Do angels and demons have free will?

  • Thread starter Thread starter stephie_venuto
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

stephie_venuto

Guest
Hello!

I saw another thread on this topic, and I read through the responses, but I wasn’t able to find a very clear answer. I know all the angels were tested, and using free will, they made a decision to either reject God or serve God, but do angels and demons currently have free will?

Thank you!
  • Stephie
 
Did. Don’t now. From the catechism:
392 Scripture speaks of a sin of these angels.269 This “fall” consists in the free choice of these created spirits, who radically and irrevocably rejected God and his reign. We find a reflection of that rebellion in the tempter’s words to our first parents: "You will be like God."270 The devil “has sinned from the beginning”; he is “a liar and the father of lies”.
414 Satan or the devil and the other demons are fallen angels who have freely refused to serve God and his plan. Their choice against God is definitive. They try to associate man in their revolt against God.
Angels had one chance to decide for God. Once they decided, they cannot change their decision.
 
Angels, like the saints in Heaven are at one with God’s Will - they have in effect volunteered their free-will back to God.

In a similar but Demonic way, Demons/Fallen Angels have ‘volunteered’ their ‘free-will’ to Satan’s Will.
 
Angels, like the saints in Heaven are at one with God’s Will - they have in effect volunteered their free-will back to God.

In a similar but Demonic way, Demons/Fallen Angels have ‘volunteered’ their ‘free-will’ to Satan’s Will.
Pax Christi!

And satan ain’t changing. I suppose angels can have trivial free will (as long as God doesn’t care: “Maybe I’ll wear my blue wings today and sing this hymn rather than that one”.)

God bless.
 
Angels, like the saints in Heaven are at one with God’s Will - they have in effect volunteered their free-will back to God.

In a similar but Demonic way, Demons/Fallen Angels have ‘volunteered’ their ‘free-will’ to Satan’s Will.
Pax Christi!

And satan ain’t changing. I suppose angels can have trivial free will (as long as God doesn’t care: “Maybe I’ll wear my blue wings today and sing this hymn rather than that one”.)

God bless.
 
Hello!

I saw another thread on this topic, and I read through the responses, but I wasn’t able to find a very clear answer. I know all the angels were tested, and using free will, they made a decision to either reject God or serve God, but do angels and demons currently have free will?

Thank you!
  • Stephie
I believe angels in heaven, just like the other saints there, have free will. But being in heaven they see God face to face and therefore would only use their freewill to choose the love of God. Every other choice other than God, would seem terribly ugly to them, and so never would sin.

I believe it is almost the same with the fallen angels in hell. They hate God so much that they would never chose God but chose to remain away from him. Their hearts have been hardened.
 
I believe angels in heaven, just like the other saints there, have free will. But being in heaven they see God face to face and therefore would only use their freewill to choose the love of God. Every other choice other than God, would seem terribly ugly to them, and so never would sin.

I believe it is almost the same with the fallen angels in hell. They hate God so much that they would never chose God but chose to remain away from him. Their hearts have been hardened.
The Church teaches that angels no longer have their free will. They decided at the time of the rebellion in heaven whom they would serve forever. That is a permanent, single time decision. Otherwise, there would be the potential for chaos in heaven,and vast numbers of angels could further revolt, which is not consistent with the Apocalypse.
 
They did have free will but unlike us they knew completely everything about God and so the bad were cast out straight away.
 
I know the saints have free will. Jesus says in the Revelations of Saint Bridget that the saints in Heaven follow all his will and that one of his wills is that they do whatever they please (but they don’t sin). I don’t know about the angels, but possibly they, too can do whatever they want.
 
Angels and demons have free will.

They are different than us because they are spiritual beings and exist outside of time. Because time does not exist for them, they can’t change their will. A decision made once is continuous.
 
Hello!

I saw another thread on this topic, and I read through the responses, but I wasn’t able to find a very clear answer. I know all the angels were tested, and using free will, they made a decision to either reject God or serve God, but do angels and demons currently have free will?

Thank you!
  • Stephie
Code:
 Angelic beings were created with infused knowledge.  All knowledge that is/was  necessary for them to be saved was given to them when they were created. Their intellects are far superior to ours.  Angelic spirits are not affected by passions
There will is irrevocable fixed in their choice.for or against God. The angels that followed Satan knew and understood fully the oonsequences of their evil choice.
Code:
Humans learn in steps and we also are affected by passions. We learn in steps.  As long as our bodies of flesh and bone are living God grants us if we ask the graces of reconciliation.   One we die our spirit is frozen in the state of grace in which we die.

 That is how I understand it.  I suggest going to the Vatican website and read through the Catechism of the the Catholic Church that is hosted there.
 
The Church teaches that angels no longer have their free will. .
That is not exactly a correct statement.

The Church teaches that angels and demons are not temporal beings. They, like God exist outside of time.

When we refer to Free Will in the sense of the OP, there is a connotation of being able to change one’s will, which implies a temporal existence.

The angels and demons, at the moment of their creation, were endowed will all the knowledge they will ever have. Of the whole of existence to the extent possible for a creature. They, like God, exist in one eternal moment.

Therefore, they will learn nothing ‘new’ as ‘new’ is a temporal term. Their will is free, but not changeable, as ‘change’ requires a temporal existence.
 
It would strike me that they still retain free will but since they cannot acquire more knowledge (they know everything they can know at the moment of their creation) they would refuse to change their decision. Being a spiritual being I imagine a majority of decisions would appear more black and white compared to the grey we muddle through. You either are constantly glorifying God and doing his will or your not.

Just my:twocents:

God Bless
 
Once the angelic beings who chose God, they became engaged in the Beatified Vision of God. Once a creature, such as those saintly souls in the Communion of Saints, becomes engaged in the state of the Beatified Vision of God they simply can do no evil.
Code:
 The demons have learned from observing us humans from Adam & Eve in the Garden. So they learn some things no doubt about that.   They hate humans but especially baby humans.  If God didn't hold them back they would kill every last one of us, quickly. So they observe us, learn our weaknesses, even see our sinful behavior, and then use it against us.

   The Holy Angels love God, and we were created in the image of God as worded in the long version of the prayer to St. Michael:
“Glorious Prince of the heavenly militia, St. Michael the Archangel, defend us in battle against the powers of darkness and their spiritual malice. Come to the aid of men created by God in his image and likeness, and redeemed at a great price from the tyranny of the devil.”
Code:
What is important from this is:  The very most important concern for our Salvation is that we stay in a state of Good Grace avoiding all sin as best we can.  We should daily examine our consciences and go to sacramental Confession or the sacrament of Reconciliation as often as possible.

  This is because after our bodies die, our will becomes fixed. We die in good graces we are SAVED. We die otherwise, may God have mercy on us and not let this be, because if we die in mortal sin unrepentant we go to Hell, literally.  Pope John Paul II wrote:
John Paul II, Redemptor Hominis (# 13), March 4, 1979: “ We are dealing with each man, for each one is included in the mystery of the Redemption and with each one Christ has united Himself forever through this mystery.”

John Paul II, Redemptoris Missio (# 4), Dec. 7, 1990: “ The Redemption event brings salvation to all, ‘for each one is included in the mystery of the Redemption and with each one Christ has united himself forever through this mystery.’”

John Paul II, Centesimus Annus (# 53): “ We are not dealing here with man in the ‘abstract,’ but with the real, ‘concrete,’ ‘ historical’ man. We are dealing with each individual, since each one is included in the mystery of the Redemption and through this mystery Christ has united himself with each one forever.”
Code:
     Some miss interpret this claiming that the Holy Father is writing of Universal Salvation.  This is not the case at all.   For those who die in a good state of Grace, God's Love is Heaven.  For those who die in mortal sin unrepentantly, God's Love is an enternal state of a fiery Hell.  

     Sorry going off topic.
 
The Church teaches that angels no longer have their free will. They decided at the time of the rebellion in heaven whom they would serve forever. That is a permanent, single time decision. Otherwise, there would be the potential for chaos in heaven,and vast numbers of angels could further revolt, which is not consistent with the Apocalypse.
I have been searching and searching for an answer to free will in the next world and what happens to it. And I found this in Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, p.484.

“On the ground of teaching of Revelation it is to be infered, that the will of the damned is immovably hardened in evil and is, therefore, inaccesable to any true repentance. The reason is that God refuses all further grace to the damned.” Cf. S. th. I II 85, 2 ad 3; Suppl. 98,2. 5.6.

So according to this, free will is still in those in hell but cannot change.

I would say it would be the same for those in heaven, that they would experience such love and glory that their will would be unchangable in a similar way.

Free will is a part of man’s nature. It would be difficult to conceive that this very thing that is him would now be taken from him. It is the very thing that brought him to where he is in the next life. I dosen’t seem that it would now be withdrawn.

However if you have some documentation on this I would appreciate it.

May God bless and keep you. May God’s face shine on you. May God be kind to you and give you peace.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top