Does 2 Tim 3:16-17 support Sola Scriptura?

  • Thread starter Thread starter RussAuburn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Shame on you.
I have no reason whatsoever to feel shame.

You did not answer my questions:
Quote:
Don’t you claim that the Holy Spirit is guiding your Christian community? No? Well, then who is guiding it? Some poor human? How prone to error is that?
Unquote

peace
 
The problem is that the RC defines the Church differently than the Bible.

The church is the body of believers - wherever they exist. But Catholics define the “Church” as membership in the Catholic denomination.
If it helps, Church is defined in the Catholic Church as the body of believers as well. As for membership, the funny thing is that many, if not most, Protestant denominations also would define church to mean exclusive membership into their said denomination. This is most true for Fundamentalist Protestant denominations.
Since you claim Tradition is the only way to correctly interpret Scripture, you make the Scriptures null.
Tradition, as defined by the Catholic Church, is Apostolic Tradition, that rich body of teachings handed down from the Apostles onwards. Now, if that’s a stumbling block, then discussion about the Bible would be a stumbling block as well, since the Bible is part of that Tradition. Now, why would it matter that to correctly interpret the Bible, we must adhere to this Tradition? It’s because if one wants to know what the Apostles taught, or indeed what Jesus Himself taught, then one has to follow that unbroken line of teachings coming down from Him onwards. See, you quote the Church Fathers yourself; you realize the validity of this unbroken line of teachings, at least in principle. However, you still do not grasp why the need to adhere to this. Catholics and Orthodox agree on this one, the adherance to Sacred Tradition in interpreting the Bible.
The Catholic Church claims that doctrines evolve. (That’s how you justify changing them)
Evolution in the sense that there is a need to clarify them; remember again, if were left as it is, there would be even more confusion now as to what the Trinity is, for instance. If not for the Council of Nicaea, when Arius and his followers were censured, then the understanding about the Trinity would still be muddled. So it is not evolution per se, but rather a clarification or making it defined.
I choose to believe that which is unchanging.
Then you must be out of luck, since Protestant understanding of the Bible, the Church, and many things else keeps on changing, depending on what denomination you’re talking to.
 
This is a false statement. I am not aware of any Scripture that states Paul needed approval for what he preached.
Galatians will be located on the right side of your bible, it is found just after 2 Corinthians, and right before Ephesians.

Galatians 2:1-2
[1] Then after fourteen years I went up again to Jerusalem with Barnabas, taking Titus along with me.
[2] I went up by revelation; and I laid before them (but privately before those who were of repute) the gospel which I preach among the Gentiles, lest somehow I should be running or had run in vain.
 
I have no reason whatsoever to feel shame.

You did not answer my questions:
Quote:
Don’t you claim that the Holy Spirit is guiding your Christian community? No? Well, then who is guiding it? Some poor human? How prone to error is that?
Unquote

peace
She’s been asked a slew of questions she can’t answer. I think this is one of those cases of invincible ignorance. :banghead: Either there is no ear to hear or simply can’t comprehend. Anti-Church indoctrination is powerful. Words won’t break it. Only much prayer and fasting by the one inflicted will dispell leigon.

Peace.
 
Milliardo,

Ginger was probably thinking of…

It appears that Peter understood that Paul’s writings (at least some of them) were scripture.
…other scripture–the Old Testament. At the time it was written, Peter would not have equated Paul’s letters in the same regard as that of the Old Testament. Subsequent Christian communities would do that, but it is highly doubtful that at that early stage Peter would.
 
The problem is that the RC defines the Church differently than the Bible.

The church is the body of believers - wherever they exist. But Catholics define the “Church” as membership in the Catholic denomination.

As I look thru the posts, I see this is a stumbling block for our discourse.

Since you claim Tradition is the only way to correctly interpret Scripture, you make the Scriptures null.

God does not change. He remains the same God’s word does not change.

Mal 3:6 For I [am] the LORD, I change not; therefore ye sons of Jacob are not consumed.
Hbr 13:8 Jesus Christ the same yesterday, and to day, and for ever.

The Catholic Church claims that doctrines evolve. (That’s how you justify changing them)

The Word of God does not change.

I choose to believe that which is unchanging.
There are a lot of errors here. First, where do you get your definition of your church.

Nobody here ever said God changes. If you would like to read the Church Fathers, St. Thomas Aquinas, the Doctors of the Church they will explain to you our teaching about the immutability and unchangeableness of our God.

You throw out Scripture quotes just for the sake of doing it, thus it is you who make Scriptures null.

The Church for us is that institution founded by Jesus Christ; she is guided infallibly by the Holy Spirit, whose members are led by Peter on earth. We have been given the Sacraments as part of the living life of the Church.

We are given membership by Baptism, and grace through faith in Christ Jesus, and we work out justification and salvation by the graces God sends us, and cooperation with the same. We have a communion of saints, on earth, in purgatory, and in heaven, who live and support each other by prayers and good works.

You are stumbling but you know that the Catholic Church is the means set up by Jesus for our salvation, which you are required to join, and be a member.

I am sure your understanding of scripture last year has changed this year.

Scriptures are not null, but have been proclaimed in our Church for 2,000 years. They make up part of the Mass of the Catechumens, and have been proclaimed by us throughout the world.

peace
 
I thought you knew that.

It means that those who through their own grave fault do not know that the Catholic Church is the true Church or, knowing it, refuse to join it, cannot be saved.

maranatha
Well then…it seems you just made the Catholic Church irrelevent. :confused:

Obviously everyone who loves the Lord and is not Catholic does not “know” what you claim to be true.

Therefore, there is salvation apart from the RC.
 
She’s been asked a slew of questions she can’t answer. I think this is one of those cases of invincible ignorance. :banghead: Either there is no ear to hear or simply can’t comprehend. Anti-Church indoctrination is powerful. Words won’t break it. Only much prayer and fasting by the one inflicted will dispell leigon.

Peace.
Pefect response.
 
There are a lot of errors here. First, where do you get your definition of your church.

Nobody here ever said God changes. If you would like to read the Church Fathers, St. Thomas Aquinas, the Doctors of the Church they will explain to you our teaching about the immutability and unchangeableness of our God.

You throw out Scripture quotes just for the sake of doing it, thus it is you who make Scriptures null.

The Church for us is that institution founded by Jesus Christ; she is guided infallibly by the Holy Spirit, whose members are led by Peter on earth. We have been given the Sacraments as part of the living life of the Church.

We are given membership by Baptism, and grace through faith in Christ Jesus, and we work out justification and salvation by the graces God sends us, and cooperation with the same. We have a communion of saints, on earth, in purgatory, and in heaven, who live and support each other by prayers and good works.

You are stumbling but you know that the Catholic Church is the means set up by Jesus for our salvation, which you are required to join, and be a member.

I am sure your understanding of scripture last year has changed this year.

Scriptures are not null, but have been proclaimed in our Church for 2,000 years. They make up part of the Mass of the Catechumens, and have been proclaimed by us throughout the world.

peace
Sometimes you seem so confused…🤷
 
The thing is before Reformation the Christians always have 73 Books in Bible. It was not until 1600s that most current translation of the Protestant Bible have 66 books.
Wrong again.

Cyril of Jerusalem catalogued the canonical Old Testament books. His list did not include the Apocrypha. (Philip Schaff and Henry Wace, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Vol VII, Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lectures IV.33-36 (c) 1952 Eerdmans, pp. 26-28)

Origen also lists 22 books, none of which are apocryphal. (Philip Schaff and Henry Wace, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, vol. I, Eusebius, Church History VI.25.1-2 (c) 1952 Eerdmans, p. 272)

The Apocrypha wasn’t added to the canon until 1546.

Hebrews was not originally included in the NT canon, nor was Revelation.
 
Is that your response? Is that the best you can do?

peace
You ask questions that are not consistent with my posts. I never claimed anyone said God changes. I said that since God is unchanging, I choose to not to place my faith in Traditions that change with time.
 
Wrong again.

Cyril of Jerusalem catalogued the canonical Old Testament books. His list did not include the Apocrypha. (Philip Schaff and Henry Wace, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Vol VII, Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lectures IV.33-36 (c) 1952 Eerdmans, pp. 26-28)

Origen also lists 22 books, none of which are apocryphal. (Philip Schaff and Henry Wace, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, vol. I, Eusebius, Church History VI.25.1-2 (c) 1952 Eerdmans, p. 272)

Hebrews was not originally included in the NT canon, nor was Revelation.
The Early Church Fathers had differing views as to the Deuterocanonicals, though it is often agreed that most Christian communities of that period included it. You offer only two; like I stated, many of the Church Fathers included or at leas allude to the Deuterocanonicals rather than exclude them.
 
The Early Church Fathers had differing views as to the Deuterocanonicals, though it is often agreed that most Christian communities of that period included it. You offer only two; like I stated, many of the Church Fathers included or at leas allude to the Deuterocanonicals rather than exclude them.
OK…
 
Wrong again.

Cyril of Jerusalem catalogued the canonical Old Testament books. His list did not include the Apocrypha. (Philip Schaff and Henry Wace, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Vol VII, Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lectures IV.33-36 (c) 1952 Eerdmans, pp. 26-28)

Origen also lists 22 books, none of which are apocryphal. (Philip Schaff and Henry Wace, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, vol. I, Eusebius, Church History VI.25.1-2 (c) 1952 Eerdmans, p. 272)

The Apocrypha wasn’t added to the canon until 1546.

Hebrews was not originally included in the NT canon, nor was Revelation.
The Council of Trent reaffirmed the canon from the council of Florence which was held in 1441

Before the council of Florence there were the councils of Laodicea held in 360 which had a canon very similar to the Catholic canon of today. Then there was The Council of Rome in 382, the Council of Hippo in 393 which has the same canon as today, and the Council of Carthage in 397 which Protestants use for their New Testament Canon. The Old Testament canon from the same council is identical to Roman Catholic canon today. Another Council of Carthage in 419 offered the same list of canonical books.
Code:
Since the Roman Catholic Church does not define truths unless errors abound on the matter, Roman Catholic Christians look to the Council of Florence, an ecumenical council in 1441 for the first definitive list of canonical books. 

The final infallible definition of canonical books for Roman Catholic Christians came from the Council of Trent in 1556 in the face of the errors of the Reformers who rejected seven Old Testament books from the canon of scripture to that time.
 
Well then…it seems you just made the Catholic Church irrelevent. :confused:

Obviously everyone who loves the Lord and is not Catholic does not “know” what you claim to be true.
Not true. There are those who love the Lord, and know the claims of the Catholic Church, but refuse to join.

Look to yourself.

Outside the Church there is no salvation. Any one who is saved is saved through the merits of the Roman Catholic Church.

peace
 
You ask questions that are not consistent with my posts. I never claimed anyone said God changes. I said that since God is unchanging, I choose to not to place my faith in Traditions that change with time.
The Deposit of Faith is for mankind. If mankind were unchangeable, you might have an argument.

The depth of knowledge to be gained about God in the Beatific Vision is infinite. Why should knowledge of God and his Church and its teachings not be explored. It is our knowledge that deepens, not that the truths are changed.

You have very faulty reasoning.

peace
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top