Doctor Refusing to Prescribe Birth Control

  • Thread starter Thread starter _Abyssinia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That is incorrect. Some people need hormone medication to help with polycystic ovarian issues. Often the most common packaging of these medications is as birth control. But in those cases, the medication is not birth control/contraception. The doctor’s letter said she would continue to prescribe medications for those conditions, just not as BC pills.
It’s unfortunate that the doctor used the term “birth control pills” for hormonal treatment, including for “non-contraceptive reasons”. She isn’t explaining herself clearly at all.
 
My sympathy for the suffering caused by the pill, but the problem with what you say here is that MANY prescribed drugs can cause severe problems for patients… its kind of a Russian roulette. There is always that small percentage of people who might have a very bad or even deadly reaction to something prescribed and one won’t know until they try it. I do believe that all medications should have write ups of all the known side effects and let the PATIENT decide if they will take it or not. (That’s what steams me… they don’t tel the patient… .what a way to totally RUIN and obliterate patient/doctor trust which is necessary and, used to be at least, somewhat of a sacred, protected thing.)
I agree with your second part, about letting people know. I feel that the side effects of the Pill are often ignored simply because some people want to portray it as the Greatest Thing Ever. If you’re telling middle schoolers about The Pill then you damn sure should be talking about the problems, especially the emotional side effects. I connect this with marriage. When my wife tried The Pill (again, long before we came back to the Church) she actually stopped being attracted to me. She quit taking it and went back to normal. It was weird.

On the first part, though, yeah, all meds have side effects. It just bothers me a little bit that with certain things they just jump right to “Are you or have you ever been on The Pill?” I mean, my wife went to a doc with leg pain while she was training for a half marathon and she has known foot problems. And yet the first thing she got was the Pill question and was then rushed to an ultrasound.

I recall a story from England too where a girl had a stroke and the EMTs showed up (they can’t diagnose a stoke) and the “is she on the Pill?” question was the first thing they asked. And then were all “yeah, we know what this is.”

The way it’s a “first question” with some things makes me wonder how common it really is.
 
First of all, I agree that a physician or practice that won’t offer contraceptive services should make known when a patient first attaches themselves to the doctor. Secondly, I would add that physicians have an obligation to provide complete and accurate information about all available treatments, even if they aren’t willing to provide that treatment. I would even go so far as to say that physicians should suggest physicians or clinics that can help a patient obtain those services. On these three points, I think that most conscientious objecting physicians would agree.

Secondly, it’s important to note that physicians aren’t medication vending machines. Yes, I think that a patient has the right to receive birth control if appropriate. That isn’t the issue here. The issue is whether a patient has a right to force every clinician they meet to provide those services. Should Dr. X be forced to provide the pill when Dr. Y will across the street? Should a physician be forced to actively participate in an activity they may find immoral? Especially when, in reality, there are other accessible avenues for a patient to pursue? Does the threat of inconvenience (and in every case of outrage that I’ve seen, this is really what it amounts to) trump duty to act ethically as they see fit?

In my opinion, the answer is no. We would be better off accepting that not everyone will do what we want — on both sides of the issue — and willing to live and let live.
You want Catholic and other pro life Drs to not only counsel women that they can have an abortion but also to give an actual referral to a clinic that performs them? Really? First off, Catholics are not to cooperate with evil, which abortion is. Secondly, what you’re advocating would make these Drs a parter in the patients sin of abortion. Thirdly, I can just see it now, they give out a referral to an abortion clinic and get sued by the patient if something goes wrong.
 
You want Catholic and other pro life Drs to not only counsel women that they can have an abortion but also to give an actual referral to a clinic that performs them? Really? First off, Catholics are not to cooperate with evil, which abortion is. Secondly, what you’re advocating would make these Drs a parter in the patients sin of abortion. Thirdly, I can just see it now, they give out a referral to an abortion clinic and get sued by the patient if something goes wrong.
Then perhaps they could be very public and upfront that they will not provide any of this information, medication (birth control), and/or referrals so patients that are seeking those specific treatments don’t have to waste their time there? Maybe put a notice on the website, or in a public profile? If a Dr doesn’t wish to do any of these things, fine. But not everyone’s religious beliefs are the same as theirs and well, if I were a Methodist going to seek a prescription for birth control I’d be really annoyed to be told that they didn’t prescribe that based on their own beliefs AFTER they helped themselves to my insurance and co-pay.
 
Perhaps the doctor is misrepresented, but the article says this:she’s a Catholic she won’t prescribe any birth control, regardless of whether it’s used for contraception or notSo a few things, ASSUMING that is true.
  • If the doctor won’t prescribe it because she does not believe it is good medicine or because of harmful side effects, then this has nothing to do with her being Catholic.
  • If she believes it is immoral to use an otherwise contraceptive drug for non-contraceptive purposes, she is actually not in line with current Church understanding. As Bishop Lori said to the congressional panel in 2012: *"[The Church] recognizes that the same drug can operate in different ways and accomplish different things. If it is used to prevent birth, it is against our teaching." *But if she is prescribing equally effective alternatives, then there should be no issue.
 
Then perhaps they could be very public and upfront that they will not provide any of this information, medication (birth control), and/or referrals so patients that are seeking those specific treatments don’t have to waste their time there? Maybe put a notice on the website, or in a public profile? If a Dr doesn’t wish to do any of these things, fine. But not everyone’s religious beliefs are the same as theirs and well, if I were a Methodist going to seek a prescription for birth control I’d be really annoyed to be told that they didn’t prescribe that based on their own beliefs AFTER they helped themselves to my insurance and co-pay.
It’s a simple matter to ask the reception desk if they rx birth control before making the appointment. The real issue that people have is that they don’t want Drs to have the choice in the first place and they don’t want to even think about the fact that some people don’t agree with them.
 
Perhaps the doctor is misrepresented, but the article says this:she’s a Catholic she won’t prescribe any birth control, regardless of whether it’s used for contraception or notSo a few things, ASSUMING that is true.
  • If the doctor won’t prescribe it because she does not believe it is good medicine or because of harmful side effects, then this has nothing to do with her being Catholic.
  • If she believes it is immoral to use an otherwise contraceptive drug for non-contraceptive purposes, she is actually not in line with current Church understanding. As Bishop Lori said to the congressional panel in 2012: *"[The Church] recognizes that the same drug can operate in different ways and accomplish different things. If it is used to prevent birth, it is against our teaching." *But if she is prescribing equally effective alternatives, then there should be no issue.
I wouldn’t trust the news media to be able to differentiate the two in the first place. The fact that this was even a news story says something about the journalist.
 
Perhaps the doctor is misrepresented, but the article says this:she’s a Catholic she won’t prescribe any birth control, regardless of whether it’s used for contraception or notSo a few things, ASSUMING that is true.
  • If the doctor won’t prescribe it because she does not believe it is good medicine or because of harmful side effects, then this has nothing to do with her being Catholic.
  • If she believes it is immoral to use an otherwise contraceptive drug for non-contraceptive purposes, she is actually not in line with current Church understanding. As Bishop Lori said to the congressional panel in 2012: *"[The Church] recognizes that the same drug can operate in different ways and accomplish different things. If it is used to prevent birth, it is against our teaching." *But if she is prescribing equally effective alternatives, then there should be no issue.
A doctor I used to go to, who was often used to answer these questions about birth control on ewtn’s q&a area, told me the pill only MASKS symptoms. A place like the Pope Paul VI institute will actually p(name removed by moderator)oint the actual problem and prescribe hormones but NOT birth control pills, which are SYNTHETIC. For example, progesterone shots and estrogen patches, but these are bio identical prescriptions, not the synthetic form that the pill has. Don’t forget the backup mechanism designed for making the womb hostile that is one of the pill’s features.

I say good for this doctor! I would go to her in an instant!
 
Then perhaps they could be very public and upfront that they will not provide any of this information, medication (birth control), and/or referrals so patients that are seeking those specific treatments don’t have to waste their time there? Maybe put a notice on the website, or in a public profile? If a Dr doesn’t wish to do any of these things, fine. But not everyone’s religious beliefs are the same as theirs and well, if I were a Methodist going to seek a prescription for birth control I’d be really annoyed to be told that they didn’t prescribe that based on their own beliefs AFTER they helped themselves to my insurance and co-pay.
My GYN doesn’t prescribe ABC. Nor will she refer you for an abortion.

When you call, they tell up front.

I wouldn’t assume that this doctor wouldn’t say anything until the end.
 
Perhaps the doctor is misrepresented, but the article says this:she’s a Catholic she won’t prescribe any birth control, regardless of whether it’s used for contraception or notSo a few things, ASSUMING that is true. (…)
It appears to be true; the letter is show in the video and other photographs of the letter are shown on other websites. I guess I would only add: assuming the letters shown in the media are the wording of the doctor in referred to here.
 
A doctor I used to go to, who was often used to answer these questions about birth control on ewtn’s q&a area, told me the pill only MASKS symptoms. A place like the Pope Paul VI institute will actually p(name removed by moderator)oint the actual problem and prescribe hormones but NOT birth control pills, which are SYNTHETIC. For example, progesterone shots and estrogen patches, but these are bio identical prescriptions, not the synthetic form that the pill has. Don’t forget the backup mechanism designed for making the womb hostile that is one of the pill’s features.

I say good for this doctor! I would go to her in an instant!
NaPro technology does not work for all reproductive health issue. It does not work for fibroids. One treatment suggested to me was a combination of depo provera and depo lupron. The doctor in question would refuse this option for me even though it is morally permissible.
 
My GYN doesn’t prescribe ABC. Nor will she refer you for an abortion.

When you call, they tell up front.

I wouldn’t assume that this doctor wouldn’t say anything until the end.
Does your GYN refuse all hormonal treatment, even for non-contraceptive purposes?
 
It’s a simple matter to ask the reception desk if they rx birth control before making the appointment. The real issue that people have is that they don’t want Drs to have the choice in the first place and they don’t want to even think about the fact that some people don’t agree with them.
The issue is her way of thinking, for a doctor, is in the minority. If that is going to be in conflict with perspective patients, maybe she should upfront say “Dr. So&So does not prescribe birth control, is that going to be an issue?”. Feel free to deny it, but most women making an appointment for birth control don’t think their doctors religion will conflict with their method of family planning. 🤷 If she’s more upfront about it (has receptionists/website/online profile bio specify she won’t prescribe birth control) then patients have no excuse for complaining about it afterwards.
 
My GYN doesn’t prescribe ABC. Nor will she refer you for an abortion.

When you call, they tell up front.

I wouldn’t assume that this doctor wouldn’t say anything until the end.
That’s very good of your doctor, she should also put it in the online LinkedIn and any other clinic website she might be on. That’s normally where I look up doctor bios before considering.
 
Does your GYN refuse all hormonal treatment, even for non-contraceptive purposes?
No, she doesn’t.

Before my hysterectomy, she had me on Provera. And now after it she has me on estrogen.

At one point she would have put me on birth control to stop the bleeding. But I have too many other health issues, so they were contraindicated.
 
Good for the doctor! The pill has backup mechanisms designed to make womb hostile and cause chemical abortions. Plus, those nasty side effects like blood clots and risk for breast cancer the longer you use it.
:rolleyes:
 
The issue is her way of thinking, for a doctor, is in the minority. If that is going to be in conflict with perspective patients, maybe she should upfront say “Dr. So&So does not prescribe birth control, is that going to be an issue?”. Feel free to deny it, but most women making an appointment for birth control don’t think their doctors religion will conflict with their method of family planning. 🤷 If she’s more upfront about it (has receptionists/website/online profile bio specify she won’t prescribe birth control) then patients have no excuse for complaining about it afterwards.
👍 Exactamundo
 
NaPro technology does not work for all reproductive health issue. It does not work for fibroids. One treatment suggested to me was a combination of depo provera and depo lupron. The doctor in question would refuse this option for me even though it is morally permissible.
The following website says:
The problems Naprotechnology deals with:
  • Infertility of various etiologies (according to prof .Hilgers infertility can be diagnosed after a 6 months of observations and regular sexual intercourse and the effectiveness of the treatment is 50-80%);
  • Unplanned pregnancy preventing; ;
  • Endometriosis;
  • Pelvic and fallopian tubes adhesions;
  • Miscarriages;
  • Premature Births;
  • Polycystic ovary syndrome;
  • Premenstrual syndrome;
  • Postpartum depression;
  • Irregular bleedings;
  • Low progesterone level;
  • Fibroids and fibroid tumors of the reproductive organs;
  • Symptoms of the premenopausal period (removal of unpleasant symptoms in 95% of cases);
  • Control or even elimination of migraine headaches (50% efficiency).
myfertiledays.com/en/content/naprotechnology

Bold text my emphases.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top