin, with the Rosary, and adoration of the Blessed Sacrament. Trust that God will lead you to higher forms of prayer in his time and place.
Well said! I would add one thing for those of us who over analyze things. Don’t. As my dad said before brain surgery: It is what it is. Let prayer be what it will be.
 
A little more on this “interior recollection” from Dom Cuthbert Butler’s excellent book, Western Mysticism:

Essentially, “recollection” consists of not consciously thinking of anything but instead having an undivided focus or “loving attention” upon God. One would make some moderate effort to detach oneself from thoughts and sense impressions and orient the focus of the mind towards Jesus. All one’s powers of concentration are upon him, yet not discursively as in thinking about one of his attributes or how infinitely kind and merciful He is. It is a non-conceptual concentration of the mind.

When distracting thoughts do arise, one “detaches” oneself from them and returns to focus upon Christ.

The word “empty” is used by the mystics and theologians, however it does not mean a “blank mind”. The mind is greatly concentrated and focused in this activity, yet focused and concentrated upon Christ alone rather than its own wandering thoughts or images.

I should add that Butler’s book has the *nihil obstat *and imprimatur 😉

**The fear that Fr. Dubay in his modern book seems to have had in relation to “empty the mind”, which he surely knows was extensively used by the mystical theologians, is the fact that it could be mistaken to signify a “blank” mind that had no concentration, when in fact this activity demands full concentration upon Jesus, yet not with mental images conjured up by ourselves about Him, about what we “think” of him and what he is like, rather than letting Him tell us.

I have the impression, Fred, that by “recollection” you might be thinking of “remembering” rather than the term in its strictly contemplative sense. **
Thank you for your answer.

What I’m attempting to do is to understand how recollection compares to contemplation.

By recollection I mean the knowing, attention, realization that Christ is in my soul and one with me. It isn’t that words as such are spoken or adjectives are used, but just knowing he is one with me. But this is broken from time to time when this thinking is distracted and attention is diverted to outside affairs.

Recollection is a state rather than a prayer, but yet it knows the oneness with Christ until the outside distraction occurs. It is knowing his presence at this moment extended. And this is caused by the state of grace, being in the goodness of the Lord. Sometimes there may be acts of praise or devotion, but mainly it is simply knowing he is there. He himself dosen’t speak or do anything but be there present. But like I mentioned, it comes and goes depending on the daily activity that comes and goes thru out the day.

My mind isn’t empty because there is the awareness of Christ’s presence.

What I would like very much to do is to be able to sustain this longer and also during my external activities. If there is a way to do this, that is override distractions of activities.
This might be what you refer to as remembering.
 
What I’m attempting to do is to understand how recollection compares to contemplation.
I’ll take a stab at this … but I sure hope I don’t mess it up! 🙂 As the Saints lament, language falters.

Recollection and acquired contemplation can be considered one in the same if one qualifies their meaning. And there are different ways this can be practiced and experienced.

First is the recollection of Brother Lawrence or even The Cloud where one seeks to maintain an awareness with Christ throughout everything one does … in business meetings with clients, cooking for the family, driving to and from work, sitting at a baseball game. It is finding God among “the pots and pans.” No special skill is required. We simply speak to Christ using interior words of our own making … and sometimes just a wordless glance toward He whom we know is present. The work-of- the work is the continual redirecting of our thoughts so that Christ is always part of our consciousness. To facilitate that we practice the “notice and return” method as recently described. The result: our interior mental activity no longer is a talking to our self (monologue) … but a dialogue with God. Again, dialogue may or may not involve words, depending on how one is moved. Lastly, the habitual practice of this type of recollection is a mark of the height of sanctity … the way one prays in the 7th mansion according to St. Teresa.

Then there is the recollection when “we go alone to our room to pray.” As Vouthon hinted, we sense the urge to close our eyes and turn inward. Here too we continue to redirect our thoughts in the “notice and return” manner. But it is much more simplified and more deeply felt than what is described above. Sometimes all that is needed is a single word that is “like puffing on a candle to keep it lit (St. Teresa).” And we begin to sense, in an experiential way, what St. John of the Cross describes in The Living Flame … that there are many centers in the soul. If one senses a union with Christ with the first method, so too it is here … but we are in a room (mansion) much closer to the center of the soul where the King that St. Teresa describes lives. And this is as far as acquired contemplation can take us because we are now standing on the threshold of the infused. Perhaps the prayer states of quiet and union lie just beyond the door we patiently stand next to … the door that The Cloud shows is where Christ is both the door and porter.

My words, I know, simply don’t do this justice. And no one has to take my word for it either. Here is a link to St. Teresa’s Way of Perfection that shows how one passes from the acquired to the infused, God willing. Chapters 28-31 are the key passages for anyone willing to wade through all the single space type of this translation!

ewtn.com/library/SPIRIT/WAYPERF.TXT

Important point: notice how many times she says of this second type of recollection that we “should enter into it often.” This, as in the first method, is a recollection we can and should do. However, we can do no more than work our way to the door. It is up to Christ to open that door if we are then to pass from the acquired to infused.

Dave 🙂
 
Blessed Angela of Foligno

HOW IT MAY BE KNOWN THAT GOD HATH ENTERED INTO THE SOUL
IT must be known that God cometh sometimes unto the soul when it hath neither called, nor prayed unto, nor summoned Him. And He doth instill into the soul a fire and a love and a sweetness not customary, wherein it doth greatly delight and rejoice ; and it doth believe that this hath been wrought by God Himself there present, but this is not certain.
Presently the soul doth perceive that God is inwardly within itself, because albeit it cannot behold Him within it doth nevertheless perceive that His grace is present with it, wherein it doth greatly delight. Yet is not even this certain.
Presently it doth further perceive that God cometh unto it with most sweet words, wherein it delighteth yet more, and with much rejoicing doth it feel God within it ; yet do some doubts still remain, albeit but few. For the soul possesseth as yet no perfect certainty, neither is it assured that God is truly within it, because such converse and such feelings can be produced likewise by other spirits.
Wherefore is it still in doubt. And it seemeth unto me that this cometh either of its own malice and sinfulness, or else truly by the will of God, who desireth not that the soul should feel certain and secure. But when the soul doth feel the presence of God more deeply than is customary, then doth it certify unto itself that He is within it.
It doth feel it, I say, with an understanding so marvellous and so profound, and with such great love and divine fire, that it loseth all love for itself and for the body, and it speaketh and knoweth and understandeth those things of the which it hath never heard from any mortal whatsoever. And it understandeth with great illumination, and with much difficulty doth it hold its peace ; and if it doth hold its peace, it holdeth it out of the abundance of its zeal, that it may not be displeasing unto God its Lover nor cause offence, and likewise by reason of its humility ; for it desireth not to speak of things so exceeding high that it may not draw attention unto itself.
Thus hath it happened divers times unto me, that, out of my burning desire to work the salvation of my neighbour, I did speak things for the which I was reproved, and it was said unto me, " Sister, turn thee again unto the Holy Scriptures, for they say not thus, and therefore do we not understand thee."
But with that feeling whereby it is certified unto the soul that God dwelleth within it, there is given unto it a disposition so perfect that it doth most entirely and verily agree with the soul in all things, and in every way do all the members of the body agree with the soul and do truly form one cause together with it ; neither do they rebel against the will of the soul, but do perfectly desire those things which are of God, but which, nevertheless, they had not heretofore in any way desired. And this disposition is granted unto the soul through grace whereby it doth perceive that the Divine Being hath entered into it, and hath granted it the assurance and the desire of God and of those things which are of God, after the manner of the true love wherewith God hath loved us. Thus doth the soul feel that God is mingled with it and hath made companionship with it.
Further, when God cometh unto the soul, it is some times given unto it to behold Him, and it beholdeth Him devoid of any bodily shape or form, and more clearly than doth one man behold another. For the eyes of the soul do behold a spiritual and not a bodily presence, of the which I am not able to speak because words and imagination do fail me. And in very truth the soul doth rejoice in that sight with an ineffable joy and regardeth naught else, because this it is which doth fill it with most inestimable satisfaction.
This searching and beholding (whereby God is seen in such a manner that the soul can behold naught else) is so profound that much doth it grieve me that I cannot make manifest aught whatsoever of it, seeing that it is not a thing the which can be touched or imagined or judged of. Moreover, the soul doth know in many other ways that God hath without doubt entered into it, of the which ways I will now speak of two.
 
Continued

One is an holy unction which doth so instantly revive the soul, make meek all the members of the body, and cause them to agree together with the soul, that they cannot be touched or offended by anything whatsoever the which could even in the smallest degree agitate the soul. Therefore doth it feel and hear that God speaketh within it, and by means of this great and in all ways unspeakable unction the soul doth understand with the utmost certainty that God is within it, because no saint nor any angel in Paradise would have power to grant this. But seeing how that it is a thing the which cannot be expressed, it grieveth me that I can find no words wherewith to describe it in comparison of that which it truly is.
Wherefore I pray God that He will pardon me, for this is not of mine own will, and if I were able and if it were pleasing unto God, I would make manifest somewhat of His goodness. The other way whereby the soul knoweth that God is within it is by an embrace which He doth give unto the soul. There is neither father, nor mother, nor son, nor any other person whatsoever who can embrace the object beloved with so great a love as that wherewith God embraceth the soul. For He doth embrace it with such love and draw it unto Himself with such sweetness and gentleness that methinketh there is not a man in the world who can declare it, nor express it, nor believe it unless he hath himself experienced it ; and although he might perchance divine somewhat of this love, yet could he not possibly know it as it truly is. Of a surety, God doth implant most sweet love in the soul, the which doth make it burn for Christ alone. And it beareth with it so great a light (whereby it understandeth the fulness of the goodness of God which it experienceth within itself) that it hath understanding of much more than it feeleth within itself.
Then hath it the assurance and certitude that Christ dwelleth within it ; but all that we can say is as nothing in comparison with that which it really is. Then the soul hath no more tears, whether of joy or of sorrow or of any other kind, seeing that when the soul hath tears it is in a lower state. For God poureth into the soul an exceeding great sweetness, in a measure so abundant that it can ask nothing more yea, verily, it would be in Paradise if this should endure, its joy being so great that it filleth the whole body ; and all injury which the soul suffereth, whether by deeds or words, is esteemed as naught and is turned into sweetness.

Peace
 
Catechism:

scborromeo.org/ccc/p4s1c3a1.htm

It can be noted that there is acquired contemplation…and* infused*.

And this is of particular importance: I should note that various authors and various schools use the same terms differently.…such needs to be kept in mind when one goes back and forth between them (same with other words like “recollection”)

Basically acquired contemplation can be on a philosophical level (read Josef Pieper on “natural contempation”) or theological …or even the ordinary of a mother contemplating her sleeping child or nature or in the sense of a kind of contemplation in prayer where things become more of a intuitive gaze etc (such as prayer of simplicity).

The other is that which is given directly by God (infused contemplation such as prayer of quiet).

For a very short and practical work on mental prayer: scepterpublishers.org/product/index.php?FULL=557

frjacquesphilippe.com/
 
Continued

One is an holy unction which doth so instantly revive the soul, make meek all the members of the body, and cause them to agree together with the soul, that they cannot be touched or offended by anything whatsoever the which could even in the smallest degree agitate the soul. Therefore doth it feel and hear that God speaketh within it, and by means of this great and in all ways unspeakable unction the soul doth understand with the utmost certainty that God is within it, because no saint nor any angel in Paradise would have power to grant this. But seeing how that it is a thing the which cannot be expressed, it grieveth me that I can find no words wherewith to describe it in comparison of that which it truly is.
Wherefore I pray God that He will pardon me, for this is not of mine own will, and if I were able and if it were pleasing unto God, I would make manifest somewhat of His goodness. The other way whereby the soul knoweth that God is within it is by an embrace which He doth give unto the soul. There is neither father, nor mother, nor son, nor any other person whatsoever who can embrace the object beloved with so great a love as that wherewith God embraceth the soul. For He doth embrace it with such love and draw it unto Himself with such sweetness and gentleness that methinketh there is not a man in the world who can declare it, nor express it, nor believe it unless he hath himself experienced it ; and although he might perchance divine somewhat of this love, yet could he not possibly know it as it truly is. Of a surety, God doth implant most sweet love in the soul, the which doth make it burn for Christ alone. And it beareth with it so great a light (whereby it understandeth the fulness of the goodness of God which it experienceth within itself) that it hath understanding of much more than it feeleth within itself.
Then hath it the assurance and certitude that Christ dwelleth within it ; but all that we can say is as nothing in comparison with that which it really is. Then the soul hath no more tears, whether of joy or of sorrow or of any other kind, seeing that when the soul hath tears it is in a lower state. For God poureth into the soul an exceeding great sweetness, in a measure so abundant that it can ask nothing more yea, verily, it would be in Paradise if this should endure, its joy being so great that it filleth the whole body ; and all injury which the soul suffereth, whether by deeds or words, is esteemed as naught and is turned into sweetness.

Peace
Hazcompat,

Thank you so much for sharing this writing of Blessed Angela. I don’t know why but it so spoke to me and of all the readings of the different Saints here her’s seemed to penetrated the deepest into the core of my being. It is almost like she knows me and is speaking for me. Will have to get a copy of her writings. I kind of feel like some one finally understands what is inside of me, the other Saints mentioned in this thread seemed to get bits and pieces of it but she seems to hit the nail square on the head and right into the exact spot…will have to start asking her to help me as I continue my journey…
Thank you again and God Bless
 
Hazcompat,

Thank you so much for sharing this writing of Blessed Angela. I don’t know why but it so spoke to me and of all the readings of the different Saints here her’s seemed to penetrated the deepest into the core of my being. It is almost like she knows me and is speaking for me. Will have to get a copy of her writings. I kind of feel like some one finally understands what is inside of me, the other Saints mentioned in this thread seemed to get bits and pieces of it but she seems to hit the nail square on the head and right into the exact spot…will have to start asking her to help me as I continue my journey…
Thank you again and God Bless
I am certain she’ll take up your cause. This site might be helpful if you double click the link to “The Book of Divine Consolation” at the bottom of each quote you can download the book for free.

enlargingtheheart.wordpress.com/category/franciscan/angela-of-foligno/

Peace
 
Then there is the recollection when “we go alone to our room to pray.” As Vouthon hinted, we sense the urge to close our eyes and turn inward. Here too we continue to redirect our thoughts in the “notice and return” manner. But it is much more simplified and more deeply felt than what is described above. Sometimes all that is needed is a single word that is “like puffing on a candle to keep it lit (St. Teresa).” And we begin to sense, in an experiential way, what St. John of the Cross describes in The Living Flame … that there are many centers in the soul. If one senses a union with Christ with the first method, so too it is here … but we are in a room (mansion) much closer to the center of the soul where the King that St. Teresa describes lives. And this is as far as acquired contemplation can take us because we are now standing on the threshold of the infused. Perhaps the prayer states of quiet and union lie just beyond the door we patiently stand next to … the door that The Cloud shows is where Christ is both the door and porter.

My words, I know, simply don’t do this justice. And no one has to take my word for it either. Here is a link to St. Teresa’s Way of Perfection that shows how one passes from the acquired to the infused, God willing. Chapters 28-31 are the key passages for anyone willing to wade through all the single space type of this translation!

ewtn.com/library/SPIRIT/WAYPERF.TXT

Important point: notice how many times she says of this second type of recollection that we “should enter into it often.” This, as in the first method, is a recollection we can and should do. However, we can do no more than work our way to the door. It is up to Christ to open that door if we are then to pass from the acquired to infused.

Dave 🙂
I like to share some thoughts on what Dave described above.

Talking about the recollection of closing one’s eyes and gazing inwardly on the Lord, the moment after receiving the Eucharist is a perfect moment for doing so. The Lord has come to reside in me with his physical union by the Holy Eucharist. He literally abides in me, and I in Him. That’s a perfect moment of entering into one’s inner chamber of heart and soul, giving the Lord thanks, praise, and loving gaze. That moment is also probably easier for people to recollect than other time, if they are not used to this kind of recollection.

We should all often close our eyes and turn inward adoring the Lord. For those who have not formed a habit of this type of recollection, the moment after receiving the Eucharist may be a good starting point. Then it may be carried into daily lives.

Hope this makes sense and helps.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top