Could you REALLY convince me?

  • Thread starter Thread starter M31
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A good proof, imo, wuld be the bible would leave you with a feeling of awe and humility; instead, it leaves you dumbfounded and annoyed. It’s probably written by primitive man.
The bible is written by man who are inspired by the Holy Spirit.
Jesus threatens in the New Testamemt,
Do you mean he warns people about hell ? Well God wants to warn us to make us aware that we need to repent and follow his way. Jesus is not threatening anyone. He is just making others aware that if they sin, it will lead to hell and they must follow God.
Paul writes like it’s a diary, etc.
There is nothing wrong about Paul talking about his own life. He also teaches, about the gifts of the Holy Spirit, love, and how a Christian should live his life
Revelations sounds like a myth.
It probably sounds like a myth because you went by your own interpretations of it.
The God of the old and new do not sound like the same God, all the laws in the old, etc. etc.
There is laws in the NT ( Matthew 6). Also, the NT is a fullfilment of the Law and since the law is fullfilled we don’t follow it anymore.
I yelled at this Christian one time cuz he was begging for money for his church. God says he will provide??Hmmmm. Yeah, through other people and God uses “puppets”!
God can work through people if he wants to. I don’t see whats wrong in doing that. God used prophets as his mouth piece, he used Moses to free his people, God used the apostles to preach the Gospel and the results are good.
We live in a “cheap” universe…atoms and chemical reactions. In my opinion, that’s cheap. I almost believed God could be the CEO of Walmart, that’s how disgusted I was. God uses chemicals for life? Seriously? Yes, it’s possible those chemical reactions in the brain could have made-up God, right?
I don’t know to much about atoms and chemicals but arent those stuff really complex ?
I doubt people are made in God’s image. Not how people behave and treat you, dont think so. Maybe that was a possible idea to make man feel superior…not just over animals but over eachother. No wonder why racism still occurs…guess man isn’t made equally…hmmmm.
Bieng made in the image of God doesn’t mean a person will act good. It just means they look like the image of God, its how they appear. Image and appearance has nothing to do with how people behave
Oh and one thing. No offense but why is the Catholic church rich…yet it doesnt help out?
The church has helped many.
 
Oh and one thing. No offense but why is the Catholic church rich…yet it doesnt help out?
Right, right, and my small school has 3 catholic charity clubs with approximately 20-30 members who go out of their way to help the poor via outreaches twice a month.

:rolleyes:
 
Fine, but what proof do you have that love exists…or again, that God exist? Why believe a saying written in a book by man?
This particular book was written by lots of different people, living in totally different times and cultures. The fact that it comes together into one story that even makes any sense at all, let alone becomes one of the cornerstones of the world’s largest religion, is, in and of itself, miraculous.

Keep in mind, Moses wrote the first section of the Bible while trying to lead a nation of very difficult, complaining people to what he hoped and prayed was the Promised Land, at some point around 1500 BC. The last writer of the Bible was John, and he was exiled to a small island called Patmos, completely alone, and only hoping and praying that anybody was out there to receive his letters.

In between there were prophets, kings, various poets, various historians, and the occasional sheep herder with a word or two to say about this God person, that he thought people should know about.
That’s your guys’ saying. What if the bible didnt come from God and just came from “man that needs a purpose in life”?
There are a thousand books in my local library that are just like that - nobody is finding a coherent thread of story between them, nor compiling them into a single volume, nor basing a successful religion on the totality of them. And these are guys who all live in the same time period, and mostly all speak and understand English as their first language - they aren’t depending on translators to tell them what the other guys are saying. And yet, there is absolutely no consistency between them. Certainly not enough to take those books and make them into something like the Bible.

The reason I believe is miracles, (and we aren’t really supposed to talk about the personal miracles that happen to us so I won’t do that) is, let’s face it, the first miracle we notice when we read the Bible is, the Bible itself. How did such a diverse group of people, most of whom didn’t know who was coming next or what they were going to write about, or even where they were going to be writing from, come up with the greatest story ever told, across three different languages, and who knows how many dialects of those three languages?
Most of them weren’t even thinking about the fact that some day there was going to be a Bible, and their work might be in it. I doubt that John was trying to figure out how to answer all the questions that Moses raises in the Book of Genesis regarding the prophecies about Mary and Jesus - yet, he succeeds, even while attempting to get his local congregation to be more faithful and more evangelical.
 
Oh and one thing. No offense but why is the Catholic church rich…yet it doesnt help out?
Mother Teresa was a Catholic, you know - her organization is a Catholic organization, and receives money from the Vatican for the support of the orphans and the sick in India and in many other countries as well.

The Catholic Church (that is to say, organizations run by Catholics, and supported by the Vatican) feeds more hungry people every day than the rest of the charity organizations of the world combined. And just fyi, I have never actually heard of any atheist charity organzations - the vast majority of those that are not Catholic are actually Protestant - and more recently we have seen some Hindu organizations come into existence, and some Muslim organizations - but by far, it is the Catholic Church that is feeding, housing, educating, and clothing the poor of the world, with Protestant Christians coming in a distant second, and everyone else just kind of trotting along in the back somewhere.
 
Hi!

I don’t think anybody can give you evidence that God exists–that is what faith is for. You also need to realize that God loves you and he always will even when you are angry with him. People though can disappoint you–and it is people that run churches. There is no perfect church but there is a perfect God. You don’t have to chose to be Catholic but you should chose to believe in the God that created you out of love. Whether you do that though is up to you and probably won’t be based on anything we say but it will be God himself that will convince you. He will try to lead you to him but you have to be willing to listen. And he may work through other people to do it–but it is still God’s doing–without God we are nothing–and we would not exist. God can speak to you in so many ways.

Kim
 
A good proof, imo, wuld be the bible would leave you with a feeling of awe and humility; instead, it leaves you dumbfounded and annoyed. It’s probably written by primitive man.
Jesus threatens in the New Testamemt, Paul writes like it’s a diary, etc. Revelations sounds like a myth. The God of the old and new do not sound like the same God, all the laws in the old, etc. etc.

I yelled at this Christian one time cuz he was begging for money for his church. God says he will provide??Hmmmm. Yeah, through other people and God uses “puppets”!

We live in a “cheap” universe…atoms and chemical reactions. In my opinion, that’s cheap. I almost believed God could be the CEO of Walmart, that’s how disgusted I was. God uses chemicals for life? Seriously? Yes, it’s possible those chemical reactions in the brain could have made-up God, right?

I doubt people are made in God’s image. Not how people behave and treat you, dont think so. Maybe that was a possible idea to make man feel superior…not just over animals but over eachother. No wonder why racism still occurs…guess man isn’t made equally…hmmmm.

Oh and one thing. No offense but why is the Catholic church rich…yet it doesnt help out?

And no, I wouldnt want to feel honored. Why would you ask that? You must feel honored to have enough proof that you believe what you believe?
I’m amazed by your lack of understanding the Catholic faith and Science.
 
Sorry guys, I didnt mean Catholic organizations or charities…I meant Rome, you know, the Vatican. I didnt mean Catholic churches, organizations, etc. in general…I meant the Vatican.

Sorry, that was my bad :o I can see why you were annoyed…sorry.

You see, I had a conversation with these people who happened to be ex-Catholics and they were they were telling me how this charity was trying to get funds but werent getting a lot and the charity tried to get funds from the Vatican but it refused…whether they were telling me the truth or not, I have no clue.

I meant the Vatican guys. Sorry if I wasnt clear 😦
 
OP: Correct me if I am wrong and I am going to go out on a limb here, but…

It seems to me that you are more MAD at God then questioning whether or not He exists. Your issue seems to be “why does bad things happen to good people?” and the vice versa. The “if God is good then why do horrible things happen?” Because… if you truly didn’t believe that God existed, then you would not bother getting on a Catholic forum to make statements such as “why does God bless America and let other countries suffer ie. Haiti?” If you didn’t believe that God existed, wouldn’t you just think that this is all just a course of nature? Or just evolution of the universe? Nothing is BAD or GOOD. It is all relative. Etc.

So, I am going to go with the idea that I think you are wondering how we Catholics can believe that God is good when there is so much evil in the world. How could a “good/just” God allow all this stuff to happen. I can sum up my answer in 2 points.
  1. God’s ways are above our ways. Many people believe that to be a “cop out” answer, but it is the truth. We have no idea. We don’t know why God doesn’t strike Satan down at this moment and make everything in the world good. And the reason that we don’t know that is BECAUSE WE ARE NOT GOD. We TRY to be God. We TRY to judge like God. But, we fall short. We are not him and we will never fully understand Him (until, perhaps, when we get to Heaven).
  2. Read Jesus’ parable on the weeds in the field. (Somebody help me out here for the Bible verse. It was the reading 2 weeks ago, I think). Yes, there are many “weeds” in God’s beautiful garden. The weeds being evil stuff. The beautiful field being the world. There is the good harvest. And the weeds are mixed in. Just like in farming, you don’t destroy everything to just kill the weeds. You nurture everything until the final harvest. Then it will be seperated. God is not allowing evil so much as he is nurturing the “non-evil.” He is full of LOVE. Not full of HATE.
The reason that I believe in God is simple. I see him. I feel him. I hear him. (No, not in some new-agey psychic way). I see him in everything beautiful in this world. I hear him in everything. He is there. Whether or not you believe in him. He is there. Whether or not you turn away from him.

And, I must say, I am glad that you are here. You said that you have lots of questions. Please continue to ask those questions… I will pray for you.
 
Purposely rejecting a concept… is not the same as purposely rejecting a reality.

Your line of questioning is with regard to something that you don’t believe exists… this isn’t about choosing our own make believe…

Knowing that God is real is the same as knowing the war in iraq is real. Why would you believe that the war exists? It’s awful. So many die in that story… so let’s purposely reject the concept of war and what it does. And then all is well. I don’t like the way wars turn out. They kill my friends… and so I don’t believe in them. I know lots of people that I don’t like. And situations that I don’t like. Dying babies… Why would I choose to believe in them?

I know a man who claims the holocaust is an entire fabricated story to make the German people look bad. It’s the story he stuck to until he died… Having lived in Germany at the time…
You believe God is a reality. Hmmmm…I guess just because we’ve never seen other life forms (aliens) doesnt mean they’re not a reality.

So you’re saying God is as real as other planets existing (and they do!) even though we can’t see him?
 
Sorry guys, I didnt mean Catholic organizations or charities…I meant Rome, you know, the Vatican. I didnt mean Catholic churches, organizations, etc. in general…I meant the Vatican.

Sorry, that was my bad :o I can see why you were annoyed…sorry.

You see, I had a conversation with these people who happened to be ex-Catholics and they were they were telling me how this charity was trying to get funds but werent getting a lot and the charity tried to get funds from the Vatican but it refused…whether they were telling me the truth or not, I have no clue.

I meant the Vatican guys. Sorry if I wasnt clear 😦
Interesting… I don’t feel as though we are seperate. We are a CATHOLIC church. We are universal, We are ONE. We are made up of a bunch of little parishes… The Vatican is our Wash. DC… The Pope is our Commander in Chief. You can not seperate the Vatican from the body… it’s the head. The Catholic Charities are nothing by definition without the Vatican…

I mean, do you class the US in the same fashion. We are the UNITED States of a America. We as citizens donate, and contribute to various and specific charities… Do we ask? How much did Obama and the indiividuals among Congress SPECIFICALLY contribute? I don’t think so…

In the same way that Obama or any pres. sends in the troops… so does the Vatican… We do nothing without the go ahead.
 
You believe God is a reality. Hmmmm…I guess just because we’ve never seen other life forms (aliens) doesnt mean they’re not a reality.

So you’re saying God is as real as other planets existing (and they do!) even though we can’t see him?
Of COURSE I believe God is a reality. Honestly, can we say that other life forms don’t exist? I don’t know that for a fact. I do know that we have not discovered other life forms. Or enough evidence to suggest so. But you know what, if we figure that out. IT won’t contradict anything. It would just mean that God created more than we realized…

Just like we learned that God made the world round, and we didn’t know forever ago…

Edit: interestingly enough. It is Isaiah 40:22 that states: Is is he that sitteth upon the GLOBE of the earth, and the inhabitants thereof are as locusts:…

How WEIRD to refer to our earth as a GLOBE when everyone just KNEW it was flat… this man must have been so out there genius???
 
I guess I should also say… I have not seen evidence of an alien population. There doesn’t seem to be a 2000 year history of some alien child that we hear random stories about.

Maybe I’m the wierdo in the group. If there were aliens… it wouldn’t bug me. I mean, couldn’t an angel be and “alien”. Their not of the human race…If there ARE aliens, then they’d still be a creation of God. A cool one at that!

I could be open to that… if I needed to be…
 
if you believe many things, why it is so hard for you to believe that there is a God who created all things?
Most agnostics are psychological people who have been through lots of pain. I studied psychology, have been through lots of pain, have had serious doubts about God, but have been (tongue in cheek on this phrase) “born again” the Roman Catholic I was intended to be by God. Wisdom seeker points out a truth we hold self evident, viz., God created all things. But keep in your MIND that in the agnostic’s mind there are thoughts that contradict God: hence the quandary, “If my thoughts are things, and if God created all things, then how could there be a God who creates contradiction of himself, just as my thoughts contradict him and are simultaneously things?” It’s a difficult thing to answer this problem–but I’m not sure that at this stage of that agnostic’s development it is always going to be effective to convince him with the content of our spirituality. The agnostic in this conversation seems resistant to argument; and the Problem Of Evil as stated previously by another conversant is a good way to start, except in that it implies logically that the agnostic is evil in his thoughts, which contradict God qua idea. I do not believe He is evil, per se. Or necessarily under the influence of evil either. Appeals to Freewill only widen the gap of his contradiction, since it appears to the agnostic mind as a doctrine aimed at widening the scope of these debates and thus ‘justifying’ them as holy in themselves because they are permitted by a facet of of our nature that God created. Exercise franchise, as the saying goes.

None the less, I would love to see any agnostic come to peace with God, to faith in Him, and ultimately to see that the light brought he or she out of the darkness is God.

If the agnostic wants convincing, you might rely on the Latin/English composition of the word for help, M31. ‘Vincere’ is the root, and it means ‘to overcome’. Clearly you want to overcome these thoughts of doubt or else you wouldn’t have posted, sought out the forum. But the meaning of the prefix ‘con’ is also telling. As a prefix it connotes harmony and with-ness. This suggests to me that you want the company of others in your debate ‘process’. Perhaps you seek fellowship that is meaningful to your beliefs of agnosticism.

Nevertheless, you might consider the stages of mental development of the mind to be relevant. Piaget showed that we go through many cognitive stages. Perhaps you simply have not reached or maintained appreciably a level of mental development that currently includes faith in God? This doesn’t mean you are lower than anyone else, just not like them in that respect. Just as to our predecessors in science, our technology would appear miraculous to people of 100 years ago, so will our fastest processors seems like rusty robots in comparison to the computers of the next 100 years. In the same way, you too will advance as God brings you closer to Him. The point is really that we often cannot perceive a reality because we are making of it a transcendent in total, and ignoring its imminent aspects. Sometimes looking at some of the things we have believed in the past and seeing our progress over the years as a thinker shows us that we have advanced even as believers. Sometimes its not a question of belief, but of realizing those beliefs and acting on them in Charity towards others.

If you are looking for an in the face victory over doubt, trying to overcome an obstacle to your faith, consider Augustine’s pedagogical evangelism of this dilemma:

“…if they wish to see the old or the new moon or some very small star which I was pointing to with my finger and they did not have keen enough sight to even see my finger, they should not on that account become … with me…[These] … should ask God to give them vision.”

I wish you good fortune in your search for that vision you suppose Catholics have; and indeed many of us do have it; but everyone has a mind and eyes to see with, including the agnostic. Perhaps it would help to know that all this energy going into these things for the agnostic is not ego building self aggrandizement or vanity, but effort made for the joy of knowing another is being given a solid invitation to look again at things from a fresh perspective. And if there is a vanity pleasure in it, perhaps it is an indulgence duly earned. No one likes it when things get old and stale. The holy Spirit says in the Book of Revelations: “Behold, I make all things new.” This includes, presumably, one’s thoughts in the definition of things.

Grace and Peace.
 
Most agnostics are psychological people who have been through lots of pain. I studied psychology, have been through lots of pain, have had serious doubts about God, but have been (tongue in cheek on this phrase) “born again” the Roman Catholic I was intended to be by God. Wisdom seeker points out a truth we hold self evident, viz., God created all things. But keep in your MIND that in the agnostic’s mind there are thoughts that contradict God: hence the quandary, “If my thoughts are things, and if God created all things, then how could there be a God who creates contradiction of himself, just as my thoughts contradict him and are simultaneously things?” It’s a difficult thing to answer this problem–but I’m not sure that at this stage of that agnostic’s development it is always going to be effective to convince him with the content of our spirituality. The agnostic in this conversation seems resistant to argument; and the Problem Of Evil as stated previously by another conversant is a good way to start, except in that it implies logically that the agnostic is evil in his thoughts, which contradict God qua idea. I do not believe He is evil, per se. Or necessarily under the influence of evil either. Appeals to Freewill only widen the gap of his contradiction, since it appears to the agnostic mind as a doctrine aimed at widening the scope of these debates and thus ‘justifying’ them as holy in themselves because they are permitted by a facet of of our nature that God created. Exercise franchise, as the saying goes.

None the less, I would love to see any agnostic come to peace with God, to faith in Him, and ultimately to see that the light brought he or she out of the darkness is God.

If the agnostic wants convincing, you might rely on the Latin/English composition of the word for help, M31. ‘Vincere’ is the root, and it means ‘to overcome’. Clearly you want to overcome these thoughts of doubt or else you wouldn’t have posted, sought out the forum. But the meaning of the prefix ‘con’ is also telling. As a prefix it connotes harmony and with-ness. This suggests to me that you want the company of others in your debate ‘process’. Perhaps you seek fellowship that is meaningful to your beliefs of agnosticism.

Nevertheless, you might consider the stages of mental development of the mind to be relevant. Piaget showed that we go through many cognitive stages. Perhaps you simply have not reached or maintained appreciably a level of mental development that currently includes faith in God? This doesn’t mean you are lower than anyone else, just not like them in that respect. Just as to our predecessors in science, our technology would appear miraculous to people of 100 years ago, so will our fastest processors seems like rusty robots in comparison to the computers of the next 100 years. In the same way, you too will advance as God brings you closer to Him. The point is really that we often cannot perceive a reality because we are making of it a transcendent in total, and ignoring its imminent aspects. Sometimes looking at some of the things we have believed in the past and seeing our progress over the years as a thinker shows us that we have advanced even as believers. Sometimes its not a question of belief, but of realizing those beliefs and acting on them in Charity towards others.

If you are looking for an in the face victory over doubt, trying to overcome an obstacle to your faith, consider Augustine’s pedagogical evangelism of this dilemma:

“…if they wish to see the old or the new moon or some very small star which I was pointing to with my finger and they did not have keen enough sight to even see my finger, they should not on that account become … with me…[These] … should ask God to give them vision.”

I wish you good fortune in your search for that vision you suppose Catholics have; and indeed many of us do have it; but everyone has a mind and eyes to see with, including the agnostic. Perhaps it would help to know that all this energy going into these things for the agnostic is not ego building self aggrandizement or vanity, but effort made for the joy of knowing another is being given a solid invitation to look again at things from a fresh perspective. And if there is a vanity pleasure in it, perhaps it is an indulgence duly earned. No one likes it when things get old and stale. The holy Spirit says in the Book of Revelations: **“Behold, I make all things new.” This includes, presumably, one’s thoughts in the definition of things.**Grace and Peace.
I think you are correct on this. a new way of seeing things and new definitions. Jesus gives us just that. Wisdom of God, what a marvelous thing.

Today, the reading about Salomon. How beautiful his request was to God. How he recognized his limitations although he was chosen to be a king. He did not let pride lead him because he was chosen to be king like so many do, instead he turns to God for help.
On the other hand we see herod who was destroyed because he accepted the idea of being a god.
 
Hello everyone, I’m new to this forum…but I must say I’m agnostic. Why? Lots of reasons.

I am someone who cant accept anything unless it makes sense…yet I’m one who can also say anything is possible - but the latter would just depend.

I have questions. Lots of questions. Too many questions. I dont know where to start exactly LOL.

Maybe you guys could tell me WHY you believe in God and how do you know for sure your beliefs are in touch with reality.

But in the meantime, I’ll ask a question.

I have always asked this question to myself and it is uncomfortable to ponder about but you have to always ask.

If God is all-everything (all-knowing, powerful, can do anything, etc.), and he really cares for ALL of humanity, and gives blessings, why can’t he evenly spread those blessing to all? In other words, why can he bless a country like America as a whole but leaves a third-world country like Haiti in devastating poverty?? Remember, God is all-powerful, all good.

Is God unfair? And does God have a justified reason to let people starve to death or live in nasty slums? Did God forget those people are really no different than Americans?

Or, is God dead or just plain imaginary?

Or, could we look at this with a scientific approach?

So, can you convince me otherwise? Convince me that God is real.
Ultimately you need faith to believe, so no, nobody can REALLY convince you in the sense of making you believe. You do have some inner knowledge of God and with prayer God can increase your faith.

The presence of sin in the world, since man’s original sin is the reason why bad/evil things happen. It’s doesn’t mean that people suffering are suffering because of their personal sin. You can be an innocent victim of sin…e.g…a crack baby, born as an addict, who may struggle with addiction all their life, and in the process go on to commit other sins, stealing to supply his addiction, selling drugs to kids, pimping women, etc. One sin begets another, sin has had a cumulative, ongoing effect even since the original sin was committed. In that sense it has attained a life of it’s own.

Good works have the same type of cumulative effect, counteracting the power of sin and eventually the Kingdom of God will achieve total victory. The battle is still in the works.
 
Ultimately you need faith to believe, so no, nobody can REALLY convince you in the sense of making you believe. You do have some inner knowledge of God and with prayer God can increase your faith.

The presence of sin in the world, since man’s original sin is the reason why bad/evil things happen. It’s doesn’t mean that people suffering are suffering because of their personal sin. You can be an innocent victim of sin…e.g…a crack baby, born as an addict, who may struggle with addiction all their life, and in the process go on to commit other sins, stealing to supply his addiction, selling drugs to kids, pimping women, etc. One sin begets another, sin has had a cumulative, ongoing effect even since the original sin was committed. In that sense it has attained a life of it’s own.

Good works have the same type of cumulative effect, counteracting the power of sin and eventually the Kingdom of God will achieve total victory. The battle is still in the works.
That is a good point. Sin does generate sin but when bad things happens, we tend to blame one who is Inocent, God.
We see that contraception has brought free sex, abortion, adultery, breaking up of the family, relativism, lack of respect for the body, lack of respect for women and men, desecration of Sacramental marriage, and so forth. Then, when we see chaos all around us, we still want to feel like we have no fault at all. We tend to believe we are all good people. When in fact, we need to look at ourselves and recognize how wrong we have been and strike our breasts 3x and say, Jesus have pity on me, Son of the Living God have…me.
 
Sorry guys, I didnt mean Catholic organizations or charities…I meant Rome, you know, the Vatican. I didnt mean Catholic churches, organizations, etc. in general…I meant the Vatican.

Sorry, that was my bad :o I can see why you were annoyed…sorry.

You see, I had a conversation with these people who happened to be ex-Catholics and they were they were telling me how this charity was trying to get funds but werent getting a lot and the charity tried to get funds from the Vatican but it refused…whether they were telling me the truth or not, I have no clue.

I meant the Vatican guys. Sorry if I wasnt clear 😦
So this nameless charity, which may or may not be supporting immoral causes, allegedly tried to get funds from the Vatican, on an unspecified date, by unspecified means. You have no idea whether this is true or not, and you’re getting it at least second-hand from people who purposely left the Catholic Church. And we are supposed to comment on this?!? Come on! Go do your own homework then come back with details.
 
Well, I was talking material-wise.
And therein lies the problem.
The great thing about materialism as a world-view is that it is self-affirming. You ask for proof of the material world and you receive measurements in answer. You ask for material proof of the spiritual world and you get nothing because the spiritual world is not physical and cannot be evaluated by physical means. The materialist interprets this lack of answer as proof against the spiritual world because she has already accepted materialism as a world-view, for no good reason.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top