Did we just kill a kid?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Maracuya
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Maracuya

Guest
’Did we just kill a kid?’: The moment drone operator who assassinated Afghans with the push of a button on a computer in the U.S. followed orders to shoot a child… and decided he had to quit…

A
former U.S. drone operator has opened up about the toll of killing scores of innocent people by pressing a button from a control room in New Mexico.
Brandon Bryant, 27, from Missoula, Montana, spent six years in the Air Force operating Predator drones from inside a dark container.
But, after following orders to shoot and kill a child in Afghanistan, he knew he couldn’t keep doing what he was doing and quit the military.

Bryant joined the military by accident when he accompanied a friend who was enlisting in the army and heard that he could go to university for free if he signed up to the Air Force.
He excelled in his course and was assigned to an intelligence collection unit where he soon learned how to control the cameras and lasers on a drone, to analyse ground images, maps and weather data.
He was made a sensor operator, the equivalent of co-pilot, and at just 20 flew his first mission over Iraq - seated in the safety of a control room in Nevada.

But it began to take its toll immediately.
The first time he fired a missile, he killed two men instantly and cried on his way home.
‘I felt disconnected from humanity for almost a week,’ he said.
But it was an incident when a Predator drone was circling above a flat-roofed house made of mud in Afghanistan, more than 6,250 miles away, that really sticks in his mind.

The hut had a shed used to hold goats and when he received the order to fire, he pressed a button with his left hand and marked the roof with a laser.

The pilot sitting next to him pressed the trigger on a joystick, causing the drone to launch a Hellfire missile. There were 16 seconds left until impact.

‘These moments are like in slow motion,’ he told the website.
As the countdown reached seven seconds, there was no sign of anyone on the ground.
Bryant could still have diverted the missile at that point.

But when it was down to three seconds, a child suddenly walked around the corner.
The next thing he saw was a flash on the screen - the explosion. The building collapsed, and the child disappeared.

Bryant had a sick feeling in his stomach, he told the website.
‘Did we just kill a kid?’ he asked the pilot next to him.
‘Yeah, I guess that was a kid,’ the man replied.

Thoughts jotted in his diary on uneventful days clearly show the heavy burden his job was placing on him.

‘On the battlefield there are no sides, just bloodshed. Total war. Every horror witnessed. I wish my eyes would rot,’ he wrote on one occasion.
He began to shut himself off from his friends, and his girlfriend complained about his bad moods.

‘I can’t just switch and go back to normal life,’ he said to her. He stopped sleeping and began to exercise instead.

One day he collapsed at work, doubling over and spitting blood. The doctor ordered him to stay home, and not to return to work until he could sleep more than four hours a night for two weeks in a row.

‘Half a year later, I was back in the cockpit, flying drones,’ Bryant told Spiegel Online.
But he was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder.
Now Bryant has left the military and is living back at home in Montana where he feels he is slowly recuperating.

‘I haven’t been dreaming in infrared for four months,’ he said with a smile.

Source

Where is BO and his tears for all these mutilated and not longer here children?..
This make me sick!
😦
 
’Did we just kill a kid?’: The moment drone operator who assassinated Afghans with the push of a button on a computer in the U.S. followed orders to shoot a child… and decided he had to quit…

A
former U.S. drone operator has opened up about the toll of killing scores of innocent people by pressing a button from a control room in New Mexico.
Brandon Bryant, 27, from Missoula, Montana, spent six years in the Air Force operating Predator drones from inside a dark container.
But, after following orders to shoot and kill a child in Afghanistan, he knew he couldn’t keep doing what he was doing and quit the military.

Bryant joined the military by accident when he accompanied a friend who was enlisting in the army and heard that he could go to university for free if he signed up to the Air Force.
He excelled in his course and was assigned to an intelligence collection unit where he soon learned how to control the cameras and lasers on a drone, to analyse ground images, maps and weather data.
He was made a sensor operator, the equivalent of co-pilot, and at just 20 flew his first mission over Iraq - seated in the safety of a control room in Nevada.

But it began to take its toll immediately.
The first time he fired a missile, he killed two men instantly and cried on his way home.
‘I felt disconnected from humanity for almost a week,’ he said.
But it was an incident when a Predator drone was circling above a flat-roofed house made of mud in Afghanistan, more than 6,250 miles away, that really sticks in his mind.

The hut had a shed used to hold goats and when he received the order to fire, he pressed a button with his left hand and marked the roof with a laser.

The pilot sitting next to him pressed the trigger on a joystick, causing the drone to launch a Hellfire missile. There were 16 seconds left until impact.

‘These moments are like in slow motion,’ he told the website.
As the countdown reached seven seconds, there was no sign of anyone on the ground.
Bryant could still have diverted the missile at that point.

But when it was down to three seconds, a child suddenly walked around the corner.
The next thing he saw was a flash on the screen - the explosion. The building collapsed, and the child disappeared.

Bryant had a sick feeling in his stomach, he told the website.
‘Did we just kill a kid?’ he asked the pilot next to him.
‘Yeah, I guess that was a kid,’ the man replied.

Thoughts jotted in his diary on uneventful days clearly show the heavy burden his job was placing on him.

‘On the battlefield there are no sides, just bloodshed. Total war. Every horror witnessed. I wish my eyes would rot,’ he wrote on one occasion.
He began to shut himself off from his friends, and his girlfriend complained about his bad moods.

‘I can’t just switch and go back to normal life,’ he said to her. He stopped sleeping and began to exercise instead.

One day he collapsed at work, doubling over and spitting blood. The doctor ordered him to stay home, and not to return to work until he could sleep more than four hours a night for two weeks in a row.

‘Half a year later, I was back in the cockpit, flying drones,’ Bryant told Spiegel Online.
But he was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder.
Now Bryant has left the military and is living back at home in Montana where he feels he is slowly recuperating.

‘I haven’t been dreaming in infrared for four months,’ he said with a smile.

Source

Where is BO and his tears for all these mutilated and not longer here children?..
This make me sick! 😦
I think it’s important for us in the west to keep in mind how many innocent children are killed by our armed forces - probably some in schools - and just considered “collateral damage”. These are real people with real families and real lives. The innocents likely always live in a state of disbelief and mourning not unlike the state of mourning we are currently feeling due to the senseless slaughter of innocent children in Connecticut. It makes one think…
 
I think it’s important for us in the west to keep in mind how many innocent children are killed by our armed forces - probably some in schools - and just considered “collateral damage”. These are real people with real families and real lives. The innocents likely always live in a state of disbelief and mourning not unlike the state of mourning we are currently feeling due to the senseless slaughter of innocent children in Connecticut. It makes one think…
If the ROE in Afghanistan is the same or similar to the ROE I operated under in Iraq than schools with kids in them are pretty much off limits for combat operations (you’d have to have a really really really good reason for conducting a combat op at a school and get said op approved by higher). And, unlike what happened in Connecticut, soldiers don’t intentionally target kids. The only commonality between what is going on in Afghanistan and what happened in Connecticut is that innocent people died.

As for the deaths of innocent people being just “collateral damage,” the only soldiers who held that view that I’ve come across are those that do so because it is a coping mechanism for some of the stuff that they’ve had to do or endure as they fulfill the mission given to them by the citizens of the United States.
 
If I remember the statistics from some uninvolved (non-military) observers, about 17 innocents are killed for every “terrorist” that is killed. That also does not take into account the number of innocents killed by our forces on the ground who often take out their frustrations by spraying lead at the locals.

Our troops should not be there in the first place.
There are a lot of government officials who will have a tough time on Judgement Day.
 
Oh yes, but let’s all just hand in our guns to the same government that kills innocents to try and get the bad guys, whom the government was arming 20 years ago.
 
If I remember the statistics from some uninvolved (non-military) observers, about 17 innocents are killed for every “terrorist” that is killed. That also does not take into account the number of innocents killed by our forces on the ground who often take out their frustrations by spraying lead at the locals.

Our troops should not be there in the first place.
There are a lot of government officials who will have a tough time on Judgement Day.
I’d like to see where your source for “often take out their frustrations by spraying lead at the locals.” Also, said government officials are in office and continue to be in office by the consent of the people. If you comment about Judgement Day is correct, they won’t be alone.
 
Our guys very seldom shoot without orders. So I don’t get where the notion of a bunch of GIs going around getting their frustrations out by murdering locals is coming from. Usually happens the other way around with Afgan forces shooting at GIs.

As far as more civilians killed then terrorists, that is not accurate. More information is here
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drone_attacks_in_Pakistan#Civilian_casualties
 
If the ROE in Afghanistan is the same or similar to the ROE I operated under in Iraq than schools with kids in them are pretty much off limits for combat operations (you’d have to have a really really really good reason for conducting a combat op at a school and get said op approved by higher). And, unlike what happened in Connecticut, soldiers don’t intentionally target kids. The only commonality between what is going on in Afghanistan and what happened in Connecticut is that innocent people died.

As for the deaths of innocent people being just “collateral damage,” the only soldiers who held that view that I’ve come across are those that do so because it is a coping mechanism for some of the stuff that they’ve had to do or endure as they fulfill the mission given to them by the citizens of the United States.
It’s a philosophical question of whether an end justifies objectively evil means.

mda
 
I hope people are ready when these guys are discharged and prepare to live “normal” lives.😦
 
Drones are the warfare weapons of the future, like it or not. They mean less pilot deaths.

The military is testing pilotless figher planes now.
 
Drones are the warfare weapons of the future, like it or not.

The military is testing pilotless figher planes now.
Sadly what the gentleman in the article experienced isn’t new. Bomber and ground attack pilots have been dealing with the type of disconnect this gentleman dealt with since world war 2. Thankfully the military is now treating PTSD as a serious issue.
 
And, unlike what happened in Connecticut, soldiers don’t intentionally target kids. The only commonality between what is going on in Afghanistan and what happened in Connecticut is that innocent people died.
Certainly some soldiers do target kids. Some in the military are sick, evil men the same as outside the military. These men have more opportunity because they can conceal their evil deeds as accidents. Some join the military precisely because it is an opportunity to blow stuff up, shoot guns and even kill people. One problem is the military is part of the governing authority so we can’t know precisely how much targeting of children occurs because the government is not trustworthy and tends to lie and cover up.
 
Certainly some soldiers do target kids. Some in the military are sick, evil men the same as outside the military. These men have more opportunity because they can conceal their evil deeds as accidents. Some join the military precisely because it is an opportunity to blow stuff up, shoot guns and even kill people. One problem is the military is part of the governing authority so we can’t know precisely how much targeting of children occurs because the government is not trustworthy and tends to lie and cover up.
If we are using broad generalizations and a general application of reason than yes such individuals can and probably do exist within the military. I’d add, though, that such individuals lasting long in the military or being in a position to carry out such attacks have a low probability given how the military and military culture works.

Once again using broad generalizations and a general application of reason, I’m sure the possibility of such events being covered up (by the local command, higher command, or the “government”) exists. However, given the international and national political and media focus on the war and the ready access to social media by the soldiers, the enemy, and the civilian populace of Afghanistan I’d say the ability to cover up such events is severally limited.
 
If I remember the statistics from some uninvolved (non-military) observers, about 17 innocents are killed for every “terrorist” that is killed. That also does not take into account the number of innocents killed by our forces on the ground who often take out their frustrations by spraying lead at the locals.
See The Independent and Business Insider.
 
It’s a philosophical question of whether an end justifies objectively evil means.

mda
As a Catholic, you should understand that the Church does not and never has taught that war is in and of itself objectively evil.

Targeting civilians is wrong, even in the course of a just war, but the US military bends over backwards to minimize civilian deaths. In fact, the Geneva conventions contain clear rules about non-military combatants designed to minimize civilian deaths. Terrorist do nit follow these rules, prefering instead to hide among their own civilans for their own protection but endangerment of those among whom they hide.
 
’Did we just kill a kid?’: The moment drone operator who assassinated Afghans with the push of a button on a computer in the U.S. followed orders to shoot a child… and decided he had to quit…

…
This is very sad, and i hope that the military sees and acts quickly to help those who suffer from doing this kind of work. It seems that PTSD is not just because the soldiers are in constant danger…

That being said, the orders were not to kill a child. The orders were to shoot a military target (not mentioned) and unfortunately a child was there.
 
’Did we just kill a kid?’: The moment drone operator who assassinated Afghans with the push of a button on a computer in the U.S. followed orders to shoot a child… and decided he had to quit…

Source

Where is BO and his tears for all these mutilated and not longer here children?..
This make me sick! 😦
Christopher Check, writing in Catholic Answers Magazine, writes the following on the issue of “distance” in war:

In his thought-provoking 1995 work, On Killing, retired Army Ranger Lt. Col. Dave Grossman examines the extent to which physical distance creates emotional distance from the act of taking a human life. He shows with numbers what we know intuitively: A soldier is more likely to resist driving his knife into an enemy soldier’s abdomen than a bomber pilot is to resist dropping a bomb on a civilian neighborhood. He reports that despite all of the historical evidence of soldiers’ unwillingness to kill in hand-to-hand combat or with their rifles from within a line-of-sight range, he did not find a single incident in which a soldier refused to fire a long-range weapon such as an artillery piece or missile launcher—nor did he find a pilot or bombardier unwilling to drop his bombs.

More unsettling, while psychological trauma is not uncommon among infantrymen who have been in close combat, Col. Grossman did not find “a single instance of psychiatric trauma” associated with long-range killing. That includes the pilot and crew of the Enola Gay, the B-29 Super Fortress that dropped “Little Boy” on the people of Hiroshima. Indeed, Enola Gay’s pilot, Col. Paul Tibbets, went to his death claiming that he never felt guilt or lost sleep over having dropped the atomic bomb on Hiroshima. Indeed, he flew reenactments of the event at air shows.

Grossman provides eerily antiseptic testimony given by Allied bomber pilots and crews who firebombed Hamburg, Dresden, and Tokyo. These campaigns together claimed the lives of nearly 400,000 noncombatants, mostly women, children, and elderly (because men of fighting age were off fighting). The bombers reported feeling “fascination” and “satisfaction” but not guilt or regret.

Grossman’s argument should provoke us to ask if many people’s comfort with the bomb does not derive, at least in part, from a condition of distance from the event. The bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki killed an estimated 180,000 civilians. Would supporters of the bombings be as sanguine if a battalion of Marines had been sent into the same cities to bayonet an equal number of women, children, and elderly? (catholic.com/magazine/articles/dropping-the-atomic-bomb-was-wrong-period)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top