Did I steal?

  • Thread starter Thread starter miguelgar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
And which commandment is that exactly?😉

MYOB is societal polite but theologically useless.
Neither are trespassing, censoring, or meddling “commandments”.
Those were the things being refuted.
Lots of things that are wrong aren’t mentioned in the commandments.
 
Neither are trespassing, censoring, or meddling “commandments”.
Those were the things being refuted.
Lots of things that are wrong aren’t mentioned in the commandments.
…which says nothing about “minding your own business” being a good thing. It occurs to me that MYOB is exactly what the German citizens did when they knew those freight trains were carrying Jews to the death camps. No, “mind your own business” does not have a great track record so that you should automatically hold it up as a good and desirable thing to strive for.

But I’m glad that you at least concede that all your other objections are inapplicable.
 
Lots of things that are wrong aren’t mentioned in the commandments.
All of the commands are summed up in two. And for something to be “wrong” it needs to break one of them.

They are indeed all encompassing. That was Jesus’s point when pointed out the two greatest.
 
…which says nothing about “minding your own business” being a good thing. It occurs to me that MYOB is exactly what the German citizens did when they knew those freight trains were carrying Jews to the death camps. No, “mind your own business” does not have a great track record so that you should automatically hold it up as a good and desirable thing to strive for.

But I’m glad that you at least concede that all your other objections are inapplicable.
Hmmm. Seems a bit of hyerbole is at work here.

Gosh, I must admit it never occurred to me that a person would have trouble discerning the difference
Maybe this will help:

Scenario A: You arrive home and find some guy taking something off your mailbox. When you ask him what he’s doing, he says “Someone left this for you to read, but I’m taking it away because you shouldn’t be allowed to.”
You might be inclined to say I’ll thank you for minding your own business, getting off my property, and not presuming to meddle in my affairs or censor what I should read"

Scenario B: You notice the government hauling people out of your neighborhood and taking them to camps for being jewish (or Jehovah’s Witnesses)…
Let’s see, what do you do about that?
 
All of the commands are summed up in two. And for something to be “wrong” it needs to break one of them.

They are indeed all encompassing. That was Jesus’s point when pointed out the two greatest.
Yes indeed. And all the venial are subsets of the 10.
I’d say this falls under the many lesser variations of stealing.
Violating your neighbor’s dignity no doubt falls under one of the last few.
Not sure where flipping the bird to someone in traffic falls. Or letting your dog poop on your neighbor’s lawn. Or doing it yourself, which happens in some places. Obviously not right things to do.
🙂
 
Hmmm. Seems a bit of hyerbole is at work here.

Gosh, I must admit it never occurred to me that a person would have trouble discerning the difference
Maybe this will help:

Scenario A: You arrive home and find some guy taking something off your mailbox. When you ask him what he’s doing, he says “Someone left this for you to read, but I’m taking it away because you shouldn’t be allowed to.”
You might be inclined to say I’ll thank you for minding your own business, getting off my property, and not presuming to meddle in my affairs or censor what I should read"

Scenario B: You notice the government hauling people out of your neighborhood and taking them to camps for being jewish (or Jehovah’s Witnesses)…
Let’s see, what do you do about that?
There is no hyperbole involved. I don’t need the two scenarios to be of comparable magnitude to make my point, which was that “minding your own business” is not automatically a good thing, and at least in the one case I cited it was definitely a bad thing. Since you offered no reasons why MYOB was good in the mailbox scenario, my example merely shows that you have some work to do if you expect to use MYOB as an objection to the action taken by the OP.

I should also point out that you are misrepresenting scenario A. I have already stated that the only case we should be discussing is where the mailbox is on the edge of the road, so the OP does not need to intrude on private property to dispose of the material. So there would be no reason for me to say “get off my property” as you suggested. You also mis-characterized the reason for removing the material. It is not that the recipient shouldn’t read that material. It is that such material was distributed illegally. If someone removed only material that he objected to but left material that he did not object to, such a person would be acting hypocritically. To be consistent about it, one would have to be just as willing to remove illegally-placed flyers from his own church as literature from some other church. So let’s stop talking about the content of the material because it truly is not relevant here.
 
There is no hyperbole involved. I don’t need the two scenarios to be of comparable magnitude to make my point, which was that “minding your own business” is not automatically a good thing, and at least in the one case I cited it was definitely a bad thing. Since you offered no reasons why MYOB was good in the mailbox scenario, my example merely shows that you have some work to do if you expect to use MYOB as an objection to the action taken by the OP.

I should also point out that you are misrepresenting scenario A. I have already stated that the only case we should be discussing is where the mailbox is on the edge of the road, so the OP does not need to intrude on private property to dispose of the material. So there would be no reason for me to say “get off my property” as you suggested. You also mis-characterized the reason for removing the material. It is not that the recipient shouldn’t read that material. It is that such material was distributed illegally. If someone removed only material that he objected to but left material that he did not object to, such a person would be acting hypocritically. To be consistent about it, one would have to be just as willing to remove illegally-placed flyers from his own church as literature from some other church. So let’s stop talking about the content of the material because it truly is not relevant here.
Ok, well maybe you’ll get to see what your reaction is when you find some creepy meddler removing things off your mailbox. That would be just.
Oh, and if it’s at the curb, you can remove “trespassing” from my list of trespasses…although I reckon most folks consider their mailbox their property. I do, and you better keep your meddling hands off of it.

And the scenario was NOT misrepresented. The OP removed it specifically so the persons would not read what he considered to be bad stuff. NOT because it had been placed illegally. That was another lame excuse someone else came up to justify meddling, stealing, and general creepy behavior.
 
Ok, well maybe you’ll get to see what your reaction is when you find some creepy meddler removing things off your mailbox.
Creepy Meddler?

What is this, scooby doo?

I would have got away with it too if it wasn’t for those creepy meddlers and that dog!
 
Ok, well maybe you’ll get to see what your reaction is when you find some creepy meddler removing things off your mailbox…
I would shake his hand and thank him for saving me the trouble. Literature left on mailboxes is invariably junk. I have never seen anything worthwhile distributed that way.
 
Reasons?
How about trespassing. meddling. stealing.
GOD gave us free will. He didn’t intend for us to go around taking it away from others, censoring what they read, judging what they think is litter.
I just suggest with any due respect that people mind their own business.
Define trespassing, meddling, and stealing, and then explain why removing a pamphlet from the top of a mailbox would be doing so.

It seems fairly clear that no trespassing or stealing is taking place, and you’ve failed to give reasons so many times it’s getting awkward.

“Meddling”? What does that mean? Is it evil? Like someone else said, meddling could have prevented the Holocaust.
Scenario A: You arrive home and find some guy taking something off your mailbox. When you ask him what he’s doing, he says “Someone left this for you to read, but I’m taking it away because you shouldn’t be allowed to.”
No one here doesn’t think you’re allowed to read JW propaganda. You’re just erecting strawmen. Consider:

Scenario C You arrive home and find some guy putting something on your mailbox. When you ask him what he’s doing, he says, “This litter/pamphlet was left on public property, and I am cleaning it up. I don’t think it should be read.”

Scenario D You arrive home and find some guy putting something on your mailbox. When you ask him what he’s doing, he says, “I am leaving this for you because I think you need to read it.”
You might be inclined to say I’ll thank you for minding your own business, getting off my property, and not presuming to meddle in my affairs or censor or suggest what I should read"
You seem to think the fellow who has written a message on the public sidewalk with chalk is innocent of spreading unwanted propaganda while the fellow who washes it off is guilty of some kind of ill-defined censorship.

Dropping the pamphlet that no one has asked for is littering whether the property is private or public. There is nothing wrong with throwing it away. Suppose it is pornography. A fortiori, there is nothing wrong with throwing it away. It’s not wrong if the pamphlet is innocent and it’s not wrong if its harmful. If the postman sees it he will probably throw it away and/or call the cops.
 
D

No one here doesn’t think you’re allowed to read JW propaganda. You’re just erecting strawmen. Consider:

.
Actually, they do. Read some of the holier than thou arrogant prideful posts here from people who very much DO think that. No strawman. Read.
 
We are on a spiritual battlefield, friend. There is only one Truth, and that is Catholicism. We fighting for souls and there is no room for political correctness. Of course we wouldn’t want anyone throwing away Catholic literature, but the two things are not equal. Catholic literature is correct, JW literature is not.
Would you feel the same way about racist leaflets in a black neighborhood? Or Nazi Propaganda in the Jewish Ghettos?

Sometimes the best thing we can do for a neighbor is help them throw away the trash.😉

Porn would be handled the same way. And your eyes cannot unsee what you see.

I support throwing them away!
Again, Catholicism is correct, Islam is not. And slowing the spread of lies is not the same thing as stoning someone to death, nor is it “disrespecting” them, it is having concern for their souls. We are called to be our brothers’ keeper. And if knowing that the Catholic Church has the fullness of Truth and acting accordingly is arrogant, then I guess I’m arrogant.

And you may not be my friend, but I am yours.
For those who are unaware:

What we are talking about here are Jack Chick Tracts
Vile pieces of former trees that are littered around for the main purpose of bringing people away from the Truth. You can bet Jesus detests these evil tracts.
You can find them in grocery store bags, movie theater seats, windshields, etc.

JWs carpet bomb an area and canvas it with material.

A CA apologist wrote a book on the subject and infiltrated the JWs.

Personally, I engage JWs or Mormons whenever I can. Charitably and calmly. I invite them in and share the Gospel with them. I was raised Mormon so I am quite familiar with the teachings and scriptures. You can catch more flies with honey than vinegar though. So I invite them in ALWAYS, Offer them food and listen to what they have to say. Then I ask questions and steer the conversation to deeper theological questions. Jesus divinity for JWs and The Great Apostasy with Mormons.

It is LITERALLY opportunity knocking!

JWs print the Jack Chick Tracts knowing that they will be discarded in a most unpleasant manner. However if as some have pointed out you wish to abide by the strict letter of the law. Perhaps the best course of action for the OP would have been to prepare a presentation, wait about a week, go door to door in the neighborhood and say, I noticed some JW leaflets last week. Did you read it? I would like to talk to you about it.

Actually, that is a better way to deal with it. Something we all should think about.
More moral relativism. Understandable, since it is so infectious in our culture. But still wrong.

If everything is right, nothing is right. Truth cannot contradict Truth. Yes, I can prove Islam is incorrect, and Jehovah’s witnesses as well. Their “theology” is absolutely laughable.

This attitude that “well we don’t know for sure, so let’s act like everybody is right” is ridiculous, politically correct BS. Geez people, grow a pair.
I’m shocked people are still trying to justify this behavior. Not for me to judge, but wow. If you truly feel like this is OK, well 🤷
 
I’m shocked people are still trying to justify this behavior. Not for me to judge, but wow. If you truly feel like this is OK, well 🤷
With ya on that.
It’s disheartening to say the least.in people who consider themselves ethical.
Methinks they are…:confused:
 
With ya on that.
It’s disheartening to say the least.in people who consider themselves ethical.
Methinks they are…:confused:
Are you saying the above posters are unethical people? Hmmmm.
 
The actions they are advocating and justifying are.
No, they are not.

It is quite odd that you judge so heavily on this? I am curious if this translates to other areas where you might judge others. But I kind of don’t think so, I kinda think that you are not on the front lines of much more serious moral issues with the judgement.

I could be wrong, but I have not seen you so defensive on other threads about much more Catholic topics.🤷
 
No, they are not.

It is quite odd that you judge so heavily on this? I am curious if this translates to other areas where you might judge others. But I kind of don’t think so, I kinda think that you are not on the front lines of much more serious moral issues with the judgement.

I could be wrong, but I have not seen you so defensive on other threads about much more Catholic topics.🤷
You’re right…I am not particularly dogmatic.
What irks me about this is:
  1. It is petty, and profoundly disrespectful of the dignity and free will of others. And arrogant. (You are not qualified to determine what you should read. I am).
  2. It’s a violation of personal space and property. Your lawyer pals may say my mailbox is federal property, but it’s in my space. I think most people think of their mailboxes as theirs.
    As for all the horsehockey about who the pamphlets belong to, to me that’s moot. They don’t belong to the person taking them.
  3. Which brings up the third one, and that is, to see people contorting themselves to justify a wrong with such…moot points.
So…other related areas that might get my dander up: if I see someone bullying someone else (and this is a petty form of bullying in my opinion), violating someone else’s “sovereignty”, or treating them like they are somehow inferior…yeah, I will defend that it is wrong and suggest they MYOB.

Hope that explains my “defensiveness”.
 
You’re right…I am not particularly dogmatic.
What irks me about this is:
  1. It is petty, and profoundly disrespectful of the dignity and free will of others. And arrogant. (You are not qualified to determine what you should read. I am).
  2. It’s a violation of personal space and property. Your lawyer pals may say my mailbox is federal property, but it’s in my space. I think most people think of their mailboxes as theirs.
    As for all the horsehockey about who the pamphlets belong to, to me that’s moot. They don’t belong to the person taking them.
  3. Which brings up the third one, and that is, to see people contorting themselves to justify a wrong with such…moot points.
So…other related areas that might get my dander up: if I see someone bullying someone else (and this is a petty form of bullying in my opinion), violating someone else’s “sovereignty”, or treating them like they are somehow inferior…yeah, I will defend that it is wrong and suggest they MYOB.

Hope that explains my “defensiveness”.
I personally think you can make your argument and take the other side of this issue without the need for overstating your case. Which I feel you have done several times, calling others unethical, thieves, meddlesome, etc. And making this into some sort of human rights issue the UN should intervene in is downright odd. Extending this to the catch all “bullying” is just a modern propaganda term for “not nice” To do so does a disservice to people who actually are bullied, censored, and under the thumb of some sort of arrogant dictator. I respect your right to have an opinion. I even respect your right to be offended at the idea that someone might take a religious piece of trash from you. The same thing that you would throw away. But you feel you need to exercise that right to make it mean something.🤷 Ok. But overstating your case and having a spittle flecked nutty about some “meddlesome” person is odd. To me, personally it indicates someone who holds to a political ideology above a religious one.
 
I personally think you can make your argument and take the other side of this issue without the need for overstating your case. Which I feel you have done several times, calling others unethical, thieves, meddlesome, etc. And making this into some sort of human rights issue the UN should intervene in is downright odd. Extending this to the catch all “bullying” is just a modern propaganda term for “not nice” To do so does a disservice to people who actually are bullied, censored, and under the thumb of some sort of arrogant dictator. I respect your right to have an opinion. I even respect your right to be offended at the idea that someone might take a religious piece of trash from you. The same thing that you would throw away. But you feel you need to exercise that right to make it mean something.🤷 Ok. But overstating your case and having a spittle flecked nutty about some “meddlesome” person is odd. To me, personally it indicates someone who holds to a political ideology above a religious one.
Who said anything about the UN?
And I assure you no spittle flecking is involved (on my end).
Given those tho, reading your post accusing me of “overstating” is amusing…🙂

Bullying is not a catchall, and has nothing to do with politics (huh?:confused:).
However, it was undoubtedly the wrong term for me to use. By way of explanation, I recognize “the soft bigotry of low expectations” as an insidious form of racism…and so unwanted incursions seemed to fit as a form of insidious or soft bullying. But I see that’s a stretch, so I withdraw it.
I guess Meddling is better after all.
🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top