Does incorruptible is really miracle?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Umm, I thought that the body of St. Bernadette had been treated so I double-checked myself. From Atlas Obscura “The Not-Quite Incorruptible St. Bernadette of Lourdes”:
As part of the canonization process, her body was exhumed three separate times, in 1909, 1919, and finally in 1925, when she was moved to the crystal casket. Her body was pronounced by the church as officially “incorrupt,” but it seems the qualifications for that term may have been somewhat lax. In the words of the attending doctor in 1919: “The body is practically mummified, covered with patches of mildew and quite a notable layer of salts, which appear to be calcium salts… The skin has disappeared in some places, but it is still present on most parts of the body.”
After a few ribs were removed to be sent to Rome as relics, it was decided that the “blackish color” of her face might be off-putting to pilgrims, and so a “light wax mask” was in order. Her new face and hands were designed by Pierre Imans, a designer of fashion mannequins in Paris.
I think the waxing process was used on other incorruptibles.
 
Umm, I thought that the body of St. Bernadette had been treated so I double-checked myself. From Atlas Obscura “The Not-Quite Incorruptible St. Bernadette of Lourdes”:

I think the waxing process was used on other incorruptibles.
Atlas Obscura is not a valid Church reference.

St Bernadette, is incorrupt according to the Catholic Church.

The wax coating on her exposed skin areas was done because of parching which is the result of the skin drying. This was common for incorruptibles, but prior to the technology of glass coffins, it was even worse. Some, having been exposed in chapels with large amounts of candles burning, turned brown and leathery.

I visited the convent at Nevers and attended Mass at her glass coffin, which is in the convent Chapel.

I also visited St Catherine of Laboure, who’s body is also incorrupt.

traditioninaction.org/SOD/SODimages5/232_incorrupt_labourel.jpg

She died in 1876, and exhumed in 1933. Her eyes are open and they are a beautiful blue.

Another characteristic of many of the incorrupt saints is that their bodies emits a perfume fragrance, which can’t be explained by scientist who study the bodies.

Jim
 
Atlas Obscura is not a valid Church reference.

St Bernadette, is incorrupt according to the Catholic Church.

The wax coating on her exposed skin areas was done because of parching which is the result of the skin drying. This was common for incorruptibles, but prior to the technology of glass coffins, it was even worse. Some, having been exposed in chapels with large amounts of candles burning, turned brown and leathery.

I visited the convent at Nevers and attended Mass at her glass coffin, which is in the convent Chapel.

I also visited St Catherine of Laboure, who’s body is also incorrupt.

traditioninaction.org/SOD/SODimages5/232_incorrupt_labourel.jpg

She died in 1876, and exhumed in 1933. Her eyes are open and they are a beautiful blue.

Another characteristic of many of the incorrupt saints is that their bodies emits a perfume fragrance, which can’t be explained by scientist who study the bodies.

Jim
Yes, this is true the waxing is done because we are talking about bodies that have been taking out, suffered multiple scientific examinations, cut opened and stitched, so they have to apply a layer of wax to place them on display. This is also done with regular mummies, all Egyptian mummies including Ramses _II which is the best preserved, have a layer of wax. However the difference is clear, even after the wax, between natural mummies and incorruptibles. And again remember, the miracle part of incorruptible is that there is no scientific explanation for the so called “mummification” as the environment where they were place does not meet mummification requirement. How does the Atlas Obscure explains the so called “mummification” of st Bernadette in a humid environment?
 
Certainly there are instances of miraculous incorruptibles. However, IIRC an uncorrupted body is not accepted by the church as a possible miracle necessary for canonization.
 
Certainly there are instances of miraculous incorruptibles. However, IIRC an uncorrupted body is not accepted by the church as a possible miracle necessary for canonization.
That is correct. For canonization, it must be a miracle attributed to their intercession from heaven. Any miracles they performed on earth while alive wouldn’t count either.
 
Atlas Obscura is not a valid Church reference.
With all due respect, why would I have to use a “valid Church reference” to describe a physical, scientific phenomenon? In reality, you shouldn’t, because of bias. Does not the Church get outside medical evaluations when judging purported miracles attributed to future saints, etc.?
 
How does the Atlas Obscure explains the so called “mummification” of st Bernadette in a humid environment?
They don’t. So what do we want: Catholic sources explaining what happened to St. Bernadette’s body or scientific sources explaining the same thing? :confused: :confused: :confused:
 
With all due respect, why would I have to use a “valid Church reference” to describe a physical, scientific phenomenon? In reality, you shouldn’t, because of bias. Does not the Church get outside medical evaluations when judging purported miracles attributed to future saints, etc.?
Yes, the Church uses independent resources to investigate miracles, often times they’re not even Christian.

They have the documentation, secular sources don’t and often have their own biases.

Anyway, take it as you will.

Jim
 
They don’t. So what do we want: Catholic sources explaining what happened to St. Bernadette’s body or scientific sources explaining the same thing? :confused: :confused: :confused:
St Albert Magnus once said that we should always look for a natural explanation to physical phenomena before looking to the supernatural. So, if is that important, we should first want a scientific explanation to any supposed miracle, and when that cannot be found look for the miraculous. I believe that is the Church’s process most of the time.

In the case of an incorruptible body, it just normally isn’t important enough to justify disturbing the relic. So the church, to my knowledge doesn’t normally pronounce one way or the other. The Church certainly doesn’t discourage private beliefs that a given saint’s body is miraculously incorruptible, but does not do much verification.
 
St Albert Magnus once said that we should always look for a natural explanation to physical phenomena before looking to the supernatural. So, if is that important, we should first want a scientific explanation to any supposed miracle, and when that cannot be found look for the miraculous. I believe that is the Church’s process most of the time.

In the case of an incorruptible body, it just normally isn’t important enough to justify disturbing the relic. So the church, to my knowledge doesn’t normally pronounce one way or the other. The Church certainly doesn’t discourage private beliefs that a given saint’s body is miraculously incorruptible, but does not do much verification.
That’s right. It’s not like we stand up in church on Sunday and say "I believe in God the Father almighty, and in the incorruptible body of St. Bernadette…etc
 
St Albert Magnus once said that we should always look for a natural explanation to physical phenomena before looking to the supernatural. So, if is that important, we should first want a scientific explanation to any supposed miracle, and when that cannot be found look for the miraculous. I believe that is the Church’s process most of the time.
My point exactly.
 
They don’t. So what do we want: Catholic sources explaining what happened to St. Bernadette’s body or scientific sources explaining the same thing? :confused: :confused: :confused:
Of course the first thing we need to look at is a scientific explanation, and that is what the church does but when the event defies every existing scientific law and explanation, then is a miracle. As I said before there is a scientific explanation called natural mummification and natural mummification happens in dry, cold environment. The atlas classifies st bernadette as a mummy however from a scientific point of view that is impossible because she was in a humid place and mummification is impossible in humid environment so if we look at scientific sources from a secular point of view then the explanation is that is all a lie, that bernadette was never exhumated, that every single scientific report done signed by several scientists and doctors was a lie and everybody is lying and the Atlas is also lying. That is the scientific explanation: bernadette’s.case is impossible.

But as Catholics we know there is a God and that God makes miracles and we know is very improbable that every single person and every single report is a lie because as you can notice from the links I posted, even secular sources indicate that there is no.scientific explanation for her body being corrupted. So then, when science fails, is that we know is a miracle.
 
Yes, the Church uses independent resources to investigate miracles, often times they’re not even Christian.

They have the documentation, secular sources don’t and often have their own biases.

Anyway, take it as you will.

Jim
Could you clear up something for me? What are you calling an “independent resource” vis–à–vis a “secular source”?
 
Of course the first thing we need to look at is a scientific explanation, and that is what the church does but when the event defies every existing scientific law and explanation, then is a miracle. As I said before there is a scientific explanation called natural mummification and natural mummification happens in dry, cold environment.
You contradicted yourself. You mentioned the mummification in the peat bogs. A bog has less drainage than a swamp.
The atlas classifies st bernadette as a mummy however from a scientific point of view that is impossible because she was in a humid place and mummification is impossible in humid environment
It **is **possible in a humid environment: bogs and glaciers. And in the Atlas Obscura quote, the one who mentioned mummification was the doctor who examined the body in 1919!
so if we look at scientific sources from a secular point of view then the explanation is that is all a lie, that bernadette was never exhumated, that every single scientific report done signed by several scientists and doctors was a lie and everybody is lying and the Atlas is also lying. That is the scientific explanation: bernadette’s.case is impossible.
How do you look at “scientific sources” from anything other than a “secular POV”? “Scientific” = “secular”. No one is saying that St. Bernadette was “never exhumated [sic]”. She was exhumed 3X! There is witnessed evidence for this. I am not saying that “every single scientific report done signed by several scientists and doctors was a lie and everybody is lying.” Frankly, I do not know how many reports were done. I haven’t said anyone is lying. I especially did not say that the Atlas Obscura was lying—why would I? I gave you the source! And just to be clear, the Atlas Obscura does not say she is incorrupt. It says that the Church pronounced her “incorrupt”. There’s a difference. In point of fact, your source “How Stuff Works” says the following:
Bernadette stands (or lies) as a sterling example of incorruptibility. But her corpse also provides ammunition for skeptics. Her hands and face appear incredibly lifelike, but this is due to a wax covering. Beneath the waxy exterior, her skin has browned. While there’s no scientific explanation for why her body would have remained so well-preserved without the aid of embalming or environmental conditions, she shows that all bodies will eventually rot. Just how long that process takes, however, may depend on any number of factors
This is exactly the same thing that the Atlas Obscura said. St. Bernadette’s face and hands are waxed. This is what you see. The body is brown and even in the words of the attending doctor in 1919 it “is practically mummified…”
But as Catholics we know there is a God and that God makes miracles and we know is very improbable that every single person and every single report is a lie because as you can notice from the links I posted, even secular sources indicate that there is no.scientific explanation for her body being corrupted. So then, when science fails, is that we know is a miracle.
I believe that God is omnipotent and can grace the body of a saint with incorruptibility. But I would like to see the documentation that disallows any possibility of mummification in the case of St. Bernadette. I would like to see the “secular” source that says that mummification did not occur. Your source from “How Things Work” doesn’t say that. Neither “Mummies of the World” nor zoology.ubc.ca even mention St. Bernadette.

I don’t know about the other posters here, but if the body of Bernadette were to crumble into dust tomorrow, I still will not doubt that she is a saint and that she indeed saw the Immaculate Conception. I don’t need relics, or incorrupt bodies, or winding sheets or whatever to believe.
 
Could you clear up something for me? What are you calling an “independent resource” vis–à–vis a “secular source”?
Yes, the Church uses independent secular sources.

Just like the latest investigations on the Shroud of Turin, conducted included Israeli scientists.

Jim
 
You contradicted yourself. You mentioned the mummification in the peat bogs. A bog has less drainage than a swamp.

It **is **possible in a humid environment: bogs and glaciers. And in the Atlas Obscura quote, the one who mentioned mummification was the doctor who examined the body in 1919!

How do you look at “scientific sources” from anything other than a “secular POV”? “Scientific” = “secular”. No one is saying that St. Bernadette was “never exhumated [sic]”. She was exhumed 3X! There is witnessed evidence for this. I am not saying that “every single scientific report done signed by several scientists and doctors was a lie and everybody is lying.” Frankly, I do not know how many reports were done. I haven’t said anyone is lying. I especially did not say that the Atlas Obscura was lying—why would I? I gave you the source! And just to be clear, the Atlas Obscura does not say she is incorrupt. It says that the Church pronounced her “incorrupt”. There’s a difference. In point of fact, your source “How Stuff Works” says the following:

This is exactly the same thing that the Atlas Obscura said. St. Bernadette’s face and hands are waxed. This is what you see. The body is brown and even in the words of the attending doctor in 1919 it “is practically mummified…”

I believe that God is omnipotent and can grace the body of a saint with incorruptibility. But I would like to see the documentation that disallows any possibility of mummification in the case of St. Bernadette. I would like to see the “secular” source that says that mummification did not occur. Your source from “How Things Work” doesn’t say that. Neither “Mummies of the World” nor zoology.ubc.ca even mention St. Bernadette.

I don’t know about the other posters here, but if the body of Bernadette were to crumble into dust tomorrow, I still will not doubt that she is a saint and that she indeed saw the Immaculate Conception. I don’t need relics, or incorrupt bodies, or winding sheets or whatever to believe.
You need to read about mummification because you are obviously talking without knowing. First, as to bogs mummification in bogs occurs because bogs have sphagnum moss which condenses and creates peats that encases bodies in an Oxygen deprived environment. The bacteria that causes the decomposition process needs oxygen to live, if there is no oxygen then the bacteria dies out of lack of oxygen and decomposition doesn’t happen. Your comparison to swamps is apples to oranges as swamps lack sphagnum moss and nobody has ever found a mummy in a swamp.

Second, show me a forensic pathology book or a mummification expert that states that mummification does happen in highly humid environments. The only way a mummification can occur in a humid environment is that there is no oxygen which is not the case of bernadette. As I said, bogs is due to the lack of oxygen, and glaciers is because of cold. I said mummification does happen in cold and dry environment. Tell me how many mummies have been found in the Amazon basin or in the tropical rainforest? again what you seem to not understand is that mummification requires very specific environmental conditions and st bernadette does not meet any the environmental conditions for mummification, her supposedly mummification is impossible and that is why I say that if we are going to stick to a pure scientific view, then the entire story is a lie, in fact all the non religious scientists I know hold exactly that view on the issue, that she is a fake wax statute and was never exhumated and all the witness are lying and they believe that because from a scientific point of view her case is impossible.

I did say that her hands and face are waxed, I do know that. They do that even with all Egyptian mummies. That is routine practice and it was already explained why. Of course there is going to be Browning of the skin, she is NOT alive! The sources I gave don’t speak about her directly, but I told the OP that in order to understand the issue you need to learn about decomposition and mummification in general and then you can look at the individual cases. All the sources I Linked do say mummification occurs in “DRY, cool” environments and they all repeat that certain environmental factors must be present. That sounds very clear to me. If I read that water in order to turns into ice needs to be under cold temperature, does that mean that water may become turn into ice at 90 degrees Fahrenheit? Same thing here. If you are expecting a report to say well there is no possibility of mummification in bernadette’s case you are not going to find it for two reasons: because that is not the job of a forensic pathologist and no forensic pathologist is ever going to write that; and second because most scientist who are not catholic and are experts in forensic pathology think it is a lie, so you are never going to find it.

And finally, yes it is true our faith is not based on incorrupt bodies, it is not required for sainthood and the church doesn’t mandate anyone to believe it, but at least in my case (just to give an example outside of religion) of someone comes to tell me that Hernan Cortes went to the moon riding a horse, I am going to say it is scientifically impossible because no one can go to the moon riding a horse. Same thing here.
 
Mary
You need to read about mummification because you are obviously talking without knowing. First, as to bogs mummification in bogs occurs because bogs have sphagnum moss which condenses and creates peats that encases bodies in an Oxygen deprived environment. The bacteria that causes the decomposition process needs oxygen to live, if there is no oxygen then the bacteria dies out of lack of oxygen and decomposition doesn’t happen. Your comparison to swamps is apples to oranges as swamps lack sphagnum moss and nobody has ever found a mummy in a swamp.
But this isn’t true mummification, because as soon as the body is exposed to the air, it decomposes and quickly. Mummification which takes place in dry heat, and the corpse has had internal organs removed, such as Egyptian mummies, do not decay rapidly once exposed to air, providing it’s kept in a controlled condition.

Not so incorrupt saints. Their bodies were buried in less than prime conditions for mummification to have occurred, a certainly once exposed, they did not begin to decay, nor were they treated with extra care for mummification, but the first people to exhume the grave.

Jim
 
You need to read about mummification because you are obviously talking without knowing.
No need for insults. Although I could, I will not argue the process of mummification with you any further because that is not the topic of this thread.
If you are expecting a report to say well there is no possibility of mummification in bernadette’s case you are not going to find it for two reasons: because that is not the job of a forensic pathologist and no forensic pathologist is ever going to write that; and second because most scientist who are not catholic and are experts in forensic pathology think it is a lie, so you are never going to find it.
I really, really don’t know what you’re trying to say here. :confused:
  1. Are you saying that the Church did not rule out the possibility of mummification in her decision to declare St. Bernadette “incorrupt”?
  2. What is it that is “not the job of a forensic pathologist”?
  3. What is that which “no forensic pathologist is ever going to write”?
  4. You seem to be saying that that most scientists and/or forensic pathologists are not Catholic and therefore they will call any Church documentation lies. Is that it?
I don’t even know why “forensic pathologists”—who were not contemporaries at the times of the exhumations—were brought into the discussion…:confused:
And finally, yes it is true our faith is not based on incorrupt bodies, it is not required for sainthood and the church doesn’t mandate anyone to believe it, but at least in my case (just to give an example outside of religion) of someone comes to tell me that Hernan Cortes went to the moon riding a horse, I am going to say it is scientifically impossible because no one can go to the moon riding a horse. Same thing here.
You’ve got me totally confused: what is the “case” that you are talking about and how does this relate to the incorrupt body of St. Bernadette? :confused::confused::confused:
 
In the early 60’s some scientists were able to preserve somebody’s body after his death – and now people think that his body is proof of his holiness (little do they know that his veins were pumped up with a special solution right after he died and that his body is preserved by means of pure science). I won’t mention this person’s name for fear of getting banned. Lenin’s body has been preserved as well by means of science. Saints, on the other hand, are incorruptible not by means of science, but by means of a holy life lived and by God preserving their holy bodies. God bless you.
 
In the early 60’s some scientists were able to preserve somebody’s body after his death – and now people think that his body is proof of his holiness (little do they know that his veins were pumped up with a special solution right after he died and that his body is preserved by means of pure science). I won’t mention this person’s name for fear of getting banned. Lenin’s body has been preserved as well by means of science. Saints, on the other hand, are incorruptible not by means of science, but by means of a holy life lived and by God preserving their holy bodies. God bless you.
Lenin’s body was preserved by a taxidermy, no different than a trophy deer head, and his body has to be kept in a controlled environment.

Not so the incorruptible saints.

Jim
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top