Do LDS baptize converts immediately?

  • Thread starter Thread starter adawgj
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
And many LDS-converts leave the Mormon church within the first year. And, AFAIK, almost all African American converts leave once they find out what the Mormons actually teach about them.
My wife introduced me to an African-American Mormon recently. I didn’t ask because I didn’t want to seem rude, but I was very curious how he could reconcile his faith and race. I just don’t understand how you can know what “prophets” like Brigham Young have said about blacks and still be OK with it all. If LDS prophets “will never lead the church astray” then… how are you ok with that? Well, rationalization is a powerful thing.
 
Our Catholic backwater has about 400 a year who are baptized at Easter. Many who are former LDS. Still, there could be more. We need so many people in RCIA that we can’t handle them all. Seriously!

The number of Catholics who no longer practice increases, and they don’t have their children baptized. Those children grow up, and some come looking for the faith their family once practiced.
I ran into the Director of Religious Education and got the official Easter Vigil tally. 33 total. 21 baptized including the infant of one of the elect. 12 candidates confirmed. Out of the 21 baptized, 3 are former LDS - a woman from my old stake (we didn’t know each other until we met in RCIA) and two of her children. :extrahappy:
 
Yes, and a lot of it has to do with how missionaries are instructed to convert. The goal is, in the shortest amount of time possible, to get them to feel good about the message, have them acknowledge that it feels good, tell them that it is the Holy Ghost witnessing to them that it’s true, and then commit them to baptism.

It’s important to baptize them while they still have this good feeling, otherwise it may fade and they will be more susceptible to changing their mind.

At least that’s what was continually reinforced when I was a missionary.
There is a fundamental problem here of course between our two views. You would say it is not the Holy Ghost, just some false good feeling, and I would say it is. If it is the Holy Ghost whispering truth then I see no problem being baptized within a short span of time. If it is not then all the evidence, training, and waiting in the world is not a sufficient reason to be baptized.
 
My wife introduced me to an African-American Mormon recently. I didn’t ask because I didn’t want to seem rude, but I was very curious how he could reconcile his faith and race. I just don’t understand how you can know what “prophets” like Brigham Young have said about blacks and still be OK with it all. If LDS prophets “will never lead the church astray” then… how are you ok with that? Well, rationalization is a powerful thing.
Not every last word the president of the church says is true. They are directed by God, they hold the keys, and they are his witnesses, but they are men and can err or be misunderstood. As always, a person must follow the spirit of the Lord. This is fundamental to our teaching. It is why a person enters the waters of baptism and it is what keeps them engaged through all the difficult challenges they face.

Elder Christofferson, one of the twelve apostles said it so well:
It is His [God’s] plan and His will that we have the principal decision-making role in our own life’s drama. God will not live our lives for us nor control us as if we were His puppets, as Lucifer once proposed to do. Nor will His prophets accept the role of “puppet master” in God’s place. Brigham Young stated: “I do not wish any Latter Day Saint in this world, nor in heaven, to be satisfied with anything I do, unless the Spirit of the Lord Jesus Christ,—the spirit of revelation, makes them satisfied. I wish them to know for themselves and understand for themselves.” (“Free Forever, to Act for Themselves”, Ensign Oct 2014)
 
There is a fundamental problem here of course between our two views. You would say it is not the Holy Ghost, just some false good feeling, and I would say it is. If it is the Holy Ghost whispering truth then I see no problem being baptized within a short span of time. If it is not then all the evidence, training, and waiting in the world is not a sufficient reason to be baptized.
Time should be spent discerning whether it’s just feeling good or the Holy Spirit, pushing people to make commitments before they’ve had time for reflection is like all the connotations associated with used car salesmen.
 
When I was the Lay Director of RCIA (18 years), I would tell all inquirers from the very beginning that absolutely no topic was out of bounds.

**Just doing a quick scan of the records before I left, we had over 200 people come through, and complete RCIA, with about an 80% retention.

We’ve even had a few converts go on to become priests, and religious brothers and sisters.
**
Our particular RCIA program was noticed by the Bishop, and most of our program became the standard for our diocese.

I can’t tell you how many times people would comment on how they were impressed with how open and frank we are/were about sensitive issues.

ETA: I would also like to mention, that every inquirer was also told there were no pressure tactics employed. You can quit at any time, just let us know, we’ll say a quick prayer, send you on your way, and not hound you.

The only exception would be if you came up to me 5 minutes before the Easter Vigil and try to back out. You are NOT messing up my seating chart or exit procession. 😃
How very cool is that! (the bold). You certainly have a very successful RCIA program there.
 
There is a fundamental problem here of course between our two views. You would say it is not the Holy Ghost, just some false good feeling, and I would say it is. If it is the Holy Ghost whispering truth then I see no problem being baptized within a short span of time. If it is not then all the evidence, training, and waiting in the world is not a sufficient reason to be baptized.
So if I had a good feeling about leaving the LDS church that I ascribed to being the Holy Ghost whispering the truth to me, would you agree? If not, what would it be?
 
So if I had a good feeling about leaving the LDS church that I ascribed to being the Holy Ghost whispering the truth to me, would you agree? If not, what would it be?
I would bet he would say it was Satan pretending to be the Holy Spirit or Ghost. Or do the LDS have another name/persona/concept of the evil one?
 
No, Mormon has been able to answer my question. It is ignored just a you did.
Perhaps I misunderstood the question. Were you asking how I know it’s the HG? I thought you were asking how I knew Taylorf’s thoughts.
 
So if I had a good feeling about leaving the LDS church that I ascribed to being the Holy Ghost whispering the truth to me, would you agree? If not, what would it be?
I would never presume to question your experience. It’s yours, not mine. We might come to more of an understanding if we talked in detail but I think this is not the forum.

However, I will comment on the HG in general, and some common misunderstandings. Impressions from the HG are much more than “good feelings”. In fact, a good feeling may lead a person down many wrong paths. We may watch a certain movie and have a good feeling or hear someone speak and have a good feeling, this is not necessarily an impression from the HG. The truth is if we don’t search deep we may even commit sin and have a good feeling for a short time. The reason is because the HG is not a feeling. The HG is provides pure intelligence. Joseph Smith said it this way, “The Holy Ghost has no other effect than pure intelligence” (TPJS p 149). Of course, such light and understanding may then trigger our emotions. But don’t mistake the HG, it is felt as intelligence pure and simple. It flows from inside us and we know.
 
I would never presume to question your experience. It’s yours, not mine. We might come to more of an understanding if we talked in detail but I think this is not the forum.

However, I will comment on the HG in general, and some common misunderstandings. Impressions from the HG are much more than “good feelings”. In fact, a good feeling may lead a person down many wrong paths. We may watch a certain movie and have a good feeling or hear someone speak and have a good feeling, this is not necessarily an impression from the HG. The truth is if we don’t search deep we may even commit sin and have a good feeling for a short time. The reason is because the HG is not a feeling. The HG is provides pure intelligence. Joseph Smith said it this way, “The Holy Ghost has no other effect than pure intelligence” (TPJS p 149). Of course, such light and understanding may then trigger our emotions. But don’t mistake the HG, it is felt as intelligence pure and simple. It flows from inside us and we know.
You’ve just moved the question back a notch, but it is still the same question.

I’ve never heard anyone, LDS or not, say “I feel an intelligence”. What would that feeling be?
 
yes

How do you know?
You’ve just moved the question back a notch, but it is still the same question.

I’ve never heard anyone, LDS or not, say “I feel an intelligence”. What would that feeling be?
There is knowledge and intelligence of the flesh and there is knowledge and intelligence of the Spirit. Intelligence from the spirit enlarges the soul, if enlightens understanding. It is revelation directly from the Holy Ghost. Where once there was confusion now knowledge takes it’s place. Where once darkness covered the mind there is light and there is joy. This is the heart of the gospel, it is the music behind all we do and the harmony that pervades the forms. You have felt it to some degree but perhaps you have not recognized it for what it is. “The wind blows wherever it pleases. You hear its sound, but you cannot tell where it comes from or where it is going. So it is with everyone born of the Spirit. …I tell you the truth, we speak of what we know, and we testify to what we have seen, but still you people do not accept our testimony” (John 3:8,11 NIV).

Marvell not then that once a person has received the truth from the Spirit they are invited to enter into the kingdom of God through baptism. But they are not ready yet. They must act on the knowledge they have received. They must make difficult changes. They must attend church weekly, perhaps enter the bonds of holy matrimony, they may need to give up smoking and drinking, deal with family issues, and pay tithing. None of that is easy, nor will the faint of heart enter in.
 
There is knowledge and intelligence of the flesh and there is knowledge and intelligence of the Spirit. Intelligence from the spirit enlarges the soul, if enlightens understanding. It is revelation directly from the Holy Ghost. Where once there was confusion now knowledge takes it’s place. Where once darkness covered the mind there is light and there is joy. This is the heart of the gospel, it is the music behind all we do and the harmony that pervades the forms. You have felt it to some degree but perhaps you have not recognized it for what it is. “The wind blows wherever it pleases. You hear its sound, but you cannot tell where it comes from or where it is going. So it is with everyone born of the Spirit. …I tell you the truth, we speak of what we know, and we testify to what we have seen, but still you people do not accept our testimony” (John 3:8,11 NIV).

Marvell not then that once a person has received the truth from the Spirit they are invited to enter into the kingdom of God through baptism. But they are not ready yet. They must act on the knowledge they have received. They must make difficult changes. They must attend church weekly, perhaps enter the bonds of holy matrimony, they may need to give up smoking and drinking, deal with family issues, and pay tithing. None of that is easy, nor will the faint of heart enter in.
John was speaking about Jesus, He is the Gospel, the Good News. He is not referring to Joseph Smith or a Book that would be published ~1800 years later. Manipulation of a person’s emotions is not something to marvel at.

And you still didn’t answer the question.
 
John was speaking about Jesus, He is the Gospel, the Good News. He is not referring to Joseph Smith or a Book that would be published ~1800 years later. Manipulation of a person’s emotions is not something to marvel at.

And you still didn’t answer the question.
Rebecca, I have explained it to you. Read what I have written and search your heart. In the context of my above statement I care not what religion you are. Conversion comes through the Holy Ghost.

Why do you refuse to see? I am talking about the heart of Christ’s message, even the Spirit! That which giveth light and understanding to man. It has not been hid in a corner. It is not a whimsical emotion. It is the very thing which leads the sincere seeker to the truth. It can no more be ignored in this discussion on conversion and baptism then can a person ignore the need for air to live. It is life blood of the gospel message.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top