Dictionaries & Grammar books Biblical times?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jim_Baur
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Jim_Baur

Guest
Where there dictionaries of Hebrew in B. C. E. eras?

Where there grammar books for written Hebrew in B. C. E. eras?

Also, New Testament Greek dictionaries in the first century C. E.?

Were there grammar books in the first century C. E.?

If so, how developed were those dictionaries and grammars?
 
I don’t know of any, but it sure would be nice! The other option to understand the anicent language through the eyes of the ancients would firs, with the Hebrew, is to compare the Hebrew with the ancient translators such as the Septuagint translators, Aquila, Symmachus, Theodotian, and St. Jerome, etc. Also ancient interinears such as the Complutenisan Polyglot, ancient translations such as the Old Latin, and commentaries from the Church Fathers who spoke the languages.

The oldest Greek lexicon and gramar book is from the 1500’s, and you can see it all here books.google.com/books?id=A0k8AAAAcAAJ&dq=Lexicon+Graecolatinum&printsec=frontcover&source=bl&ots=LUIzXOidrs&sig=zmwoBTFEPInus-ELBS7k4U8NcVE&hl=en&ei=9Su4SorDIYH2sQOp69En&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2#v=onepage&q=&f=true
 
Where there dictionaries of Hebrew in B. C. E. eras?

Where there grammar books for written Hebrew in B. C. E. eras?

Also, New Testament Greek dictionaries in the first century C. E.?

Were there grammar books in the first century C. E.?

If so, how developed were those dictionaries and grammars?
Consider the difference between a modern Catholic parish and a Jewish community in B.C. years (or even in more modern times). We build the church first, then build the school. Jews traditionally build the school first, then the church. The reason for that, particularly in BC days, was because the written Hebrew language of scripture contains no vowels, punctuation, capitals, etc. and those schools were considered vitally important to keep the oral tradition alive.

If we did that to Exodus 20:2 in English, it would look like this:

mthlrdthgdwhbrghtthtfthlndfgpttfthhsfbndg. (<-- don’t know why the space is there)

So how do we ensure the last word, those last four letters, are rendered “bondage” and not "bandage? Well, the Jews taught this father-to-son, generation to generation, in a rich oral tradition. They taught each successive generation how to render the text, where the breaks in words are, what sounds were supposed to come out of each syllable, etc. Some words weren’t even considered certain by scholars until the Massoretic texts were discovered. These were texts kept by a particular sect of Judaism where they used a series of dots (marks) around the letters of text to indicate what exact vowel sound went where. Here’s a Wiki article on the text

So the answer to your questions are, no, there was no written pronunciation guides or dictionaries in that era.
 
DOSHEA

And

COPLAND 3

THANKS!!!

COPLAND 3
If you have the time, energy and love, what is the difference between Kingdom of God and Kingdom of Heaven in the Fathers (is there a difference)?

Also, what is your personal judgment based on your scholarship? Thanks

THANKS to any wonderful person who might answer, thanks!
 
DOSHEA

And

COPLAND 3

THANKS!!!

COPLAND 3
If you have the time, energy and love, what is the difference between Kingdom of God and Kingdom of Heaven in the Fathers (is there a difference)?

Also, what is your personal judgment based on your scholarship? Thanks

THANKS to any wonderful person who might answer, thanks!
Perhaps the most important source to consult is the Catechism, which uses both terms synonymously. I imagine that the Fathers have kicked this around, and I will look into because that has got me curious as well. Aquinas probably has discussed it, which would be worth looking into.

I will get back to this!
 
COPLAND 3

You have helped me in the past. I hoped that you would come through again, thanks!

I have read a great deal, but you are most gifted in these areas.

I have tried to look this up, but just do not have the talent that you do.

THANKS
 
COPLAND 3

I am praying that you come up with some good ideas on Kingdom of God and Heaven.

I think I read in Origen some things about it, but I could not find it, sorry!

God Bless,

Jim Baur
 
I’ll give it a good looking into soon, I have not had time today, hopefully tomorrow!
 
COPLAND 3

Thanks!

If you have the time any energy, tell me once again how you go about doing your research.

Thanks!
 
Jim,

As for looking for those quotes I just found, all I did was use the word search tool on my site to find where in the Bible that has Kingdom of Heaven and Kingdom of God were, and then I chose some of the passages and then checked what some of the commentaries of the Church Fathers to see what they say about those passages.

As for how I do research concerning the Fathers, I love indexes because they can lead me to key words that will help me to find what I am looking for. Google is wonderful because it can help you to find a lot by using key words that relate to what you are looking for. I’ve have done lots of research in the last few years and I have gotten lots of practice. Over time you learn what to look for.

I have studied the Bible for a lot of years which also is obviously helpful, and I have studied the Church Fathers alot too which helps me because when I am looking for something specific I often recall reading soemthing about that in the Fathers which in turn means that I have a direction to go searching.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top