Does Midnight Mass fulfill the Christmas obligation?

  • Thread starter Thread starter coolcatholicguy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Brother JR:

With respect to Canon 1248, let’s see what happens when you underline a different phrase:
Can. 1248 §1. A person who assists at a Mass celebrated anywhere in a Catholic rite either on the feast day itself or in the evening of the preceding day satisfies the obligation of participating in the Mass.
You’re implying that a person must go to the proper “Mass of the day” to satisfy the obligation, but as discussed here and here, to give two examples, that’s not true. That is why weddings and funerals, if celebrated for some reason on Saturday evening or Sunday, always satisfy the Sunday obligation, even though they are not the proper Mass of the day.
What happens in these cases is that the mass of the day is celebrated. The wedding rite stands alone, as does the Rite of Christian burial. That’s why you can attend a wedding on Saturday night and fulfill your Sunday obligation. The mass is the mass for the Sunday. There is not a wedding mass per se. There is a Rite of Marriage that is celebrated within the mass. But you always celebrate the mass of the day. The Church gives you choices in the readings, but the rest remains the same as prescribed for the Sunday, obviating the prayers of the Rite for the Sacrament of Matrimony.

I don’t know of any diocese that celebrates funeral masses on Sundays. Once again, theoretically you could, if it is allowed by the local bishop. The Rite of Christian Burial can be celebrated within the mass. The key word is within. The rubrics do make allowances for variations in the readings here too.
If it were true that the Christmas obligation required attending a “Christmas Mass” and the Sunday obligation required attending a “Sunday Mass,” then of course it would follow that if Christmas and Sunday are on different days no one Mass could satisfy both requirements. It would also have bizarre results, for instance that, in a country where the Feast of the Ascension is transferred to Sunday, a person who attended the EF on that day would fail to satisfy his obligation because the Mass of the Ascension had been done three days earlier and the Mass of the Sunday after the Ascension was being celebrated.
No it would not cause a problem. Because the law requires that you observe the solemnity. It does not say that it must be on a given day. There is a provision in the law to move it to Sunday, but it is not an obligation to celebrate it on Sunday. My community never celebrates it on Sunday.

When it is moved, In that case the mass for that Sunday is the mass of the Ascension. The reason that it can be done is because it does not coincide with another holy day. The Sunday after the Ascension is a Sunday of Easter. It’s not a specific holy day. There is no conflict. That’s why the law allows the Ascension to be moved to Sunday.

What happens in this case is that you have two solemnities. There is the conflict. That’s why the Saturday evening mass, this year, will not satisfy the Christmas obligation. The Christmas mass cannot replace the mass for the Sunday. Both masses must be celebrated or the other option is not to have a Saturday evening mass.
But the word “day” in Canon 1248 must refer to a calendar day, not a liturgical day, because otherwise the reference to “the evening of the preceding day” would be nonsensical.
It’s a liturgical use of the frase “the evening of the preceding day” which is borrowed from the breviary. We always had Evening Prayer I or First Vespers for Sundays and Solemnities. That’s where the term came from. It was used to mean that the solemnity begins at Vespers on the preceding day, not the calendar day.

In the English translation it becomes a little odd sounding. We don’t have a word for “visperas” which is in the Latin and the Romance Languages. We have to use “preceding day”. When the Code was translated into English, it took the language from the breviary’s reference to First Vespers as the vespers that precede the solemnity. To precede, in liturgy, means to lead or to initiate. The mass of the preceding day is the first mass of the solemnity or the mass that opens the solemnity. This year, the Saturday evening mass will open the Sunday Solemnity.

Just like the Ascension, the reason that you can put the Feast of the Holy Family there is because it does not conflict with another holy day. If it were not there, then it would simply be the First Sunday of the Octave of Christmas.

The law allows for any ordinary Sunday to be used to celebrate a holy day authorized by the Church. Not every holy day can be celebrated on a Sunday, even if there is no conflict. Notice, I said ordinary Sunday, not Sunday of Ordinary Time. Those are two different things.

We had a similar situation with the Solemnity of St. Francis. It fell on a Sunday. But it’s not a solemnity for the Catholic Church. It’s only a solemnity for the four Franciscan Orders and for Italy. The Holy See had to authorize the use of the mass of St. Francis on that day in every Franciscan parish and house and in Italy. But there was no conflict, because it was an ordinary Sunday.

The laity who attended fulfilled their Sunday obligation. They simply had a whole different set of readings, different collects, a different liturgical prayer, a very long sequence before the Gospel and the renewal of vows in place of the Creed. If there were an established holy day on that Sunday, then there would be a conflict. The universal holy day would take precedence.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
OY VEH!

Could it possibly be less complicated?
The priests, servers and choir do the heavy lifting.
All that’s required of us is to show up and pray the Mass.
  • 0600 FRI Lauds & Matins
  • 0800 FRI Regular Daily OF
  • 0000 SAT Mid-Christmas EF
  • 0700 SAT Day-Christmas EF
  • 0700 SUN Regular Sunday EF
  • 1000 SUN Melkite Divine Liturgy
Piece of cake.
Our friars are simply not celebrating a Saturday evening mass. Our superior said that the friars had to stop everything at noon on Christmas day in order to celebrate Christmas as a community. That solved that problem. Our parishes will close at noon or after the noon mass, something like that. Piece of cake.

I’m so glad that I belong to a conventual community. We don’t complicate our lives this way. The people we serve roll right along with our schedule, so everyone is happy.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
Our friars are simply not celebrating a Saturday evening mass. Our superior said that the friars had to stop everything at noon on Christmas day in order to celebrate Christmas as a community. That solved that problem. Our parishes will close at noon or after the noon mass, something like that. Piece of cake.

I’m so glad that I belong to a conventual community. We don’t complicate our lives this way. The people we serve roll right along with our schedule, so everyone is happy.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
**If you’re happy - and they’re happy - I’m happy too.

Deo Gratias.**
 
It’s a liturgical use of the frase “the evening of the preceding day” which is borrowed from the breviary. We always had Evening Prayer I or First Vespers for Sundays and Solemnities. That’s where the term came from. It was used to mean that the solemnity begins at Vespers on the preceding day, not the calendar day.

In the English translation it becomes a little odd sounding. We don’t have a word for “visperas” which is in the Latin and the Romance Languages. We have to use “preceding day”. When the Code was translated into English, it took the language from the breviary’s reference to First Vespers as the vespers that precede the solemnity. To precede, in liturgy, means to lead or to initiate. The mass of the preceding day is the first mass of the solemnity or the mass that opens the solemnity. This year, the Saturday evening mass will open the Sunday Solemnity.
You make a good point here.
Can. 1248 - §1. Praecepto de Missa participanda satisfacit qui Missae assistit ubicumque celebratur ritu catholico vel ipso die festo vel vespere diei praecedentis.
 
Why is the thread continuing?

All Catholics MUST go to two Masses this weekend. Period.
 
For those of us that don’t know Latin (yet)? 😊
The trick is to know ENOUGH of the Latin so that it makes sense. Certainly “evening” doesn’t make sense when you see or hear of Masses done in the late afternoon.

After all, it is in the language of the Church that these rules are written. If you’re interested, here is the 1983 Code of Canon Law in Latin:

jgray.org/codes/cic83lat.html
 
Also, do we have to go to Church again on Sunday?
Not sure if you HAVE to, but the most grace for your buck comes from going to 1. christmas eve mass 2. christmas day mass 3. sunday after christmas mass

then if you really enjoyed all that grace, keep going every day!
 
Not sure if you HAVE to, but the most grace for your buck comes from going to 1. christmas eve mass 2. christmas day mass 3. sunday after christmas mass

then if you really enjoyed all that grace, keep going every day!
Yes…beyond any question…Catholics must go to Mass on Christmas and again on Sunday.

This is silly…
 
If the mass being celebrated is the Mass for the Sunday, then you have missed the Christmas mass.

This will probably be the case in most dioceses. The evening mass on Dec 25 will be the mass for Holy Family Sunday.

To fulfill the Christmas obligation, many parishes will have a Christmas mass on the evening of the 24th, early. Then the midnight mass. Then several masses on Christmas day in the morning. Check your parish buletin to find out the times for the Christmas masses or call. Their answering service will have the information recorded.

May Mary and the Holy Child bless you,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
Ours doesn’t have their usual Saturday evening ‘Sunday’ Mass (as well as not having confession), probably in part to avoid the said confusion of a 5pm Mass, and so it doesn’t wear out the priests who are already celebrating 8 Masses (including 2 in 30 minutes, one at church, and another at the local highschool auditorium), then 4 on Sunday.

(I wonder how next year will work with Christmas being on a Sunday, or 2017 when Sunday is Christmas Eve.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top