Yes. Basically if it ain’t yours don’t mess with it. Such I was taught as a child.
Even picking a flower IS theft if it isn’t YOUR flower.
In my view the JWs owned the literature until they placed it on the mailbox of a specific person. At that point ownership transferred to the individual who recieved mail in that particular box. By placing each pamphlet on a particular box, they clearly communicated their intention to transfer ownership to that particular person.
Yes. Basically if it ain’t yours don’t mess with it. Such I was taught as a child.
Even picking a flower IS theft if it isn’t YOUR flower.
What you were taught as a child has no moral weight. I was taught that "ain’t"is not proper English but that does not affect the morality of using it or the appearance of it in a dictionary.
From the Catholic encyclopedia.
catholic.org/encyclopedia/view.php?id=11428
Theft is the secret taking of another’s property against the reasonable will of that other.
(Bolding mine)
There is more on the link.
Legally
A criminal act in which property belonging to another is taken without that person’s consent.
legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/theft
Again we have the issue of ownership. You can plainly see that in both the theological and legal sense that theft is not taking of something that does not belong to you, but rather it must belong to someone else who does not want you to take it.
To go even further: Petty theft is usually under 500 dollars, so what if the pamphlet was under 1 cent cost ( in this case it is free) if the OP hypothetically took 1. What is the legal crime?
In my view the JWs owned the literature until they placed it on the mailbox of a specific person. At that point ownership transferred to the individual who recieved mail in that particular box. By placing each pamphlet on a particular box, they clearly communicated their intention to transfer ownership to that particular person.
I disagree but I conclude that your argument here is at least logical. So, would it potentially be a crime for the 16 year old teen in the house to read this pamphlet?
I think by taking the trouble to individually distribute them to specific individual boxes they clearly indicated that their intent was not to “freely distribute them to the public domain” had they been trying to do that they would, for example, have simply placed an open box of pamphlets on a street corner.
Again, logical.
And again I disagree. But it is interesting. Following this, could the JWs be guilty of multiple felonies on each owner of the mailbox? Or just one count of government mischief (or whatever they would term it)
I assure you if I had seen the OP take something off of my mailbox we would have seen such a court case as I would have sworn a warrant against him for theft, no matter what the thing I saw him take was. He has no right whatever to determine what I read or see.
So noted! I wonder what the legal outcome of the sworn warrant would be? What was taken from you?
I’m surprised a little Georgia justice was not called for!
“You can have my leaflet, when you pry it from my cold dead hands, Yankee!”
For the record there are few such as I who would be so bold as to approach a Georgians mailbox. Even to remove blaspheme. I guess I don’t have the maryter’s faith.
What and to whom does the Church give legal authority to prevent the spread of heresy
Does Georgia still have the death penalty for removal of “Chem lawn” door hanging advertisements?