Dear LZ2000,
Cordial greetings and a very good day. Thankyou for your contribution relating your experience.
Whilst D&D is not the actual occult of the real world, its resemblance to that world is quite disturbing and decidedly unsavoury. It is beyond me how those who profess the *holy *religion of Christ would wish to squander their time by playing a game that extols vice and denigrates virtue. Moreover, dear friend, who can say that the curosity of fallen man will never lead him to take an evil path, even if he does consider himself to be well-rounded and balanced. Let us remember that Satan and his forces have deeply invaded manās social and cultural structures and there is no reason to believe that RPGās have been omitted. Thus he will never cease to draw men into the world of darkness, by whatever means. It admits of no doubt that there is a very clear and present danger with D&D and the game cannot be regarded as harmless fantasy fun, for it can, at least for some people, be a pathway to the occultic subculture. Even one soul lost to the occult as a result of this unwholesome game is surely cause for Catholic concern. What if it was our own son or daughter who had been drawn into the occult?
There can, dear friend, be no doubt that the fantasy element of D&D is both very descriptive and realistic. Frequently this RPG treats of subject matter, which to the Catholic is either blasphemous or downright demonic and, as I said in the preceding paragraph, this is very disturbing, notwithstanding that it is fictional world. Fictional or not, it does not make the subject matter any less unsavoury and it is deeply saddening that some professing Catholics are unable to appreciate this. Alas, fantasy games such as D&D are the ones which deal with this dark subject matter the most, since they thrive on imagination and exaggeration of reality. It calls upon the players to allow themselves to mentally enter a fictional world where things are different than in reality and take pleasure in this world and believe in it. Those in the actual real world, view that sort of material as blasphemous and occultic, whereas your gamer would see it as perfectly natural in the context of the game, far removed from reality and their own beliefs respecting the occult. However, it must be asked to what extent can participating in this RPG over a long period of time desensitize a man to occultic influence, irrespective of the fact that he may be able to differentiate between fact and fiction? Now men may entertain differing opinions upon this, but I do think that there is legitimate concern that this game could well be a pathway to the occult, given its very dark subject matter.
Those who have spoken very favourably and positively of the game in this thread are unlikely to be convinced of any spiritual danger and will probably depict those who have grave concerns as naive in the extreme. They will ardently contend that such āgrave concernsā are based upon either ignorance or a cursory knowledge at best and spring from an inabilty to separate fact from reality. Whilst I would not deny that some *very *credulous people may have issues as regards distinguishing fact and fantasy, more often than not this is a disengenuous attempt to make a cheap debaterās point and discredit any opposition. Incidently, while it is true that some ultra-Fundamentalists have critiqued this RPG, it does not automatically follow that their critique must be wrong because they are Fundamentalists. That is irrational thinking for Fundamentalist Christians believe, in common with us Catholics, many of the cardinal verities of our most holy religion and are correct to that extent, at least. At any rate, the D&D game does present unsavoury material and subject matter for the player to become involved that is contrary to how they should be acting in the real world. A pious Catholic who is earnestly pursuing holiness in the fear of God, would hardly want to desire or pretend to be some evil or dark character. On the contrary, they would be pre-occupied with what is good, pure, lovely, noble and virtuous - even with respect to their leisure activities (see Phillip. 4: 8).
The acceptance and enthusiatic defence of this D&D game, as with the Harry Potter tales, evinces clearly the jolly poor state of catechesis within the contemporary Church. Men ought to be able to discern, unless they have a radically defective conscience, that this game resembles far too closely the real world of the occultic subculture, notwithstanding that it is a fictional world. That cannot surely be a good and wholesome thing.
God bless.
Warmest good wishes,
Portrait
Pax