Do Catholics still support Trump part 2

  • Thread starter Thread starter dvdjs
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

dvdjs

Guest
Continuing the discussion from Do Catholics still support Trump:
from what standpoint? subjective truth or objective truth
Objective. Subjective truth is oxymoronic.
the ccc. the death penalty should rarely be used. how we define rarely is negotiable. rarely does not mean never.
This is wrong.

You are wrong about this. Here is what the CCC, which you do not quite, says:
2267 Assuming that the guilty party’s identity and responsibility have been fully determined, the traditional teaching of the Church does not exclude recourse to the death penalty, if this is the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against the unjust aggressor.

If, however, non-lethal means are sufficient to defend and protect people’s safety from the aggressor, authority will limit itself to such means, as these are more in keeping with the concrete conditions of the common good and more in conformity to the dignity of the human person.

Today, in fact, as a consequence of the possibilities which the state has for effectively preventing crime, by rendering one who has committed an offense incapable of doing harm - without definitely taking away from him the possibility of redeeming himself - the cases in which the execution of the offender is an absolute necessity “are very rare, if not practically nonexistent.”

It does not say to we negotiate over its rare use. It says its use today is rarely, if ever, not evil.
 
Part 1 was such a rousing success. I mean, look how many people actually changed their position! I know of no other thread that provided over 3000 posts with, I think, 3 distinct viewpoints.
 
The then-prefect of the CDF (Cardinal Ratzinger) said that Catholics are at liberty to have differing opinions about how frequently the death penalty should be used.

If anything, we use it far too infrequently. Obviously it will have no effect on deterrence if it’s used only once in a thousand cases.
 
Well yes, but if that’s the justification, then tax evaders and rapists should be executed as well. What I’d like to see is actual evidence that capital punishment brings down murder rates.
 
On the other hand, there are gang members who order murders from their prison cells. I’m not pushing the death penalty here, but I am saying simply imprisoning people does not necessarily deter them from committing further crimes.
 
Excellent question. I have long thought Pope JPII never finished his statement about how little the death penalty could be necessary. He would be right in the U.S. at least if we spent a lot more on prisons, particularly supermax prisons where deadly prisoners have no unvetted outside contact and no access to other prisoners. I guess we would have to add cryptographers as well, as I understand the Aryan Nations is able to very skillfully encrypt kill orders in otherwise innocent-seeming letters, and does do that.
 
Last edited:
40.png
Arkansan:
The then-prefect of the CDF (Cardinal Ratzinger) said that Catholics are at liberty to have differing opinions about how frequently the death penalty should be used.
Source? …
I generally assume that people know how to use Google:

http://www.ewtn.com/library/curia/cdfworthycom.htm

“There may be a legitimate diversity of opinion even among Catholics about waging war and applying the death penalty”
 
I generally assume that people know how to use Google:
If I had used google on your phrase
“at liberty to have differing opinions about how frequently the death penalty should be used”.

I would not have come across the document that you linked, which, I think is more nuanced, than being “at liberty”.
 
The fact that (supposing the criticisms you referenced to be correct) no one has done a valid study on the subject isn’t evidence for your view. It’s evidence that no one has done a valid study on the subject.

States that have the DP also have higher crime rates in general, higher rates of poverty, and larger black populations than the country as a whole. Unless you’re suggesting that all of those factors (which dispose for high murder rates) are caused by the DP, the correlation between DP use and high murder rates is meaningless.
 
Which is the chicken and which is the egg? Do states with high murder rates resort to capital punishment out of desperation (however misguided it might be) or does the existence of the DP cause murders to increase?

Seems to me it really has to be the former.
 
Well yes, but if that’s the justification, then tax evaders and rapists should be executed as well. What I’d like to see is actual evidence that capital punishment brings down murder rates.
I expect it’s biggest value today is as DA leverage when plea bargaining for a confession, and saving the cost of a trial.
 
if it was evil, it would be evil anywhere. if the death penalty was evil they would not allow it at all.
This is the mistaken idea that I am trying to dispel.
Abortion is intrinsically evil. It is, in every circumstance, sinful
Sex is not intrinsically evil in many circumstances is is healthy and blessed; in others it is gravely sinful.
The sinfulness in those latter circumstances is not mitigated or consigned prudential judgment, bacuase fo the blessedness in other circumstances. In those later circumstances it is evil in every occurrence, like abortion. Likewise with the death penalty.
 
The sinfulness in those latter circumstances is not mitigated or consigned prudential judgment, bacuase fo the blessedness in other circumstances. In those later circumstances it is evil in every occurrence, like abortion. Likewise with the death penalty.
The fact that the person you’re having sex with is or is not your spouses changes the very object of the act, it isn’t simply a “circumstance”. The death penalty analogue would be to execution of the guilty vs. the innocent. That’s not to say that circumstantial considerations aren’t relevant to the morality of executing criminals (or having sex with one’s spouse), but such don’t render the action intrinsically evil. “Intrinsically evil” isn’t just a fancy term for sin, it’s a category of it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top