I have never seen anyone ‘recover’ from dementia and I work with this population. It is a chronic, progressive, disabling and ultimately fatal condition. I suspect that if the other poster’s grandmother appeared to recover from dementia, it’s more likely that she was experiencing dementia-like symptoms that improved when an underlying condition was treated or resolved.
People with dementia often have a worsening of their dementia when they have other health problems and the dementia can appear to improve when their other health problems improve. There are types of dementia that progress rapidly but more often it happens slowly, over decades in some cases. Dementia is ultimately a fatal condition although many people do die of other causes in the meantime.
I think we need to take a common sense approach to dementia in order to maintain function and quality of life for as long as possible, and provide supportive care when the end is inevitable.
I love working with people with dementia but what I don’t like seeing are family members who insist that CPR be done on a 95 year old with advanced dementia who can longer move, speak, swallow, or understand what is going on around them. When a person like this stops breathing or their heart stops, I believe that is natural death, not an unexpected occurrence that requires admission to the intensive care unit with death a couple of days later despite aggressive but futile treatment. It’s far more likely that CPR will not be effective anyway and the person dies at the time anyway except that they die with someone breaking their ribs or forcing a tube down their throat in an attempt to get their heart beating again. That doesn’t make any sense to me.
There’s a lot of grey areas of course. Should we attempt to cure an overwhelming infection in the 95 year old mentioned above if this means admission to ICU and multiple IVs and other interventions or do we give an antibiotic, fluids, and other supportive care? Do we treat say bowel cancer if we find it even if the person would likely not survive the treatment and the treatment is going to be painful and distressing or do we instead treat any symptoms that the cancer is causing? Does it change if the person is 75 or 85 instead of 95? Should the cost of treatment influence the decision?
I think “it all depends” and it’s probably going to be different in each case but as a general rule, for myself, I don’t want anything out of the ordinary done. Keep me comfortable, treat me if it’s likely to be of some benefit, but don’t start doing things that are probably futile just because of an outside chance that I may live a couple of days, weeks, or months longer.