Death Pathways

  • Thread starter Thread starter marci
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
False. People do recover from dementia. My grandma had it just recently and in a few weeks she was cured. She also revealed some pretty, awkward stuff but I don’t want to go into too much detail.
An isolated case is not compelling. A simple walk through the local extended care facilities in my area would quickly demonstrate that few, if any, people recover from dementia/Alzheimers…the others are more obvious.

The 800 pound gorilla of the healthcare debate is precisely along these lines…when do you stop attempting to heal and move to end-of-life care? We will have to confront these issues if we are ever to effectively manage health costs.

John
 
An isolated case is not compelling. A simple walk through the local extended care facilities in my area would quickly demonstrate that few, if any, people recover from dementia/Alzheimers…the others are more obvious.

The 800 pound gorilla of the healthcare debate is precisely along these lines…when do you stop attempting to heal and move to end-of-life care? We will have to confront these issues if we are ever to effectively manage health costs.

John
I have never seen anyone ‘recover’ from dementia and I work with this population. It is a chronic, progressive, disabling and ultimately fatal condition. I suspect that if the other poster’s grandmother appeared to recover from dementia, it’s more likely that she was experiencing dementia-like symptoms that improved when an underlying condition was treated or resolved.

People with dementia often have a worsening of their dementia when they have other health problems and the dementia can appear to improve when their other health problems improve. There are types of dementia that progress rapidly but more often it happens slowly, over decades in some cases. Dementia is ultimately a fatal condition although many people do die of other causes in the meantime.

I think we need to take a common sense approach to dementia in order to maintain function and quality of life for as long as possible, and provide supportive care when the end is inevitable.

I love working with people with dementia but what I don’t like seeing are family members who insist that CPR be done on a 95 year old with advanced dementia who can longer move, speak, swallow, or understand what is going on around them. When a person like this stops breathing or their heart stops, I believe that is natural death, not an unexpected occurrence that requires admission to the intensive care unit with death a couple of days later despite aggressive but futile treatment. It’s far more likely that CPR will not be effective anyway and the person dies at the time anyway except that they die with someone breaking their ribs or forcing a tube down their throat in an attempt to get their heart beating again. That doesn’t make any sense to me.

There’s a lot of grey areas of course. Should we attempt to cure an overwhelming infection in the 95 year old mentioned above if this means admission to ICU and multiple IVs and other interventions or do we give an antibiotic, fluids, and other supportive care? Do we treat say bowel cancer if we find it even if the person would likely not survive the treatment and the treatment is going to be painful and distressing or do we instead treat any symptoms that the cancer is causing? Does it change if the person is 75 or 85 instead of 95? Should the cost of treatment influence the decision?

I think “it all depends” and it’s probably going to be different in each case but as a general rule, for myself, I don’t want anything out of the ordinary done. Keep me comfortable, treat me if it’s likely to be of some benefit, but don’t start doing things that are probably futile just because of an outside chance that I may live a couple of days, weeks, or months longer.
 
I have never seen anyone ‘recover’ from dementia and I work with this population. It is a chronic, progressive, disabling and ultimately fatal condition. I suspect that if the other poster’s grandmother appeared to recover from dementia, it’s more likely that she was experiencing dementia-like symptoms that improved when an underlying condition was treated or resolved.

People with dementia often have a worsening of their dementia when they have other health problems and the dementia can appear to improve when their other health problems improve. There are types of dementia that progress rapidly but more often it happens slowly, over decades in some cases. Dementia is ultimately a fatal condition although many people do die of other causes in the meantime.

I think we need to take a common sense approach to dementia in order to maintain function and quality of life for as long as possible, and provide supportive care when the end is inevitable.

I love working with people with dementia but what I don’t like seeing are family members who insist that CPR be done on a 95 year old with advanced dementia who can longer move, speak, swallow, or understand what is going on around them. When a person like this stops breathing or their heart stops, I believe that is natural death, not an unexpected occurrence that requires admission to the intensive care unit with death a couple of days later despite aggressive but futile treatment. It’s far more likely that CPR will not be effective anyway and the person dies at the time anyway except that they die with someone breaking their ribs or forcing a tube down their throat in an attempt to get their heart beating again. That doesn’t make any sense to me.

There’s a lot of grey areas of course. Should we attempt to cure an overwhelming infection in the 95 year old mentioned above if this means admission to ICU and multiple IVs and other interventions or do we give an antibiotic, fluids, and other supportive care? Do we treat say bowel cancer if we find it even if the person would likely not survive the treatment and the treatment is going to be painful and distressing or do we instead treat any symptoms that the cancer is causing? Does it change if the person is 75 or 85 instead of 95? Should the cost of treatment influence the decision?

I think “it all depends” and it’s probably going to be different in each case but as a general rule, for myself, I don’t want anything out of the ordinary done. Keep me comfortable, treat me if it’s likely to be of some benefit, but don’t start doing things that are probably futile just because of an outside chance that I may live a couple of days, weeks, or months longer.
You have summed up my feelings and conflicts very well…thank you. These are issues that must be dealt with, as uncomfortable as that may be.

John
 
Emphasis mine. You’re still arguing against a strawman. The intention is to not delay the inevitable; to not needlessly prolong the act of dying.

When JPII had his feeding tube removed, was he, his medical advisers or all parties acting immorally? JPII isn’t “the church”.

Within the context of the conditions I’ve been discussing, if those were my wishes, I’d say “Thanks”

If you can’t imagine a situation where the quality of life and/or the prospects for life are so diminished that death would be preferable, then you would seem to either lack imagination or experience. In any case, I’m finished dealing with your invective.
John Paul II had his feeding tube removed? I had no idea! Oh wait, no he didn’t: nytimes.com/2007/09/27/world/europe/27iht-27pope.7658856.html Congratulations on doing research. Really, congratulations you empty idiot.

Also, you ignored the point that a lot of the people those doctors killed would have still been alive today if they were taken care of properly as a lot fo them still do. Delaying the inevitable just because someone is dying from cancer for example is like saying that we should still give up on life because we’ll all eventually die. You may not think that but ultimately thats what your argument amounts to because people should prolong their lvies as much as possible in the hope that they may recover one way or another and not waste their life.

And what if those weren’t your wishes? Did those babies voice their wish to die? They didn’t, they’re flipping babies.

Of course I can imagine a situation in life where someone falls into utter despair (use english please) that he wants to die. I pass through it all the time. Yet no matter how beat up we humans are, we always rise up and fight back. If we don’t, it’s not humanity who is at fault, it’s a few select individuals. It’s better to face your problems like a man than to throw up your arms and give up on life like a coward.
 
An isolated case is not compelling. A simple walk through the local extended care facilities in my area would quickly demonstrate that few, if any, people recover from dementia/Alzheimers…the others are more obvious.

The 800 pound gorilla of the healthcare debate is precisely along these lines…when do you stop attempting to heal and move to end-of-life care? We will have to confront these issues if we are ever to effectively manage health costs.

John
As I said a billion times, there is a diffirence between end of life care which is good and refusing nutrition in order to kill people. That is bad. Life should always be prolonged.
 
I have never seen anyone ‘recover’ from dementia and I work with this population. It is a chronic, progressive, disabling and ultimately fatal condition. I suspect that if the other poster’s grandmother appeared to recover from dementia, it’s more likely that she was experiencing dementia-like symptoms that improved when an underlying condition was treated or resolved.

People with dementia often have a worsening of their dementia when they have other health problems and the dementia can appear to improve when their other health problems improve. There are types of dementia that progress rapidly but more often it happens slowly, over decades in some cases. Dementia is ultimately a fatal condition although many people do die of other causes in the meantime.

I think we need to take a common sense approach to dementia in order to maintain function and quality of life for as long as possible, and provide supportive care when the end is inevitable.

I love working with people with dementia but what I don’t like seeing are family members who insist that CPR be done on a 95 year old with advanced dementia who can longer move, speak, swallow, or understand what is going on around them. When a person like this stops breathing or their heart stops, I believe that is natural death, not an unexpected occurrence that requires admission to the intensive care unit with death a couple of days later despite aggressive but futile treatment. It’s far more likely that CPR will not be effective anyway and the person dies at the time anyway except that they die with someone breaking their ribs or forcing a tube down their throat in an attempt to get their heart beating again. That doesn’t make any sense to me.

There’s a lot of grey areas of course. Should we attempt to cure an overwhelming infection in the 95 year old mentioned above if this means admission to ICU and multiple IVs and other interventions or do we give an antibiotic, fluids, and other supportive care? Do we treat say bowel cancer if we find it even if the person would likely not survive the treatment and the treatment is going to be painful and distressing or do we instead treat any symptoms that the cancer is causing? Does it change if the person is 75 or 85 instead of 95? Should the cost of treatment influence the decision?

I think “it all depends” and it’s probably going to be different in each case but as a general rule, for myself, I don’t want anything out of the ordinary done. Keep me comfortable, treat me if it’s likely to be of some benefit, but don’t start doing things that are probably futile just because of an outside chance that I may live a couple of days, weeks, or months longer.
I agree with your post. Theres a diffirence between natural death and murder, just as there is a diffirence between treating a patient and recklessness. Its a pity those doctors in lvierpool didn’t recognize that.
 
MODERATOR NOTICE

The charity on this thread is digressing. Please charitably discuss the issues and not each other. Please refrain from name calling
 
If the children were taken off the pathway, then apparently the doctors changed their prognosis. If the doctors later felt that the individual’s chance of survival had increased to the point where being on the pathway was no longer an ethical choice, then the doctors should resume treatment.
This is confusing. How does withholding food and water improve a person’s chance of recovery? I fail to see how a lack of nutrition and hydration can lead to a better prognosis.
 
This is confusing. How does withholding food and water improve a person’s chance of recovery? I fail to see how a lack of nutrition and hydration can lead to a better prognosis.
I don’t suppose that a lack of nutrition and hydration can lead to a better prognosis but people’s conditions do improve and when that happens, the situation is (or should be) always reassessed. Sometimes people actually improve when aggressive treatment, interventions, and medications are reduced or stopped. Sometimes people are temporarily unable to tolerate artificial feeding and so it is stopped but if they then begin to improve, it would be started again, usually cautiously and in small amounts at first to make sure their body actually can tolerate it.

Palliative care pathways are guidelines for providing quality care for people who are dying, they’re not rigid rules. Palliative care pathways or guidelines don’t say that hydration and nutrition should be discontinued, they suggest that the benefit to the patient needs to be assessed, and that for some people this means that it would be commenced, for some it would be continued and for some it would be discontinued. The Church does not require artificial nutrition and hydration when the dying person is no longer able to tolerate it.
 
Mother Teresa said,“Any country that accepts abortion, is not teaching its people to love, but to use any violence to get what it wants”.
I can only imagine what she would have to say about allowing a baby (or anyone) to starve to death on purpose.
What kind of a world do we live in?
The kind of world where you would be thrown in prison for doing the same thing to an animal.
(An rightly so)
 
Going back to the original post about death pathways for babies…This article was taken from the British newspaper The Daily Mail which is notorious for it’s misrepresentation of the truth!
PLEASE read the Oxford University medical ethics web-page to see how a few half quotes, taken out of context and with a few extra bits surreptitiously added can totally distort the truth. Sadly this style of reporting is a common phenomenon these days for newspapers that want to boost their sales and for various groups that want to discredit their opponents. I’ve learnt that we HAVE to check the sources!!
blog.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/2012/11/the-liverpool-care-pathway-in-the-news-even-by-the-mails-standards-this-is-low/
 
theblaze.com/stories/uk-doctors-horrifying-admission-reveals-how-sick-disabled-babies-are-put-on-death-pathways-deprived-of-food-fluid-for-10-days/

HEALTH
UK DOCTOR’S HORRIFYING ADMISSION REVEALS HOW SICK & DISABLED BABIES ARE PUT ON ‘DEATH PATHWAYS’, DEPRIVED OF FOOD & FLUID FOR 10 DAYS
I cannot believe such things happen even among wild tribes or even animals in our times.

Sadly, very few doctors in the world are real doctors who save lives, rest such as these are just a bunch certificates with a pretext. Can these instruments or messengers of death be even called human? Their level is lower than a rabid mad dog.

They are not killing babies, but killing God from their lives, a willful spiritual death of their own souls if they only understood. I wouldn’t be surprised if these certified murderers are satanists practicing their rites under different medical excuses.
 
I cannot believe such things happen even among wild tribes or even animals in our times.

Sadly, very few doctors in the world are real doctors who save lives, rest such as these are just a bunch certificates with a pretext. Can these instruments or messengers of death be even called human? Their level is lower than a rabid mad dog.

They are not killing babies, but killing God from their lives, a willful spiritual death of their own souls if they only understood. I wouldn’t be surprised if these certified murderers are satanists practicing their rites under different medical excuses.
As I said - this article in the Daily Mail IS NOT TRUE! Please don’t be taken in by this sensationalist mish-mash of misleading half truths.
I am not discussing abortion here…I am pointing out that our British doctors do not behave in this inhuman way with sick young babies that the article would have you believe…PLEASE check on the Oxford University website.
 
I’m sure I’ll be corrected if I’m mistaken, but I thought the RCC permitted a terminally ill patient to refuse nutrition and hydration if their death was considered immanent. If that’s true, then by extension, couldn’t parents also make that decision for a newborn under the same circumstances?
As others have already said, no, this isn’t true.
Food and water must be offered and available, but the patient cannot be forced to receive them, and no invasive procedures should be administered to “make” them eat and drink. Deprivation of food and water must not be done for the primary purpose of causing death, either. This was the difference between Terry Schiavo and Pope John Paul II. Terry was denied food and water in order to kill her. Blessed JP2 got to the point where food or water would no longer delay the inevitable.
My own mother had a feeding tube. We regularly fed her through it.

As her health deteriorated her stomach processed less and less. The day before her death, when drawing back on the tube, we could tell that her stomach wasn’t empty. Her body was no longer processing anything. To put food into the tube would have been medically wrong. There was no where for it to go and I am sure it would have caused my mother undue harm.

Food and water were available, but death was immanent. Her body no longer needed nourishment. 😦
 
As others have already said, no, this isn’t true.

My own mother had a feeding tube. We regularly fed her through it.

As her health deteriorated her stomach processed less and less. The day before her death, when drawing back on the tube, we could tell that her stomach wasn’t empty. Her body was no longer processing anything. To put food into the tube would have been medically wrong. There was no where for it to go and I am sure it would have caused my mother undue harm.

Food and water were available, but death was immanent. Her body no longer needed nourishment. 😦
I’m sorry for your mother. But, and really, really forgive me if I am going to sound insensitive or cruel here but something like that is natural. Pope Leo XIII died by choking because of old age. It’s natural. But this wasn’t the case for babies and the other old people who were killed in that hospital. They could have been saved but weren’t because somebody didn’t want to save them not because death was immanent.
 
I’m sorry for your mother. But, and really, really forgive me if I am going to sound insensitive or cruel here but something like that is natural. Pope Leo XIII died by choking because of old age. It’s natural. But this wasn’t the case for babies and the other old people who were killed in that hospital. They could have been saved but weren’t because somebody didn’t want to save them not because death was immanent.
Oh, no, not insensitive at all.

My mother’s death was entirely natural. And how it should be. Her body decided when to stop “eating.” That decision wasn’t made by doctors or caregivers.

It is inconceivable to me how someone could “withhold” food from a patient, baby or adult. Their body will tell you when it is through, you don’t need to push it along.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top