D&D (Dungeons and Dragons)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ophelia23
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
👍 Clearly, something should be done about this.
OK–everyone who is actually interested in playing in a play-by-post format–follow this link:
Play Here.

Right now, the site’s a little screwy when you log in. Let me know if you have any issues w/ creating an account. I’m president of the group that runs the site, and I’ve got a tech person working on the scripting error, but let’s get a game on.
 
OK–everyone who is actually interested in playing in a play-by-post format–follow this link:
Play Here.

Right now, the site’s a little screwy when you log in. Let me know if you have any issues w/ creating an account. I’m president of the group that runs the site, and I’ve got a tech person working on the scripting error, but let’s get a game on.
Registered as Lochias. Game on! ~fwoooosh~
 
Whilst no player of D&D is actually using supernatural powers and it is a fanstasy world of pretend, the fact remains, dear friend, that they are mimicking powers that are denounced in Sacred Scripture in the real world. What is problematic and worrisome is that these powers resemble too closely the genuine evil powers of the occult and that, sir, is decidedly morally unhealthy and distasteful for those who profess the holy religion of Christ. Thus being able to distinguish fact from fanstasy is wholly irrelevant and therefore not germane to this debate.
Everyone, note the use of the word of ‘mimicking’.

Anyone who knows fantasy from fact will say that for Portrait’s statement to be true, it would in fact deny many Church teachings regarding the reality of the universe. The same goes for science.

The worlds of fantasy, even polytheistic ones are the first example. (And as a side note, I’d like to second the statement regarding the polytheism of Tolkien’s universe. Seems like Portrait is getting ever so closer to losing ground for NOT condemning the author.)

Christian theology presupposes the events of its own historicity as, at the very least, based on fact. Fantasy on the other hand presupposes that certain deities have long existed. At this point, it also clashes with science.

For Portrait’s parallelomania to remain consistent, he and the rest of the Anti-Fantasy League must prove how embracing Wicca or some obscure occult faith leads to:

Pyrokinesis
Cryokinesis
The ability to close wounds via some golden/green energy
Animating stone statues

Finally, they must prove why humanity hasn’t been taken over by such Satanically super-powered individuals without resort to:

Logically obscure conspiracy theories.
Proving the Richard Dawkin’s counter argument of the Pink Unicorn
Anything that makes our world look like I horrid cliche ripped out of a Chick tract.

P.S.

With that said, I’d like to take this chance to shamelessly broadcast a great, real-life achievement.

Behold! Teh fruit of my labors!!! ;w;

View attachment 14854
 
I used to play D&D and for the record do not believe it is intrinsically evil, but the above statement is false. Anyone who has read the Silmarillion knows the first chapter shows the creation of the world by Illuvatar, the only true deity. The Valar are angelic powers but they are creatures of Illuvatar.
:tiphat: drforjc & (name removed by moderator), I stand corrected good people. Alas, if only my knowledge of Tolkien’s works were the equal of my Trekkie knowledge.😊 I would point out however that my assertion about C.S. Lewis’ work still stands.
F.A.O. Baelor Unless our consciences are in harmony with God’s law and the moral sense of the faithful then their moral intuitions will necessarily be wrong and off beam.
The Church has not condemned D&D. You are stating your opinion on what constitutes ‘harmony’ with God’s law as doctrine.
Intent is inconsequential since the players of D&D are still pretending to use powers that are condemned by the word of God in the real world and that, as I have remarked in the preceding paragraph, is unbefitting for those who indentify as Catholics and Christians
All the faithful are called to a life of holiness (CCC 2013-2015) and that entails renouncing, inter alia, unworthy and ignoble pursuits or pastimes as these present a hindrance to the pursuit of sanctity and separation from the godless world. Thus, dear friend, the issue is not whether the Church allows for leisure time, it certainly does, but how that time is used.
So any Christian who portrays a roman centurion or member of the Sanhedrin in any number of reenactments of Christ’s Passion is sinning and in endanger of losing his soul?

I would agree with you that intent is inconsequential. I don’t doubt for an instance that your intent is pure. But I have to point out that your intent does not justify bearing false witness on message boards. An ignoble pursuit itself.
Moreover, dear friend, even if men are fully aware of the moral truth that is frequently conveyed in these films, they still, nonetheless, reinforce moral principles in the mind, which an unsavoury and amoral RPG like D&D will never do. Classic Westerns like Shane and High Noon could only be considered “bland and vacuous” in a morally bankrupt age like ours, dear friend. It is deeply saddening to hear a Catholic of all people talk in this manner about superior films of excellent character, free from innane humour, salacious content, gratuitous violence and downright evil. Surely it is a far better and morally healthy to watch these so called cliched films that at least reinforce moral virtues, than immerse oneself in the corrupt worlds of D&D and Potter, which hardly promotes moral health and aspirations after goodness.
I have to, once again, point out that not all classic westerns are paragons of moral virtue. I would point to the ‘Spaghetti’ Western, particularly Clint Eastwood’s portrayal of The Man With No Name. You might not consider it a classic, but cinema disagrees. Lumping anything, Westerns or rpg’s, in a single group and then passing judgement on that entire genre based on only a small subsection of that group is plain silly. If I were to employ your reasoning on the Church’s faithful, which subsection would I use to pass judgement? The saints and martyrs or the pedophile priest?
Let us not be too pedantic, dear friend, D&D is a world-view inasmuch as it presents an outlook that is undeniably anti-Christian and anti-Catholic.
Actually, D&D itself, in its original incarnation, presents no world view as such. It is a set of rules in which one can create any setting imaginable. In fact, one of my fellow players created a fantasy campaign that had everyone playing a faithful member of the Catholic Church. Does portraying a faithful man of God standing strong before the forces of evil in a fantasy setting really endanger my soul?
Indeed, each man must make a “determination” for himself but that does not rule out fraternal counsel and correction when that is called for, provided it is done in a charitable manner. Moreover, this may help a man to have a change of mind and aid him in his pursuit of holiness and the life of faith.
And so here I am, counseling you to reconsider attacking something you have limited understanding of as sinful. Your lack of comprehension does not automatically equate to sinfulness. See the quote in my last post. your attacks and the attacks of others like you make it very hard for those like me to fulfill our roles as missionaries amongst non-believing gaming companions. Your words drown out any attempt to serve as an example of Christ’s love. All my friends see when they look at my faith is your ignorance, when they should see God’s love for them.
may I just wish you and all other contributors to this thread a jolly splendid and relaxing weekend.

God bless you all.
Thank you. The sentiment is appreciated and returned in full.
 
Open invitation:
We’ve gotten things fixed so it’s not so wonky on the site.

Come over to PlayByWeb (it’s free)
Create a character (all you need is a name)
Next to the name, there’ll be a link “Request to Join” - click that
Click “AD&D” (rule set) --note, I use 2nd ed AD&D
Click “Accidental Adventurers” & fill out the questionnaire
Soon as I get it, I’ll add you.

I’d like to have at least 5-6 players to start, and I’ve got 1 so far.
 
Open invitation:
We’ve gotten things fixed so it’s not so wonky on the site.

Come over to PlayByWeb (it’s free)
Create a character (all you need is a name)
Next to the name, there’ll be a link “Request to Join” - click that
Click “AD&D” (rule set) --note, I use 2nd ed AD&D
Click “Accidental Adventurers” & fill out the questionnaire
Soon as I get it, I’ll add you.

I’d like to have at least 5-6 players to start, and I’ve got 1 so far.
Will you be posting session reports? I’m curious as to how this play by post business works.
 
Will you be posting session reports? I’m curious as to how this play by post business works.
Well, you could go to that site and look at Romaghnan Wanderers (also under the heading of AD&D). The numbered threads are the play threads.

Generally, we’ll try for a certain frequency of posting, but the best way to see what it’s like is to read an actual game.
 
I’m going to be running an old module (beaten up a little bit to fit the world where I have my other game set, although this is in a different part of the world, so there shouldn’t be paths crossing between the games) which starts with 0-level characters who haven’t yet achieved a character class.

Join, it’ll be fun!

I’ve got 2 players, and because it’s online and people have a tendency to drop out, I’ll go up to 8 players, hoping for a core of 5-6 players.
 
In light of this statement:
40.png
Portrait:
Thus being able to distinguish fact from fanstasy is wholly irrelevant and therefore not germane to this debate.
I will not respond to anything related to that statement to tighten up the argument. Note that I do not agree with that statement, but Portrait’s argument does not hold even when I make this concession.
However, if a man has a radically defective conscience then it is almost next to certain that he will make catastrophic errors of prudential judgment.
The Church requires us to use our conscience, which should be well-formed. In cases where the conscience can only lead all of us to one outcome if well-formed, the Church speaks explicitly on that issue, e.g. abortion, murder, idolatry, and so forth.
Thus a mind that is imbued with the spirit of the age is unlikely to see anything disquieting or unsavoury with D&D or the Potter series.
A well-formed conscience may feel the same way, since these activities are not sinful according to Catholic teaching.
Whilst no player of D&D is actually using supernatural powers and it is a fanstasy world of pretend, the fact remains, dear friend, that they are mimicking powers that are denounced in Sacred Scripture in the real world.
Which means that they are not actually attempting to use any real powers in the real world. I fail to see the issue. If I say, “I summon R’Hagdar, Lord of the Eternal Darkness and Slayer of Cockroaches,” are you going to make the claim that I actually, in real life, intend to summon this fictional being?
What is problematic and worrisome is that these powers resemble too closely the genuine evil powers of the occult and that, sir, is decidedly morally unhealthy and distasteful for those who profess the holy religion of Christ.
They resemble genuine evil powers in no way. Do you see physical and physically identifiable demons, ghouls, goblins, etc. roaming around? Perhaps you have ESP. Perhaps you are thinking of specific examples from D&D – please share. Furthermore, real magic is ritualistic; D&D is not.
the players of D&D are still pretending to use powers that are condemned by the word of God in the real world and that, as I have remarked in the preceding paragraph, is unbefitting for those who indentify as Catholics and Christians
Which means they are not actually using any real powers, so I fail to see how the mimicry is relevant.

Are you familiar with the party game Mafia? In it, two factions compete. The mafia is trying to eliminate the townspeople, and the townspeople are trying to eliminate the mafia members. The mafia “kills” townspeople, and the townspeople “lynch” someone each day. Your argument would state that this game is sinful because we are pretending to do something sinful. I can only hope you see why that is absurd – there is a difference between pretending and doing. Here, there is no intent whatsoever to actually kill anyone. In D&D, there is no intent to actually summon demons.
All the faithful are called to a life of holiness (CCC 2013-2015) and that entails renouncing, inter alia, unworthy and ignoble pursuits or pastimes as these present a hindrance to the pursuit of sanctity and separation from the godless world.
Fortunately, the Church does not dictate what pursuits those are.
reinforce moral principles in the mind, which an unsavoury and amoral RPG like D&D will never do.
This is not a requirement of art according to Catholic teaching.
It is deeply saddening to hear a Catholic of all people talk in this manner about superior films of excellent character,
Few of them are of any artistic merit. They are simplistic and banal, with a couple of exceptions.

Furthermore, the Church does not require art to reaffirm clear morality.
Surely it is a far better and morally healthy to watch these so called cliched films that at least reinforce moral virtues, than immerse oneself in the corrupt worlds of D&D and Potter, which hardly promotes moral health and aspirations after goodness.
First, you are not in a position to tell other people what benefits their moral health and aspirations for goodness. Second, the Church does not dictate the role or use of art to any specific degree.
Let us not be too pedantic, dear friend, D&D is a world-view inasmuch as it presents an outlook that is undeniably anti-Christian and anti-Catholic.
It has no outlook. The fact that you are unable to cite this world-view from a D&D manual is proof enough.

(cont.)
 
It cannot be neutral for it is either advancing truth and goodness and moral virtue or it is not; it is either appealing to what is good and noble in man or it is not.
This is untrue. The fact that I am eating an apple versus an orange is a morally neutral decision. Whether I prefer Bruce Springsteen or Frank Sinatra is similarly morally neutral. That I like Calvin and Hobbes more than Garfield is morally neutral. That I may play D&D over reading a particular book is also inherently morally neutral. In all cases, circumstances may affect this morality.

Furthermore, the Church does not teach that art must explicitly reaffirm moral values.
Your comparison with footwear is like comparing apples with oranges, dear friend.
In what way? It is much easier to insult other people and their arguments instead of actually addressing them.
Moreover, it is a puerile and wholly irrelevant comparison since shoes are a necessity to protect the feet, D&D is an optional past time.
So if shoes were optional, the fact that a few people are tempted by them is enough to prohibit them completely? I am afraid, Portrait, that you have painted yourself into a rather small corner. I assume that you will not answer, which will delight me as much as it will delight those others who rejoice in reason and Catholicity and reject anti-Catholic superstition and paranoia.

I think the outcome of this discussion is rather obvious. Not once have you mentioned anything specific from Catholic teaching that condemns D&D explicitly, not once have you even referenced any specifics from D&D. This is yet another rant against something permitted by the Catholic Church. I hope that you learn more about your faith to avoid these kinds of issues in the future.
 
Here’s a question.
Why is D&D and M:tG so confusing?
People give Jack Chick more credit than he’s due?
chick.com/reading/tracts/0046/0046_01.ASP

Seriously, it isn’t confusing. Its no more actual than its guns and ammo when you playing Cowboys and Indians.

Some people like to confuse the issue by reaping myths and lies about what DnD is.
These things fall under the concept of “opening the door”. It is the same concept Christ speaks about when he says “If you look at a woman lustfully you have already committed adultery”. It is not that most people who look at another lustfully will act on it, but all actions begin in the mind.
Okay, then you better get rid of your TV because you can show porn on it. You need to burn all your books because some people use them to incite lust. Dice, yeah they are evil cause people can gamble away all their money with them. Cards, people can play immodest games with them AND gamble way all their money, those must be doubly bad. Pool tables too, glad Prince Harry made as aware of that one …
The guiding question to ask is: “does this activity bring me closer to Christ or potentially farther away?” Spending hours reading about, meditating on and playing a fantasy game which uses the occult as a fundamental principle in the playing probably falls into the “farther away” category (No sarcasm intended).
I’m sorry, I missed where fiction and real world occult are all the same plane of existence.
If anything with things that even slightly resemble the occult make it a fundamental principle we better get rid of all Tolkien and CS Lewis.

Obviously, moderation is required for all things and if you are obsessing over ANYTHING its not helping you get to heaven. You can even take obsess over prayer to the point your ignoring your other duty’s in life, which fall in the “farther away” category too.
Realistically, all who are damaged by the occult go into it thinking they are not in danger. Whether the occult in a game, ghost hunters, ouji boards, reiki, etc… That’s how they enemy works… “It’s not dangerous… he says”. Sort of like “He didn’t really say not to eat the fruit from that tree…”
That’s not true. Plenty of people who got damaged by the occult did so knowing they were playing with fire, but the seduction of personal power pulled them.

Ouji boards and other such divination items are an issue expressly because you are trying to contact a being not of this world.

D&D has no relation to either if these things. Yes it has a few similar terms, so does the Bible.
Rhetorical question: Of those of you who use spells in the game: Who has never, not even once thought “what would it be like to be able to do that in real life?”. No one. Everyone one has had that thought, that’s why they play the game. That act, of wondering if it’s possible to actually do it, is the door being opened. All who play are contemplating the concept of using dark spiritual forces for harming another person, even if just a fantasy, thinking about using occult forces to hurt someone else is a problem spiritually speaking. Even if you have no intention of ever carrying it out.
You ever want a light saber? Were you afraid that by wanting a light saber you would open your self up to the spiritual force of the dark side?

You ever see a cool gun or sword an think you might like that. Weren’t you afraid you might be a serial killer?

Its the same logic.
The answer I gave was to the OP. For those of you who play, keep playing, enjoy it. I’ll stay away and suggest to those who ask to do the same.

PAX
The only people that have an issue with D&D place that belief on myth and lies. I know plenty of people that use D&D in perfectly health moral ways, including a few priests that play. D&D is really nothing other than a set of rules. Its your personal responsibility to use them morally. Just like cards can be used to cause sin. Blaming what “might” happen in D&D on the occult is no different that blaming people that use playing cards immoral on the occult because people can use cards for divination style readings.
 
That’s not true. Plenty of people who got damaged by the occult did so knowing they were playing with fire, but the seduction of personal power pulled them.

Ouji boards and other such divination items are an issue expressly because you are trying to contact a being not of this world.

D&D has no relation to either if these things. Yes it has a few similar terms, so does the Bible.
The power of the occult is only an illusion compared to anything the real world considers power. The day superstitions like divination and demon worship can actually summon threats worthy of an Iraq/Vietnam war-style reaction from the G8 is when I start taking types like ChurchSoldier just slightly seriously.
 
The power of the occult is only an illusion compared to anything the real world considers power. The day superstitions like divination and demon worship can actually summon threats worthy of an Iraq/Vietnam war-style reaction from the G8 is when I start taking types like ChurchSoldier just slightly seriously.
LOL I see what you did there 😉
 
LOL I see what you did there 😉
Meh, I’m actually neutral on those issues. 😛 I just think that if you want to tempt people with power these days, you’re better with cold cash, a dictatorship, or the resources to blow up a building any time you wanted.

Moving a piece of glass randomly over a piece of wood produces… nothing really. Call me utilitarian, heck call me Tony Stark when I say, “Hm, inefficient.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top