Crystal Cathedral is Bankrupt

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cat_Herder
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Cat_Herder

Guest
The Associated Press:
GARDEN GROVE, Calif. (AP) – Crystal Cathedral, the megachurch birthplace of the televangelist show “Hour of Power,” has filed for bankruptcy in Southern California after struggling to emerge from debt that exceeds $43 million.

In addition to a $36 million mortgage, the Orange County-based church owes $7.5 million to several hundred vendors for services ranging from advertising to the use of live animals in Easter and Christmas services.

The church had been negotiating a repayment plan with vendors, but several filed lawsuits seeking quicker payment, which prompted a coalition formed by creditors to fall apart, church officials said.
Read more.

This isn’t necessarily the end for the Crystal Cathedral; they have tightened their belts and may be able to work out a deal with their creditors.

But this raises all sorts of questions about the megachurch phenomenon. I’ll ask a few to start: Will it survive the recession? Should there be megachurches to begin with, if the donated money ends up going to creditors instead of to the poor?

What if a megachurch was to come to understand the Sacraments and the biblical role of the church? Does that change the previous answers?
 
But this raises all sorts of questions about the megachurch phenomenon. I’ll ask a few to start: Will it survive the recession? Should there be megachurches to begin with, if the donated money ends up going to creditors instead of to the poor?
I’m not sure that the primary purpose of a church, even a megachurch, is to be a poverty relief agency. Certainly the same criticism could be (and has been) leveled at the Catholic Church. I think both Martha and Mary have appropriate roles to play.

As for the long term survival of the Crystal Cathedral, we’ll have to see. I’m not sure that its financial problems have so much to do with the economy (although it must be a factor) as with the retirement of its charismatic founder, Robert Schuller.
 
I live in Orange County Ca.
TBN , the Trinity Broadcasting Network(Santa Ana) and the Crystal Cathedral (Garden Grove)are in very close proximity as well as Rick Warrens SaddleBack Church(Lake Forest) as well as Chuck Smiths Calvary Chapel (Costa Mesa).

Being from nearby I probably know just a tad more than most or at least have come across some local news more often than most to form an opinion.
.
As to the Crystal Cathedral, Rober Schuller has been a charismatic figure with great appeal to everyone. However, nepotism within ministry turns it into nothing less than ‘church as business’.

Schullers nepotism has lead to his son taking over and failing to connect with the parishioners either through a different emphasis and focus than his father or different doctrinal stances. It seems the daughter (also a minister & senior pastor ) has stepped up into some serious shoes there and that would also be problematic(female ministers).

The phenomenon of each successive generation within Protestantism being less devout or throwing out some doctrines and then doubling down on others or even having a different emphasis and foucus has led to divisions there. For instance, Chuck Smiths son (Calvary Chapel) has significantly deviated from his father and has led to a rather public ministry split. His son is part of the ‘Emergent Church’ trend which has a focus on liturgy with smells and bells.
 
I’m not sure that the primary purpose of a church, even a megachurch, is to be a poverty relief agency.
[BIBLEDRB]Matthew 25:31-46[/BIBLEDRB]
Certainly the same criticism could be (and has been) leveled at the Catholic Church.
…which is the world’s largest charity, making such criticism unsustainable.
 
The good part is that they’ve got the power of positive thinking on their side.

But seriously, maybe they wouldn’t have this problem if they got with it and allowed a married clergy. Or if they ordained women, then they would flourish.
 
The good part is that they’ve got the power of positive thinking on their side.

But seriously, maybe they wouldn’t have this problem if they got with it and allowed a married clergy. Or if they ordained women, then they would flourish.
Ha! You just pegged my sarcasm meter!😃
 
Can’t get too worked up about this. Churches go under all the time. There are more than twenty Catholic churches being closed in the Twin Cities largely for financial reasons, although their failure isn’t as spectacular as the Chrystal Cathedral.
 
I am not a big fan of mega-churches. I think it’s another form of big business. Look at “Bishop” Long. He rolls in private jet, Bentley, and lives in multimillion dollar home.
 
The New York Times reveals some of the causes of the bankruptcy, at least according to the younger Rev. Schuller, who led the church for a couple years before being deposed.

An ambitious construction project left the church $40 million in the red, and they couldn’t find donors to bail them out.

The audience for the TV show (a major source of donations) is shrinking, in part due to not attracting a new generation of supporters and in part because competition from other shows.

The leadership unheaval didn’t help matters.

And, of course, it is hard to duplicate the charisma of the senior Rev. Schuller, now 84 years old, who has retired.
nytimes.com/2010/10/24/us/24cathedral.html?_r=1
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top