Could Syria ignite World War 3?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SeanF1989
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s not so much a Sunni vs Shia struggle as it is a confrontation pitting Salafists vs Everyone who isn’t a Salafist.
 
I doubt it will cause WW111. I don’t see Russia or China putting troops into Syria and I hope the US doesn’t. With the super powers sending military support to both sides, it’s going to get uglier.

If the US puts in a no fly zone and patrols it, the Russians and China may send aircraft. Lets hope they take a wait and see approach and the whole thing doesn’t create further conflict.
 
It’s not so much a Sunni vs Shia struggle as it is a confrontation pitting Salafists vs Everyone who isn’t a Salafist.
I agree with you to a degree, but only to a degree. Persians, Turks and Arabs have been at war for millenia, and while that struggle for hegemony in the region might have a sectarian aspect to it, that is not the whole story. Right now the struggle is between a well-organized Iranian regime and poorly organized Sunni states, some of whose partisans are Salafist.
 
Wahhabist influence in the Sunni world is growing rapidly thanks to Saudi Arabia, it’s in the Middle East, North Africa, Sub Saharan Africa, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Malaysia, and the Caucasus Mts, not to mention that it’s found adherents in the immigrant communities in the West. Iran can’t even come close to that, partly because Shias make up 15 pct or less of the world’s Muslim population.
 
My fear is the development of a proxy war where the Russians and Chinese are propping up Assad and for some UNFATHOMABLE reason we think we should arm the “rebels” although we don’t know who the heck they are, what they want, and whether they will ever be an ally to America.

How did arming the rebels in Libya work out for Ambassador Stevens? How did that “Arab Spring” work out in Egypt?

I say develop our energy resources here and let them spill their own blood and treasure. I remember an old cartoon “Let’s you and him fight.”

My philosophy toward the whole bunch.

Lisa
 
There are 1 Billion Muslims in the world. Even if China, Russia, the US, NATO, the EU, etc don’t get involved, it could very well spark a global war between Sunni and Shia.

A prominent Egyptian cleric (with a weekly show on al Jazeera) has already called for Sunnis worldwide to join the “jihad” against Shia, and the Muslim Brotherhood has also made some inflamatory statements.
 
Wahhabist influence in the Sunni world is growing rapidly thanks to Saudi Arabia, it’s in the Middle East, North Africa, Sub Saharan Africa, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Malaysia, and the Caucasus Mts, not to mention that it’s found adherents in the immigrant communities in the West. Iran can’t even come close to that, partly because Shias make up 15 pct or less of the world’s Muslim population.
It only took 10% of the Soviet population to dominate the rest, and Assad’s minority Alawite sect dominated the Sunni majority for decades.
 
My fear is the development of a proxy war where the Russians and Chinese are propping up Assad and for some UNFATHOMABLE reason we think we should arm the “rebels” although we don’t know who the heck they are, what they want, and whether they will ever be an ally to America.

How did arming the rebels in Libya work out for Ambassador Stevens? How did that “Arab Spring” work out in Egypt?

I say develop our energy resources here and let them spill their own blood and treasure. I remember an old cartoon “Let’s you and him fight.”

My philosophy toward the whole bunch.

Lisa
I pretty much agree with this as well. The only thing I wish to add is that the Syrian rebels are members of al-qaeda. I don’t know if arming them is such a good thing. To me leave them alone and let them wipe each other out.

If Nazi Germany declared war on Communist Russia only (Nazi’s hated communists), would we have intervened? If they went to war with our enemies, why would we want to intervene?

I hear a lot of people say that the USA can’t be the world’s police, which is a nice way of saying but out, but then situations like Libya, Syria or even Darfur get brought up. You can’t have it both ways.
 
That Sunni and Shia and the various ethnicities in the region have historically hated each other is no surprise. The last few decades seem to be more an aberration than anything else.
 
That whole conflict is just a mess. To me, the best course of action would have been for a strong UN peace-keeping force in the very early stages of the conflict, before the whole powder keg exploded. I know the UN’s reputation isn’t very great around here, but I do believe it is a tad above that of Al-Qaeda, Hezbollah, Ahmadenajad or Assad the Terrible. Now we have all sorts of elements (good and bad) making themselves out to be the “people’s defenders” when we could have had the international community in there trying to prevent all out war. Right now it seems to me that we’re between a rock and a hard place. Letting them slug it out equates to standing by while innocent people suffer - including those in the overwhelmed host countries to which refugees are flooding. We may not be the world’s policeman, but it may be to our advantage to be our brother’s keeper.
 
That whole conflict is just a mess. To me, the best course of action would have been for a strong UN peace-keeping force in the very early stages of the conflict, before the whole powder keg exploded. I know the UN’s reputation isn’t very great around here, but I do believe it is a tad above that of Al-Qaeda, Hezbollah, Ahmadenajad or Assad the Terrible. Now we have all sorts of elements (good and bad) making themselves out to be the “people’s defenders” when we could have had the international community in there trying to prevent all out war. Right now it seems to me that we’re between a rock and a hard place. Letting them slug it out equates to standing by while innocent people suffer - including those in the overwhelmed host countries to which refugees are flooding. We may not be the world’s policeman, but it may be to our advantage to be our brother’s keeper.
Yes, but in the real world, Russia would have nixed that proposal, as it would threaten their access to a southern warm-water port. When it comes to diplomacy, Russia is the heir of Kissinger.
 
I pretty much agree with this as well. The only thing I wish to add is that the Syrian rebels are members of al-qaeda. I don’t know if arming them is such a good thing. To me leave them alone and let them wipe each other out.

If Nazi Germany declared war on Communist Russia only (Nazi’s hated communists), would we have intervened? If they went to war with our enemies, why would we want to intervene?

I hear a lot of people say that the USA can’t be the world’s police, which is a nice way of saying but out, but then situations like Libya, Syria or even Darfur get brought up. You can’t have it both ways.
I would like to see humanitarian aid for the refugees and the injured in Syria. If we can’t or shouldn’t be the world’s policeman, I hope we can at least be the world’s face of compassion.

I am appalled that we are sending BILLIONS to Egypt. I have to assume that it’s some sort of bribe to keep them out of Israel. They are clearly no longer an ally. Some upper level government official was caught with a hot mic saying that the US and Israel are the real enemies of Egypt. I see the mess in Libya and everything I’ve read indicated that Ambassador Stevens was truly committed to the LIbyan people and many mourned his loss. But there are too many competing factions and we don’t know who we are arming. That high powered arms could easily get into the hands of enemies is a major concern to me.

We’ve been entangled in foreign wars too long and with little positive result. I hope we can pressure the Russians or other supporters of Assad to back off. I truly believe had those supporting Saddam told him “leave!” we wouldn’t have gone in to Iraq. The last thing I want to see is military support for one side or the other.

Lisa
 
And again, when the protestors were in Iran, Tehreran, barely a word of support until it was way too late.
 
“In recent weeks the international community has reaffirmed its intention to promote concrete initiatives to bring about a fruitful dialogue designed to bring an end to the war,” he said.
“These initiatives are to be encouraged, and it is hoped that they will lead to peace,” the pope said during a meeting with Catholic aid groups working with refugees in Syria and the region.
It’s very obvious to anyone who is following what the Holy Father says about this conflict is that we are not to arm anyone but to work for peace through dialogue and negotiation as well as aid the refugees. Any catholic supporting military interventionism is not listening or following our Holy Father.
 
It’s very obvious to anyone who is following what the Holy Father says about this conflict is that we are not to arm anyone but to work for peace through dialogue and negotiation as well as aid the refugees. Any catholic supporting military interventionism is not listening or following our Holy Father.
That line of thinking is better accepted when it comes from the Pope. When it comes from a world leader, the words ‘dialogue’ and ‘diplomacy’ are treated as wimp talk.
 
That line of thinking is better accepted when it comes from the Pope. When it comes from a world leader, the words ‘dialogue’ and ‘diplomacy’ are treated as wimp talk.
Pretty much. The brainwashing of public and higher education, the media including much of talk radio, have been very effective in misguiding the people into believing military intervention is always the answer when in reality it’s mostly about profiteering.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top