Did I steal?

  • Thread starter Thread starter miguelgar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The purpose is for me to take it home to read and convert.

The purpose I would take it home for is to read and refute.

How do we know what the “purpose” is or how far that purpose must be obeyed?
I guess we disagree on their expectations. They can reasonably expect people to read their material. They have no reasonable expectations that such reading will always lead to conversion. Even if you only read it to refute it, you read it. If the material had any liturgical merit, that might have been enough to move you.

I expect that if you asked the people that placed those books whether you could take one to read it even for the sole purpose of refutation they would have encouraged you do so even on that basis. Wouldn’t you say the same thing to an atheist or agnostic about a bible? or a Catechism? I would.
 
Seriously? Theft is okay with the person leaving the property committed some trivial administrative error? Going back to the bike example. My town has an ordinance against leaving bikes propped up against a building, instead requiring them to be parked in designated racks.

I leave my bike propped against a building while I go into a store. No one disputes that the city has the right to impound my bike for violating the ordinance. Nor is anyone disputing that the owner of the building has the right to call the cops to enforce the ordinance. What is in dispute is whether some random person (the OP) can come along and steal my bike because it is illegally parked. Clearly he can’t.
Again, I ask. What is theft? Simply taking of what is not yours? Then picking a flower is theft. Ownership must be defined. Who owns the pamphlet?
JWs? The person who’s address is on the (government mailbox)? The government who’s mailbox it is? Or does no one own it?
Or is it public domain, freely given to the society at large to do with as they please.🤷
I think the latter. Though it would make an interesting court case.

But the OP’s sin (if any) is the lesser of the sins. Theologically speaking spreading heresy is a sin. Legally speaking, interference with mail is not only a crime but a possible felony. And of course the trespassing of all parties involved.🤷
 
The problem is that in your example we can show ownership of the bike. Who owns the pamphlet? Could one dispose of a yard sale sign illegally posted on a telephone pole?
Who exactly owns the bike or the pamphlet is unimportant. The OP knew it wasn’t his. He knew he had no right to it.

If I see some unattended property I don’t appropriate it to my own use. I assume it belongs to someone else and leave it along.
 
I expect that if you asked the people that placed those books whether you could take one to read it even for the sole purpose of refutation they would have encouraged you do so even on that basis. Wouldn’t you say the same thing to an atheist or agnostic about a bible? or a Catechism? I would.
Sure I would! But only to a certain extent. Could someone take the Bible with the purpose to read it and refute it? Sure, I’d be ok with that because I would weigh the risk of an informed atheist or non Christian against the faith I have in the Word. But what if the person told you they would read it, and destroy it. Burn it, or defile it. Would you hand your rosary over to someone who intended to feel it and then defile or destroy it?
How about the Eucharist? Should the Church encourage all to receive regardless of intent?

It is interesting. And certainly not as black and white as any one side is presenting.
 
Again, I ask. What is theft? Simply taking of what is not yours? Then picking a flower is theft. Ownership must be defined. Who owns the pamphlet?
JWs? The person who’s address is on the (government mailbox)? The government who’s mailbox it is? Or does no one own it?
Or is it public domain, freely given to the society at large to do with as they please.🤷
I think the latter. Though it would make an interesting court case.

But the OP’s sin (if any) is the lesser of the sins. Theologically speaking spreading heresy is a sin. Legally speaking, interference with mail is not only a crime but a possible felony. And of course the trespassing of all parties involved.🤷
Not really. “What is theft?” Really? Is it the same as picking a wildflower (which is what I assume you meant) from public lands? What is the OP & JW intent here?

Clearly the intent is for the JW to get a message to the homeowner. The intent of the OP was to disrupt this transaction which does not include him, other than his own home.

That it was on or around a mailbox, that the mailbox may or may not have been on a public easement is all irrelevant, and please keep in mind if you are a JW, it isn’t heresy, and destruction of property isn’t the best course of action to correct a heresy.

I see no concrete evidence here that there was a felony or any “interference with mail,” but even if there were - is correcting it with a wrong when you aren’t involved what we are advocating?
 
Sure I would! But only to a certain extent. Could someone take the Bible with the purpose to read it and refute it? Sure, I’d be ok with that because I would weigh the risk of an informed atheist or non Christian against the faith I have in the Word. But what if the person told you they would read it, and destroy it. Burn it, or defile it. Would you hand your rosary over to someone who intended to feel it and then defile or destroy it?
How about the Eucharist? Should the Church encourage all to receive regardless of intent?

It is interesting. And certainly not as black and white as any one side is presenting.
Every example above that you present involves informed decision making from both parties, and therefore not applicable to the situation here, right?
 
Again, I ask. What is theft? Simply taking of what is not yours? Then picking a flower is theft.
Yes. Basically if it ain’t yours don’t mess with it. Such I was taught as a child.

Even picking a flower IS theft if it isn’t YOUR flower.
Ownership must be defined. Who owns the pamphlet? JWs? The person who’s address is on the (government mailbox)? The government who’s mailbox it is? Or does no one own it?
In my view the JWs owned the literature until they placed it on the mailbox of a specific person. At that point ownership transferred to the individual who recieved mail in that particular box. By placing each pamphlet on a particular box, they clearly communicated their intention to transfer ownership to that particular person.
Or is it public domain, freely given to the society at large to do with as they please.🤷 I think the latter.
Clearly we disagree.

I think by taking the trouble to individually distribute them to specific individual boxes they clearly indicated that their intent was not to “freely distribute them to the public domain” had they been trying to do that they would, for example, have simply placed an open box of pamphlets on a street corner.
Though it would make an interesting court case.
I assure you if I had seen the OP take something off of my mailbox we would have seen such a court case as I would have sworn a warrant against him for theft, no matter what the thing I saw him take was. He has no right whatever to determine what I read or see.
But the OP’s sin (if any) is the lesser of the sins. Theologically speaking spreading heresy is a sin. Legally speaking, interference with mail is not only a crime but a possible felony. And of course the trespassing of all parties involved.🤷
Yeah, but the OP hasn’t been given authority by the Church to prosecute spreading heresy. Nor is theft an appropriate way to prevent the spread of heresy.
 
Who exactly owns the bike or the pamphlet is unimportant. The OP knew it wasn’t his. He knew he had no right to it.

If I see some unattended property I don’t appropriate it to my own use. I assume it belongs to someone else and leave it along.
If the intent is public domain then the person most certainly did have the right and perhaps even the OBLIGATION to remove the item illegally placed on government property. If the pamphlet has “dear Mr and Mrs Smith” on it then one could argue that the JWs intended it for a single person. But if it is canvasing of a neighborhood with paraphernalia illegally, who owns it?
In my opinion the JWs have relinquished ownership. The property owner cannot claim ownership without knowledge of the item. And there would need to be intent that ONLY the owner of the mailbox was to be the sole recipient.

Intent is almost as important as ownership here.

I still submit that the item is in limbo. Stealing is not solely defined as taking of something you do not own. It has to be owned by someone else. And it probably has to have value. And in the case of the public. If the “public in general” is the intended owner then it is a member of the public who is taking the literature. I think it bothers some people because it feels shady. But I cannot see where it is stealing. And if it is it is less of a crime than trespassing or felony mail molestation.

Theologically speaking how does one confess that? I destroyed anti Catholic literature illegally spread all over my community?
What is the penance? Type up some JW material and make restitution all over the neighborhood?

I still like the idea of waiting a week and then door to dooring your neighbors and engaging in some apologetics! Perhaps one could leave a nice copy of the CCC at the doorstep of the Kingdom Hall.
 
If the intent is public domain then the person most certainly did have the right and perhaps even the OBLIGATION to remove the item illegally placed on government property. If the pamphlet has “dear Mr and Mrs Smith” on it then one could argue that the JWs intended it for a single person. But if it is canvasing of a neighborhood with paraphernalia illegally, who owns it?
In my opinion the JWs have relinquished ownership. The property owner cannot claim ownership without knowledge of the item. And there would need to be intent that ONLY the owner of the mailbox was to be the sole recipient.

Intent is almost as important as ownership here.

I still submit that the item is in limbo. Stealing is not solely defined as taking of something you do not own. It has to be owned by someone else. And it probably has to have value. And in the case of the public. If the “public in general” is the intended owner then it is a member of the public who is taking the literature. I think it bothers some people because it feels shady. But I cannot see where it is stealing. And if it is it is less of a crime than trespassing or felony mail molestation.

Theologically speaking how does one confess that? I destroyed anti Catholic literature illegally spread all over my community?
What is the penance? Type up some JW material and make restitution all over the neighborhood?

I still like the idea of waiting a week and then door to dooring your neighbors and engaging in some apologetics! Perhaps one could leave a nice copy of the CCC at the doorstep of the Kingdom Hall.
This is more justification gymnastics. Is “on your mailbox” public domain? I wouldn’t consider that true for mine. $0.02. “Limbo?” I haven’t had the opportunity to go look at what is on my mailbox before OP gets there to destroy it.

:confused: We all get samples and lawn advertisements and whatever else put inside our front doors, on our garage doors, around our mailboxes, right? Do you indicate your intent to forfeit ownership by leaving it there? Of course not. You take it in or throw it away. The owner did not have this opportunity.

Do you really feel in your heart that this is OK?
 
Sure I would! But only to a certain extent. Could someone take the Bible with the purpose to read it and refute it? Sure, I’d be ok with that because I would weigh the risk of an informed atheist or non Christian against the faith I have in the Word.
Right me too. And since I’m Catholic, I would believe there is an excellent chance that such a read could represent an occasion of grace for them dispute their initial skepticism.
But what if the person told you they would read it, and destroy it. Burn it, or defile it.
I think I would still give it to them because I would believe that there is an excellent chance that the power of the Word would overcome their initial intent. I would weigh it against the actual harm done if they did choose to defile the book after they read it.
Would you hand your rosary over to someone who intended to feel it and then defile or destroy it?
How about the Eucharist? Should the Church encourage all to receive regardless of intent?
To me these are fundamentally different because they are only suitable for their intended use by people who have already made that initial investment (so to speak) in the Truth of the Faith. The Eucharist is only useful to people who believe in the True Presence. Let me give you an example that might speak to what you’re talking about.

If I knew a woman who was intending an abortion and could not talk her out of. I would obviously refuse to facilitate or support her obtaining one, but if she asked me for the loan of my Rosary so she could pray. I would loan her the Rosary in a heartbeat, despite the risk that she would carry it with her to the abortuary during the procedure, because I would believe that there was an outside chance that praying the Rosary might turn her heart.
 
I still submit that the item is in limbo. Stealing is not solely defined as taking of something you do not own. It has to be owned by someone else. And it probably has to have value.
I profoundly and strenuously disagree. Every definition of “theft” or “stealing” fundamentally specifies taking something which doesn’t belong to you. Who the item belongs to is irrelevant, if you don’t own it, and you take it, it is stealing and you are a thief. Period.
Theologically speaking how does one confess that? I destroyed anti Catholic literature illegally spread all over my community?
What is the penance? Type up some JW material and make restitution all over the neighborhood?
That sounds about right to me. If in some fit of presumptuousness I somehow was motivated to do such a thing, that’s about what I would confess. As for penance, well I’m not a Priest so that’s above my paygrade, but if I were, I’d probably focus more on the failure to respect the rights and property of others and say assign some service to the poor or sick along with reading the appropriate Church documents on the rights of others and Religous Liberty.
I still like the idea of waiting a week and then door to dooring your neighbors and engaging in some apologetics! Perhaps one could leave a nice copy of the CCC at the doorstep of the Kingdom Hall.
No need to wait a week. If the OP is really so concerned with the state of his neighbors he should have taken the time to address the actual issue instead of stealing their property “for their own good”.
 
Yes. Basically if it ain’t yours don’t mess with it. Such I was taught as a child.

Even picking a flower IS theft if it isn’t YOUR flower.
In my view the JWs owned the literature until they placed it on the mailbox of a specific person. At that point ownership transferred to the individual who recieved mail in that particular box. By placing each pamphlet on a particular box, they clearly communicated their intention to transfer ownership to that particular person.
Yes. Basically if it ain’t yours don’t mess with it. Such I was taught as a child.
Even picking a flower IS theft if it isn’t YOUR flower.
What you were taught as a child has no moral weight. I was taught that "ain’t"is not proper English but that does not affect the morality of using it or the appearance of it in a dictionary.
From the Catholic encyclopedia.
catholic.org/encyclopedia/view.php?id=11428
Theft is the secret taking of another’s property against the reasonable will of that other.
(Bolding mine)
There is more on the link.

Legally
A criminal act in which property belonging to another is taken without that person’s consent.
legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/theft

Again we have the issue of ownership. You can plainly see that in both the theological and legal sense that theft is not taking of something that does not belong to you, but rather it must belong to someone else who does not want you to take it.
To go even further: Petty theft is usually under 500 dollars, so what if the pamphlet was under 1 cent cost ( in this case it is free) if the OP hypothetically took 1. What is the legal crime?
In my view the JWs owned the literature until they placed it on the mailbox of a specific person. At that point ownership transferred to the individual who recieved mail in that particular box. By placing each pamphlet on a particular box, they clearly communicated their intention to transfer ownership to that particular person.
I disagree but I conclude that your argument here is at least logical. So, would it potentially be a crime for the 16 year old teen in the house to read this pamphlet?
I think by taking the trouble to individually distribute them to specific individual boxes they clearly indicated that their intent was not to “freely distribute them to the public domain” had they been trying to do that they would, for example, have simply placed an open box of pamphlets on a street corner.
Again, logical.
And again I disagree. But it is interesting. Following this, could the JWs be guilty of multiple felonies on each owner of the mailbox? Or just one count of government mischief (or whatever they would term it)
I assure you if I had seen the OP take something off of my mailbox we would have seen such a court case as I would have sworn a warrant against him for theft, no matter what the thing I saw him take was. He has no right whatever to determine what I read or see.
So noted! I wonder what the legal outcome of the sworn warrant would be? What was taken from you?
I’m surprised a little Georgia justice was not called for!
“You can have my leaflet, when you pry it from my cold dead hands, Yankee!”
For the record there are few such as I who would be so bold as to approach a Georgians mailbox. Even to remove blaspheme. I guess I don’t have the maryter’s faith.
What and to whom does the Church give legal authority to prevent the spread of heresy

Does Georgia still have the death penalty for removal of “Chem lawn” door hanging advertisements?
 
No need to wait a week. If the OP is really so concerned with the state of his neighbors he should have taken the time to address the actual issue instead of stealing their property “for their own good”.
I could get behind that!

What is interesting to me here is that I don’t think it legally fits the definition of stealing.
Nor theologically.

Also I think we as Americans sometimes confuse our Constitution and system of government with morality or even holiness. Make no bones about it, the constitution is not a religious document. Free speech and property rights are different theologically and legally in this country.

The law is rarely Holy or Moral.
 
Right me too. And since I’m Catholic, I would believe there is an excellent chance that such a read could represent an occasion of grace for them dispute their initial skepticism.

I think I would still give it to them because I would believe that there is an excellent chance that the power of the Word would overcome their initial intent. I would weigh it against the actual harm done if they did choose to defile the book after they read it.

To me these are fundamentally different because they are only suitable for their intended use by people who have already made that initial investment (so to speak) in the Truth of the Faith. The Eucharist is only useful to people who believe in the True Presence. Let me give you an example that might speak to what you’re talking about.

If I knew a woman who was intending an abortion and could not talk her out of. I would obviously refuse to facilitate or support her obtaining one, but if she asked me for the loan of my Rosary so she could pray. I would loan her the Rosary in a heartbeat, despite the risk that she would carry it with her to the abortuary during the procedure, because I would believe that there was an outside chance that praying the Rosary might turn her heart.
If I knew a woman who was intending an abortion and could not talk her out of. I would obviously refuse to facilitate or support her obtaining one, but if she asked me for the loan of my Rosary so she could pray. I would loan her the Rosary in a heartbeat, despite the risk that she would carry it with her to the abortuary during the procedure, because I would believe that there was an outside chance that praying the Rosary might turn her heart
Of course we all would! A sacramental should be in the evil of the abortuary. But the analogy does not fit.

What if she intended to use it as the instrument for the abortion? Would you hand it over then?

Geesh ! this got weird fast huh?
 
I agree that the destruction of one’s scripture smacks of fascism. I agree with you on this point. But what if one read the book. Could I take a book of Mormon home to read it? To learn what they believe to better help evangelize them? I wonder what the person (or most likely company) who left it there.

Most Mormons I know would encourage a person to take the book to learn more about the faith.
The person who posted it said she takes them and puts them in recycling (the trash).
 
The person who posted it said she takes them and puts them in recycling (the trash).
Yes, so are you implying there is a contract.

“you are welcome to the book as long as you promise to read it and not throw it away?”
 
I didn’t make anything up. I asked a question.

Why are people so emotional about this?

What is your opinion of the question?
Ownership of pizza coupons would even be different because there is a monetary value to the coupon left on your door. But what is the value of the JWs literate that says Catholicism is false?

The answer may very well be that it is theft. I don’t know. I just asked a question.

There are some pretty quick triggers and egos on this particular thread that really is not that important of an issue.🤷 Certainly the sin would not be mortal? Right?
I don’t think anyone said it was a mortal sin…and I don’t know that it’s all that emotional…just disappointing to see catholics twisting themselves into pretzels to justify a wrongdoing.
The value? It obviously has value to someone. Who takes it upon themselves to decide something has no value, so they an steal it?
 
I don’t think anyone said it was a mortal sin…and I don’t know that it’s all that emotional…just disappointing to see catholics twisting themselves into pretzels to justify a wrongdoing.
The value? It obviously has value to someone. Who takes it upon themselves to decide something has no value, so they an steal it?
Who owns it? Against whom is the wrong being done?
 
I don’t care who owns the mailbox. I think it takes a lot of nerve to walk onto someone’s property and steal something. I don’t care what it is. This is really tacky behavior!

I’m surprised that someone would have the audacity to decide what kind of literature their neighbors may or may not see. It seems that most adults would be capable of deciding this for themselves.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top