Dallas Public Library - No Internet Filter?

  • Thread starter Thread starter briang72
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

briang72

Guest
Parents of children in Dallas, are you filtering your child’s internet content? Well, now you might need to take their public library cards away from them.

Patrons viewing Internet porn on Dallas library computers

dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/latestnews/stories/011508dnmetlibraryporn.27bb24d.html
article:
During a 45-minute period on Dec. 19, for example, central library computer users accessed more than 5,200 Web pages containing identifiably pornographic material, such as photographs depicting full nudity, intercourse and other sex acts. That figure represents about 7.5 percent of the more than 69,000 Web pages accessed on the central library’s public computers during the time period studied.

With 26 public library branches throughout Dallas, the data suggest that tens of thousands of pornographic Web pages each day flash across the screens of public computers in plain view of any passer-by, from unflappable adults to impressionable children – who may freely access pornography themselves.
 
Are you saying you want filters on the internet because you think your kids might look at porn if you’re not breathing down their necks? Maybe you just phrased that one wrong!

Well, regardless I think the net at those places should be filtered b/c they are public. I’ve seen guys looking at gay stuff on public internet terminals before. Sick freaks.
 
Are you saying you want filters on the internet because you think your kids might look at porn if you’re not breathing down their necks? Maybe you just phrased that one wrong!
Where did you come up with this from what I posted?
40.png
briang72:
Parents of children in Dallas, are you filtering your child’s internet content? Well, now you might need to take their public library cards away from them.
The first sentence is just a question to concerned parents. Any well-informed parent knows that internet filtering is a MUST for their children. It doesn’t start from a lack of trust in your child, it should start from a lack of trust in the websites themselves. Children most likely don’t start viewing this kind of stuff on their own. It probably starts with associating with the wrong people online, or through advertising on websites that they go to all the time. It could even start with an innocent web search that lands them on a page cluttered with pornographic content.

The second sentence is a suggestion. I wouldn’t want my child strolling through the library past 20 public computers, where 2 of the screens have pornographic material on them. Taking away their library card can’t prohibit them from walking through, but it will stop them from sitting down at one of those computers and exploring a bit more.

This isn’t a lack-of-trust issue with a child as much as it is protecting their innocence. We aren’t talking about Huck Finn and Tom Sawyer here, we’re talking about pornography!
 
Our public library requires each patron to get a daily password and to log-in with their library card in order to use any of the library computers. There is a record of who was using each computer, and when, so if there is any abuse of privileges that person will be banned from using the computers in the future. This seems like a sensible approach.

As far as internet filters go, perhaps some filtered computers could be reserved for children. Our public library doesn’t do this, but maybe it is worth considering.
 
One of the public libraries I frequent has the computer rooms separated. Adults use the computers that are in the main library, children are restricted to the computers that are in the children’s library. Even with this, I am pretty sure there should be filters at most libraries, just so people aren’t trolling the net looking for porn for hours at a time.
 
I guess I don’t see a problem with people using library computers to look at porn. I mean, you can argue well why should you pay for that kind of access but then you’re paying for folks looking at lolcatz, info on the Brittany Spears debacle, tips for dieting, pro-anorexia sites, hypochondriacal medical sites, etc. And what is considered porn? Just images or erotic stories? Stories and photos about foot fetishes (which might not have anything titillating for non-fetish types)? It might be better to educate your child on why s/he shouldn’t look at such things or supervise them even at the library, rather than affecting all the other patrons.

As for accidentally looking at someone else’s screen and seeing naughty bits—custody of the eyes, my friend. Although I’ll agree, I’ve seen things that made me wish I could scrub by eyes (and mind) out with bleach, but that was just autopsy photos a detective as looking at (I’m going to say, I’d much rather look at a gay sex scene).
 
First, let me say that I am all for keeping porn away from children.

However, I would like to say that filtering can often be circumvented unless it is a “whitelist” system and those are rather restrictive because they only allow specifically approved sites. I personally know of a few ways to get around filtering off the top of my head. In fact, when I used to work at CompUSA, I got around their corporate filter with ease on a daily basis (not to access anything bad, mind you).

The best way to keep kids from looking at porn on the net at the library is for the librarians to monitor what is being viewed in some way. It is probably the only really effective way.
 
Every library should have an Internet filter appliance.

Since access to a porn site is limited to those over 18 the library can be liable if a child gains access.
 
The best way to keep kids from looking at porn on the net at the library is for the librarians to monitor what is being viewed in some way. It is probably the only really effective way.
I have to disagree. The best way to keep kids from looking at porn is for their parents to monitor what they are doing.

Parents are the ones who are responsible for raising their children and for setting the standards for what TV shows they watch, what books they read, what movies they view, and what Internet sites they visit.
 
I have to disagree. The best way to keep kids from looking at porn is for their parents to monitor what they are doing.

Parents are the ones who are responsible for raising their children and for setting the standards for what TV shows they watch, what books they read, what movies they view, and what Internet sites they visit.
I understand that parents should monitor their children… but you have to think about what you are saying here.

Are you suggesting that one should not allow one’s children to go to the public library by themselves? The library is supposed to be a place of education and culture which a parent can safely let their child visit.

Further, having the kind of constant watch on one’s children that would be required is not at all practical and would probably make the child resent it.

On the other hand, if the library simply monitors the histories of all internet access and suspends the access privileges of those who visit pornographic sites, it would effectively deal with the whole situation.
 
I was under the impression that most libraries did not filter internet content. That means that porn is freely available on library computers.

Usually, when patrons call for internet filters, library associations object on the basis that they are not in the business of censorship. Yet most libraries do not carry print or magazine porn material. So, you can’t get it in the stacks, but you can get it off the computer.
 
I was under the impression that most libraries did not filter internet content. That means that porn is freely available on library computers.

Usually, when patrons call for internet filters, library associations object on the basis that they are not in the business of censorship. Yet most libraries do not carry print or magazine porn material. So, you can’t get it in the stacks, but you can get it off the computer.
There are actually laws in some states that define the requirement to protect minors from such content in schools and libraries. But not for Texas:
linked article regarding state laws:
Prohibits a public school or public library that provides a computer used for Internet access from eligibility for a Texas Infrastructure Fund loan or grant unless the school or library adopts and implements an Internet safety policy protecting children from access to obscene materials.

Requires an interactive computer service provider to place a link to free or shareware filtering software conspicuously on the first accessible web page of the service provider. Provides for a civil penalty of $2,000 for each day that the provider fails to comply.
Here is a link to the Children’s Internet Protection Act as well.
 
There are actually laws in some states that define the requirement to protect minors from such content in schools and libraries. But not for Texas:

Here is a link to the Children’s Internet Protection Act as well.
Thanks for that information. I wonder how widespread and how effective such protective policies are with respect to public libraries.

It’s always bothered me that everything in a public library is subject to prior censorship–except the internet.

You can’t just put anything on the shelves, even if it’s donated. It has to get through the library selection committee.

But put the worlds largest collection of porn images and literature on a server somewhere in the world, connect the server to the internet, and you bypass all the library selection committees. You’re in! It seems like a double standard. Unless there is an effective way of applying the same criteria to the internet as is applied to all other library material.
 
Are you suggesting that one should not allow one’s children to go to the public library by themselves? The library is supposed to be a place of education and culture which a parent can safely let their child visit.
That’s precisely what I’m saying. The public library is no different from any other public place. Would you drop a young child off at the shopping mall and assume they’d be OK? The public library – open to anyone – is potentially as dangerous as any other public place.

Further, if you want control over what your children read or view, it’s up to you to monitor it. If that means watching over them at the library or the movie theater or your family room, then that’s what you need to do.
 
That’s precisely what I’m saying. The public library is no different from any other public place. Would you drop a young child off at the shopping mall and assume they’d be OK? The public library – open to anyone – is potentially as dangerous as any other public place.

Further, if you want control over what your children read or view, it’s up to you to monitor it. If that means watching over them at the library or the movie theater or your family room, then that’s what you need to do.
Exactly what age range are we talking about here? Because I am not talking about a “young” child really. They would probably be in their early teenage years if they are looking at porn anyway.

You don’t think it’s reasonable for a thirteen year old to go to their local library on their own? I guess it depends on where you live. But I would think you can leave someone that age at the library and it is reasonable to think that while they are there they would not be provided with smut.
 
But I would think you can leave someone that age at the library and it is reasonable to think that while they are there they would not be provided with smut.
I would hope that that expectation would be reasonable, but I’m not sure that it is in actuality. A kid can, after all, get smut off his own computer in his own bedroom. Will the libraries do a better job of preventing access to it?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top