To summarize then: According to the National Journal’s research, upwards of half of all prisoners at Guantanamo weren’t captured on the battlefield. Rather, they came into our custody by way of third parties “who had their own motivations for turning people in, including paybacks and payoffs.” Many — perhaps most — of the men rounded up in these sweeps have no connection to al-Qaeda or the Taliban, and the evidence against them is often weak, sometimes nonexistent, and all too frequently known to be fabricated. And yet they remain in prison.
