Defending my decision to convert

  • Thread starter Thread starter HeatherWB
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Welcome to the Catholic Church!

If you don’t want to talk to the “elders” of your old church, that’s fine, but I suggest that if they do come over, you keep it short and simple and not let them “camp” on you, meaning they try to keep talking/arguing with you until you wear out and give in.

If, when you tell them you’re done talking and they don’t leave, then you leave the house yourself.
 
It’s odd how things play out…

Thursday before last, my FIL was working in the yard, fell, and broke his hip and had to have an emergency hip replacement a couple of days later. Due to some other complications that came up after the surgery, he remains in the hospital and there’s no telling how much longer he’ll be there.

Needless to say, the hubs’ attention has shifted to dealing with that. When he’s not working or sleeping, most of his time is spent at the hospital. Obviously, I’ve been given a reprieve and don’t plan on bringing it up again until after this crisis has passed.
 
It’s odd how things play out…

Thursday before last, my FIL was working in the yard, fell, and broke his hip and had to have an emergency hip replacement a couple of days later. Due to some other complications that came up after the surgery, he remains in the hospital and there’s no telling how much longer he’ll be there.

Needless to say, the hubs’ attention has shifted to dealing with that. When he’s not working or sleeping, most of his time is spent at the hospital. Obviously, I’ve been given a reprieve and don’t plan on bringing it up again until after this crisis has passed.
Prayers for your FIL
 
He has made it clear that he will not participate in any of it with me and that would include reading anything pro-Catholic that I might give him.
.
Hi,
Welcome into the Church Jesus started.
I think you were wise to postpone the meeting. It would have been unfair in that several so called experts of their view would have been teamed up against you. Even a very well trained Catholic apologist would have a hard time with that. Two, or three heads are better than one. The psychological dynamic in that situation is unfair to you. It is not unlikely that they will come with a closed mind. And they will come thinking that you have nothing to teach them, so they will feel free, and maybe duty bound to interrupt you at every chance, and change the subject just as you are making a good point because “they know everything and you – in their mind – know nothing.”

If you do agree to a meeting in the future, I suggest you ask if an equal number of knowledgeable Catholics also attend to assist you. Their assistance will be valuable, not in making them become Catholic, but just in explaining what Catholics really believe. Most likely, if Catholics really believed what they think Catholics believed everyone on this list would not be Catholic either.

Many non-Catholics believe that the doctrines on Mary take away from the Glory due to God.

I suggest you pray about considering sharing this with your husband
(but not the parenthesis sections.)

Your love for your husband and his for you is a good thing. It is not perfect because we are not perfect. But it is good.

Why is it good?
There is only one reason why. It is because God’s grace works through us enabling us to love others. If it was not good, and / or not the working of God’s grace it would be pointless to try to love anyone as the result is useless at best, or the equivalence of hatred at the worst.
Point here is that God’s grace does work through us and molds our character if we are open to it.

(God’s grace is not just some external covering of a heap of manure as Martin Luther believed.)

Why do we honor Mary and the doctrines about her?
This practice and those doctrines about Mary give glory to God.

For example :
It offends God to deny Mary’s perpetual virginity.

( We know this for various reasons. The shortest explanation is because our Lady of Fatima asked the children to make sacrifices for those who sin in this way. No sacrifices would have been asked for if it was not a sin. – Our sacrifices, just as we daily do to help others, needs to be understood as a participation in the One Sacrifice of Jesus Christ.
Colossians 1:24

His Sacrifice won the grace for us to make our sacrifices done in Him and by that help good and beneficial to others.

The denial of Mary’s virginity is also a rejection of the Church’s teaching authority given to her by Jesus Christ.)

How does this denial offend God?
God is a Master Artist.
His greatest work is in our hearts and souls is to make us good people.
The donkey that Jesus rode into Jerusalem had never been ridden before.
Why? It points to Jesus being special.
Mary’s perpetual virginity also points to Jesus being special.
Jesus has exercised his power in changing our lives. He also changed Mary’s life
from the beginning of her Immaculate Conception.

If we deny this work of God, we deny giving to Him the credit He deserves.

God is a God of Love. His relationship with Mary - and all the rest of us -
can only be understood from that perspective. Jesus loves Mary. We imitate Him. And no matter how much we love her, we will never love her as much as He does.

Also see

defendingthebride.com/ma3/only11.html

I hope this helps,
John
 
Recently, I started RCIA classes and I’m really excited about the whole process. Unfortunately, my husband doesn’t share my enthusiasm. We’ve both been active in a Protestant church (Church of Christ) for many years. My husband intends on staying there and I’m OK with that and don’t hold anything against him for it.

Originally we had agreed that I would be the one to let the church know of my departure. He comes home from church today and announces that one of the elders and his wife want to come to our house one night this week to talk about this. The cat is out of the bag. :mad: The husband announced that he had joined one of the church’s small groups and he will resume attending Wednesday night Bible study.

I don’t want to be rude, but frankly I’m not interested in talking to anybody, particularly if I suspect that they want to feed me a bunch of anti-Catholic babble. They don’t have to agree with my decision, but they need to respect my right to make decisions in my own best interest.

Any (name removed by moderator)ut would be much appreciated.
You and your husband are in my Prayers and I am so sorry to hear about your FIL. He is in my Prayers as well.

I can’t help to mention this but your story kind of reminds me of Servant of God, Cora Louise Evans

parishretreat.org/index.php?id=story

Just click on the left hand side where it states remarkable story and keep on clicking down from there to go to the next page.

God bless you,

goforgoal
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top