Do you find eating mutilated animals to be disgusting?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Robert_Sock
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m talking about chicken, beef, and pork. I first had an extreme experience while preparing chicken for the first time. I found it to be very gross washing the pieces of mutilated chicken. It was a very strong experience that made me feel gross being human and I became a vegetarian. Today I eat all kinds of meats, but I still remember my first experience and I still feel gross being human and having to eat mutilated animals.
Robert, God gave you a stomach connected to a chewing apparatus. He expects you to use it wisely. Humans, like bears and certain types of goldfish He created to be Omnivorous.
I think any feeling of revulsion has its source in modern-day packaging. Todays youth are just not encouraged anymore to butcher their own animals.
 
Do you find eating dogs the way they do in China to be gross? If yes, then why not with other animals. I think we grow so accustomed to eating butchered animals that it seems the normal thing to do.
If you had a starving family in desperate circumstances, would you kill and eat a dog to feed them?
What if beings from another planet decided to eat humans?
Are you saying that eating a cow would be as bad as eating a human?
 
Robert, God gave you a stomach connected to a chewing apparatus. He expects you to use it wisely. Humans, like bears and certain types of goldfish He created to be Omnivorous.
I think any feeling of revulsion has its source in modern-day packaging. Todays youth are just not encouraged anymore to butcher their own animals.
Mmmmmmmm…pork products. (sorry, your username + thread topic= mandatory lame joke:D)
 
I think some people would have a problem with eating dogs or cats because they view them as pets, that is, companions, rather than as a source of food. Personally, I think it’s just a cultural difference and I have no ethical or moral problem with eating dog or cat or horse meat, any more than I have a problem with eating cow or chicken or pig or deer or turkey or fish or rabbit or snake… or, for that matter, eggs, dairy, and even plants and fungi.

I appreciate and respect that they are God’s creation, and I try to always remember to thank Him for giving us our food from His bounty. :gopray

But find it disgusting? Nope, not at all.
Also in the case of horses the cultural taboo against their meat in many cultures including our own (if our own may be considered English for this purpose) goes back to the days of conversion from Germanic paganism. The Germanic pagans sacrificed horses and ate their flesh ritually, and when they were converted local church and secular leaders often felt the need to ban horse-eating as a way of suppressing paganism. The ban turned into a cultural taboo which far outlasted the laws and the reason for them. France, with less Germanic heritage except in their name, has no problem with horseflesh.
 
Last night I tore a chicken to pieces with my bare hands. It didn’t bother me. And I very much enjoyed the chicken soup I made with his pieces.

I don’t think this makes me a bad person. 🙂 I am VERY compassionate, even to suffering animals. But once it’s dead, I may as well put it to good use.
 
You have to chop them up…just like you chop a fruit or vegetable. “Mutilate” is not the correct word to describe this. Eating roadkill or some other horribly disfigured beyond recognition animal might be described as “mutilated” but not one that is orderly dissected into manageable pieces.

You “mutilate” an apple when you bite it, or a steak when you cut into it or bite it. The difference is you can use your teeth, or a utensil. Using just your teeth on an entire chicken or an entire cow would not be practical…therefore you butcher, or chop it, into pieces you can cook or eat. Then you further chop it with either a knife of fork, or your teeth.

I guess you could say something like ground beef is “mutilated”…but then you would also say you “mutilate” a tomato to make pasta sauce…so I don’t think that’s the best way to describe it either. 🙂

Either way, no I’m not disgusted by it. 🙂 Yes, I would be put off a bit by eating roadkill or a genuinely mutilated animal. However, if it was prepared right and I didn’t know it was disfigured or how it died, I’d have no problem.
 
Um, dog as a food item isn’t limited to China.
People in Vietnam also eat dogs. From a Los Angeles article a while back, the practice was to terrorize (severe abuse) the dogs before slaughtering them to get the adrenaline flowing throughout the body.
 
I certainly would find it disgusting, and I think most people would. The eggs you buy at the supermarket are supposed to be unfertilized. Of course, sometimes mistakes are made and a fertilized egg with a partially formed chicken embryo gets mixed in. I think you’d be entitled to a refund for that carton of eggs.
I don’t know about most but there are those with the opinion that fertilized eggs are healthier. 🤷 The eggs from the store are caged chickens that have no access to a rooster.
 
Well, I’m no longer alone in strongly agreeing that it’s disgusting to eat animals! That’s 9%!
 
People in Vietnam also eat dogs. From a Los Angeles article a while back, the practice was to terrorize (severe abuse) the dogs before slaughtering them to get the adrenaline flowing throughout the body.
And abuse of animals should never be condoned. But that still doesn’t mean it’s a bad thing to eat them.
 
Well, I’m no longer alone in strongly agreeing that it’s disgusting to eat animals! That’s 9%!
Well, to be fair, you are no longer alone in thinking that it’s disgusting to eat “mutilated” animals. Most people would define a mutilated animal as roadkill, or maybe an animal that was killed and ripped to shreds by a bear, or one that was butchered horribly and still has bits of fur attached. 🙂 Not everyone will scroll down and read your unique definition of “mutilated” as “professionaly butchered.” 🙂

Also, it does not filter out those that don’t like butchered animals, but have no problem eating whole animals, such as small fish or insects. 😛
 
Well, to be fair, you are not longer alone in thinking that it’s disgusting to eat “mutilated” animals. Most people would define a mutilated animal as roadkill, or maybe an animal that was killed and ripped to shreds by a bear, or one that was butchered horribly and still has bits of fur attached. 🙂 Not everyone will scroll down and read your unique definition of mutilated. 🙂
Yes, I should have said ‘butchered.’
 
Do you find eating dogs the way they do in China to be gross? If yes, then why not with other animals. I think we grow so accustomed to eating butchered animals that it seems the normal thing to do.
That’s part of culture: we are socialized to become comfortable with certain things and therefore other practices seem weird or disturbing to us. But we can learn to overcome our repulsion and even appreciate diversity by studying cultural anthropology. Unlike many posters here, I do not find cultural relativism a bad thing.
 
I would never want to eat a dog or a cat, just because I grew up in America, so I’ve been conditioned emotionally to be against it. But I don’t think it’s wrong for anyone to eat any animal.
 
That’s part of culture: we are socialized to become comfortable with certain things and therefore other practices seem disturbing to us. But we can learn to overcome our repulsion and even appreciate diversity by studying cultural anthropology. Unlike many posters here, I do not find cultural relativism a bad thing.
I find the bolded to be unfair. Cultural relativism and spiritual relativism are two different animals.
 
I’ll never forget the first time I handled a whole raw chicken. It weirded me out a little bit, but I got over it pretty quickly. If it is feeding my family and providing nutrition to our bodies then I’ll get my hands dirty and make a killer meal. …Sorry for the pun.

All of God’s creation deserves respect and appreciation for what it is! It is for this reason that I am an active supporter of the ASPCA. Abused animals need help. Eating animals for food, however, is not inherently the same as abusing them. And we were given dominion over the animals for good reason.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top