Data center glitch is latest problem in 'Obamacare' rollout

  • Thread starter Thread starter markomalley
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

markomalley

Guest
From Reuters:
A data center critical for allowing uninsured Americans to buy health coverage under President Barack Obama’s healthcare law went down on Sunday, the U.S. government said, in the latest problem for the “Obamacare” rollout.

Verizon’s Terremark operates the data center behind a federal system for determining eligibility for government subsidies to buy insurance nationwide and hosts HealthCare.gov, the website that makes insurance available in 36 of the 50 states.

The data center experienced a failure on Sunday that led it to lose network connectivity, Health and Human Services Department spokeswoman Joanne Peters said.
Who set up this information system? The Keystone Cops?
 
From Reuters:
A data center critical for allowing uninsured Americans to buy health coverage under President Barack Obama’s healthcare law went down on Sunday, the U.S. government said, in the latest problem for the “Obamacare” rollout.

Verizon’s Terremark operates the data center behind a federal system for determining eligibility for government subsidies to buy insurance nationwide and hosts HealthCare.gov, the website that makes insurance available in 36 of the 50 states.

The data center experienced a failure on Sunday that led it to lose network connectivity, Health and Human Services Department spokeswoman Joanne Peters said.
Who set up this information system? The Keystone Cops?
In any project, be it government or otherwise, those who work on the project get to pick two out of three things: time, quality, or quantity. It is only possible to get two of these at once; if you try to get all three, one or more of them will crash.

The government has tried to get all three, and their quality has failed so badly that they are actually losing all three: the time to get this thing in motion is going to be multiplied by a large factor, the quality of the product (healthcare coverage) is minuscule or non-existent, and the quantity of Americans who are actually receiving and benefiting from this product is tiny.

And I’m glad.
 
It blows my mind how badly this was implemented. It’s as if they never tested the website.

I’m not glad it failed - it’s utterly embarrassing and even when the website is fixed it won’t fix other issues with the law. If anything, it will only delay our getting to those problems and seeing the pain of the insurance reforms because it delays folks from signing up for it. Thinking as a statistician here, we could easily have set up some kind of simulator (an agent-based model perhaps) to demonstrate impacts to spending habits, household budget health, employer reactions, etc, but there’s no such planning taking place with this law.

I like three things about the law: the intent for everyone to have affordable insurance; the lift on lifetime benefit caps ($1 Million doesn’t go far anymore for a serious condition); the end of penalizing sick folks for not being covered for a period of time. Otherwise, I don’t like the law, I don’t like the way that the insurance requirements have raised premiums at my company by 140% over the past 5 years, I don’t like that we’re now all on a “Wellness Credit” that means we have to keep within biometric profiles checked once per year or we get socked with a massive penalty. I don’t like that a good chunk of our company was let go and is now staffed with part-time contractors who work no more than 22 hours per week - that means I can talk to one person Monday and Tuesday and another Wednesday and Friday to get my project work done. I would love to walk Princess Nan through our offices and show her the empty desks and empty cubes and how the remaining folks are working 60+ hours/week, and they’re able to because they’re young. The layoffs here have suspiciously been of people over 50 for the most part, and new hires are almost exclusively under 25. It’s really atrocious but it reeks of moral turpitude in hiring. But health care costs are now an overriding concern in employment - that’s the essence of the reform.
 
I tried to sign-up late last week but was unable to do so. 🤷
 
In any project, be it government or otherwise, those who work on the project get to pick two out of three things: time, quality, or quantity. It is only possible to get two of these at once; if you try to get all three, one or more of them will crash.
👍 You sound like a very experienced techie. For forty years I tried that approach with management and it’s like management is taught differently and hears little of what you tell them. And if they don’t understand the realities, how can the customers? Or the politicians, in this application. Computers were intended to make life easier and faster. The downside is that errors can be generated just as quickly if not faster.
 
Looks like back to the old-fashioned way, the telephone and paper documents.
Or hopefully back to the old old-fashioned way before there was ObummerCare.
It deserves to be scrapped on the increase in abortions alone, not to mention forcing groups like Mother Angelica’s nuns to provide abortion coverage.
 
… not to mention forcing groups like Mother Angelica’s nuns to provide abortion coverage.
I thought all-Catholic groups were exempt from that mandate.

That said, I was reading in Bottom Line where small business employers need not worry about having someone in their group needing catastrophic coverage would raise the premiums for everyone in that group. Not that everything in the healthcare bill is good.
 
Then why is EWTN suing them?
You may be right but it doesn’t make sense.
in June 2013, the government finalized an exemption from the mandate for certain religious organizations, however, the exemption only applies to houses of worship, and not religious non-profit ministries, schools, hospitals or charities, nor does it apply to for-profit organizations run by religious persons.
 
You may be right but it doesn’t make sense.
The HHS secretary narrowly defined what a religious group is. A religious group can only hire religious people and cater to people of their own faith, like a church. A Catholic business or hospital does not qualify because they hire and minister to non Catholics.

That’s what the brouhaha is all about: leave your faith at the church door.
 
[/INDENT]Who set up this information system? The Keystone Cops?
What concerns me about this incident is that there was no fail-over. Its Verizon so I’m not surprised, but the government should have required a fail-over. The problem with using the private sector for public sector work is that private sector IT people, in my experience, prefer testing in production. No one wants to be responsible for a delay so the rollout proceeds without adequate testing. People can berate the government all they like, but the reality is that this is private sector work.
 
I thought all-Catholic groups were exempt from that mandate.

That said, I was reading in Bottom Line where small business employers need not worry about having someone in their group needing catastrophic coverage would raise the premiums for everyone in that group. Not that everything in the healthcare bill is good.
Catholic employer’s are not.
 
You may be right but it doesn’t make sense.
Because the final rule doesn’t include EWTN in its list of exempt organizations. The final HHS rule changed to requiring that an organization meet Section 6033(a)(3)(A) (i) or (iii) of the IRS code.

cms.gov/CCIIO/Resources/Fact-Sheets-and-FAQs/womens-preven-02012013.html

From 6033(a)(3)(A):

(i) churches, their integrated auxiliaries, and conventions or associations of churches,
(ii) any organization (other than a private foundation, as defined in section 509 (a)) described in subparagraph (C), the gross receipts of which in each taxable year are normally not more than $5,000, or
(iii) the exclusively religious activities of any religious order.

And EWTN is neither a church, an integrated auxiliary, convention or association of churches, nor a religious order.
 
What concerns me about this incident is that there was no fail-over. Its Verizon so I’m not surprised, but the government should have required a fail-over. The problem with using the private sector for public sector work is that private sector IT people, in my experience, prefer testing in production. No one wants to be responsible for a delay so the rollout proceeds without adequate testing. People can berate the government all they like, but the reality is that this is private sector work.
You are correct on both counts. (1) There should have been a back-out or recovery plan but there didn’t appear to be so. (2) The privates deserve much of the blame.

We actually used to joke about “testing in production” but sometimes there is no choice like there was in the y2k situation. Simulation for the most part isn’t enough.
 
So did I hear wrong, that all-Catholic groups aren’t exempt?
You may have.

The final rule, which was published last June talks about an accommodation made for religious employers. It defines a religious employer as one with the following characteristics:


  1. *]have the inculcation of religious values as its purpose;
    *]primarily employ persons who share its religious tenets; and
    *]primarily serve persons who share its religious tenets.

    Here’s the trick: the religious organization does not have to provide contraception or abortion coverage to its employees…if it is self-insured (obviously, an insurance company would be the administrator of the self-insurance plan). The insurance company administrator then would be required, by regulation, to provide abortion/contraception coverage to the women…without cost to the employer.

    The regulation states that either the third party plan administrator or the religious employer would have to provide notice of the availability of (separate) contraceptive coverage to the woman. And then the woman has to be given the opportunity to sign up.

    From the final regulation:Consistent with the simplified approach described previously, these final regulations provide that this notice must be provided by either the issuer providing separate payments for contraceptive services under the accommodation, or a third party administrator arranging or providing such payments (or its agent). The notice must be provided contemporaneous with (to the extent possible), but separate from, any application materials distributed in connection with enrollment (or re-enrollment) in coverage that is effective beginning on the first day of each plan year to which the accommodation applies, and it must indicate that the eligible organization does not fund or administer contraceptive benefits, but that the issuer or third party administrator will provide separate payments for contraceptive services at no cost.
    Here’s the fun part about this.

    Either the woman selecting the premium is going to have to mail a separate check to the actual administrator to cover her premiums for this service (in as much as there is no co-pay for contraceptives, but there is still a premium cost for the service) or the woman is going to have an additional pre-tax deduction taken out of her paycheck to cover the cost of the premiums. And the religious employer will know about the additional pre-tax deduction…whether they are involved in administering the plan or not.

    It’s a messed up scheme. Sure would have been a whole lot simpler to say that religious organizations and religiously-based non-profits are exempt from the requirement…but that would interfere with the administration’s agenda.
 
You are correct on both counts. (1) There should have been a back-out or recovery plan but there didn’t appear to be so. (2) The privates deserve much of the blame.

We actually used to joke about “testing in production” but sometimes there is no choice like there was in the y2k situation. Simulation for the most part isn’t enough.
Testing in production is a running joke where I work as well. Still, you make a valid point in that simulation is not enough. Still, I’m surprised that a project as large as this one wasn’t delivered in phases rather than trying to cobble everything together in a single release.
 
The problem with using the private sector for public sector work is that private sector IT people, in my experience, prefer testing in production.
I work in software development. I don’t know what people you have worked with, but every single employer I have ever worked with and worked for abhors the idea of “testing in production.” It is expensive and extremely embarrassing. It is a well known maxim in software development that the later in the development cycle a defect is found, the more expensive it is to fix it. And no developer ever wants to spend more than they have to.

In my experience, it is the client that prefers testing in production, not the developer. More below.
No one wants to be responsible for a delay so the rollout proceeds without adequate testing.
I worked for several years at a company that developed products 3rd parties. A guy comes in, thinks he has the next great idea, and we turned it into a product. We would quote them for design, implementation, and testing. When they saw the amount of money they’d have to spend on testing (usually somewhere between 50% to 66% of the total cost), they would balk. We’d explain to them that it was extremely important that the product be thoroughly tested before it was made available to the public.

They would say things like “Why do you need so much testing? Are you guys not good at what you do?” Or “We can live with a few bugs, how far can we whittle down those hours and only have a few we can work out later?”

And in all those years working with clients, only 1 agreed to the total cost. The other pushed for much less testing before release. And inevitably, those client would come back to us and ask us to fix the issues found post-release. And it would cost more.

Our VP of engineering during an internal meeting presented a post-mortem of the last several projects we had done. He compared the amount of money a company spent on testing if testing was done pre-release (only 1 sample) and post-release. The pre-release testing cost was a fraction (as a percentage of overall cost) of the post-release fixes/testing. And this became new data to use when selling to clients the need for testing pre-release.
People can berate the government all they like, but the reality is that this is private sector work.
In this case, the government is the client. And in my experience, it is the client that pushes for testing in production. I don’t doubt the government pushed for releasing on schedule, and overrode objections from the developers about the need for more testing. And I’d bet a $100 that the developers told the government they shouldn’t go live until the testing was done.

It doesn’t matter if it is private sector work or public sector work. In both cases the government is the client. And the client wanted schedule over quality. And, like most clients who do this, they get neither schedule nor quality.
 
Testing in production is a running joke where I work as well. Still, you make a valid point in that simulation is not enough. Still, I’m surprised that a project as large as this one wasn’t delivered in phases rather than trying to cobble everything together in a single release.
One of the big mistakes companies still make IMO is to translate everything into man-hours. One who isn’t too brilliant won’t see the difference between hiring one individual for a 365-day project and hiring 365 programmers to do it in one day. From the hearings they only had a month or two to get all the testing done. That part wasn’t thought out too well either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top