Do you belive other gods exist?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hoosier_Daddy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh, something else:I attended Saturday Vigil today, and the First Reading given was from 2 Kings
5:14–17
, in which a King (I think) Naaman was cured of leprosy by the instruc-
tions given by Elisha, to which he said,
“Now I know that there is no other God anywhere in the world but in Israel.ˮ
Yes, but he was converting. He was forsaking the so called pagan “god” and became a believer in the Jewish God.

It is very possible that the “gods” of the other ancient religions were either angels and/or demons (where man misunderstood who they were).

Or who knows… maybe they were aliens! 😃
 
The Wiccans I’ve talked to–admittedly not many–do not seem particularly interested in power, except insofar as they want a religion that is more individualistic and generally “empowering” (particularly for women) than traditional Christianity. That certainly can be an idolatrous and demonic desire, although it may also be a healthy reaction to the demonic elements in historic Christianity.

Mostly, Wiccans seem interested in having a spiritual connection to the natural world and the cycles of life.

Edwin
That is what they SAY, yes. But they are also being fooled by satan, and they definitely do not ascribe to christian love
 
Yes; please don’t insult the Pagans on our forum. We CAFers are lucky to have them here for discussion, so please don’t chase them away my maligning them.
Or provoke me into getting myself banned 😃
 
That is what they SAY, yes. But they are also being fooled by satan
I am not particularly confident in my ability (or yours) to tell when someone is being “fooled by Satan.” I think it’s particularly pernicious to ascribe differences of belief to “the other” being fooled by Satan. I think that such an approach is the surest way to be fooled by Satan myself. Insofar as I’ve seen a clear case of being fooled by Satan, it was inmy maternal grandmother, a devout Christian who was continually worried about being fooled by Satan. She became increasingly willing to condemn others out of a fear of being fooled by Satan into accepting something that was wrong. She caused a lot of destruction, all the while sincerely believing that she was serving God and loving other people in doing so.

My grandmother does not appear to be unique among Christians by any means. Insofar as she stands out, it’s from the fact that I knew her personally and knew her deep sincerity and her fervent love for God and her neighbor. I am therefore very suspicious of any attempt by Christians to dismiss other people’s beliefs as Satanic. If anything comes from Satan, that way of thinking probably does.
and they definitely do not ascribe to christian love
Perhaps we should let them say what kind of love they subscribe to, so that we can make a comparison.

Edwin
 
Perhaps we should let them say what kind of love they subscribe to, so that we can make a comparison.

Edwin
I’m not Wiccan but as far a neighborly love goes…
2.Hail to the giver! | a guest has come; Where shall the stranger sit?
Swift shall he be who, | with swords shall try The proof of his might to make.
(note: the second line may not be from the original)
3. Fire he needs | who with frozen knees Has come from the cold without;
Food and clothes | must the farer have, The man from the mountains come.
4. Water and towels | and welcoming speech Should he find who comes, to the feast;
If renown he would get, | and again be greeted, Wisely and well must he act.
Havamal stanzas 2-4
Hospitality is one of the 9 noble virtues.
On the other hand it is just as important that the guest behaves correctly.

Edit: To be perfectly clear I’m Asatru this is from the Poetic Edda
 
T without so much as an attempt to save them from the firey hell he was condemning them to.
Stop making stuff up. I’ll give you $100 if you can prove to me that God sent the children to hell.

The truth of the matter is that we can’t understand God full reasoning in all things. We have a longing for God, but we don’t have His knowledge - otherwise we would be God.
 
Stop making stuff up. I’ll give you $100 if you can prove to me that God sent the children to hell.

The truth of the matter is that we can’t understand God full reasoning in all things. We have a longing for God, but we don’t have His knowledge - otherwise we would be God.
Well lets assess this:
  1. According to the Bible, idolaters go to hell.
  2. Caananites were pagans.
  3. The Battle of Jericho
    They devoted the city to the Lord and destroyed with the sword every living thing in it—men and women, young and old, cattle, sheep and donkeys. Joshua 6:21
    So at least in Jericho EVERYONE died (except Rehab and her family)
Therefore Skadi isn’t making anything up. He’s thinking logically and drawing conclusions. You may disagree but he’s not making it up. I can’t tell you if those children went to hell, but the fact does remain that the devotion of the city to YHWH and killing everything are in the same verse.
 
Well lets assess this:
  1. According to the Bible, idolaters go to hell.
  2. Caananites were pagans.
  3. The Battle of Jericho
    They devoted the city to the Lord and destroyed with the sword every living thing in it—men and women, young and old, cattle, sheep and donkeys. Joshua 6:21
    So at least in Jericho EVERYONE died (except Rehab and her family)
Therefore Skadi isn’t making anything up. He’s thinking logically and drawing conclusions. You may disagree but he’s not making it up. I can’t tell you if those children went to hell, but the fact does remain that the devotion of the city to YHWH and killing everything are in the same verse.
Can you prove point #1? Where, exactly, does God say that ALL idolaters go to hell?

The current understanding is that a person cannot be held culpable for a sinful act if they do not know it is wrong; thus, idolaters who did not know they were worshiping the wrong God would not be held responsible.
 
Can you prove point #1? Where, exactly, does God say that ALL idolaters go to hell?

The current understanding is that a person cannot be held culpable for a sinful act if they do not know it is wrong; thus, idolaters who did not know they were worshiping the wrong God would not be held responsible.
Fair point
 
Stop making stuff up. I’ll give you $100 if you can prove to me that God sent the children to hell.

The truth of the matter is that we can’t understand God full reasoning in all things. We have a longing for God, but we don’t have His knowledge - otherwise we would be God.
If im correct, according to christian doctrine everyone prior to Jesus went to hell because of original sin. In fact wasnt Jesus supposed to have rescued the OT prophets while he was in hell?
 
Well lets assess this:
  1. According to the Bible, idolaters go to hell…
Let’s pause here: unrepentant idolaters who know they are rejecting Christ in this life may go to hell. We have no idea what happens to others in the final moments of life, so we can’t even say (for example) that Hitler went to hell.
 
Can you prove point #1? Where, exactly, does God say that ALL idolaters go to hell?

The current understanding is that a person cannot be held culpable for a sinful act if they do not know it is wrong; thus, idolaters who did not know they were worshiping the wrong God would not be held responsible.
I dont think many people knowingly worship a false god. I mean unless you created it in your mind there realy isn’t any way to know if it is real at all.
 
I dont think many people knowingly worship a false god. I mean unless you created it in your mind there realy isn’t any way to know if it is real at all.
That’s the point. People in Canaan who were killed may or may not have gone to hell because of it, because they were honestly worshiping gods they believed in.
 
That’s the point. People in Canaan who were killed may or may not have gone to hell because of it, because they were honestly worshiping gods they believed in.
I honestly worship gods I believe in, so even if im wrong (which im not) im not going to hell by that logic. If this was actually true that would deprive Christianity of its #1 missionary tool, scary stories about hell.
 
Well lets assess this:
  1. According to the Bible, idolaters go to hell.
The parts of the Bible Skadi is talking about say nothing about a fiery hell. You only get a fiery hell in the NT. But if you’re going to interpret the OT through the NT, then you have to do so consistently. And you probably should listen to Christians explain how we do it. You really don’t have the right to tell us how to interpret our own Scriptures theologically. And if we’re just interpreting historically, then the Torah and the “Former Prophets” know nothing of a fiery hell.

Most of the references to a “fiery hell” come from the Synoptic Gospels and are directed against people who knew the Word of God but perverted it in self-righteousness (which in post-NT terms would mean orthodox Christians), not against pagans.
  1. Caananites were pagans.
  2. The Battle of Jericho
    They devoted the city to the Lord and destroyed with the sword every living thing in it—men and women, young and old, cattle, sheep and donkeys. Joshua 6:21
    So at least in Jericho EVERYONE died (except Rehab and her family)
If you take it literally. Most scholars think that Joshua probably is not a historical account. In some ways that’s more disturbing, because it means that ancient Hebrews regarded genocide as an ideal to which they had failed to live up . . . But a case can be made that Rahab is actually the main point of the story. Ancient Hebrews had a concept of “herem” warfare in which everything and everyone was supposed to be destroyed (but it’s questionable how far this was actually put into practice, and some scholars argue that the “kill everyone” language is typical ancient hyperbole that obviously can’t be taken literally from the fact that many such passages are followed by descriptions of survivors). But the stress in Joshua seems to fall on the exceptions, in fact.

T
herefore Skadi isn’t making anything up. He’s thinking logically and drawing conclusions. You may disagree but he’s not making it up. I can’t tell you if those children went to hell, but the fact does remain that the devotion of the city to YHWH and killing everything are in the same verse.
But a fiery hell is nowhere to be found in those sections of the OT–probably not anywhere in the OT, but perhaps the image of “the valley of Hinnom” in the prophetic literature is the beginning of it.

Literary texts have to be interpreted carefully and sensitively. Ancient texts are of course particularly alien and particularly hard to interpret. And sacred texts can only be interpreted, as sacred texts, by members of the community that holds the text to be sacred.

Edwin
 
I honestly worship gods I believe in, so even if im wrong (which im not) im not going to hell by that logic. If this was actually true that would deprive Christianity of its #1 missionary tool, scary stories about hell.
Well, perhaps since you are on a Catholic forum you should acquaint yourself with what the Catholic Church teaches on the matter, instead of expecting Catholics (who are, after all, the largest Christian church) to adhere to your stereotype of Christianity. The Catholic Church does not teach that people who act in good faith are going to hell. It teaches that people who reject Christianity in general and/or Catholicism in particular, knowing it to be true, cannot be saved.

Edwin
 
Well, perhaps since you are on a Catholic forum you should acquaint yourself with what the Catholic Church teaches on the matter, instead of expecting Catholics (who are, after all, the largest Christian church) to adhere to your stereotype of Christianity. The Catholic Church does not teach that people who act in good faith are going to hell. It teaches that people who reject Christianity in general and/or Catholicism in particular, knowing it to be true, cannot be saved.

Edwin
I went K-12 in a catholic school and actually took extra religion classes and talked with my teachers during and after classes, and had to go through the confirmation process against my will. I’m no expert, but I certainly know a fair share about it. Ive actually argued for catholicism against evangelical protestantism using bible quotes ect. just for the hell of it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top