Creation of God

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jp2.0
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Jp2.0

Guest
So if God couldn’t be able to create God then does that mean that God has a limitation on what he can create? But than again God can’t have limits because he’s God, there is no one that is higher than he. Can God create something higher than him? If He can’t create things higher than He has limits, but if He can does that mean that there could be something higher or better than God?
I know I am wrong somewhere I just need to know where.
 
Last edited:
God is the Creator, there is no other. If there was something greater, then “God” wouldn’t be God, but just another creature. If you understand the term “recursion”, you are invoking recursion in an invalid way. Recursion is a mental tool of humans to comprehend a mystery. If there’s no endpoint, no “final” fundamental case, then the recursion is infinite and meaningless, in a practical or useful way.
 
Yeah, you’re not understanding what God is. If you were, these questions wouldn’t need asked.

A creator is always greater than the creature. The potter is always greater than the pot that he makes. No matter how big.

If God’s existence depended on some other being’s existence, well that wouldn’t be God. The other being would be.
Can God bring about an existence that doesn’t depend on Him to bring it about?
 
Why do you believe that God has no limits? I believe that your understanding of the nature of God is incorrect and that is the cause of your troubles. I will provide you with some excerpts from a well-crafted article by Richard Swinburne published in American Philosophical Quarterly, Vol. 10, No. 3 (Jul., 1973), pp. 234-6. If you have access to JSTOR, you can use the link provided below. In short, God can most certainly rid himself of omnipotence by creating a stone too heavy for him to lift or (in your example) creating a being with more power than himself. That is, assuming that omnipotence entails a level of “higher than thou(ness).” If it doesn’t, which could be argued, then the mere act of God creating a being higher than himself would not necessarily contradict his omnipotence. Afterall, God is still just as capable as before the creation of this higher being. Good post though. Really got me thinking.

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
https://www.jstor.org/stable/20009498
 
Last edited:
So basically, what I concluded is that it is illogical to to assume that God can’t do something because by definition, God can do anything.
 
Not quite. God can do anything that is logically possible for him to do. For example, God could not bring about a square triangle. Nor could he make 2+2 = 5.
 
I agree that God can do anything. I just add a qualifier so as not to confuse anyone. God can do anything that is logically possible for him to do. It goes without saying that God cannot do something that is incoherent, such as making 2 + 2 = 5 or making a triangular circle.
 
You are right in that God does not necessarily rely on our understandings. For example, the finer details of Holy Trinity continue to elude us, as do the finer details of omnipresence. However, there is a difference between those examples and, say, creating a triangular circle. We, as humans, know what a circle is as we have defined it. We also know what a triangle is for the same reason. Because we know fully what a circle is and what a triangle is, we can say that it is incoherent to suggest that there is a triangular circle. Therefore, we cannot even conceptualize such a situation in our minds because “such a situation” is a logical impossibility. Likewise, God cannot create a triangular circle because “such a situation” is a logical impossibility.
 
The problem that devolves into is…
Can God great a rock that is so heavy that He can’t lift it?

That puts the logical issue into a more physical realm than perhaps a square triangle does.

The skeptic would then say to the above, if God can’t create such a rock, then He has limits. If He can’t lift it, He has limits.

But we know God is limitless. We, on the other hand have limited understanding, and thus cannot comprehend why that question does not “prove” God has no limits without invoking the logical paradox issue.
 
God can’t make a square circle because there’s no such thing as a square circle. But God can move in the world in miraculous ways
 
The question of whether God can make a rock so heavy he couldn’t lift it is a physics problem. The greatest mass any rock could have is infinite, which God being omnipotent, could create. The greatest force is an infinite force, which, again, God could create. The question then becomes: what happens if an infinite force meets a (stationary) object of infinite mass? (The problem is usually stated as: what would happen if an irresistible force met an immovable object?)

We remember from our physics classes that force = mass x acceleration (F = ma) The acceleration is the rate at which the object moves when a force is applied to it, so it’s the acceleration we’re interested in. Solving the equation for a gives: a = F/m (acceleration equals force divided by mass).

Now, as both F and m are infinite, a = infinity / infinity. Mathematicians call this an indeterminate form, which means you can’t say one thing nor another about the matter and therefore no logical conclusion can be drawn from it. Atheists try to say both one thing and another about it and conclude that God can’t be omnipotent. It is an example of a sophism, i.e. an argument that appears logical at first glance, but proves false after a closer look.
 
It is important to realize that what we mean by omnipotence is not doing that which is logically impossible.
Hence a square triangle or such would be impossible.
The same logic applies in the rock idea.

It is actually asking, “Can a being capable of lifting anything create something He cannot lift?” and hence it is a logical impossibility with no damage done to God’s omnipotence.
Similarly, what you are asking is “Can an uncreated and eternal being be created?”
And again, it is clearly a contradiction of terms, and hence it can be answered with no damage done to God’s Omnipotence.
 
@tstor has it right. It isn’t actually true to say God can do absolutely anything. He can’t do something that is a logical impossibility. St. Thomas Aquinas actually offers insights into this in his treatment of God and angels.
 
According to Aquinas, the Christian God is existence itself and cannot lack anything. He cannot change (thus he has no potential and he is pure actuality meaning existence itself). If He could change, He would have had to move from potentially changing to actually changing. And nothing can move itself from being potentially to being actually.

Thus, if God created another God, that other God (OG) would not be God. The reason being is that the OG would have potentiality. It moved from potentially being to actually being. Thus, if you have potentiality, you cannot have pure actuality and never change. And never changing means you are in an eternal state of just “being”. That is what God does. And the OG does not.

Hopefully that made some sense. 😐

I suppose to sum up, anything created cannot be existence itself which is what God is. So God cannot create another God.
 
Blessings
God is the beginning and the end. He’s the Aloha and Omega. No one is higher than He…
Our Faith accepts His existence. He is infinity. Always was and always will be. The church has brought the message of God from our Jewish Hx and the gospels sharing the story of JESUS.
God created the angels. Lucifer was the highest angel. He had pride and wanted to be God. Angel of Light. So, the battle was fought and Satan and all his followers were cast into hell.
Nothing is higher than God
In Christ’s love
Tweedlealice
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top