Do LDS Prophets Really Talk To God?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TexanKnight
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
gets his glasses and his bible Ok, and forgive me for saying this in a crowd of Catholics, where does it say that in the Bible? Sounds to me like your reaching. St. John 4:24 is pretty clear that God is not a personage of flesh and bone, however noting that Joe changed the verse in his “inspired version” “For unto such hath God promised his Spirit. And they who worship him, must worship in spirit and in truth”( John 4:26 IV) The orginal reads of course:God is a Spirit: and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth(John 4:24 KJV)
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by theidler
That’s great Parker, but it doesn’t touch on anything to do with the idea of God once being a man on another planet…?!
theidler,

Jesus was born on this earth, a planet. He is Man of holiness. He took upon himself a tabernacle of flesh and bones. After His death, He brought about His own resurrection with a glorified body of flesh and bones.

To say that the Father also did those things, before, on another earth, is the answer to your question about why those verses apply. Jesus did what He had seen that His Father had already done.
Stating that God the Father once was a man … based on the verse that states that Jesus does Gods will, and only God’s will … is a stretch…

Jesus prayed;
Father in Heaven. Holy is your name. Your kingdom come. Your will be done on Earth as it is in heaven…
Jesus, at the same time, through his faith and obedience, demonstrated to his students, how God’s will can be done,by a man,… on Earth … as it is in Heaven.

Here is what Jesus meant, as well as the reason for the statement when he said “I only do what I see my Father do”…
God the Father’s will … is perfect.
Jesus, on Earth, was in perfect communion with God the Father. Because of his intimate, constant communication with his Father (Jesus immediately knew when that communication was broken on the cross, “Father, why have you forsaken me?”) … He saw, clearly, what God’s prefect will was in every circumstance and he chose willingly to do only God’s will. He did this specifically to demonstrate, for us, how God the Father thought and acted. (If you have seen me, you have seen The Father) The line of communication was unbroken. Jesus always “saw” in his spirit … what God wanted him to say and do in every specific circumstance…

Jesus instructed his students by saying… be perfect, even as your Father in Heaven is perfect … he spoke the instruction … and then he demonstrated how it was done. He was telling us that we can have God’s perfect will for our lives … here and now… Just as he had… if we do God’s will in the same way that Jesus demonstrated. He sent the Holy Spirit on Pentecost so that his disciples could have the same relationship of communication with God the Father that Jesus demonstrated in his public ministry.

All of this has to do with Jesus demonstrating how mankind can please God here and now … God the father did not have to be a man on another planet in order to demonstrate his character and his will… and begin to establish his Kingdom on Earth … as it is in Heaven.
 
One can say such and such is in the Bible, but again…who is the interpreter?

The Mormon interpreters invalidate the entire Judeo Christian history of believers. The Jews did not believe in any of the claims Mormons have made…such as the lost tribe of Israel in America…the whole tone and perspective, the imagery used, where Mormonism is going…of man, in man, for man…is not deist.

It is all going back to Who is God???
 
Regarding God creating everything from nothing… it derives from the fact that he created ALL things. A belief in pre-existing matter contradicts this. If matter existed that God did not create, it would mean He did not create all things.
 
theidler,

Jesus was born on this earth, a planet. He is Man of holiness. He took upon himself a tabernacle of flesh and bones. After His death, He brought about His own resurrection with a glorified body of flesh and bones.

To say that the Father also did those things, before, on another earth, is the answer to your question about why those verses apply. Jesus did what He had seen that His Father had already done.
Okay, I’m understanding how they get there. This is inference. Inference is a “guess” based on what the majority of people agree is that natural progression and conclusion of a scenario or situation.
I recently had it explained to me like this -
You are going into a court in the morning and it is sunny outside. The court has no windows to see outside. Several hours later, a person walks into the court and they are carrying a wet umbrella. A few minutes later, a second person enters the court carrying a wet umbrella. You may reasonably infer that it is now raining outside.

The problem with that is - I could also infer that there was an inaccurate weather forecast, the new hip trend is to carry an umbrella, two people were standing together on an elevator when a woman walking in carrying bottled water, tripped and spilled it on them - one went to the restroom to clean up, while one walked directly into the court room. It is far better to know the truth than to rely on inference or conjecture.

At the end of the day - inference is just that. What a group of fallible human beings voted on and decided was plausible.

You stated that Jesus did what He saw the Father do … (because He had seen Him do it before). In this context - He (Jesus) was not referring to making man out of the dust of the Earth and breathing the breath of life into him. He was actually referring to teaching Truth, praying for us and our salvation, and giving Mercy to sinners.
To be invited mystically into the body of Christ and become a co-heir with Christ, does not mean that all of sudden we, as humans, are now gods and able to function as gods. It means that God, in His mercy has condescended to reach down to us at our sinful, fallible state and give us a dignity (crowning us with eternal life) that comes from His own power (He has the eternal life to give us, we do not posess it in and of ourselves). WE still are not doing any of it by ourselves.
To argue the contrary, I would listen and just ask for an example of one person - really any Latter Day Saint, okay, let’s dispense with limiting it to LDS - let’s broaden it to ANYONE at all…
an example of any human being becoming a god and doing that which only God can do. What is a function of God that only God could do? Create something that did not exist before out of nothing. Radically alter the weather… turn day into night at his command. Be present in several places at one time, know all things, send an Angel to fill the sky and speak their message to several witnesses… Anything like that?
There isn’t any. It has never, ever happened. There’s black magic, Satanic power, but absolutely no record of any LDS followers who’ve become “gods” ever doing anything a “god” would do. They just die and people talk about how they became a god becausee they had several wives.
People rule and kings reign on Earth. I rule over my car on the way to work, and control its every movement, but I can’t supernaturally “heal” it if it breaks. I can’t know in advance and prevent another driver from hitting me. I can’t physically transport myself and my car to a different location to prevent a collision.
Kings have reigned, but none like Christ, whose reign is eternal and of whose rule there shall be no end. The scripture about us ruling and reigning with Him in Heaven is about Him being God and inviting us to be with Him. It’s still His kingdom, we don’t turn into gods just because He invites us to His banquet.
And literally multitudes of people have been married to multiple wives. It’s never resulted in deifying anyone. Ask their wives if you don’t believe me.
And the Bible is very clear about worshipping anything but the One, True, Almighty, and Ever-living God. Idolatry and Self-idolatry (mortal men becoming gods) is a mortal / deadly sin. It kills the soul and those who die with this sin on their soul do not go and sit in thrones next to ‘John Smith and his buddy Jesus-the-lesser’. Jesus is God eternally. He has the Authority to judge the sins of man and if you stand before Him with this sin on your soul in the final judgement, you consign your own soul to eternal damnation. That’s no laughing matter. It’s forever.
Men cannot become God, some just think they can. Jesus did do miracles (things that superceded the laws of nature, which He created,) and manifested His divine wisdom in His teachings. God has made the claim - not that man would never fail, but that He would never fail…HIs Church - He is the head, we are INCORPORATED into Him as parts of one body. We don’t incorporate ourselves by our own will and our own power. It’s HIs body. It’s His Chruch. He is God, He can make that claim and back it up. To believers - “I’ll never leave you nor forsake you.” “The world will pass away, but not one iota of my Word will pass away…” He is “the Beginning and the End.” He is already there eternally, so He can tell you accurately what will happen, not make educated guesses. He is.
If John Smith were “god” would he not be here still? Does he still speak, or has he passed into a higher realm where he’s too good to speak with lesser mortals?
No LDS ‘god’ has ever done anything truely divine or supernaturally miraculous, have they? I mean, wouldn’t we have heard about it by now?
 
theidler,

Jesus was born on this earth, a planet. He is Man of holiness. He took upon himself a tabernacle of flesh and bones. After His death, He brought about His own resurrection with a glorified body of flesh and bones.

To say that the Father also did those things, before, on another earth, is the answer to your question about why those verses apply. Jesus did what He had seen that His Father had already done.
Parker, Jesus was God FIRST. He did not start being when He was born in Jerusalem.

Remember your temple…Jesus and Michael came to earth to create it like they had done to many other planets.
 
theidler,

Jesus was born on this earth, a planet. He is Man of holiness. He took upon himself a tabernacle of flesh and bones. After His death, He brought about His own resurrection with a glorified body of flesh and bones.

To say that the Father also did those things, before, on another earth, is the answer to your question about why those verses apply. Jesus did what He had seen that His Father had already done.
This may be an area in which I am completely igmorant as far as Mromon theology goes, so would you please help me and some others here understand your position?

As TexanKnight has already pointed out, the Christian world believes that Christ, the second Person of the Trinity, was God from eternity and dwelt in heaven with the Father and the Holy Spirit prior to His incarnation. Scripture verifies that “…the Word (Jesus) was God. He was in the beginning with God.” (John 1:1-2) Now, we all know that you do not believe in the Trinity, but I have always thought that Mormon belief held that Jesus was also with the Father prior to his incarnation. How does this fit in with the doctrine of “progression” if Christ was God before he was man? How did he become God in the first place? I’m sure this issue has been brought up before but I don’t really remember the Mormon response.

Thanks.

Thanks
 
Jesus was born on this earth, a planet. He is Man of holiness. He took upon himself a tabernacle of flesh and bones. After His death, He brought about His own resurrection with a glorified body of flesh and bones.

To say that the Father also did those things, before, on another earth, is the answer to your question about why those verses apply. Jesus did what He had seen that His Father had already done.
In which LDS document is this interpretation recorded and who wrote it down?
 
Jesus was born on this earth, a planet. He is Man of holiness. He took upon himself a tabernacle of flesh and bones. After His death, He brought about His own resurrection with a glorified body of flesh and bones.
To say that the Father also did those things, before, on another earth, is the answer to your question about why those verses apply. Jesus did what He had seen that His Father had already done.
If one followed the “Jesus does things he has seen his Father do” logic in the other direction, would one then be looking for a new son and new sacrifice?

When the Mormon man becomes a god of his own, does he expect to have to save his creation through the sacrifice of his son?

Christ’s sacrifice (death and resurrection) is a unique event in time and space - it is literally the one, single, best piece of news there is. This is Christian teaching. Many sacrifices = paganism.
 
It matters little how you frame or craft questions to mormons. If your question touches upon a “doctrine” or practice or belief that they are uncomfortable discussing or that is nonsensical or that flies in the face of Christian belief, you will never, and I repeat NEVER, get a straight answer, if you even get an answer at all. They will clam up at the first sign of probing, this is a reflex action that they have been taught to employ. Like all cults, mormonism innoculates it’s members against attack by ascribing any attack as driven by Satan and questioners as automatically anti-mormon. Even if the truth is laid totally bare, they will deny and tap-dance furiously. It is only when the armour cracks from inside does the once True-Blue mormon begin to question. Then the reaction usually becomes like the finger-sized hole in the base of the dam. Final destruction is not far away. All the Ex-Mos on here have shown me that. Get the blade into that crack in the armour and the whole goofy house of cards comes down. But, they know where the cracks are and they guard them well, because they know that the armour guards a body of lies.
 
It matters little how you frame or craft questions to mormons. If your question touches upon a “doctrine” or practice or belief that they are uncomfortable discussing or that is nonsensical or that flies in the face of Christian belief, you will never, and I repeat NEVER, get a straight answer, if you even get an answer at all. They will clam up at the first sign of probing, this is a reflex action that they have been taught to employ. Like all cults, mormonism innoculates it’s members against attack by ascribing any attack as driven by Satan and questioners as automatically anti-mormon. Even if the truth is laid totally bare, they will deny and tap-dance furiously. It is only when the armour cracks from inside does the once True-Blue mormon begin to question. Then the reaction usually becomes like the finger-sized hole in the base of the dam. Final destruction is not far away. All the Ex-Mos on here have shown me that. Get the blade into that crack in the armour and the whole goofy house of cards comes down. But, they know where the cracks are and they guard them well, because they know that the armour guards a body of lies.
Hmmmm…very similiar to JW’s.
 
theidler,

Jesus was born on this earth, a planet. He is Man of holiness. He took upon himself a tabernacle of flesh and bones. After His death, He brought about His own resurrection with a glorified body of flesh and bones.

To say that the Father also did those things, before, on another earth, is the answer to your question about why those verses apply. Jesus did what He had seen that His Father had already done.
Somebody permanently save this post, because somewhere down the line, there is going to be a denial that it was ever said.

I’m just sayin…😃
 
WQowsers!!! :eek:

Someone elsewhere just said they have seen this kind of statement from others.
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by ParkerD
theidler,
Jesus was born on this earth, a planet. He is Man of holiness. He took upon himself a tabernacle of flesh and bones. After His death, He brought about His own resurrection with a glorified body of flesh and bones.
To say that the Father also did those things, before, on another earth, is the answer to your question about why those verses apply. Jesus did what He had seen that His Father had already done.
Where in the Bible does it state **God the Father ** incarnated,lived and resurrected? Second, it is pure conjecture on your part to assume because Jesus said He has seen what His Father already did,thus meaning His Father also came to earth,etc,etc. If so,did His Father also die on the cross? Does that mean God the Father failed,thus His Son had do it a second time to get it right for the salvation of humanity? :ehh:
 
Where in the Bible does it state **God the Father ** incarnated,lived and resurrected? Second, it is pure conjecture on your part to assume because Jesus said He has seen what His Father already did,thus meaning His Father also came to earth,etc,etc. If so,did His Father also die on the cross? Does that mean God the Father failed,thus His Son had do it a second time to get it right for the salvation of humanity? :ehh:
Actually I got the impression from other conversations that Mormons believe that each new planet requires the same salvation process.
 
This may be an area in which I am completely ignorant as far as Mormon theology goes, so would you please help me and some others here understand your position?

As TexanKnight has already pointed out, the Christian world believes that Christ, the second Person of the Trinity, was God from eternity and dwelt in heaven with the Father and the Holy Spirit prior to His incarnation. Scripture verifies that “…the Word (Jesus) was God. He was in the beginning with God.” (John 1:1-2) Now, we all know that you do not believe in the Trinity, but I have always thought that Mormon belief held that Jesus was also with the Father prior to his incarnation. How does this fit in with the doctrine of “progression” if Christ was God before he was man? How did he become God in the first place? I’m sure this issue has been brought up before but I don’t really remember the Mormon response.

Thanks.

Thanks
SteveVH,

We don’t use the words “his incarnation”, but certainly we understand and know that Jesus, Jehovah, the Word, was God as God the Son in the pre-mortal life, and that He created the heavens and the earth and other earths also. Jesus Christ is the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, who gave the Ten Commandments to Moses and who said “I AM THAT I AM” (Exodus 3:14) (Also see John 8:58, where Jesus says He is I AM.)

I don’t think of Jesus as having the quality of “becoming God” as though He progressed as a Spirit. He is the Only Begotten Son, already possessing the quality of being God as the First Born Spirit and the Only Begotten Son with likeness to God the Father in His love, His goodness, His complete oneness with God the Father’s will, and thus His omnipotence and omniscience. He had those qualities while He was a Spirit, which enabled Him to bring about the Creation and enabled Him to be the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, and the God of Israel who guided the children of Israel through the wilderness.

So when He is described as “Emmanuel”, God with us, we mean that with all our heart and soul.
 
If one followed the “Jesus does things he has seen his Father do” logic in the other direction, would one then be looking for a new son and new sacrifice?

When the Mormon man becomes a god of his own, does he expect to have to save his creation through the sacrifice of his son?

Christ’s sacrifice (death and resurrection) is a unique event in time and space - it is literally the one, single, best piece of news there is. This is Christian teaching. Many sacrifices = paganism.
JHow,

The idea “a god of his own” doesn’t convey the right meaning of the Savior’s intercessory prayer or of His teaching about “ruler over many things” or of the descriptions in the book of Revelation, or of Paul’s writing about being “joint heirs”. “Enabled through Christ’s grace to be like Him” is the meaning I see in those teachings.

Good questions about how that situation would happen in the far distant future. My personal belief, since there is not a doctrinal statement about that and so we don’t know, is that Jesus’ infinite atonement was infinite for all the worlds that will be created under His tutelage, just as for all the worlds that He created already.

So my opinion is that there will not be other “Saviors” needed for all the worlds that will be created in the future, but others might have a different opinion about that. Doctrine and Covenants 76 states “the inhabitants thereof are begotten sons and daughters unto God,” speaking of the worlds that “are and were created”.
 
Where in the Bible does it state **God the Father ** incarnated,lived and resurrected?
Nicea325,
Jesus said as recorded in that passage in John
Second, it is pure conjecture on your part to assume because Jesus said He has seen what His Father already did,thus meaning His Father also came to earth,etc,etc. If so,did His Father also die on the cross? Does that mean God the Father failed,thus His Son had do it a second time to get it right for the salvation of humanity?

The gospel of John was written to believers, and contains greater knowledge about Jesus and His relationship to God the Father than the other three gospels. Jesus said “For as the Father hath life in himself; so hath he given to the Son to have life in himself;” (John 5:26)

How, one asks as they read that simple statement, did Jesus have “life in himself”?

Answer: by being able to resurrect Himself after His death, and to lay down His life in and of Himself.

So the Father must have had that power also.

It doesn’t mean anything about whether the Father had to die on a cross. It means the Father had life in Himself, also. The Father didn’t fail, of course, ever.
 
The gospel of John was written to believers, and contains greater knowledge about Jesus and His relationship to God the Father than the other three gospels. Jesus said “For as the Father hath life in himself; so hath he given to the Son to have life in himself;” (John 5:26)

How, one asks as they read that simple statement, did Jesus have “life in himself”?

Answer: by being able to resurrect Himself after His death, and to lay down His life in and of Himself.

So the Father must have had that power also.

It doesn’t mean anything about whether the Father had to die on a cross. It means the Father had life in Himself, also. The Father didn’t fail, of course, ever.
Answer: Jesus has life in Himself because He is God. God is the source from which all life flows, He is life.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top