Cruz or Clinton

  • Thread starter Thread starter Peter_J
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Or maybe, we shouldn’t put so much burden on one person. I don’t see a lot of priests preach about abortion. If there is no preaching, hearts won’t be changed. Preachers have a bigger responsibility than the president, IMHO.
I think politicians are a fairly accurate barometer of their constituency. If abortion exists in both our countries, it’s because the people support it, and if the people support it, so will the politicians. In Canada, not a single jury would convict Henry Morgentaler as he worked his way through the courts. The only surefire way to solve the abortion problem is to evangelize, or as you put it, changing hearts.
I hope those who bring up this criticism have likewise faithfully voted pro-life when able. If they have not, this argument is rather meaningless and self-serving.
I have not been able to vote pro-life in a Federal election in Canada since 1988. All parties support abortion. The Senate undid the last attempt of the Progressive Conservatives to regulate abortion. Since then there are no abortion regulations in Canada, and no political party with the courage to bring up the issue again.

I do not say this with any joy, it is simply the reality. I myself was adopted as an infant in 1958. I consider myself lucky I was conceived then.

The real job of overcoming abortion does not reside in the voters booth, but with our Christian mission to evangelize.
 
Probably more Republicans than Democrats participating on Christian forums is what I’m suggesting. As far as being a member of the Democratic party and being a Christian I never said a thing about it. However as you see in the post right above its apparent many people do have concerns with your point. Probably make an interesting topic something to the effect of, The Democrats view on religious freedom and abortion.
Personally, I do not think politics has a huge role in the Catholic Christian faith. I thought that baptism makes one a Christian, and not politics.
 
Rubio is my first choice, but I would vote for Cruz (then take a cold shower). If it’s Trump v. Hillary, I’m voting 3rd party and prepping for the apocalypse. Seriously.

As for Cruz, his attitude bugs me (it’s why he doesn’t have any endorsements from other Senators), but, honestly, there’s not much difference policy-wise between himself and Rubio. The main policy difference is on immigration, but the biggest difference between the two candidates is honestly, attitude. This is why Rubio is so much more palatable to the “establishment” than Cruz - but, really, only one of the two could survive.
 
🙂

Actually, now seeing how many posters fall in that category, it would be nice if I had split it into two (but that wouldn’t have worked with the ten option limit).
Well when I just now signed back on, those posters still held an ever so slight plurality. Reminds me of the Republican primary season with all the options splitting the votes. 👍
 
Very fair question. Unlike Catholics, Episcopalians accept abortion as a complicated, nuanced issue. Some Episcopalians, like some Catholics, are pro-choice. Some Episcopalians, like some Catholics, are anti-choice. Some Episcopalians, like some Catholics, have abortions. **I believe all of us, on both sides of the issue, are pro-life.
**
I am cradle Episcopalian and had 16-years of formal Episcopal Church schooling and I have never heard an Episcopalian describe abortion as “murdering a baby.” I’m not saying that some Episcopalians wouldn’t use that language, but just that I’ve never heard it used - not in my 49 years as a member of the Church.

I’ve not ever been closely involved with a woman who needed an abortion when her child was one push from being born. Perhaps, that does happen, but I personally have no experience with it - not enough to comment cogently. I would have to have so much more information to weigh in on such a scenario. I do not believe such a scenario is common, but I do think it makes for compelling rhetoric on the anti-choice side,( just like I think that “but she was raped” or “but she might die” makes compelling rhetoric on the pro-choice side).

In the final analysis, I believe the only person who has the right to make a decision concerning abortion is the woman facing that tough decision. I can’t begin to imagine who else might validly make such a decision - the woman’s government? her neighbors?..not on my watch.
With regard to what I bolded, :clapping: That needed to be said. And thank you for doing so. It is something I believe many on what society has come to call the “pro-life” side misunderstand about the pro choice side. I realize the rhetoric can be hyper-aggressive when it comes to this subject. But I still never understood why those who choose to weight the scale entirely on the side of unborn rights and against a woman’s reproductive rights just assume a pro choice person is not pro life. The issue as to what should be legal in a pluralistic society of people of many faiths and non faiths and how to balance rights can be difficult and as you have said can be complicated and nuanced for many. So it’s not as simple in my view as saying those against a woman’s right to choose to abort the fetus in her womb are pro life and others are not.
 
“None of the above because my first choice is Clinton or Sanders” has 20 votes?

😊
Well, I couldn’t tell you what brought those 20 people to CAF. But whatever it may have been I can’t say I’m sorry that they are here.

Do you believe that we shouldn’t bring others around to our way of thinking? That there are “enough of us already” as it were?
 
Can I try: "after 8 years of Reagan, 4 years of Bush Sr., and 8 years of Bush Jr,
Not to change the subject, but wasn’t there another president in between there. Like, Clin-something-or-other? Maybe someone here can help me think of it. :idea:
 
“None of the above because my first choice is Clinton or Sanders” has 20 votes?

😊

I should hope that those 20 people weren’t Catholics.

How can one call oneself a Catholic and vote for a person with a 100% NARAL voting record (applies to **both **Hillary and Sanders - I recently looked it up) who believes that killing children is ok? They not only believe it is ok, they advocate for it - and strongly. No other person besides the POTUS can have more effect on the protection or destruction of these human beings.

Image, if you will, that Hitler was running for election in the 1920’s. He lays out a great plan to get the economy moving again, against corporate greed, for a state-of-the-art highway system (the Autobahn), and any number of things you support. Oh, but there is that nasty thing about how he wants to kill millions of Jews. Would you support him?

There is no difference in these situations.

What will you say to God when He calls you to judgment and asks you “Why did you not vote to protect My precious children?” or “Why did you put __________ (insert your issue(s) here) over the right of my children to be born and not be killed in the womb of their mothers?”

Better think of an answer. Better yet, repent and go to confession. 👍
Maybe they call themselves Catholic because the Catholic Church does? 🤷

Or maybe they fear someone with the temperament that Donald Trump has shown us during this primary season having his finger on the nuclear button and annihilating over a billion people? Or someone like a Ted Cruz carpet bombing the Middle East killing innocent Muslims? Perhaps they fear a candidate once in office will support the intrinsic evil of torture? But that the candidate will be ineffective on ending legal abortion. Just a few examples. I imagine they may have many other reasons.

Probably why the collective assembly of bishops in their voting guide clearly state that bishops are not intending to tell Catholics for whom or against whom to vote. That they recognize the the responsibility to make choices in political life rests with each individual and that a Catholic face difficult choices.
 
There is no such thing as “reproductive rights”. Things are made “rights” these days not because they are “rights” but to stunt and silence opposition to someone getting a government entitlement to in almost all cases take the easy way out in life.

I believe similar arguments were made during the slave trade, and I’m surprised at all to hear Democrats in America making the same fundamental claims for abortion 150 years later.
But I still never understood why those who choose to weight the scale entirely on the side of unborn rights and against a woman’s reproductive rights just assume a pro choice person is not pro life.
Well…that would be because abortion is almost always murder.
"So it’s not as simple in my view as saying those against a woman’s right to choose to abort the fetus in her womb are pro life and others are not.
There is no such thing as a “right to choose”. It is not enough for Catholics or Christians to dislike abortion but still be pro-choice.

What would happen if people said “You know, I dislike slavery, but it’s a choice, so it should be legal, safe and regulated”.
 
Or maybe they fear someone with the temperament that Donald Trump has shown us during this primary season having his finger on the nuclear button and annihilating over a billion people? Or someone like a Ted Cruz carpet bombing the Middle East killing innocent Muslims? Perhaps they fear a candidate once in office will support the intrinsic evil of torture? But that the candidate will be ineffective on ending legal abortion. Just a few examples. I imagine they may have many other reasons.
I think it’s all about personal selfishness and entitlements for a lot of people.

I very much doubt that Democrats and liberals care as much as they say they do about places like the Middle East beyond trying to appease people who are different because that’s what is :cool: today.

Besides, the numbers in charitable giving and their track record from Reservations to inner cities isn’t good.

And in this election cycle I doubt very many Americans are concerned about nuclear war. It’s just scare tactics the left uses to make their candidates look better.

Which I have to say is interesting because based on some folks’ idealism, that’s a tactic they shouldn’t even need if what the DNC is selling is so great.
Probably why the collective assembly of bishops in their voting guide clearly state that bishops are not intending to tell Catholics for whom or against whom to vote. That they recognize the the responsibility to make choices in political life rests with each individual and that a Catholic face difficult choices.
The bishops will never endorse a candidate, they will just more or less advise Catholics on the issues.

That’s not a large problem.

The problem is Christians running around making excuses to support things that go against natural or the clear and common sense teachings of the Gospel, and they actually expect me to buy into their lame, transparent excuses for doing so.

And I will say this about the forums: I have seen accounts ask if it’s acceptable to vote Democratic or for certain foreign parties in a country that are all vehemently anti-Catholic.

But I have yet to see anyone come on here and ask if it’s okay to vote for a conservative republican or who was struggling in conscience to do so.

Really says something about First World politics.
 
Rubio is my first choice, but I would vote for Cruz (then take a cold shower). If it’s Trump v. Hillary, I’m voting 3rd party and prepping for the apocalypse. Seriously.

As for Cruz, his attitude bugs me (it’s why he doesn’t have any endorsements from other Senators), but, honestly, there’s not much difference policy-wise between himself and Rubio. The main policy difference is on immigration, but the biggest difference between the two candidates is honestly, attitude. This is why Rubio is so much more palatable to the “establishment” than Cruz - but, really, only one of the two could survive.
Let me just say this about voting 3rd Party: Some folks voted for Gary Johnson and Virgil Goode in 2012.

It’s 2016 and I have not heard a single one of them say “Despite the fact that it got Barack Obama and Joesph Biden re-elected, I’m happy with what I did and accept the consequences of my actions even if it hurts me and my family”.

Where does one think endorsements from Senators rank in terms of importance from God’s perspective?

Would that be the same American Senate that at some points has had single-digit approval, but now all a sudden their endorsements are so terribly important?? :eek:

Also: a question to conservatives: if this is as bad as some say, why are so many of them sitting at home and not voting?
 
Or someone like a Ted Cruz carpet bombing the Middle East killing innocent Muslims?
To be fair, Mr. Cruz clarified that his definition of the term “carpet bombing” is slightly different.

But regardless, Cruz isn’t my first choice. What would really be nice is if supporters of Mr. T***p started saying “You know what? We’re never going to get our first choice into the White House, given that we’re just 35% of Republicans. But if we get behind Rubio, he could get the nomination instead of Cruz.” But I just don’t think that’s going to happen.

(Of course if it comes down to “Cruz or Clinton” I prefer Cruz. :))
 
Rubio is my first choice, but I would vote for Cruz (then take a cold shower). If it’s Trump v. Hillary, I’m voting 3rd party and prepping for the apocalypse. Seriously.

As for Cruz, his attitude bugs me (it’s why he doesn’t have any endorsements from other Senators), but, honestly, there’s not much difference policy-wise between himself and Rubio. The main policy difference is on immigration, but the biggest difference between the two candidates is honestly, attitude. This is why Rubio is so much more palatable to the “establishment” than Cruz - but, really, only one of the two could survive.
This is basically my POV, but I would write in a candidate.

Maybe if many people do this. :hmmm: And we all got together and wrote in the same candidate? :hmmm:
 
Hi all. Suppose hypothetically that Ted Cruz wins the Republican nomination and Hillary Clinton wins the Democratic nomination. Which one would you vote for?

Choices are partitioned according to your first presidential choice. Intended primarily for those who would make either Donald Trump, Marco Rubio, or John Kasich their first choice for president (but I’ve also included a few alternative vote-options at the bottom, naturally).
None of the above.
I could not vote for any Democrat under virtually any circumstance. I would prefer not to have to vote for Trump, but I will if need be.

Jon
 
With regard to what I bolded, :clapping: That needed to be said. And thank you for doing so. It is something I believe many on what society has come to call the “pro-life” side misunderstand about the pro choice side. I realize the rhetoric can be hyper-aggressive when it comes to this subject. But I still never understood why those who choose to weight the scale entirely on the side of unborn rights and against a woman’s reproductive rights just assume a pro choice person is not pro life. The issue as to what should be legal in a pluralistic society of people of many faiths and non faiths and how to balance rights can be difficult and as you have said can be complicated and nuanced for many. So it’s not as simple in my view as saying those against a woman’s right to choose to abort the fetus in her womb are pro life and others are not.
Thank you, Sy Noe. I appreciate it. It can be hard because the two sides frame the issue in such different ways that each side seems inaccessible to the other.

For me, the rhetoric (on both sides) is the toughest part, because it shuts down conversation. I myself never directly engage with a “murder” or “baby-killer” accusation. People who say that lose my honest attention - I can’t really hear them any more after that.

And I imagine those that would outlaw abortion, rarely feel like talking much after someone calls them a misogynistic sadist for forcing a rape victim to carry a pregnancy to term. I see this stuff all the time when this subject comes up online. I’m sure you have too.

And that’s the frustration. There are many smart, passionate people on all the different sides of this issue. Imagine what we could accomplish if we could actually come together, hear each other and work for a common goal! I’ll keep dreaming, though…🙂
 
Or someone like a Ted Cruz carpet bombing the Middle East killing innocent Muslims?
He only said he’d carpet bomb a terrorist camp; how many innocent Muslims are there in that?

Oh well, I haven’t heard the same complaint via drone strikes in Afghanistan and Iraq over the last 7 years.
 
Not to change the subject, but wasn’t there another president in between there. Like, Clin-something-or-other? Maybe someone here can help me think of it. :idea:
I was talking about what the Republicans did (or did not do).

Last I checked Clin-something-or-other was a democrat. I may be a hick from Canada but even I know that… 🤷
 
Thank you, Sy Noe. I appreciate it. It can be hard because the two sides frame the issue in such different ways that each side seems inaccessible to the other.

For me, the rhetoric (on both sides) is the toughest part, because it shuts down conversation. I myself never directly engage with a “murder” or “baby-killer” accusation. People who say that lose my honest attention - I can’t really hear them any more after that.

And I imagine those that would outlaw abortion rarely feel like talking much after someone calls them a misogynistic sadist for forcing a rape victim to carry a pregnancy to term. I see this stuff all the time when this subject comes up online. I’m sure you have too.

And that’s the frustration. There are many smart, passionate people on all the different sides of this issue. Imagine what we could accomplish if we could actually come together, hear each other and work for a common goal! I’ll keep dreaming, though…🙂
 
I was talking about what the Republicans did (or did not do).

Last I checked Clin-something-or-other was a democrat. I may be a hick from Canada but even I know that… 🤷
Thank, OraLabora. But I don’t think that affects my point, namely that “Bush Jr” didn’t pick up where GHWB left off.

(I’ll spare you the speech about how we also have three branches of government. :))
 
This is basically my POV, but I would write in a candidate.
I’m not going to lie to you and promise that we’ll all be happy with the eventual Republican nominee – I won’t even rule out the possibility I won’t be happy with the eventual Republican nominee (not to name names :)). But I promise you that I won’t help HRC by supporting any Republican’s decision to run as a third party candidate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top