Do we worship the same God?

  • Thread starter Thread starter dulcissima
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
hdbarton said:
:confused: What in the world are you trying to talk about? We Catholics are taught that faith and REASON can not be separated!
you should check out the trinity thread when you get a chance. faith and reason dont always go hand in hand.
If it has no reason in it it is not Faith, but something else.
hmmm…interesting
 
40.png
Faith101:
you should check out the trinity thread when you get a chance. faith and reason dont always go hand in hand.
hmmm…interesting
🙂 it is as I say, check it out, reason is consciousness itself, and it can be appied to the persons and nature of god with wonderful results - interesting to anyone, check it out - I’ve explained it all in an interesting and abosolutly non-boring way I promise ] at http;//www.godmodern.com/ 🙂
 
hdbarton,

As who worships who seems to be the topic that most interests you, I would like to invite you to post your thoughts on the thread; Christians and Jews: Do We Worship the Same God? that I started today. I would be interested in your thoughts regarding that topic.

Thank you.

George
 
George Waters:
hdbarton,

As who worships who seems to be the topic that most interests you, I would like to invite you to post your thoughts on the thread; Christians and Jews: Do We Worship the Same God? that I started today. I would be interested in your thoughts regarding that topic.

Thank you.

George
👍 Ok, thanks for the invite, 😉
 
Hashi Al-Eritre:
We worship the creator of the heavens and the earth.
But isn’t that pretty much what most gods do: Create Heaven and Earth?
 
:bigyikes:
George Waters:
hdbarton,

As who worships who seems to be the topic that most interests you, I would like to invite you to post your thoughts on the thread; Christians and Jews: Do We Worship the Same God? that I started today. I would be interested in your thoughts regarding that topic.

Thank you.

George
:mad: I don’t want to burn a pinch of incense to the God of War [formerly called Mars]. Someone in authority whom I am not at liberity to mension, informed me that the Church teachs that Muslims and Catholic worship the same God! How can Allah, who says he has no children, being sterile, doesn’t want any, and says anyone who dies believing he has a son, or any children will be sent to the lowest Hell where they will be tortured with the worst tortures forever and ever. This is our God? Of course not! I will not offer a pinch of incense to this God of revenge. Why that would be idolatry! ** If it is not idolatry, there is no such thing as Idolatry! ** Yet so many christians fall for it on this site. Do you think any of the muslims on this site think that Jesus is God? No, but so many Christian do believe that Allah, that war god whom the romans called Mars, is also our God, Jesus! I want to be like Jesus and strive only for peace. I want only peace brought forth by the free will choice of those who hear the good news. I want to be like Jesus, not like that other god who says that my God is not God and did not die on the cross for the sins of all mankind. What do I have to do with such a god as this? I do not worship Allah! I do not even give him lip service! So why do people want to infuence people to see me as a partial follower of Allah? A persons reputation is in large part determined by the god or gods they are perceived to worship or give respect to. I don’t want to be seen as giving deference to the god of war. Do you? :bowdown2:
 
mark a:
But isn’t that pretty much what most gods do: Create Heaven and Earth?
:eek: Are you telling us you worship most gods? How long have you been doing this? How is it working for you? :eek:
 
hdbarton said:
:eek: Are you telling us you worship most gods? How long have you been doing this? How is it working for you? :eek:

lol. Mark is Catholic according to his profile…now you have to be nice to him 👍
 
40.png
hdbarton:
How can Allah, who says he has no children, being sterile, doesn’t want any, and says anyone who dies believing he has a son, or any children will be sent to the lowest Hell where they will be tortured with the worst tortures forever and ever. This is our God?
So you don’t believe that they worship the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob? Have you not thought that this is their imperfect understanding of who God is?
Do you think any of the muslims on this site think that Jesus is God?
No, but that doesn’t negate that they believe in God, does it now?
so many Christian do believe that Allah, that war god whom the romans called Mars, is also our God, Jesus!
Do Muslims say they worship Mars, the god of war? I think this is an insult to our Muslim brothers.
I want to be like Jesus and strive only for peace.
If you want to be like Jesus, then first learn to be understanding like Him. Then you will know what peace is.
 
hdbarton,

As an obedient son of Holy Mother Church I accept CCC #841 The Church’s relationship with the Muslims. “The plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator, in the first place amongst whom are the Muslims; these profess to hold the faith of Abraham, and together with us they adore the one, merciful God, mankind’s judge on the last day.” I am a bit surprised that a “Dominican 3rd Order” would continue to question the collective wisdom of the Church.

Peace,

George
 
George, if you and other fellow catholics want to believe that we worship the same God as muslims then it is fine. Are you trying to make all free people here to think that we should agree for what all the vaticans decide? cant we have some personal opinion about other faith?
 
George Waters:
hdbarton,

As an obedient son of Holy Mother Church I accept CCC #841 The Church’s relationship with the Muslims. “The plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator, in the first place amongst whom are the Muslims; these profess to hold the faith of Abraham, and together with us they adore the one, merciful God, mankind’s judge on the last day.” I am a bit surprised that a “Dominican 3rd Order” would continue to question the collective wisdom of the Church.

Peace,

George
:confused: george, you seem to be in perfect agreement with faith 001. How can this be? She, like all muslims, does not believe Jesus is God. She seems to have more freedom of choice than you do: Consider: It is Good that Muslims believe in one God. Thats why the vaticum Council puts them as first place among all the pagans. Read again what you think states that the Church recognizes Allah as the true God! In your rush to blindly obey without thinking you have stumbled into idolatry. It does not say Allah is God! It only says that these non christians are first among pagans because they recognize that there is only one God! And, also, that Abraham is the father of many nations! And that they see a final judgement of all mankind!
And that this God they are looking for, and mistakenly think they found, is merciful! I’m a Dominican Crusader, I know the Church is infallible - and you are a son of God, and if you search within yourself you will find an infallible knowledge that will tell you with absolute certitude that Allah is not Jesus! Not a Bit!!! :nope: :tsktsk: P.S. Faith means the gift of perserverence and the personal fortitude to keep on keeping on with keeping on towards the truth! Mulims have this last kind of faith, the Church so states
 
40.png
Milliardo:
So you don’t believe that they worship the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob? Have you not thought that this is their imperfect understanding of who God is?

No, but that doesn’t negate that they believe in God, does it now?

Do Muslims say they worship Mars, the god of war? I think this is an insult to our Muslim brothers.

If you want to be like Jesus, then first learn to be understanding like Him. Then you will know what peace is. :confused: Dear milliardo, every pagan has an imperfect understanding of who God is – we don’t!/ That is why they are false gods! Do you think they are not? – No, they don’t know Jesus is God – so they worship imperfection only – a war god is a war god - is one significantly more peaceful than another? Do you really think I’m ignorant about peace? Well, what can I say? :bible1: font]
 
❤️
40.png
Faith101:
lol. Mark is Catholic according to his profile…now you have to be nice to him 👍
We are called to share the world and all it’s evils with you in love, so, we have many mentally ill brothers and sisters, as you people do. I am not saying Mark is mentally ill, but if he is, that would prove nothing to add to your post. But I didn’t say Mark worshipped many gods, I just inquired, not knowing that he was a fervent Catholic. Actually, most gods do not create ex nilo – its quite rare to become cognizant of this great truth, that’s the main reason we Catholics are so impressed with your amazing religion. ❤️
 
🙂 Jesus is Perfect - how is such perfection going to be compaired with imperfection? Can we place something imperfect on the alter next to Jesus and bow down to them both? What to you is God like down here in this valley of tears? Should we not only have eyes for him? Why are the Father and the Son and the Holy spirit ONE? No reason, except that they are Perfect – they and only them in all the universe! I know this is not hard for you! :tiphat:
40.png
hdbarton:
 
Dear George and many others,

I am a bit disappointed by your notion. Politically correct is good, but stating the truth is much more important.

Please remember this verse (not perfect though, because I seldom read Bible).

“You need to be cold or hot. You can’t be both. If you cannot be cold or hot, God will spit you out.” Psalm, I think.

I hope this helps.

Fox
 
40.png
DeExupery:
Dear George and many others,

I am a bit disappointed by your notion. Politically correct is good, but stating the truth is much more important.

Please remember this verse (not perfect though, because I seldom read Bible).

“You need to be cold or hot. You can’t be both. If you cannot be cold or hot, God will spit you out.” Psalm, I think.

I hope this helps.

Fox
👍 That is in the Book of revelations or The apocalypse in catholic bible. To the Catholic Church of Laodica (means the people are victorius in Greek) and the Chuch was mainly concerned with building respect for God. But, they pleased the people too much, and so they held back the respect they should have given God. They walked the middle line. They gave half of the respect to God, and the other half to the other gods, so, Jesus told them: either be hot or cold, if you keep on being luke warm, I will vomit you out of my mouth!" So, the Holy Ghost put you up to puting the perfect teaching in just the right place at the right time for this thread - God has spoken at this post by your faithfulness, :amen: :blessyou:
 
hdbarton said:
👍 That is in the Book of Revelations or The Apocalypse in Catholic Bible. To the Catholic Church of Laodica (means the people are victorius in Greek) and the Chuch was mainly concerned with building respect for God. But, they pleased the people too much, and so they held back the respect they should have given God. They walked the middle line. They gave half of the respect to God, and the other half to the other gods, so, Jesus told them: either be hot or cold, if you keep on being luke warm, I will vomit you out of my mouth!" So, the Holy Ghost put you up to puting the perfect teaching in just the right place at the right time for this thread - God has spoken at this post by your faithfulness, :amen: :blessyou:

++++++++ once again better this time for spelling: Rusty i am: That is in the Book of revelations or The apocalypse in catholic bible. To the Catholic Church of Laodica (means the people are victorius in Greek) and the Chuch was mainly concerned with building respect for God. But, they pleased the people too much, and so they held back the respect they should have given God. They walked the middle line. They gave half of the respect to God, and the other half to the other gods, so, Jesus told them: either be hot or cold, if you keep on being luke warm, I will vomit you out of my mouth!" So, the Holy Ghost put you up to puting the perfect teaching in just the right place at the right time for this thread - God has spoken at this post by your faithfulness,
 
Dear milliardo, every pagan has an imperfect understanding of who God is – we don’t!/ That is why they are false gods!
So you think the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob is a false god then?
No, they don’t know Jesus is God – so they worship imperfection only – a war god is a war god
And yet if you read the Old Testament–what do you see? God would set His people against those against it. God let them overrun a place where people are not even at war with them just to claim the Promised Land. Does this mean we must foresake the Old Testament because God there does not act the way Jesus does? Of course, as Catholics we know why God is like that in the Old Testament (I will not go into that here, as it is not pertinent to the discussion), but my point is that, at least in the surface, we see God to be different in the Old and New Testament (again, the reason for that can be explained once we establish that God is our Father, but for this discussion that would only lead to a tangent that’s not relevant to the discussion).
 
Cyber Knight,

It is not a case of what I or other Catholics believe, but what the Catholic Church attests to be true. Everyone has free will and can think for him or herself, but we must also recognize the collective wisdom of the church and defer to Her wisdom. The quote I provided is not simply an opinion by someone at the Vatican, but a valid and legimate directive from the Catholic Church that is to be used as the norm for teaching the faith.

Fox,

This has nothing to do with political correctness. I also struggle with this issue. As
I have stated many times in many different posts Christianity and Islam have many, many fundamental differences and I am quite skeptical of the claim Islam is a peaceful religion. However as I stated above I will defer to the wisdom of the Catholic Church who, in its authority from Jesus and under the direction of the Holy Spirit, have made the determination that Muslims do worship the God of Abraham.

If I refuse to accept this authority then I might as well be non-denominational and lose forever the fullness of the Christian faith.

hdbarton,

I know Jesus is God and I know Faith101 does not believe Jesus is God, so I am not in perfect agreement with her though I hope God is merciful to her as she is a person of good faith.

You are continuing to claim (or so I have interpreted from your posts) that Muslims do not worship the God of Abraham, which is contrary to the teachings of the Catholic Church. You also continue to state how Christians and Muslims do not worship the same God and Muslims refuse to accept Jesus as God. I am a true monotheist; there is only one God. I do not know if Muslim worship God, Satan or some figment of imagination, but I do know the Catholic Church has plainly stated that the plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator. By obeying this teaching of the Catholic Church I have not “stumbled into idolatry”. Also, as I have reminded you earlier, Jews do not accept Jesus as God either. Do they worship a different God? (I am hopeful that you will accept my invitation to address the God of the Jews.) Of course not, but by your criteria, they must.

Pagans? Allow me to remind you that by definition a pagan is not a Christian, Jew or Muslim, unless you want to go with the more strict definition which states all non-Christians are pagans. If you wish to use the later, then why does not the Church state “…first place amongst whom are the Jews…”?

So, if based upon the fact that I acknowledge Jesus as the Son of the Living God, know there is only one God and support the directives of the Catholic Church, which includes the teaching that salvation if through the grace of God alone and that we should not assume in our own arrogance that we can determine who will or will not go to hell than by all means sir condemn me.

Peace to you all and may we all remember to love one another as Jesus loves us.

George
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top