D&D (Dungeons and Dragons)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ophelia23
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It says you should RTJ Accidental Adventurers šŸ˜‰
Accidental? Harrumph! I need not accidents! I create my own adventures under numerous aliases!!! >8D <—Translated: I have so many author avatars and self-inserts that I wonder if I already committed social suicide. T_T
 
SAGA edition Star Wars was the last D20 version. I was GM’ing a campaign with the rule set before school got in the way. I like it, but I’m pretty sure it was made for campaigns like mine where Dark Side characters aren’t allowed. If one of my players characters goes over to the DS, that PC becomes an NPC.

That said, it’s actually pretty easy to modify as you see fit. It wouldn’t be to hard to modify the DS point rules. Check out the site below for a metric ton of resources specifically for D20 Star Wars.

saga-edition.com/
 
SAGA edition Star Wars was the last D20 version. I was GM’ing a campaign with the rule set before school got in the way. I like it, but I’m pretty sure it was made for campaigns like mine where Dark Side characters aren’t allowed. If one of my players characters goes over to the DS, that PC becomes an NPC.

That said, it’s actually pretty easy to modify as you see fit. It wouldn’t be to hard to modify the DS point rules. Check out the site below for a metric ton of resources specifically for D20 Star Wars.

saga-edition.com/
Totaly agree, its maid with all good guy charecters in mind. I enjoy playing anti-heros however, and the base rules make it tough, I went out and bought the ā€œScum and Villanyā€ and "Force Unleashed " guides and cant even use alot of it without being afraid my mercenary gunslinger will become an NPC. changing the rules is definitely required for anything but a strictly black and white campaign.
 
Accidental? Harrumph! I need not accidents! I create my own adventures under numerous aliases!!! >8D <—Translated: I have so many author avatars and self-inserts that I wonder if I already committed social suicide. T_T
grin Well, I chose the name for the game (Accidental Adventurers) because the particular PCs are people who weren’t always planning to become adventurers, so they became adventurers by accident (kind of like the Star Wars quote ā€œthey were in the wrong place at the wrong time, so of course, they became heroesā€).

(edited because I forgot this was ubb not html)
 
This link is an informative as well as humorous treatment of this matter.
Well, I am seeing some posts where people seem to think that players are actually casting real spells. It really is just a game. The spells are not real, nor do they resemble anything real. If I understand right, it’s more like… ā€œI conjure a fireball at you! Mwa ha ha!!ā€ But, I don’t play so I guess I don’t know for sure. 🤷 šŸ™‚
This is correct. No actual magic is done, attempted, or even aesthetically approximated in any way by the behavior or words of the players.

Certain characters, in the story of the game, will use magic. But saying, ā€œOkay, my character casts a fireball at the ogre!ā€ is just not occult at all. Or anything close.

In fact, not even all player characters use magic. If you’re playing some kind of fighter or something, your character will use swords and stuff like that - never spells.
 
This link is an informative as well as humorous treatment of this matter.

This is correct. No actual magic is done, attempted, or even aesthetically approximated in any way by the behavior or words of the players.

Certain characters, in the story of the game, will use magic. But saying, ā€œOkay, my character casts a fireball at the ogre!ā€ is just not occult at all. Or anything close.

In fact, not even all player characters use magic. If you’re playing some kind of fighter or something, your character will use swords and stuff like that - never spells.
^This! šŸ™‚
And yes, the same idea also applies to RPGs. A perfect example of this is found in Rush On Seven Episodes online. Only the Muse, Cleric and Magician jobs do any in-game magic as far as the job classes are concerned. The other jobs do not even do magic. šŸ™‚
 
I used to play Dungeons and Dragons.

Of course, I heard it was satanic and stuff like that. I ignored the advice I was given about that game and I played it.

It’s funny. I had good experiences and bad, I learned how to be a better and more mature person in dealing with bad situations (when my character died, etc), and to be graceful and treat it more of a game and a game session which you can socialize around.

Erm, there were times which I felt I could have handled my own negative emotions when I played that game when things went wrong, but eventually I treated it more like a socializing session to meet people and be friends with them.

But I quit playing mainly because the game doesn’t seem so challenging and exciting anymore, and probably at the deepest darkest levels of my conscience, I decided I shouldn’t play this game which may be a spiritual danger to myself.

And I’ll tell you guys one thing. There are quite a fair bit of D&D playing individuals who would behave in a way which I believe isn’t Christ-like. So it was easy for me to give it up.
 
And I’ll tell you guys one thing. There are quite a fair bit of D&D playing individuals who would behave in a way which I believe isn’t Christ-like. So it was easy for me to give it up.
When you find the field of endeavor where everyone who takes part behaves in a Christ-like manner, let us know.
 
When you find the field of endeavor where everyone who takes part behaves in a Christ-like manner, let us know.
I apologize if I have offended anyone.

I was speaking from my own experiences. Others may have experienced D&D differently, so I would like to state that I only speak for myself, and I can’t speak for others.
 
No offense taken. šŸ™‚

The arguments you’ve seen here were all put forth to me at my Catholic high school back in the 1980s. When I told Father Principal that the D&D club members got into far less trouble than his beloved football teamā€¦šŸ˜ƒ

Hey, I was 16 and an epic wiseass. 🤷

I’ve known all manner of people who play D&D. As long as they share in the conviviality of the game, they are welcome at my gaming table.
 
I was speaking from my own experiences. Others may have experienced D&D differently, so I would like to state that I only speak for myself, and I can’t speak for others.
If it’s not for you then it’s not for you.
On the other hand, I don’t think quitting just due to the presence of unsavory players (an experience I’m well familiar with, I assure you) is very reasonable.
 
I used to play Dungeons and Dragons.

Of course, I heard it was satanic and stuff like that. I ignored the advice I was given about that game and I played it.

It’s funny. I had good experiences and bad, I learned how to be a better and more mature person in dealing with bad situations (when my character died, etc), and to be graceful and treat it more of a game and a game session which you can socialize around.

Erm, there were times which I felt I could have handled my own negative emotions when I played that game when things went wrong, but eventually I treated it more like a socializing session to meet people and be friends with them.

But I quit playing mainly because the game doesn’t seem so challenging and exciting anymore, and probably at the deepest darkest levels of my conscience, I decided I shouldn’t play this game which may be a spiritual danger to myself.

And I’ll tell you guys one thing. There are quite a fair bit of D&D playing individuals who would behave in a way which I believe isn’t Christ-like. So it was easy for me to give it up.
Well, it’s good to know yourself, and who you are. If you think that, for whatever reason, the game could have presented a spiritual danger, it’s good that you let it go. Certainly, we should be prepared to let anything go if we think it’s harming our spiritual life in some form or fashion. I don’t agree that the game in and of itself presents a spiritual danger, but that doesn’t mean that, like almost anything, it can’t be a problem for individuals.

I’ve been fortunate to play with folks who are level-headed and good-hearted, but I’ve run into those problem players on occasion, too. Like any other hobby, you get some strange people in the mix.
 
I apologize if I have offended anyone.

I was speaking from my own experiences. Others may have experienced D&D differently, so I would like to state that I only speak for myself, and I can’t speak for others.
Dear LZ2000,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. Thankyou for your contribution relating your experience.

Whilst D&D is not the actual occult of the real world, its resemblance to that world is quite disturbing and decidedly unsavoury. It is beyond me how those who profess the *holy *religion of Christ would wish to squander their time by playing a game that extols vice and denigrates virtue. Moreover, dear friend, who can say that the curosity of fallen man will never lead him to take an evil path, even if he does consider himself to be well-rounded and balanced. Let us remember that Satan and his forces have deeply invaded man’s social and cultural structures and there is no reason to believe that RPG’s have been omitted. Thus he will never cease to draw men into the world of darkness, by whatever means. It admits of no doubt that there is a very clear and present danger with D&D and the game cannot be regarded as harmless fantasy fun, for it can, at least for some people, be a pathway to the occultic subculture. Even one soul lost to the occult as a result of this unwholesome game is surely cause for Catholic concern. What if it was our own son or daughter who had been drawn into the occult?

There can, dear friend, be no doubt that the fantasy element of D&D is both very descriptive and realistic. Frequently this RPG treats of subject matter, which to the Catholic is either blasphemous or downright demonic and, as I said in the preceding paragraph, this is very disturbing, notwithstanding that it is fictional world. Fictional or not, it does not make the subject matter any less unsavoury and it is deeply saddening that some professing Catholics are unable to appreciate this. Alas, fantasy games such as D&D are the ones which deal with this dark subject matter the most, since they thrive on imagination and exaggeration of reality. It calls upon the players to allow themselves to mentally enter a fictional world where things are different than in reality and take pleasure in this world and believe in it. Those in the actual real world, view that sort of material as blasphemous and occultic, whereas your gamer would see it as perfectly natural in the context of the game, far removed from reality and their own beliefs respecting the occult. However, it must be asked to what extent can participating in this RPG over a long period of time desensitize a man to occultic influence, irrespective of the fact that he may be able to differentiate between fact and fiction? Now men may entertain differing opinions upon this, but I do think that there is legitimate concern that this game could well be a pathway to the occult, given its very dark subject matter.

Those who have spoken very favourably and positively of the game in this thread are unlikely to be convinced of any spiritual danger and will probably depict those who have grave concerns as naive in the extreme. They will ardently contend that such ā€˜grave concerns’ are based upon either ignorance or a cursory knowledge at best and spring from an inabilty to separate fact from reality. Whilst I would not deny that some *very *credulous people may have issues as regards distinguishing fact and fantasy, more often than not this is a disengenuous attempt to make a cheap debater’s point and discredit any opposition. Incidently, while it is true that some ultra-Fundamentalists have critiqued this RPG, it does not automatically follow that their critique must be wrong because they are Fundamentalists. That is irrational thinking for Fundamentalist Christians believe, in common with us Catholics, many of the cardinal verities of our most holy religion and are correct to that extent, at least. At any rate, the D&D game does present unsavoury material and subject matter for the player to become involved that is contrary to how they should be acting in the real world. A pious Catholic who is earnestly pursuing holiness in the fear of God, would hardly want to desire or pretend to be some evil or dark character. On the contrary, they would be pre-occupied with what is good, pure, lovely, noble and virtuous - even with respect to their leisure activities (see Phillip. 4: 8).

The acceptance and enthusiatic defence of this D&D game, as with the Harry Potter tales, evinces clearly the jolly poor state of catechesis within the contemporary Church. Men ought to be able to discern, unless they have a radically defective conscience, that this game resembles far too closely the real world of the occultic subculture, notwithstanding that it is a fictional world. That cannot surely be a good and wholesome thing.

God bless.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
I play Dungeons and Dragons Online, a version of 3rd and 4th edition rules, set in (now) the worlds of Eberron (steampunkish magitek) and the Forgotten Realms (the original game world).

In this MMORPG world, you can play Neutral or Good characters. You cannot be an evil character. Surprisingly, this works, as many people take Neutral characters and push them to the edge in game play. However, DDO is not role-play in the formal sense but action-adventure due to its live-action format.

I’ve played many a game over the years. What I play does represent how I live my life. I find myself feeling disconnected if I wantingly kill foes in a game without cause. I play the Monk class; always Lawful. I prefer Good alignment. Depending on the quest, if I needn’t kill everything my party finds, it’s comfortable.

So I guess my thoughts are that one should play games that mesh with their real personality in as much as the game system allows. There’s still plenty of wiggle room for creative personality quirks in your character and game play.

I’m surprised that our moderator has not closed the thread in a nifty way, like:

Jesus saves.
The rest of us must roll 15d8 for damage.
šŸ™‚
 
Dear LZ2000,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. Thankyou for your contribution relating your experience.

Whilst D&D is not the actual occult of the real world, its resemblance to that world is quite disturbing and decidedly unsavoury. It is beyond me how those who profess the *holy *religion of Christ would wish to squander their time by playing a game that extols vice and denigrates virtue. Moreover, dear friend, who can say that the curosity of fallen man will never lead him to take an evil path, even if he does consider himself to be well-rounded and balanced. Let us remember that Satan and his forces have deeply invaded man’s social and cultural structures and there is no reason to believe that RPG’s have been omitted. Thus he will never cease to draw men into the world of darkness, by whatever means. It admits of no doubt that there is a very clear and present danger with D&D and the game cannot be regarded as harmless fantasy fun, for it can, at least for some people, be a pathway to the occultic subculture. Even one soul lost to the occult as a result of this unwholesome game is surely cause for Catholic concern. What if it was our own son or daughter who had been drawn into the occult?

There can, dear friend, be no doubt that the fantasy element of D&D is both very descriptive and realistic. Frequently this RPG treats of subject matter, which to the Catholic is either blasphemous or downright demonic and, as I said in the preceding paragraph, this is very disturbing, notwithstanding that it is fictional world. Fictional or not, it does not make the subject matter any less unsavoury and it is deeply saddening that some professing Catholics are unable to appreciate this. Alas, fantasy games such as D&D are the ones which deal with this dark subject matter the most, since they thrive on imagination and exaggeration of reality. It calls upon the players to allow themselves to mentally enter a fictional world where things are different than in reality and take pleasure in this world and believe in it. Those in the actual real world, view that sort of material as blasphemous and occultic, whereas your gamer would see it as perfectly natural in the context of the game, far removed from reality and their own beliefs respecting the occult. However, it must be asked to what extent can participating in this RPG over a long period of time desensitize a man to occultic influence, irrespective of the fact that he may be able to differentiate between fact and fiction? Now men may entertain differing opinions upon this, but I do think that there is legitimate concern that this game could well be a pathway to the occult, given its very dark subject matter.

Those who have spoken very favourably and positively of the game in this thread are unlikely to be convinced of any spiritual danger and will probably depict those who have grave concerns as naive in the extreme. They will ardently contend that such ā€˜grave concerns’ are based upon either ignorance or a cursory knowledge at best and spring from an inabilty to separate fact from reality. Whilst I would not deny that some *very *credulous people may have issues as regards distinguishing fact and fantasy, more often than not this is a disengenuous attempt to make a cheap debater’s point and discredit any opposition. Incidently, while it is true that some ultra-Fundamentalists have critiqued this RPG, it does not automatically follow that their critique must be wrong because they are Fundamentalists. That is irrational thinking for Fundamentalist Christians believe, in common with us Catholics, many of the cardinal verities of our most holy religion and are correct to that extent, at least. At any rate, the D&D game does present unsavoury material and subject matter for the player to become involved that is contrary to how they should be acting in the real world. A pious Catholic who is earnestly pursuing holiness in the fear of God, would hardly want to desire or pretend to be some evil or dark character. On the contrary, they would be pre-occupied with what is good, pure, lovely, noble and virtuous - even with respect to their leisure activities (see Phillip. 4: 8).

The acceptance and enthusiatic defence of this D&D game, as with the Harry Potter tales, evinces clearly the jolly poor state of catechesis within the contemporary Church. Men ought to be able to discern, unless they have a radically defective conscience, that this game resembles far too closely the real world of the occultic subculture, notwithstanding that it is a fictional world. That cannot surely be a good and wholesome thing.

God bless.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
I typically play necromancers who, within the game setting, animate corpses as zombies to do their bidding. They’re not always evil, but certainly usually dark.

Back in the real world, I am an Inquirer into the OFS and all of the religious I know, including the Mother Superior of the local Franciscan Sister’s convent, tell me that they’re waiting for me to become a priest, and the other members of my choir tell me the same, that they can ā€œjust feel something right about it.ā€

Take from that what you will. I think it totally blows your position out of the water.
 
Whilst D&D is not the actual occult of the real world, its resemblance to that world is quite disturbing and decidedly unsavoury.
Real Occult
View attachment 14996

Fantasy Magic
View attachment 14997
There can, dear friend, be no doubt that the fantasy element of D&D is both very descriptive and realistic.
Question to readers: Is this realistic?
View attachment 14998
Alas, fantasy games such as D&D are the ones which deal with this dark subject matter the most, since they thrive on imagination and exaggeration of reality. It calls upon the players to allow themselves to mentally enter a fictional world where things are different than in reality and take pleasure in this world and believe in it. Those in the actual real world, view that sort of material as blasphemous and occultic, whereas your gamer would see it as perfectly natural in the context of the game, far removed from reality and their own beliefs respecting the occult.
Notice the irony here people. On one hand, Portrait calls it realistic. On the other he now goes on to admit its based on imagination and exaggeration.

Please take a step back folks. Imagine if our world was in fact like one in D&D. What if there was a natural force that allowed people to even substitute for technology.

What if people like me were born with a strong affinity for this force?

I’ll say it before and I’ll say it again: Everyone, meet High Inquisitor William Stryker and Magistrate Robert Kelly.
However, it must be asked to what extent can participating in this RPG over a long period of time desensitize a man to occultic influence, irrespective of the fact that he may be able to differentiate between fact and fiction?
Translated: How can one play a game that differentiates fact from fiction regardless of one’s ability to distinguish fact from fiction?
Whilst I would not deny that some *very *credulous people may have issues as regards distinguishing fact and fantasy, more often than not this is a disengenuous attempt to make a cheap debater’s point and discredit any opposition.
Translated: While I do not deny that those who argue against D&D are loons who can’t tell fiction from fact, calling loons is not an argument.

Possible analogies to Portrait’s conclusion:
You don’t discredit an illogical opponent because they’re being illogical.
You don’t argue that a spade is a spade simply because it’s a spade.

Findings on Portrait’s arguments so far:

Downplays the psychological significance of differentiating fiction from fact.
Considers fantasy magic to have a wholly, realistic resemblance.

Conclusion: Fantasy critics need a shrink. Fast.
 
I realize just how southern I have become when reading the latest post by Portrait, my first thought is … Portrait, bless your heart.

To repeat previous points–there is nothing inherently unwholesome or otherwise inappropriate about role playing games. These games neither extol vice nor denigrate virtue. The stubborn fact remains that fantasy magic does not resemble anything like real world occult practice, nor is it blasphemous (though I would find playing in a world with our actual God as a game character to be quite blasphemous) nor unsavory.

And for the n[sup]th[/sup] (since I doubt it will be anything close to the last) time, no one believes in the game world, nor in game world deities, nor in the notion that there is any more connection between my wizard character casting magic missile and real world activity than there might be between my fighter character stabbing an orc to death and real world activity.
 
And for the n[sup]th[/sup] (since I doubt it will be anything close to the last) time, no one believes in the game world, nor in game world deities, nor in the notion that there is any more connection between my wizard character casting magic missile and real world activity than there might be between my fighter character stabbing an orc to death and real world activity.
Actually, even if one insists on parallels as Portrait does, it still falls on itself (as demonstrated by marcvsthebard):
http://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/archive/4501185/images/1241809486549.jpg

"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic." ~ Arthur C. Clarke, ā€œProfiles of The Futureā€, 1961

šŸæ
Here’s another parallel that I came up using my own life experience:
Real Life
Web Designer: Hey dude, added a new template. You won’t need to hit Enter too much any more.
Content Writer: Cool. ._.
Artificer: Hey dude, got myself a new enchantment. You won’t need to spread your boom spells out anymore.
Warlock: Cool. ._.
 
I’d like to post a reply to Portrait. I recently picked up an offshoot of D&D called Pathfinder, and have just started a game session with my wife and a couple of friends. I spent a good deal of time considering the ups and downs of RPG’s before deciding to play one, and so there are several things I’d like to address that you mention.

First of all, the admonition that participation in an RPG might lead to occult dabblings is certainly a valid concern given the press that they have been given in the last number of years. You seem to summarily dismiss people’s arguments that the fictional nature of the game precludes people from taking it seriously enough to actually pursue real-world occult. However, what has been repeated ad nauseam by the defenders of RPG’s here is that a reasonable person will not mistake the two and leave fiction to its own world. That, for the sake of moral argument, should be sufficient. Everything can be taken to sinful excess, and RPG’s are certainly no exception. Should not drive cars because some people might speed? Should we not eat food because some people are gluttons? Should we not sleep because some people may be prone to sloth? It’s important to consider that abuse of an activity doesn’t lend the activity itself an inherent sinful quality; the responsibility to exercise that activity in a prudent manner falls to each individual. Playing any game, RPG’s included, certainly bears a similar responsibility to each person to play in a moderate, reasonable fashion, exercising one’s judgement on what is right and what is wrong. These games do not inherently lend themselves to excesses such as seeking out the occult.

Now, I do think there’s something to be said for vicariously living out sinful desires through playing games like this. If one gets a certain thrill out of doing wrongful deeds within the game, that’s certainly worth considering as perhaps a sin of the mind. I’m just not sure that’s even something you could accurately judge from an outside perspective, though. Most of the ā€œsinsā€ in the game are used as tools for overcoming challenges presented in the course of an adventure. Does a person playing a thief character feel good about the act of stealing from one of the creatures they encounter during play, or is it merely the case that they use their thieving skills as a means to an end during play and feel good as a player for overcoming challenges using the proper methods of play for their character. I think the latter is the likeliest scenario for most people, as I doubt they’re truly ā€œgetting into characterā€ enough to truly derive pleasure from imagined sinful scenarios. I think that question is the more reasonable one to ask.

In fact, given how much attention is being put on the content of the fantastical worlds, let’s ask the same question about games that don’t have any fantasy elements to them. Is playing a game that recreates historical battles equally sinful because of its content? Does pretending to be a military commander, pretending to send troops to their historical deaths, give rise to questions of about catering to a lust for violence/mass-murder/warcrimes? Should I be burning my RISK boardgame?

Or if you want to address a similar issue, how would you approach people who take part in historical re-enactments, where they pretend to kill people on the fields of battle? They aren’t real soldiers, so how would you address people that are in it for the fun of pretending to shoot others?

For the record, I don’t think any of it necessarily amounts to sin when exercised in moderation. I think if you’re playing these games (RPG or otherwise) for fun and not for some twisted reveling in sinful desires, you’re pretty much in the clear. It seems to me that people mostly play games to overcome challenges present to them, and that the means by which those challenges are met (violence, magic, cunning, etc.) is rarely of concern to the player. This could be equally descriptive of video games, and even just fiction in general. I’m not sure where the line is (or if there even is one) between enjoying the challenge and reveling in the tools of its conquest. As game-players, it’s certainly worth considering.

Frankly, I’m finding entertainment in general to be rather tiring as of late. Trying to find unquestionably righteous amusements seems to get harder every day. I’m starting to think we should all just take up gardening and call it a day on the entertainment industry šŸ˜›
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top