Does the study of religion and philosophy contradict each other?

  • Thread starter Thread starter anon52328184
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
someone else had posted that studying the earliest philosophers might not make anyone question their faith, but reading some of the modern philosophers might. surprisingly, i think they also posted that the modern philosphers began around the time of the reformation. not sure about that though. maybe someone with more knowledge of philosophy could answer that.
Reading the history of thought, from ancient Greece to now, will help you understand better why modern thought is the way it is. It also makes it much easier to see how much poppy-cock there is in modern thought (as well as some ancient thought). Perhaps most importantly, it will show you how the modern world takes for granted as axiomatic so much of the nonsense that it does. This in turn will help you to situate your world view more cohesively and powerfully among competing strands of thought, and you will be better able to defend yourself and the Church, even among so-called “scholarly” people (who more often than not simply take for granted the same things the modern world does without knowing that much more than anyone else about it).

Modern philosophy is generally regarded as having been inaugurated by Descartes. He published his first great work in 1637. By the way, he was a devout Catholic who thought he was really working in that vein. The trouble was his whole radical doubt method. He had a version of Anselm’s ontological proof for God’s existence which wasn’t terribly successful in my opinion. But I still love Descartes and would recommend everyone with an interest to read him. But do not neglect the ancients and medievals. In fact, read them first. I think some people put the modern movement with Francis Bacon and his Novum Organum in 1620 in which he explicitly tries to replace Aristotelean thought with his own. I think Descartes was on the whole more interesting, and more influential, so he is the historical designation marker for modern thought. By the way, contemporary philosophy is very complex and representative of a lot of world-views. There are some great Christian/Catholic philosophers today as well. I like analytic philosophy. Some people go the Continental route, but I think that tradition swallowed itself a while back. There are analytic Thomists now, so don’t discount philosophy or faith. Incidentally, I’ve been studying philosophy for about 18 years now. My conversion took place about a year and a half ago, and I came into the Church on March 22nd of this year. You do the math. No, I would say that far from hindering or “contradicting” one’s faith, philosophy can be a great boon to one’s faith. In fact, as Catholics, I think we have a duty to know as much as we are capable of the great truths, or even the little ones.

God Bless

Jon Winterburn
 
I already recommended this encyclical way back in post #12. 😛 I guess a lot has happened between now and then. 😉

It really is essential reading to see just how reason and faith fit together and how they relate. I highly recommend it! 👍
hi joe!! yes, you did recommend that encyclical to me in post #12. can you believe that was august 19th?!! already almost a month ago. and i still haven’t read it since the last recommendation. just haven’t had the time.
i did glance over it quickly and it definitely looks like it is worth reading. i hope to get to it someday!! thanks. if two people have recommended it, that says something.
 
hi joe!! yes, you did recommend that encyclical to me in post #12. can you believe that was august 19th?!! already almost a month ago. and i still haven’t read it since the last recommendation. just haven’t had the time.
i did glance over it quickly and it definitely looks like it is worth reading. i hope to get to it someday!! thanks. if two people have recommended it, that says something.
No problem! Has it been that long already? 🙂 It isn’t short, nor is it necessarily a “light read”, but it is well worth reading.
 
yes, i think that is why i haven’t take the time to read it yet, because i know it is lengthy and i do want to take my time to read it. it definitely looks like it is worth reading.

with much prayer, i am planning a major move the end of october, so no i am trying to get everything organized for that. maybe sometime between and thanksgiving and christmas i will have the time to read it!

when i do, i will get back to you!

this has been a somewhat popular thread anyway and there have been more good posts than bad ones, so i am thankful for that. it has been very helpful!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top