Did God Give us Sin for a Reason?

  • Thread starter Thread starter In_Training
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I

In_Training

Guest
Long story short, the priest that I go to said he’s starting to see old habits happening with me. An easy example to give would be swearing, which I haven’t done in 8 months but is starting to happen again. Admittedly, I did start doing that again, feeling like it’s relatively harmless but it feels good. I reluctantly see a psychologist every once in a while, and he said I find it therapeutic, which is true. I don’t know why. It’s been that way since I was in elementary school. I actually think it’s a healthier way for me to deal with stuff, anger, etc, because it’s better to curse to yourself than yell at someone else or take it out on them. I used to use more detrimental things to deal with stuff, i.e. smoking, drinking too much, sex, etc to relieve all that, so by comparison swearing doesn’t seem all that bad. It doesn’t hurt anyone else.

But looking over my past threads, I think I might have a tendency to justify sin, because nobody’s perfect, so it’s bound to happen. My doctor said he doesn’t encourage it, but God knows I’m going through something, so it’ll stop when I’m ready for it to. But I’ve been trying to take moral responsibility for things, and I think I feel guilty for not taking responsibility for this (but not guilty for the actual act).

Is it possible that we were given sin for a reason, or that there’s a reason an individual might be predisposed to sin a lot in certain areas? Or is it possible that God gives us specific coping mechanisms to use but I’m just using the wrong ones? :confused:
 
Long story short, the priest that I go to said he’s starting to see old habits happening with me. An easy example to give would be swearing, which I haven’t done in 8 months but is starting to happen again. Admittedly, I did start doing that again, feeling like it’s relatively harmless but it feels good. I reluctantly see a psychologist every once in a while, and he said I find it therapeutic, which is true. I don’t know why. It’s been that way since I was in elementary school. I actually think it’s a healthier way for me to deal with stuff, anger, etc, because it’s better to curse to yourself than yell at someone else or take it out on them. I used to use more detrimental things to deal with stuff, i.e. smoking, drinking too much, sex, etc to relieve all that, so by comparison swearing doesn’t seem all that bad. It doesn’t hurt anyone else.

But looking over my past threads, I think I might have a tendency to justify sin, because nobody’s perfect, so it’s bound to happen. My doctor said he doesn’t encourage it, but God knows I’m going through something, so it’ll stop when I’m ready for it to. But I’ve been trying to take moral responsibility for things, and I think I feel guilty for not taking responsibility for this (but not guilty for the actual act).

Is it possible that we were given sin for a reason, or that there’s a reason an individual might be predisposed to sin a lot in certain areas? Or is it possible that God gives us specific coping mechanisms to use but I’m just using the wrong ones? :confused:
God did not give us sin!!
 
God allows sin to exist in the world. God created us with concupiscence, which is the tendency to sin. This is because God endowed us with free will, the ability to choose our own path. Look at what happened to the angels, whom God also created with free will and intellect. A third of them chose to sin and fell from Heaven. An eternal battle rages between the demons and the angels loyal to God. But God will vanquish evil in the end. At the final Judgement, God will establish His eternal kingdom and the dead will live in our glorified bodies. God created us in His image so that we could freely choose to love Him and to make the reward of Heaven that much sweeter.
 
God is incapable of creating a negative. Not only would this violate His nature, as all good, but sin is not a thing that exists, but a lack of something - a lack of goodness. Sin and the evil that ensues are what rushes into the vacuum that is created when good is departed from. What God did create was the radical freedom that we have to choose Him or reject Him. Evil is the result of rejecting Him.
 
I guess I just mean, does God know why we handle certain situations the way we do, and empathize? I don’t reject God and I’m not evil, I’m just screwing up. I don’t understand why something that’s wrong would feel therapeutic for me. I don’t know what my motivation is, or why I handle things the way that I do, and that’s scary. How do you ask God for help with stopping sins if it’s natural to sin? To be honest, I really don’t see myself getting to a point where, for example, I never curse again, so how do you ask God for help when you suspect you’ll never be able to use that help?

My concern is that the more I trust God, the less I trust myself. Probably for good reason. I suspect I have a tendency to ignore God on purpose, and I don’t want to end up like that. 😦 I guess I was thinking that maybe he gives us sin as an option so that we can learn from it and realize what kind of work it takes to stay with him? I’m sure it’s common to try so hard to accomplish something only to go back to right where you were before. So…God expects us to sin. That’s why Christ had to do what he did, right? 🤷
 
I guess I just mean, does God know why we handle certain situations the way we do, and empathize? I don’t reject God and I’m not evil, I’m just screwing up. I don’t understand why something that’s wrong would feel therapeutic for me. I don’t know what my motivation is, or why I handle things the way that I do, and that’s scary. How do you ask God for help with stopping sins if it’s natural to sin? To be honest, I really don’t see myself getting to a point where, for example, I never curse again, so how do you ask God for help when you suspect you’ll never be able to use that help?
It feels therapeutic because you are being lied to by the liar and father of lies. Once you know this, and call it to mind each time that sin rears its ugly head, it will help you to reject the devil and sinfulness. Remember that your flesh is at war with your spirit.
My concern is that the more I trust God, the less I trust myself. Probably for good reason. I suspect I have a tendency to ignore God on purpose, and I don’t want to end up like that. 😦 I guess I was thinking that maybe he gives us sin as an option so that we can learn from it and realize what kind of work it takes to stay with him? I’m sure it’s common to try so hard to accomplish something only to go back to right where you were before. So…God expects us to sin. That’s why Christ had to do what he did, right? 🤷
He never gives sin - He allows it to preserve your freedom. He knows that we will sin, but he does not expect it - as in requiring it. He expects us to be faithful and to seek His help against sin.
 
All right, it takes 21 days to break a habit…here we go again…

I should at least get points for trying. Somewhere, God is laughing. 🍿
 
When you were a baby, you began to walk by taking a step at a time. Of course, you fell - many times. But, did you stay on the floor? No! You got up and kept trying until you mastered it. And, so it is with sin.
 
It seems to be simple. You just need to express your feelings. God loves you unconditionally, so do not be afraid. When you lose your cool and find yourself swearing. Just apologize for acting in a way that is below your dignity as a child of God and move on. Don’t give the devil a chance to work on you. Jesus KNOWS our human weakness!

Any saint I ever read about EXPECTED that they would sin but hoped not to. Ask Jesus to show you a knew way of expressing yourself. Live confidently in the compassion of your God.
 
Long story short, the priest that I go to said he’s starting to see old habits happening with me. An easy example to give would be swearing, which I haven’t done in 8 months but is starting to happen again. Admittedly, I did start doing that again, feeling like it’s relatively harmless but it feels good. I reluctantly see a psychologist every once in a while, and he said I find it therapeutic, which is true. I don’t know why. It’s been that way since I was in elementary school. I actually think it’s a healthier way for me to deal with stuff, anger, etc, because it’s better to curse to yourself than yell at someone else or take it out on them. I used to use more detrimental things to deal with stuff, i.e. smoking, drinking too much, sex, etc to relieve all that, so by comparison swearing doesn’t seem all that bad. It doesn’t hurt anyone else.

But looking over my past threads, I think I might have a tendency to justify sin, because nobody’s perfect, so it’s bound to happen. My doctor said he doesn’t encourage it, but God knows I’m going through something, so it’ll stop when I’m ready for it to. But I’ve been trying to take moral responsibility for things, and I think I feel guilty for not taking responsibility for this (but not guilty for the actual act).

Is it possible that we were given sin for a reason, or that there’s a reason an individual might be predisposed to sin a lot in certain areas? Or is it possible that God gives us specific coping mechanisms to use but I’m just using the wrong ones? :confused:
To be clear, God didn’t “give us” sin. He simply allows it. He has many reasons, I’m sure, for allowing it… one might be to make clear our dependence on His mercy for those of us inclined to penance, another might be to suffer just punishment (sin being its own punishment) for those not so inclined, a third might be that the native evil of the world can only be responded to with evil in kind, such that it serves His purposes (in much the way the perfidy of the Jews was used by Christ to the advantage of all mankind).

What is clear, though, is that God doesn’t want you to sin. That’s pretty much tautological: sin just is what God doesn’t want for you. So there is never, ever a “justification” for sin. You must work to find ways to do without it, even acknowledging the probability of failure and the necessity of repentance.
 
When you truly love God, you will love and trust yourself more than the start. Because love of God is love of neighbor, and love of neighbor is love of self. Perhaps you have a low self-image, or you have trouble with discernment of spirits. Learn to recognize the good in what you follow. It may be hard at first. Trusting God is an act of self-sacrifice. You may trust yourself less to begin with, but that is simply recognition that sin and attachment to sin is detrimental to your well-being.

Free will is a powerful thing. It can take us down any path possible. The wide and easy paths are roads to perdition. When you truly love God you will experience a wonderful feeling of freedom and a light burden. God doesn’t tell us what to do, but He shows us by example how to live life. Spend some time reading the Gospels and the lives of the saints. There are certainly some saints whose example you can follow. Don’t be afraid to pretend you are in a cafeteria. You can choose a little from one saint’s life and a little from Jesus’ life to imitate. Everyone has his or her own unique mix of good virtues.

Remember to pray without ceasing. Start with five minutes a day, morning and night. Learn some common prayers by heart and recite them twice a day. Then you can explore devotions such as the rosary, or Liturgy of the Hours. It is important to have an active prayer life, and an active spiritual life including church attendance. I guess you are non-Catholic. But Catholics are obliged to go to Mass on all Sundays and Holy Days of Obligation. Start going to church on a regular basis and enjoying the fruits of the Word of God. Read the Bible on your own. Learn the mind of God, it is essential to know Him before you can imitate Him. Good luck and I will be praying for you.
 
When you truly love God, you will love and trust yourself more than the start. Because love of God is love of neighbor, and love of neighbor is love of self. Perhaps you have a low self-image, or you have trouble with discernment of spirits. Learn to recognize the good in what you follow. It may be hard at first. Trusting God is an act of self-sacrifice. You may trust yourself less to begin with, but that is simply recognition that sin and attachment to sin is detrimental to your well-being.

Free will is a powerful thing. It can take us down any path possible. The wide and easy paths are roads to perdition. When you truly love God you will experience a wonderful feeling of freedom and a light burden. God doesn’t tell us what to do, but He shows us by example how to live life. Spend some time reading the Gospels and the lives of the saints. There are certainly some saints whose example you can follow. Don’t be afraid to pretend you are in a cafeteria. You can choose a little from one saint’s life and a little from Jesus’ life to imitate. Everyone has his or her own unique mix of good virtues.

Remember to pray without ceasing. Start with five minutes a day, morning and night. Learn some common prayers by heart and recite them twice a day. Then you can explore devotions such as the rosary, or Liturgy of the Hours. It is important to have an active prayer life, and an active spiritual life including church attendance. I guess you are non-Catholic. But Catholics are obliged to go to Mass on all Sundays and Holy Days of Obligation. Start going to church on a regular basis and enjoying the fruits of the Word of God. Read the Bible on your own. Learn the mind of God, it is essential to know Him before you can imitate Him. Good luck and I will be praying for you.
I am Catholic, but left the church in middle school and came back 2 years ago. I help with my church’s bible school classes so I’m at church a lot but haven’t actually gone to mass in a number of months. I’ve read a little bit of the bible on my own but quickly become angry with it, if that makes sense. So even though my family’s devoutly Catholic, only in the last 2 years or so have I actually tried to be Catholic myself. I actually go to the priest I knew as a kid. After I came back to the church, one of the first times I actually went to confession, I couldn’t stop shaking and ended up going home right after and throwing up because of guilt. I’m not good at confronting stuff.

My priest said once you go to confession, you’re forgiven. But I don’t feel that way. I don’t feel better. I still feel guilty. Like I haven’t proven anything. Maybe God’s still mad. I don’t blame him. I’ve been very destructive and self-destructive, and manipulative, so I don’t know what I have to do to get that trust back. I love God with all my heart, but I shouldn’t be trusted. I’m a flight risk, and I do things over and over again that I swore I’d never do again. I think I’m tempted easily and I tend to justify things at the time, then feel guilty later and get sick. I don’t want God to see me like this. I’ve asked (begged) for help, lots of times, and even though I keep trying, and even though I’ve come a long way since a thread I made last December when I first joined, I feel like I’m doing better and yet the guilt doesn’t go away. You know the story about how the angels fell, how one in particular got proud and turned away? I can’t believe I was that stupid and did the same thing, and might continue to. I’m not the leader I always felt I was supposed to be. Since I was a kid I’ve wanted to join the priesthood. In a way, I don’t want God to trust me, because I don’t trust myself with that responsibility. That’s why I made this thread, I was kind of hoping someone would say God wants you to sin and experience that so you’ll learn from it and do your crime and do your time and eventually you’ll come around… How do you accept forgiveness for past and future mistakes if no one holds you accountable or makes you do penance? I know what Jesus did for us and I still wear my crucifix and try to take time every day to say a short prayer, but I’m angry that I’m not the leader, or even the person, I’m supposed to be. 😦 And then I feel guilty because everything is I feel, I want, I, I, I…and I’m supposed to be focusing on helping others, not myself.

Sorry for unloading. It’s really hard for me to “express my feelings,” or say what I’m really thinking, so when I feel like I can talk, now I actually try to. Of course, it usually comes out as, That’s F-ing BS or How the eff am I supposed to do that… so maybe it’s better if I don’t talk.
 
It’s not wrong to focus on yourself for the first steps of spiritual growth. But you are right that we should be thinking of others. I don’t think God wants us to sin. God knows in His wisdom that our ancestors have sinned much in the past, and we wrote all of it down in the Bible, so that we can learn from those stories, and not repeat the past. The Bible also documents the history of salvation. That is the central narrative of the Bible. How God intervened in every age to bring us closer to Him and help us choose to do right.

I think that you need to take serious corrective action in order to set yourself on the right path. If you are becoming physically sick because of confession, you need to examine your mental stability and perhaps seek professional help for your psychological and emotional needs. Perhaps you would benefit from talk therapy, or perhaps you would benefit from some kind of medication to control your anxiety. We can’t really help you with that in specific on the forums, you need to ask a professional.

I would also suggest that you shop around and look for a trusted confessor who puts you at ease. This is critical for anyone who struggles with the sacrament. It sounds like your priest means well, but perhaps your personal ties with him are too strong to make it work. Consider also the options of anonymous confession, or if you already do so, try face-to-face if your confessor will allow it. Make an appointment with the priest and give a general confession - an appointment will relieve you of the burden of thinking that you are holding up the line, and a general confession of all your past mortal sins will help you confront them and receive spiritual counseling for them. But keep in mind that your priest is right: all your sins have already been forgiven, and spiritual counseling is not the point of being in the confessional, but rather, receiving God’s freely given graces and restoring our soul to its baptismal state of spotlessness.

It is critical that you get back to Mass. Do it in parallel with seeking professional help, but do it ASAP, because you need to be nourished by the Eucharist, and you need to be nourished by God’s Word proclaimed every time. Perhaps if you attend some daily Mass with a smaller crowd, your anxiety will be reduced. You will still have to go on Sundays, but as you get to know attendees, hopefully they will bid you welcome and put you at ease.

Another worthy activity is Adoration of the Blessed Sacrament. This is a quiet time when you can truly let God speak to you in your heart. Particularly if you are discerning your vocation in life, many holy men and women have received theirs at the foot of the altar of worship. There is an indulgence attached to visiting Our Lord in Adoration, and I believe that indulgences would be a very good thing for you to seek. Perhaps it is the temporal punishment due to sin that you fear, and indulgences can wipe that away and give you a truly clean slate.

Work on finding yourself a spiritual director. A SD is not a confessor, but is also a priest who can meet with you on a regular basis, perhaps an hour a month, and help you find purpose and direction in life. He is the one who can help you with a possible vocation to the priesthood. He can tell you where to look, and what resources are out there.

I am glad that you have come back to the Church, and I am pleased with your earnest effort to improve yourself. You are really on the right path already, in some respects. You know right from wrong and you are helping in your parish, these are good signs of a healthy conscience and a good soul just waiting to be freed from the prison of sin. I will pray for you again, as always.
 
It’s not wrong to focus on yourself for the first steps of spiritual growth. But you are right that we should be thinking of others. I don’t think God wants us to sin. God knows in His wisdom that our ancestors have sinned much in the past, and we wrote all of it down in the Bible, so that we can learn from those stories, and not repeat the past. The Bible also documents the history of salvation. That is the central narrative of the Bible. How God intervened in every age to bring us closer to Him and help us choose to do right.

I think that you need to take serious corrective action in order to set yourself on the right path. If you are becoming physically sick because of confession, you need to examine your mental stability and perhaps seek professional help for your psychological and emotional needs. Perhaps you would benefit from talk therapy, or perhaps you would benefit from some kind of medication to control your anxiety. We can’t really help you with that in specific on the forums, you need to ask a professional.

I would also suggest that you shop around and look for a trusted confessor who puts you at ease. This is critical for anyone who struggles with the sacrament. It sounds like your priest means well, but perhaps your personal ties with him are too strong to make it work. Consider also the options of anonymous confession, or if you already do so, try face-to-face if your confessor will allow it. Make an appointment with the priest and give a general confession - an appointment will relieve you of the burden of thinking that you are holding up the line, and a general confession of all your past mortal sins will help you confront them and receive spiritual counseling for them. But keep in mind that your priest is right: all your sins have already been forgiven, and spiritual counseling is not the point of being in the confessional, but rather, receiving God’s freely given graces and restoring our soul to its baptismal state of spotlessness.

It is critical that you get back to Mass. Do it in parallel with seeking professional help, but do it ASAP, because you need to be nourished by the Eucharist, and you need to be nourished by God’s Word proclaimed every time. Perhaps if you attend some daily Mass with a smaller crowd, your anxiety will be reduced. You will still have to go on Sundays, but as you get to know attendees, hopefully they will bid you welcome and put you at ease.

Another worthy activity is Adoration of the Blessed Sacrament. This is a quiet time when you can truly let God speak to you in your heart. Particularly if you are discerning your vocation in life, many holy men and women have received theirs at the foot of the altar of worship. There is an indulgence attached to visiting Our Lord in Adoration, and I believe that indulgences would be a very good thing for you to seek. Perhaps it is the temporal punishment due to sin that you fear, and indulgences can wipe that away and give you a truly clean slate.

Work on finding yourself a spiritual director. A SD is not a confessor, but is also a priest who can meet with you on a regular basis, perhaps an hour a month, and help you find purpose and direction in life. He is the one who can help you with a possible vocation to the priesthood. He can tell you where to look, and what resources are out there.

I am glad that you have come back to the Church, and I am pleased with your earnest effort to improve yourself. You are really on the right path already, in some respects. You know right from wrong and you are helping in your parish, these are good signs of a healthy conscience and a good soul just waiting to be freed from the prison of sin. I will pray for you again, as always.
I’ve actually been going to confession every week for the past 3 weeks. It’s never as bad as I think it’s going to be. People have asked me, how can you help teach Bible classes if you never even go to church? And I’ve always kind of been one of those ‘do as I say, not as I do’ types… So maybe I’m growing out of that. 🙂 One of my more interesting problems is that I’ve never prayed a lot or asked for anything, thinking I was beyond that and praying is for people who actually deserve help, so I’ve tried never to ask for it. It’s like asking to be paid for hours you didn’t work, so I’ve tried never to ask for that, but I think it’s also important to know when to ask for help, whether you worked for it or not. Does that make sense? 🤷 I just want to be someone who does the right things without hesitation, so theoretically God can be like, “nice job” instead of “what’d you do wrong this time?” I want to do what I’m supposed to do, but that’s not always clear. I’ve gone to about 10 or 12 confessions in the last year, but still feel guilty, just can’t figure out why or what it’s about.

Something I have noticed, is that every time I almost say Goddamn it, it comes out “God help me.” I tried to start doing that a long time ago and it never worked until now. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top